Results of syndactyly release using a modification of the Flatt technique

Comparison Between Surgical Techniques for Correction of Congenital Syndactyly: A Systematic Review and Meta Analysis

This review aimed to assess which surgical technique has better outcomes to correct one of the most common congenital anomalies of the upper limb: syndactyly. The following databases were used in the search: PubMed, Embase, Cochrane (CENTRAL), LILACS, SciELO, Scopus and Web of Science, on October 27, 2022. Studies that described a surgical technique for correcting syndactyly and evaluated surgical complications were included. Studies about noncongenital or foot syndactyly were excluded. The risk of bias was assessed using a specific method for case reports. For synthesis of results, the characteristics of the studies and techniques were demonstrated by a qualitative analysis. Meta-analysis models were applied for complications, functionality, and aesthetic. 73 studies were included, of which 70 were series or case reports, 27 studies did not use skin grafts and 7 studies used external fixators. To evaluate functional results, 42 studies used only the surgeon's opinion. Meta-analyses showed a higher incidence of scar defects when using skin grafts and of infection when using external fixators. There was no difference for web creep and readmission. Few studies evaluated results using the VSS scale, showing worse scar pigmentation when skin grafts were used, but there was no difference in other parameters (PROSPERO CRD42022368930).

Omega Flap Technique: Revisiting Conventional Wisdom

Various surgical techniques have been described for the release of syndactylized fingers. In our experience, the omega flap technique, which includes a dorsal truncated flap and an anchor incision on the volar side, stands out as a good technique to release syndactyly. Incidentally, in symbrachydactyly also, the fused digits can be released using this technique. Despite this, we could find no reference in the recent years. We would like to stress the ease and importance of this technique, hoping many practicing hand surgeons will benefit from this. Our purpose was to revisit this technique and expose it to the younger generation of hand surgeons. We have operated on 20 cases of syndactyly of different types-simple, compound, and complex-and 5 cases of symbrachydactyly. In all cases, the omega flap on the dorsum and anchor incision on the volar aspect of the finger forming 2 lateral palmar flaps were used. The release of syndactyly was satisfactory in all patients. There was no flap necrosis. None of these cases have required secondary surgery because the primary releases were adequate. Release of syndactyly had been a problem for centuries. Awareness of the disability was insufficient in earlier days; currently, they seek early medical care. The release should be complete. These children must be able to achieve the form and function of the hand, and additionally precision to work. We believe that the use of omega flap and anchor flap is a good procedure for syndactyly release.

Single-stage Congenital Polysyndactyly Release: Outcomes and Long-term Followup

The current surgical strategy for syndactyly is multistage operations in which every other web is released, leaving adjacent webs unoperated for the next stage to avoid a presumed possible digital vascular compromise. In this series, we present our experience with single-stage multiple syndactylies release. A total of 7 patients, including 2 patients with bilateral hand involvement, were included. Dorsal and volar triangular flaps were created for commissure reconstruction, and zigzag manner volar and dorsal incisions were made to release the webbed fingers. Sterile thermoplastic splints were molded directly over the skin grafts without any dressing or tie-over. Following the surgical operation, minimal flexion contracture was seen in three patients that needed future correction procedures. Cosmesis and functional outcome were acceptable. This study shows that the release of all webs in 1 setting can be accomplished by no vascular compromise, and there is no need for a preoperative vascular imaging study.

Comparing Results of Syndactyly Operated Children Younger and Older Than 1 Year

INTRODUCTION

Syndactyly has a cosmetic, functional, and psychosocial impact, and surgical treatment is indicated in most cases. This study aimed to retrospectively identify whether patients undergoing surgical release of syndactyly younger than 1 year presented different results compared with those operated older than 1 year.

METHODS

Patients were assessed through photographic records by 3 independent specialist surgeons for the quality of scar, presence of web creep, rotational, flexion-extension, and lateral flexion deformities using the Withey score.

RESULTS

Thirty-four patients were included in the study, totaling 51 commissures operated. The score was higher in the group operated younger than 1 year (5.83 ± 2.39) compared with the group older than 1 year (3.94 ± 1.93), being statistically significant, with a P value of 0.011.

CONCLUSIONS

Children with syndactyly operated younger than 1 year have worse postoperative outcomes measured by the Withey score than those operated older than 1 year.

Syndactyly

Here we present an interesting case of simple syndactyly and provide a narrative review of its incidence, associations and management.

New Simple Technique for Syndactyly Release

Can good functional and cosmetic result be achieved in syndactyly separation using a straight midline incision with a hexagonal dorsal skin flap?

Treatment of congenital syndactyly

Defined as the union of two adjacent digits, syndactyly is one of the most common congenital deformities. The severity of the malformation depends on the fusion level, the tissues involved in the union, and whether it is isolated or syndromic. In order to improve the hand's appearance and function, surgery is recommended in the great majority of cases, ideally during early childhood (i.e., before entering school). Web space reconstruction is done using local flaps. Depending on the flap design, digital resurfacing can be done with or without skin grafts. While graftless techniques have shorter operating times and no morbidity associated with skin harvesting, their cosmetic outcomes seem to be worse than those of traditional grafting techniques, with more postoperative complications; furthermore, such techniques cannot be used in all cases, especially those with osteoarticular fusions. When the fingertip is involved, paronychial reconstruction is carried out with pulp flaps. The prognosis for these deformities directly depends on their severity, with excellent outcomes in cases of cutaneous fusion, and much less predictable ones when osteoarticular and/or tendinous tissues are involved.

External fixation: Role in decreasing postoperative complications of complex syndactyly release - A review of 18 patients

BACKGROUND

Primary and revision surgery for complete complex congenital syndactyly (CCCS) of the hand carries a risk of complications such as web maceration, which can result in flap or graft loss and alter the final appearance. No consensus emerges from the scant published data on postoperative care after CCCS surgery. The objective of this study was to assess the role for temporary external fixation in stabilising the commissure and facilitating surgical wound care.

HYPOTHESIS

Using external fixation after CCCS release facilitates postoperative wound care and decreases the complication rate.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Eighteen patients requiring primary CCCS surgery or revision CCCS surgery due to adhesions or web creep were included in a single-centre retrospective study. After release, an external fixator made of Kirschner pins was installed to temporarily immobilise the inter-phalangeal joints. The dressing was changed every 3 days for 3 weeks, and the external fixator was then removed. The parents and nurses completed questionnaires that used 0-10 point scales to assess ease and duration of dressing changes and perceptions and apprehensions experienced by parents and nurses, as well as pain by patients, during dressing changes.

RESULTS

No patient experienced maceration or failure of a graft or flap. Pin site discharge was noted in 1 patient and resolved fully after pin removal. Pain intensity was estimated at 4.2/10 during the first dressing change and 1.3/10 during the last dressing change. In the parents, apprehension was 9.6/10 and 5.1/10 during the first and last dressing changes, and stress was 8.1/10 and 4.1/10, respectively. Dressing change difficulty was rated 1.1/10 at the first and 0.9/10 at the last dressing change. Dressing change duration decreased from 13 to 10minutes.

CONCLUSION

These encouraging results support temporary commissure stabilisation by an external fixator to decrease postoperative complication rates and facilitate dressing changes after CCCS release.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, retrospective observational study.

[Results of Blauth Palmar Flap in congenital syndactyly: Long-term outcome in a 31 webs study]

OBJECTIVES

The main purpose of our study was to assess the web creep rate of congenital syndactyly treated with a Blauth palmar commissural flap.

METHODS

Every child with at least one syndactyly, simple or complex, syndromic or not, were included in this study. The main criterion of this study was the web creep rate according to the Withey scale (0 to 4). Scar assessment according to the Vancouver Scar Scale, hair growth and/or dyschromia on the full-thickness graft, digital spacing, flexion deformity, clinodactyly, range of motion of the finger, sensitivity and satisfaction were also assessed.

RESULTS

Separation of the webbed fingers was performed in 65 syndactylies between 1993 and 2015. The median age at the time of surgery was 14 months. We reviewed 31 web flaps with a mean follow-up time of 9 years. Fifty eight percent of the webs were grade 0 on the Withey scale, 36% were grade 1, 6% were grade 2. There was no grade 3 or 4. No correlation was found between the age at the time of surgery, gender, web space involved, complexity of the syndactyly, and the web creep. A decrease in range of motion and a flexion deformity of the fingers involved were more frequently found in complex syndactylies. Eighty seven percent of full-thickness grafts presented dyschromia, and 42% abnormal pilosity.

CONCLUSION

Palmar flap as described by Blauth is a safe technique ensuring good functionals outcomes and a low web creep rate for the reconstruction of the web space in congenital syndactyly.

Interdigitating Rectangular Flaps and Dorsal Pentagonal Island Flap for Syndactyly Release

PURPOSE

Interdigitating triangular flaps is the most commonly described technique for syndactyly release. However, triangular flaps may be associated with flap misalignment, flap tip necrosis, and a steep learning curve in design and technique. This study describes a series of syndactyly reconstructions using interdigitating rectangular flaps in both simple and complex syndactyly.

METHODS

A single surgeon's experience of syndactyly reconstruction using interdigitating rectangular flaps was reviewed retrospectively. Patient demographics, associated syndromes, operative technique, complications, and recurrences were analyzed.

RESULTS

Ninety-four web spaces in 50 children with 16 simple incomplete, 36 simple complete, 14 complex, 26 complicated, and 2 unclassified syndactylies were reconstructed with interdigitating rectangular flaps. Seventy-eight commissures were reconstructed with a dorsal pentagonal island flap and 16 with a dorsal rhomboid flap. Full-thickness skin grafts were used in 98% of webs. Five major complications required surgical intervention-2 recurrences, 2 web space scarrings, and 1 wound infection. Ten minor complications occurred-skin graft donor site dehiscence (3), partial loss of the skin graft (4), minor distal interphalangeal joint flexion contractures (2), and a case of minor web creep (1). Average follow-up was 13.7 months. All parents were satisfied with the function and appearance of their child's reconstructed digits.

CONCLUSIONS

Interdigitating rectangular flaps provide an effective technique for release of both simple and complex syndactyly. Advantages include easy learning owing to the relative simplicity of design; intraoperative modification of flap design (cut as you go), and wide flap tips, which prevent flap tip necrosis.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Complications and Cost of Syndactyly Reconstruction in the United States: Analysis of the Pediatric Health Information System

BACKGROUND

Syndactyly is one of the most common congenital differences of the upper extremity and offers an exceptional opportunity to evaluate value-based care in pediatric orthopedic surgery. We designed a study to characterize complications and cost associated to syndactyly surgery among US pediatric hospitals.

METHODS

A total of 2047 patients were identified for syndactyly surgery at 38 pediatric hospitals from 2009 to 2012 using the Pediatric Health Information System (PHIS) database. We examined costs as well as complication rates across hospitals stratified by patient and hospital variables.

RESULTS

The postoperative complication rate was 1.9% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.3%-2.5%). Postoperative infection rate was 1.6% and surgical complication rate was 0.3%. Median adjusted standardized cost was $4112.5 (interquartile range: $2979-$6049). Patients with more than 1 diagnosis had 19 times higher risk of complications and were associated with 13% more hospital cost than those with syndactyly as single diagnosis ( P < .001). Finally, there was a wide variation in cost across hospitals; 8 (21%) yielded confidence limits above the benchmarked value.

CONCLUSIONS

In the United States, it is important to recognize variations in practice of syndactyly surgery in hopes of developing quality improvement strategies in pediatric orthopedic surgery.

A Systematic Review and Comparison of Outcomes Following Simple Syndactyly Reconstruction With Skin Grafts or a Dorsal Metacarpal Advancement Flap

PURPOSE

Many techniques exist for simple syndactyly reconstruction. The most commonly used techniques involve either skin grafts or a dorsal metacarpal advancement flap. Our aim was to review and compare the outcomes of these 2 techniques systematically.

METHODS

We reviewed articles from PubMed, MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Google Scholar published between January 1966 and January 2016. We identified studies that reported outcomes after reconstruction of simple syndactyly using skin grafts and those using only a dorsal metacarpal advancement flap. Cases of complex syndactyly and those that were not clearly differentiated by technique or type of simple syndactyly were excluded. Outcomes were then stratified by technique and type of syndactyly (complete and incomplete).

RESULTS

We identified 693 articles and selected 34 for inclusion. No standardized outcome measure was uniformly applied in the examined studies. Overall, skin grafting procedures were associated with more complications (eg, flap necrosis/graft failure, contracture, web creep, hypertrophic scarring) and a greater need for revision. When stratified by subtype, patients with simple, complete syndactyly who underwent skin grafting had a significantly higher rate of hypertrophic scarring than those who underwent reconstruction with a dorsal metacarpal advancement flap.

CONCLUSIONS

Simple syndactyly reconstruction with a dorsal metacarpal advancement flap may lead to fewer complications than procedures using skin grafts. However, substantial limitations of currently available evidence do not allow for the recommendation of a specific technique. Future research should use a uniform reporting system for syndactyly classification and complications.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Syndactyly Release

Syndactyly is one of the most common congenital hand anomalies treated by pediatric plastic surgeons. Established principles of syndactyly separation dictate the timing and order of syndactyly release, with the goals of surgery being the creation of an anatomically normal webspace, tension-free closure of soft tissue, and return of function to the fingers. Numerous surgical methods have been described, many of which involve the use of local flaps to reconstruct the commissure and full-thickness skin grafts for coverage of raw areas. Recently, reconstructive techniques without the use of skin grafts have been devised, which work well for certain indications. Special considerations are described for complete, complex, and syndromic syndactylies. Outcomes for simple syndactyly release are typically good when surgical principles are followed, whereas complex syndactyly release tends to have less-favorable outcomes and more complications.

Long-term results of syndactyly correction by the trilobed flap technique focusing on hand function and quality of life

Syndactyly is usually corrected surgically during the first years of life. The trilobed flap, a surgical method that does not require skin grafting, was developed in the 1990s and the short-term results were comparable with previously reported techniques. Here we report on long-term outcomes, focusing on how children perceive their hand function and quality of life when they grow up. A total of 19 patients (29 web spaces) were operated on between 1990 and 2000, and followed-up 16 years later with questionnaires and clinical tests. The patients reported low QuickDASH scores, normal sensibility and dexterity, and minor cold intolerance. Only two reoperations, due to early web creep, were needed. The condition minimally affected the choice of occupations, leisure activities and perceptions of appearance. The trilobed flap technique for release of syndactyly provides a good long-term outcome with good hand function and minimal impact on the quality of life.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Transverse soft tissue distraction preceding separation of complex syndactylies

Various surgical techniques are described for separation of syndactylies leading to good results. However, the use of standard techniques is limited in complex syndactylies with extensive bony fusion and tight soft tissues. The aim of this study was to assess the outcomes of a two-stage procedure involving progressive soft tissue distraction prior to syndactyly release. Between 1996 and 2012 we treated 168 complex syndactylies with this technique. The main indications were syndactylies in Apert syndrome. The digits were distracted through an external fixator at 0.5 mm/day. Distraction of 15-25 mm was achieved. Soft tissue distraction provided additional skin, a wider nail matrix and more bone in the form of callus. Thus subsequent modelling of the fingertips was improved, especially if they were closely fused. This technique facilitates treatment of complex cases and improves aesthetic outcome.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Congenital Anomalies of the Hand--Principles of Management

Physicians who specialize in pediatric orthopedics and hand surgery frequently encounter congenital hand abnormalities, despite their relative rarity. The treating physician should be aware of the associated syndromes and malformations that may, in some cases, be fatal if not recognized and treated appropriately. Although these congenital disorders have a wide variability, their treatment principles are similar in that the physician should promote functional use and cosmesis for the hand. This article discusses syndactyly, preaxial polydactyly and post-axial polydactyly, and the hypoplastic thumb.

CT angiography-guided single-stage release of adjacent webspaces in non-Apert syndactyly

We describe the CT angiography protocol and surgical technique utilized at our institution for single-stage release of adjacent web-spaces in non-Apert syndactyly. In a series of seven consecutive hands we analyse syndactyly anatomy, CT angiographic findings, operative details, and complications. Outcomes were assessed with a functional activity evaluation, range of motion, and a parental visual analogue scale. Seven affected hands in four patients underwent single-stage release of adjacent webspaces. In all cases, the CT angiogram correctly predicted the presence of at least one artery supplying each digit. There were no cases of digital ischemia or loss. Angiographically guided, single-stage release of adjacent webspaces is technically feasible and benefits patients by reducing the number of surgical stages and allowing complete release to be achieved at an earlier age compared with the standard multi-stage approach.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Management of complications of congenital hand disorders

This article reviews treatment and presents complications seen in the treatment of 7 common congenital hand differences, including syndactyly, camptodactyly, ulnar and radial polydactyly, thumb hypoplasia, radial longitudinal deficiency, and epidermolysis bullosa. The management of these conditions is challenging but has evolved over the last several decades with refined understanding of the disease processes and treatments. The goal of this article is to synthesize prior knowledge and provide further insights into these conditions that will help the surgeon avoid treatment complications.