Blastocyst Development in a Single Medium Compared to Sequential Media: A Prospective Study With Sibling Oocytes

Mammalian embryo culture media: now and into the future

For over 70years, since the culture of the first mammalian embryo in vitro , scientists have undertaken studies to devise and optimise media to support the manipulation and culture of gametes and embryos. This area of research became especially active in the late 1970s onwards following the successful birth of the first human in vitro fertilised embryo. This review summarises some of the key advances in mammalian embryo culture media over time based on a greater understanding of the biochemical milieu of the reproductive tract. It highlights how learnings from studies in mice and agricultural species have informed human culture media compositions, in particular the inclusion of albumin, growth factors, cytokines, and antioxidants into contemporary culture media formulations, and how these advances may then in turn help to inform and guide development of in vitro culture systems used in other arenas, in particular agriculture. Additionally, it will highlight how the introduction of new technologies, such as timelapse, can influence current trends in media composition and usage that may see a return to a single step medium.

A propensity score-based, comparative study assessing humid and dry time-lapse incubation, with single-step medium, on embryo development and clinical outcomes

STUDY QUESTION

Does culture in a high relative humidity atmosphere improve clinical outcomes when using a time-lapse integrated incubator and single-step culture medium?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Using an integrated time-lapse system and single-step culture medium, culture in a high relative humidity atmosphere increases the likelihood of embryos, especially those subjected to preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies, to achieve a pregnancy compared to those cultured in dry conditions.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

The use of a humid atmosphere inside incubators can reduce changes in culture media osmolality, which has been reported to have a significant effect on embryo quality and morphokinetics. Studies assessing the effect of humid culture (HC) in clinical outcomes are, however, scarce and inconclusive, mostly due to a high variability in culture conditions and reduced sample size.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

Retrospective cohort study performed over 1627 ICSI cycles performed during 3 consecutive years in which embryo cohorts were cultured in a time-lapse incubator with three dry and three humidified chambers, and using single-step culture medium. Clinical outcomes were compared between treatments in which embryo cohorts were cultured in either humid (n = 833) or dry (n = 794) conditions.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

The study includes autologous treatments, with (N = 492) and without (N = 372) preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A) and ovum donation treatments (N = 763), performed in three university-affiliated private IVF centres. Stimulation, oocyte pickup and fertilization were performed according to the standard procedures of the clinic. All embryo cohorts were cultured in the same model of time-lapse incubator, distributed to either a dry or humidified chamber, while the rest of the culture variables remained equal. The population was weighted by the inverse probability of treatment to control for all measured confounders. The association between HC and the main outcome was assessed by logistic regression over the weighted population. The E-value was reported as a way of considering for unmeasured confounders. Differences in embryo development and other secondary outcomes between the study groups were assessed by Pearson Chi-squared test, ANOVA test and Kaplan-Meier survival analysis.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

An univariable logistic regression analysis, weighted by the inverse probability of treatment, determined that embryos cultured in humid conditions are more likely to achieve a clinical pregnancy than those cultured in dry conditions (odds ratio (OR) = 1.236 (95% CI 1.009-1.515), P = 0.041, E = 1.460). Through stratification, it was determined that said effect is dependent on the type of treatment: no improvement in clinical pregnancy was present in ovum donation or autologous treatments, but a statistically significant positive effect was present in treatments with preimplantation genetic testing (OR = 1.699 (95% CI 1.084-2.663), P = 0.021, E = 1.930). Said increase does not relate with an improvement in later outcomes. Differences were also found in variables related to embryo developmental morphokinetics.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The retrospective nature of the study makes it susceptible to some bias linked to the characteristics of the treatments. To lessen the effect of possible biases, cases were weighted by the inverse probability of treatment prior to the evaluation of the outcome, as means to assess for measured confounders. In addition, the E-value of the weighted OR was calculated as a sensitivity analysis for unmeasured confounders. A randomized prospective study could be performed for further assessing the effect of humid conditions in clinical outcome.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

These results support that embryo culture under conditions of high relative humidity contributes to optimize clinical results in undisturbed culture in a time-lapse incubator with single-step medium. To our knowledge, this is the largest study on the matter and the first performing a propensity score-based analysis.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This work was supported by the ''Centro para el Desarrollo Tecnologico Industrial'' from the Spanish Ministry of Science, Innovation, and Universities (CDTI-20170310) and Generalitat Valenciana and European Social Fund (ACIF/2019/264). None of the authors have any competing interest to declare.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

The impact of single-step and sequential embryo culture systems on obstetric and perinatal outcomes in singleton pregnancies: the Massachusetts Outcomes Study of Assisted Reproductive Technology

OBJECTIVE

To compare the obstetric and perinatal outcomes of deliveries conceived with embryos from single-step vs. sequential culture media systems.

DESIGN

Historical cohort of Massachusetts vital records linked to assisted reproductive technology clinic data from the Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology Clinic Outcome Reporting System and laboratory embryology data from two large academic hospital fertility centers.

SETTING

Not applicable.

PATIENTS

Patients with singleton live birth deliveries between 2004 and 2017 conceived with autologous assisted reproductive technology cycles with fresh blastocyst transfer using either single-step (n = 1,058) or sequential (n = 474) culture media systems.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Associations of single-step vs. sequential culture with obstetric outcomes (mode of delivery, placental abnormalities, pregnancy-induced hypertension, and gestational diabetes) and perinatal outcomes (preterm birth, low birthweight, small-for-gestational-age, and large-for-gestational-age [LGA]) were assessed with multivariate logistic modeling, adjusted for maternal age, race/ethnicity, education, parity, insurance type, protein supplementation, oxygen concentration, fertilization method, and number of transferred embryos.

RESULTS

Compared with sequential culture, single-step culture was associated with increased odds of LGA (adjusted odds ratio 2.1, 95% confidence interval 1.04-4.22). There were no statistically significant differences between single-step and sequential culture media systems in the odds of placental abnormalities, pregnancy-induced hypertension, gestational diabetes, prematurity, small-for-gestational-age, or low birthweight.

CONCLUSIONS

Single-step culture is associated with increased odds of LGA, indicating that embryo culture media systems may affect perinatal outcomes.

Effect of sequential versus single-step culture medium on IVF treatments, including embryo and clinical outcomes: a prospective randomized study

PURPOSE

Sequential media G5 series (Vitrolife) and single-step medium Continuous Single Culture Complete (CSC-C) (Irvine Scientific) are two different culture media. We want to examine difference between culturing effects of the two media.

METHODS

To compare the fertilization and early embryo development, a prospective randomized controlled trial with sibling oocytes in infertile patients, aged ≤ 45 years with ≥ 8 oocytes (226 cycles) was conducted. Each half of the retrieved oocytes from the same patient were randomly allocated to two culture media separately. The remaining fresh cycles were randomly assigned to two culture media during the same period (179 cycles). We compared the clinical outcomes based on the total fresh ET cycles in this periods, in which the transferred embryos were only from one culture medium.

RESULTS

Embryo outcomes: 226 cycles, included 176 IVF and 50 ICSI cycles, were analyzed, which correspond to 3518 inseminated or micro-injected oocytes. Clinical outcomes: 71 (CSC-C) and 71 (G5 series) fresh ET cycles were compared. There were no significant differences in clinical outcomes and general fertilization rate. However, the fertilization rate was superior in the CSC-C when compared with G5 in ICSI cycles (76.51% vs. 67.25%, P = 0.008). In addition, the compacted embryo development rate was significantly higher in CSC-C on day 3. The cycles that had compacted embryos on day 3 demonstrated better outcomes both in embryos as well as clinically.

CONCLUSIONS

CSC-C had higher fertilization rates than G5 series in ICSI cycles. In addition, the compaction rates of day 3 embryos were significantly higher in CSC-C.

The influence of the type of embryo culture media on the outcome of IVF/ICSI cycles

OBJECTIVE

Embryo culture media are important factors in IVF, which can significantly influence clinical outcome of IVF/ICSI cycles. Despite this, it is still not completely clear which formulation is most optimal and whether sequential or continuous media should be favored.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study retrospectively analyzed the outcome of IVF/ICSI cycles with regard to different types of culture media used to culture embryos, namely sequential and two types of single step continuous embryo culture media.

RESULTS

If the data were combined for both types of single step continuous embryo culture media the only significant difference we observed was the proportion of poor quality embryos on day 3, which was significantly higher (16.9% vs. 22.5%; P = 0.017) in the sequential media. The pregnancy (55.1% vs. 40.5%; P = 0.113) and live birth rates (42.9% vs. 33.8%; P = 0.308) were lower in continuous media, although the difference was not statistically significant. Furthermore, the blastocyst rate (sequential vs. continuous; 47.4% vs. 47.3%; P = 1), and birthweight (3280 ± 630g vs. 3272 ± 575g; P = 0.96) did not significantly differ regardless of the medium used to culture embryos. Additional comparison of each type of continuous medium to sequential media revealed that the difference in the quality of cleavage stage embryos for combined data of both continuous culture media may be derived from the group of cycles were SAGE 1-Step was used to culture embryos.

CONCLUSION

These results therefore indicate that continuous media can be equivalent to sequential media and could help lower the workload in busy IVF labs without impairing the clinical results. Although, caution is needed because this study is limited by its retrospective design. To confirm the results, especially in terms of live birth rates and perinatal outcome, a prospective study is needed with a higher number of included couples.

Elimination of stress factors by continuous embryo culture and its influence on in vitro fertilization outcomes

Recently, infertility has become one of the most important endemic conditions, affecting approximately 15-20 % of couples worldwide. Among others, the careerist lifestyle, the increasing maternal age and the parallel increment in the aneuploidy rate of embryos play a crucial role in this phenomenon. In this study, embryological parameters and pregnancy outcomes were investigated in IVF cycles using either sequential embryo culture or a single step culture system. By sequential media, oocytes/embryos are needlessly exposed to the potentially negative effects of light exposure, temperature decrement and altered oxygen tension. In comparison with sequential media, single step media induced 1.28, 1.21 and 1.21-fold increments in implantation, biochemical pregnancy and clinical pregnancy rates, respectively. Pregnancy outcomes showed strong maternal age-dependency, so the difference between the two investigated culture systems was equalized by the increasing maternal ages (35-44 years) and the supposed incidence of embryo aneuploidy. Nevertheless, the significant enlargements in the outcomes of the younger ages (25-34) induced by the single step cultures suggest that, beside the resultant maternal aneuploidy, aneuploidy (reduced pregnancy rates) may evolve from exposure to the mentioned environmental stress factors.

The impact of culture conditions on blastocyst formation and aneuploidy rates: a comparison between single-step and sequential media in a large academic practice

PURPOSE

To compare a single-step medium with a sequential medium on human blastocyst development rates, aneuploidy rates, and clinical outcomes.

METHODS

Retrospective cohort study of IVF cycles that used Sage advantage sequential medium (n = 347) and uninterrupted Sage 1-step medium (n = 519) from July 1, 2016, to December 31, 2017, in an academic fertility center. Main outcome measures are blastocyst formation rates per two-pronuclear (2PN) oocyte and aneuploidy rates per biopsy.

RESULTS

Of all IVF cycles, single-step medium yielded higher blastocyst formation rate (51.7% vs 43.4%) but higher aneuploidy rate (54.0% vs 45.8%) compared with sequential medium. When stratified by maternal age, women under age 38 had no difference in blastocyst formation (52.2% vs 50.2%) but a higher aneuploidy rate (44.5% vs 36.4%) resulting in a lower number of euploid blastocysts per cycle (2.6 vs 3.3) when using single-step medium compared to sequential medium. In cycles used single-step medium, patients ≥ age 38 had higher blastocyst rate (48.0% vs 33.6%), but no difference in aneuploidy rate (68.8% vs 66.0%) or number of euploid embryos (0.8 vs 1.1). For patients reaching euploid embryo transfer, there was no difference in clinical pregnancy rates, miscarriage rates, or live birth rates between two culture media systems.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study demonstrates an increase in aneuploidy in young women whose embryos were cultured in a single-step medium compared to sequential medium. This study highlights the importance of culture conditions on embryo ploidy and the need to stratify by patient age when examining the impact of culture conditions on overall cycle potential.

Cumulus-corona gene expression analysis combined with morphological embryo scoring in single embryo transfer cycles increases live birth after fresh transfer and decreases time to pregnancy

PURPOSE

Clinical pregnancy rate after IVF with eSET stagnates between 30 and 40%. In order to increase pregnancy and live birth rates, multiple embryo transfer is still common practice. Providing additional non-invasive tools to choose the competent embryo for transfer could avoid multiple pregnancy and improve time to pregnancy. Cumulus mRNA analysis with quantitative PCR (QPCR) is a non-invasive approach. However, so far, no gene sets have been validated in prospective interventional studies.

METHODS

A prospective interventional single-center pilot study with two matched controls (day-3 and day-5 eSET) was performed in 96 patients consenting to the analysis of the cumulus-corona of their oocytes. All patients were super-ovulated for ICSI and eSET at day 3. All oocytes were denuded individually and cumulus was analyzed by quantitative PCR using three predictive genes (EFNB2, SASH1, CAMK1D) and two housekeeping genes (UBC and β2M). Patients (n = 62) with 2 or more day-3 embryos (good or excellent morphology) had their embryo chosen following the normalized expression of the genes.

RESULTS

Corona testing significantly increased the clinical pregnancy and live births rates (63% and 55%) compared to single embryo transfer (eSET) on day 3 (27% and 23%: p < 0.001) and day 5 (43% and 39%: p = 0.022 and p = 0.050) fresh transfer cycle controls with morphology-only selection. Time-to-pregnancy was significantly reduced, regardless of the number of good-quality embryos available on day 3.

CONCLUSION

Combining standard morphology scoring and cumulus/corona gene expression analysis increases day-3 eSET results and significantly reduces the time to pregnancy.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

This is not an RCT study and was only registered by the ethical committee of the University Hospital UZBRUSSEL of the Vrije Universiteit Brussel VUB (BUN: 143201318000).

Comparison of two commercial embryo culture media (SAGE-1 step single medium vs. G1-PLUSTM/G2-PLUSTM sequential media): Influence on in vitro fertilization outcomes and human embryo quality

OBJECTIVE

To compare embryo quality, fertilization, implantation, miscarriage and clinical pregnancy rates for embryos cultured in two different commercial culture media until D-2 or D-3.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, we analyzed 189 cycles performed in 2016. Metaphase II oocytes were microinjected and allocated into single medium (SAGE 1-STEP, Origio) until transferred, frozen or discarded; or, if sequential media were used, the oocytes were cultured in G1-PLUSTM (Vitrolife) up to D-2 or D-3 and in G2-PLUSTM (Vitrolife) to transfer. On the following day, the oocytes were checked for normal fertilization and on D-2 and D-3 for morphological classification. Statistical analysis was performed using the chi-square and Mann-Whitney tests in PASW Statistics 18.0.

RESULTS

The fertilization rates were 70.07% for single and 69.11% for sequential media (p=0.736). The mean number of embryos with high morphological quality (class A/B) was higher in the single medium than in the sequential media: D-2 [class A (190 vs. 107, p<0.001), B (133 vs. 118, p=0.018)]; D-3 [class A (40 vs. 19, p=0.048) but without differences in class B (40 vs. 49)]. Consequently, a higher number of embryos cultured in single medium were frozen: 197 (21.00%) vs. sequential: 102 (11.00%), p<0.001. No differences were found in implantation rates (30.16% vs. 25.57%, p=0.520), clinical pregnancy rates (55.88% vs. 41.05%, p=0.213), or miscarriage rates (14.29% vs. 9.52%, p=0.472).

CONCLUSION

Embryo culture in single medium yields greater efficiency per cycle than in sequential media. Higher embryo quality and quantity were achieved, resulting in more frozen embryos. There were no differences in clinical pregnancy rates.

Continuous embryo culture elicits higher blastulation but similar cumulative delivery rates than sequential: a large prospective study

PURPOSE

To assess whether continuous embryo culture involves better embryological and/or clinical outcomes than sequential.

METHODS

Prospective study at a private IVF center. All consecutive IVF cycles (September 2013-2015) fulfilling the inclusion criteria underwent embryo culture in either Continuous-Single-Culture-Media (CSCM, n = 972) or sequential media (Quinn's Advantage, n = 514), respectively. ICSI, blastocyst culture in either standard (MINC) or undisturbed (Embryoscope) incubation, transfer (until September 2016), and pregnancy follow-up (until September 2017) were performed. When aneuploidy testing was required, trophectoderm biopsy and qPCR were performed. Sub-analyses and logistic regression corrected for confounders were performed. The primary outcomes were overall blastocyst rate per oocyte and mean blastocyst rate per cycle. The sample size was defined to reach 95 and 80% statistical power for the former and the latter outcome, respectively. Secondary outcomes were euploidy (if assessed), cumulative delivery rates, gestational age, and birthweight.

RESULTS

Continuous embryo culture resulted into a higher overall blastocyst rate per inseminated oocyte than sequential (n = 2211/5841, 37.9% vs. 1073/3216, 33.4%; p < 0.01), confirmed also from a cycle-based analysis (mean blastocyst rate: 38.7% ± 29.7% vs. 34.3% ± 29.4%; p = 0.01). The continuous media (OR = 1.23), the undisturbed incubation system (OR = 1.22), the maternal age (OR = 0.92), and the sperm factor (OR = 0.85) were outlined as positive predictors of blastulation. However, the cumulative delivery rates per ended cycle (i.e., delivery achieved or no blastocyst produced or left; > 90%) were comparable in the two groups (n = 244/903, 27.0% vs. 129/475, 27.2%). The neonatal outcomes were similar.

CONCLUSIONS

Continuous culture involves better embryological but similar clinical outcomes than sequential. This large prospective study supports the absence of clinical disparity among the two approaches.

Complex chromosomal aberrations in a fetus originating from oocytes with smooth endoplasmic reticulum (SER) aggregates

The presence of smooth endoplasmic reticulum aggregates (SERa) in the ooplasm is considered as the most severe oocyte dysmorphism due to its serious and potentially lethal outcomes in offspring. In the present case report, a couple underwent their first intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) cycle using a gonadotrophin releasing hormone (GnRH) antagonist protocol, followed by fetal ultrasound scanning and amniocentesis. SERa were observed in all oocytes retrieved. A singleton pregnancy was established. The second trimester fetal ultrasound scan revealed a female fetus with overlapping fingers in both hands, and amniocentesis was performed for the detection of chromosomal abnormalities. Comprehensive genetic analysis with the combined use of array-comparative genomic hybridization (CGH), fluoresence in situ hybridization (FISH) and conventional cytogenetics revealed a complex chromosome rearrangement (CCR) involving three break points on two chromosomes, resulting in a reciprocal translocation with a cryptic 2q31 deletion. A week following amniocentesis, there was rupture of amniotic membranes and a stillborn was delivered. This is the first case in the literature to report a CCR with concomitant 2q31 deletion resulting in a well-defined and clinically recognizable contiguous gene syndrome with an abnormal phenotype in a fetus arising from a cohort of oocytes affected by SERa. It is suggested that fertilization and transfer of oocytes with SERa should be avoided, until further research establishes whether there is a causal relationship between the presence of SERa and chromosomal abnormalities in the resulting fetus.

ABBREVIATIONS

SER: smooth endoplasmic reticulum; ICSI: intracytoplasmic sperm injection; GnRH: gonadotrophin releasing hormone; CGH: comparative genomic hybridization; FISH: fluoresence in situ hybridization; FSH: follicle stimulating hormone; hCG: human chorionic gonadotrophin; OHSS: ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome; IVF: in vitro fertilization; MII: metaphase II; GV: germinal vesicle; CCR: complex chromosome rearrangement.

Blastocyst utilization rates after continuous culture in two commercial single-step media: a prospective randomized study with sibling oocytes

PURPOSE

The aim of this study is to determine whether blastocyst utilization rates are different after continuous culture in two different commercial single-step media.

METHODS

This is a paired randomized controlled trial with sibling oocytes conducted in infertility patients, aged ≤40 years with ≥10 oocytes retrieved assigned to blastocyst culture and transfer. Retrieved oocytes were randomly allocated to continuous culture in either Sage one-step medium (Origio) or Continuous Single Culture (CSC) medium (Irvine Scientific) without medium renewal up to day 5 post oocyte retrieval. Main outcome measure was the proportion of embryos suitable for clinical use (utilization rate).

RESULTS

A total of 502 oocytes from 33 women were randomly allocated to continuous culture in either Sage one-step medium (n = 250) or CSC medium (n = 252). Fertilization was performed by either in vitro fertilization or intracytoplasmic sperm injection, and embryo transfers were performed on day 5. Two patients had all blastocysts frozen due to the occurrence of severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome. Fertilization and cleavage rates, as well as embryo quality on day 3, were similar in the two media. Blastocyst utilization rates (%, 95% CI) [55.4% (46.4-64.1) vs 54.7% (44.9-64.6), p = 0.717], blastocyst formation rates [53.6% (44.6-62.5) vs 51.9 (42.2-61.6), p = 0.755], and proportion of good quality blastocysts [36.8% (28.1-45.4) vs 36.1% (27.2-45.0), p = 0.850] were similar in Sage one-step and CSC media, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Continuous culture of embryos in Sage one-step and CSC media is associated with similar blastocyst development and utilization rates. Both single-step media appear to provide adequate support during in vitro preimplantation embryo development. Whether these observations are also valid for other continuous single medium protocols remains to be determined.

CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

NCT02302638.