Do volar locking plates fit the volar cortex of the distal radius?

Three-dimensional imaging of the distal radius with reference to volar locking plate surgery

BACKGROUND

The watershed line is widely accepted as the distal limit of the volar locking plate (VLP); however, the VLP placement could vary depending on the plate contour and morphology of the distal radius. The aim of this study was to investigate the morphology of the distal radius and VLP fitting using 3D images.

HYPOTHESIS

We hypothesized that attachment of the VLP would affect the contour of the volar prominence of the distal radius.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Variable-angle LCP two-column volar distal radius Plate 2.4 and 16 formalin-fixed cadavers were studied. The plate and forearm were scanned using a computed tomography scanner. The plate was fixed to the radial shaft in the most distal position without flexor pollicis longus tendon contact. Postero-antero and lateral radiographs were obtained using fluoroscopy. Postero-antero radiographs were superimposed on a 3D image of the distal radius. The virtual plate was attached to the distal radius in the computer simulations and the plate was adjusted in the sagittal plane. In the postero-antero radiographs, the distance between the plate and distal end of the radius (DPR) was measured. In the sagittal plane, the height of the volar lunate facet (VLF) and the plate-to-bone distance of each locking screw hole was measured. The volar cortical angle (VCA) was measured as the angle formed by a line drawn along the volar surface and a line drawn on the radial shaft on the sagittal plane at each locking screw plane.

RESULTS

A significant correlation was observed between the height of the VLF and the DPR and between the height of the VLF and the VCA. The plate-to-bone distance at the ulnar screw hole was significantly smaller than that of the other screw holes.

DISCUSSION

Our study revealed that the higher the VLF, the more proximal is the VLP. The plate fits on the bone surface at the ulnar side, whereas the radial side has more space between the plate and bone.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III, diagnostic Level.

ANATOMICAL STUDY OF VOLAR FACE OF DISTAL RADIUS AND COMPARISON WITH THE SHAPE OF LOCKING VOLAR PLATES

ABSTRACT Objective: To evaluate the volar cortical angle (VCA), the variation in lateral and intermediate columns, the shape and pattern of the watershed line (WL) of the distal radius and its correlation with locking volar plates available. Methods: 27 human cadaveric radial bones of the Department of Morphology and nine locking volar plates of six different companies were analyzed. VCA were measured from lateral and intermediate columns and their corresponding values on plates, as well as comparing the relief of radius and plates. In the WL analysis, we compared the standard format found on the radius and its equivalent on plates and divided into four types: biconvex, convex, ulnar convex and plan. Results: VCA varied between columns of the distal radius extremity. The mean in the lateral column was 153.40 degrees and 146.06 degrees in the intermediate. Four of nine plates showed no variation in volar angulation. From 27 distal radius, 13 showed convex pattern and 12 had biconvex, whereas most plates (seven of the nine analyzed) were biconvex drawing. Conclusion: Radial bone anatomy was variable. The intermediate column was, on average, steeper than lateral column. Synthes®-2 plate presented the closest design to the anatomy of the distal end of the radial bone, followed by Newclip®-2 plate. Level of Evidence II, Anatomic and Descriptive Study.

Age-Related Variations in Volar Cortical Angle of the Distal Radius

Background: The ideal volar locking plate for the treatment of distal radius fracture should anatomically fit the volar surface of the distal radius. The purpose of this study was to measure the volar cortical angle (VCA) of uninjured adult distal radii to determine how well the VCA matches that of modern volar locking plates and whether variations in the VCA are related to demographic factors. Methods: A retrospective radiographic analysis of 273 uninjured adult distal radii was performed. Patients were stratified into age quintiles: less than 27 years, 27 to 43 years, 44 to 51 years, 52 to 64 years, and 65 years or older. The VCA was measured on lateral wrist radiographs, and patient demographics, including age and sex, were collected. Multivariable linear regression analyses were performed to determine the relationship between VCA and demographic factors. Results: The VCA ranged from 23.2° to 42.6°, with a mean of 32.2° (SD = 3.79). Mean VCA was 32.8 (SD = 4.17) in the youngest cohort (<27 years) and 30.4 (SD = 3.63) in the oldest cohort (>65 years). Mean VCA decreased with age, approximately 0.04° per year after adjusting for sex. Men had a 1.6° greater VCA than women after adjusting for age. Conclusion: Mean VCA was greater than the VCA of modern volar locking plates. The VCA decreased with age in both men and women, and men had a greater VCA than women. Such differences must be taken into account to avoid malreduction, tendon irritation, or intra-articular screw placement using current volar plate designs.

Morphometric Variations in the Volar Aspect of the Distal Radius

Background

Significant discrepancy exists between anatomical plate designs and the anatomy of the native distal radius, which may be attributable to considerable morphometric variations in the volar aspect of the distal radius. We aimed to evaluate the degree of variability in the morphometry of the distal radius and identify factors associated with this variability.

Methods

We measured the volar surface angle (VSA) of the intermediate and lateral columns and the volar surface width (VSW) in the distal radius from three-dimensional computed tomography scans acquired from 81 cadaveric forearms. These morphometric parameters were compared between the lateral and intermediate columns, between males and females, and between Koreans and Caucasians. Caucasian morphometric data were obtained and pooled from the previous studies. The coefficient of variation was used to assess the variability of the parameters and Cohen's d to estimate the effect size of the difference between groups.

Results

The average VSA of the lateral column was 22° ± 6°, and that of the intermediate column was 29° ± 8° in Koreans (p < 0.001). The variability was high for both VSAs. The VSA of the intermediate column was significantly larger in males than in females (p < 0.001) and in Caucasians than in Koreans (p < 0.001). The average VSW of distal radius was 30 ± 3 mm at the watershed line, and it became narrower proximally. The VSW was significantly larger in males than in females (p < 0.001) and in Koreans than in Caucasians (p < 0.001). The effect sizes of the difference for the VSA and VSW between sexes, races and columns were medium to large.

Conclusions

Considerable variability exists in the morphometry of the volar distal radius, with sex, race, and column as contributing factors. These results suggest that surgeons should carefully choose an anatomical volar locking plate with appropriate angulation characteristics for each patient to achieve patient-specific alignment of the distal radius.

Morphological Study of the Anterior Surface of the Distal Radius

The shape of the anterior surface of the distal radius is important for designing a distal radius plate for wrist fracture surgery. The aim of this study was to describe the shape of the anterior surface of the distal radius and to compare the results between female and male. We used 90 sides from three-dimensional radial models based on computer tomography images from Korean adult cadavers for this study. The anterior surface was measured in two dimensions in the coronal view, and we sectioned the anterior surface of the models to obtain intermediate and radial sections to measure the curved shape of the anterior surface in sagittal view. Several parameters were statistically different between females and males; however, there were no differences between the right and left sides for any parameters. The width of the anterior surface in the coronal view was larger in males than females, and the curved part of the anterior surface of the males was longer and more concave than that of females. In both the female and male specimens, the intermediate section was longer and more concave than the radial section. Our results are useful for anthropological studies and for designing distal radial plates.