Isolated Gastrocnemius Recession for the Treatment of Achilles Tendinopathy

Gastrocnemius Release in the Treatment of Achilles Tendinopathy: A Systematic Review

Background

The aim of this study is to evaluate the use of isolated gastrocnemius release in the treatment of Achilles tendinopathy. The primary outcome is the change in patient-reported pain outcomes. Secondary outcomes include the change in patient-reported foot and ankle function, ankle range of motion and strength, patient satisfaction and rate of surgical complications.

Methods

A systematic review was undertaken of studies involving patients treated with an isolated gastrocnemius release for Achilles tendinopathy. Randomised controlled trials, cohort studies, case-control studies and case series were eligible and identified from the following databases: MEDLINE and EMBASE.

Results

Isolated gastrocnemius release results in improved patient-reported outcome scores for pain and foot and ankle function. There is an increase in ankle range of motion but a reduction in ankle strength. Patients report a high rate of overall satisfaction. The most common surgical complications are sural nerve injury and wound infection.

Conclusions

Isolated gastrocnemius release may offer maintained and clinically meaningful improvements in pain and foot and ankle function with an associated reduction in ankle strength.

Endoscopic calcaneoplasty with gastrocnemius recession for Haglund's syndrome: Is it safe and effective? Results from a retrospective case series

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic calcaneoplasty (ECP) and gastrocnemius recession (GR) are procedures that have been described to effectively treat Haglund's deformity and insertional Achilles tendinopathy respectively. The purpose of our manuscript is to evaluate the efficacy and safety of ECP and GR with immediate weightbearing for the treatment of Haglund's deformity with mild to moderate insertional Achilles tendinopathy.

METHODS

We performed ECP coupled with GR on 14 patients with an average age of 52 years. All patients demonstrated < 50% tendinous degeneration on MRI. All were allowed weightbearing as tolerated in a CAM boot within the first post-operative week. AOFAS scores and plain film radiographic findings were collected pre-operatively and post-operatively.

RESULTS

The radiographic exam of the Fowler-Philip angle significantly improved from an average 60.1-40.7° (p < 0.001). The AOFAS ankle/hindfoot score significantly improved from an average 54.7-91.4 (p < 0.001). The average return to work was 7.5 weeks. There were two cases of temporary sural nerve paresthesia, and two cases of delayed wound healing.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first mid-term study evaluating the outcomes of ECP with GR. The results of our study suggest that ECP with GR followed by immediate weightbearing is a safe and effective procedure for the treatment of Haglund's deformity and mild to moderate insertional Achilles tendinopathy.

Level of Evidence for the Treatment of Chronic Noninsertional Achilles Tendinopathy

BACKGROUND

Noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy affects both athletes and sedentary individuals, and its incidence is rising. Conservative management is the mainstay of treatment, but a variety of operative techniques have been described to treat recalcitrant cases. We seek to outline the current available evidence for surgical management of noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A systematic review was performed using the MEDLINE and EMBASE databases, and all articles were reviewed by at least 2 authors. Each article was assigned a level of evidence in accordance with the standards of Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. The available data were reviewed and a level of evidence was assigned to each intervention of interest, based on the revised classifications of Wright.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

A total of 46 articles met inclusion and exclusion criteria. There is fair evidence (grade B) in support of open debridement with 1 level II study, 1 level III study, and 8 level IV studies. There is fair evidence (grade B) in support of arthroscopic or minimally invasive surgical techniques. There is poor evidence (grade C) in support of flexor hallucis longus transfer, longitudinal tenotomy, peritenolysis, gastrocnemius recession, and plantaris excision. There is insufficient evidence (grade I) to provide a recommendation about other surgical treatment methods for noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy.Levels of Evidence: Level III: Systematic review.

Factors Associated With Poor Patient-Reported Outcomes in Isolated Gastrocnemius Recession for Heel Pain

Background

Gastrocnemius recession is commonly performed for a variety of pathologies of the foot and ankle, yet studies characterizing risk factors associated with patient-reported outcomes are limited. In this cohort study, patient outcomes were compared against the general population for PROMIS scores with correlation analysis comparing demographics and comorbidities. Our primary goal in this study is to identify risk factors associated with poor patient-reported outcomes following isolated gastrocnemius recession for patients with plantar fasciitis or insertional Achilles tendinopathy.

Methods

A total of 189 patients met inclusion criteria. The open Strayer method was preferred. However, if the myotendinous junction could not be adequately visualized without expanding the excision, then a Baumann procedure was performed. The decision between the two did not depend on preoperative contracture. Patient demographics and visual analog scale (VAS) scores were obtained via the electronic medical record. Telephone interviews were completed to collect postoperative Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System (PROMIS) and Foot Function Index (FFI) scores. The data were analyzed using the type 3 SS analysis of variance test to identify individual patient factors associated with reduced PROMIS, FFI, and VAS scores.

Results

No demographic variables were found to be significantly associated with postoperative complications. Patients who reported tobacco use at the time of surgery had significantly decreased postoperative PROMIS physical function (P = .01), PROMIS pain interference (P < .05), total FFI scores (P < .0001), and each individual FFI component score. Patients undergoing their first foot and ankle surgeries reported numerous significant postoperative outcomes, including decreased PROMIS pain interference (P = .03), higher PROMIS depression (P = .04), and lower FFI pain scores (P = .04). Hypertension was significantly associated with an increased FFI disability score (P = .03) and, along with body mass index (BMI) >30 (P < .05) and peripheral neuropathy (P = .03), significantly higher FFI activity limitation scores (P = .01). Pre- and postoperative VAS scores demonstrated improvement in patient-reported pain from a mean of 5.53 to 2.11, respectively (P < .001).

Conclusion

We found in this cohort that numerous patient factors were independently associated with differences in patient-reported outcomes following a Strayer gastrocnemius recession performed for plantar fasciitis or insertional Achilles tendinopathy. These factors include, but are not limited to, tobacco use, prior foot and ankle surgeries, and BMI. This study strengthens previous reports demonstrating the efficacy of isolated gastrocnemius recession and elucidates variables that may affect patient-reported outcomes.

Level of Evidence

Level III, retrospective cohort study.

The Medial Gastrocnemius Recession, an Alternative Surgical Treatment for Isolated Gastrocnemius Contracture: A Cadaver Study With Discussion Emphasizing Variable Conjoint Tendon Anatomy

BACKGROUND

Gastrocnemius recession is a popular procedure utilized to treat chronic conditions related to isolated gastrocnemius contracture (IGC). Recent anatomical research detailing variable gastrocsoleus tendon morphology has raised important questions regarding the safety of some traditional recession procedures. Alternative gastrocnemius recession strategies may produce comparable dorsiflexion improvement results while avoiding the surgical risk related to conjoint tendon anatomical variability.

METHODS

Ten matched cadaver pairs were randomized to receive either a medial gastrocnemius recession (MGR) procedure or a gastrocnemius intramuscular recession "Baumann" procedure. Postoperative dorsiflexion improvement was measured and then compared between groups. Detailed postoperative surgical dissections were performed to assess structures at risk, conjoint tendon morphology, and anatomical symmetry.

RESULTS

Medial gastrocnemius recession and Baumann procedures were equally effective at producing significant increases in passive ankle dorsiflexion. No sural nerve injuries were observed. Thirty-five percent of specimens showed direct muscular fusion of at least a portion of the distal gastrocnemius muscular tissue to the adjacent soleus.

CONCLUSION

The MGR procedure produced comparable dorsiflexion improvement results to the Baumann procedure in our cadaver model. Surgeons must account for certain conjoint tendon anatomical variants when surgically treating IGC as traditional recession methods risk tendo-Achilles overlengthening.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level V: Cadaver Study.

ICON 2020-International Scientific Tendinopathy Symposium Consensus: A Systematic Review of Outcome Measures Reported in Clinical Trials of Achilles Tendinopathy

BACKGROUND

Nine core domains for tendinopathy have been identified. For Achilles tendinopathy there is large variation in outcome measures used, and how these fit into the core domains has not been investigated.

OBJECTIVE

To identify all available outcome measures outcome measures used to assess the clinical phenotype of Achilles tendinopathy in prospective studies and to map the outcomes measures into predefined health-related core domains.

DESIGN

Systematic review.

DATA SOURCES

Embase, MEDLINE (Ovid), Web of Science, CINAHL, The Cochrane Library, SPORTDiscus and Google Scholar.

ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA FOR SELECTING STUDIES

Clinical diagnosis of Achilles tendinopathy, sample size ≥ ten participants, age ≥ 16 years, and the study design was a randomized or non-randomized clinical trial, observational cohort, single-arm intervention, or case series.

RESULTS

9376 studies were initially screened and 307 studies were finally included, totaling 13,248 participants. There were 233 (177 core domain) different outcome measures identified across all domains. For each core domain outcome measures were identified, with a range between 8 and 35 unique outcome measures utilized for each domain. The proportion of studies that included outcomes for predefined core domains ranged from 4% for the psychological factors domain to 72% for the disability domain.

CONCLUSION

233 unique outcome measures for Achilles tendinopathy were identified. Most frequently, outcome measures were used within the disability domain. Outcome measures assessing psychological factors were scarcely used. The next step in developing a core outcome set for Achilles tendinopathy is to engage patients, clinicians and researchers to reach consensus on key outcomes measures.

PROSPERO REGISTRATION

CRD42020156763.

Gastrocnemius release is an effective management option for Achilles tendinopathy: a systematic review

PURPOSE

This systematic review aims to summarise the outcomes of gastrocnemius release in the management of Achilles Tendinopathy.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed according to PRISMA guidelines. A computer-based search was performed in PubMed, Embase, Cinahl, Scopus and ISI Web of Science. Two independent reviewers performed both title/abstract and full-text screening according to a-priori selection criteria. English-language original research studies reporting outcomes for gastrocnemius recession in patients with Achilles tendinopathy were included. Study quality and risk of bias were assessed using the MINORS criteria.

RESULTS

Of the 229 articles identified following database searching, nine studies describing 145 cases of gastrocnemius recession were included in the review. Clinically important differences were reported across a range of validated patient reported outcome scores including VISA-A, FFI, FAAM and VAS pain score. Outcomes appear to be superior in patients with noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy, however further research is required to confirm this. Studies also reported an increase in ankle dorsiflexion range of motion and a good rate of return to sport/work. The overall complication rate was 10/123 (8.1%), with sural nerve injury being the most common complication, occurring in 5/123 (4.1%) of cases.

CONCLUSION

The results of this review suggest gastrocnemius release to be an effective treatment option in the management of patients with Achilles tendinopathy, who have gastrocnemius contracture and have previously failed to respond adequately to non-operative treatment.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

Retrocalcaneal Enthesophyte Resection With Functional Lengthening of the Achilles Tendon and Buried Knot Technique: A Case Series

Retrocalcaneal exostosis can be debilitating and in severe cases, surgical resection is indicated. Complications can arise from surgical resection of the exostosis and reattachment of the Achilles tendon, including irritation of the suture knot, recurrence of the bony prominence, and dehiscence. The use of a buried knot technique with functional lengthening of the Achilles tendon and gastroc-soleal muscle complex can minimize these complications. Complete detachment of the Achilles tendon allows for aggressive and thorough resection of the exostosis and functional lengthening with reattachment. The buried cruciate knot technique allows for firm reattachment with buried knots to prevent soft tissue irritation. A total of fourteen patients (14 limbs) underwent retrocalcaneal enthesophyte resection with functional Achilles tendon lengthening, (8/14) of which had difficultly wearing shoe gear, (10/14) had edema, and (2/14) had erythema preoperatively. Postoperatively, (11/14) of patients returned to full activities and sports, and (11/14) returned to normal shoe gear. Complications included (1/14) of patients with Achilles tendon avulsion and (3/14) of patients with surgical site dehiscence requiring revisional surgery. Overall, this technique helps prevent short-term complications and long-term recurrence due to the functional lengthening mitigating insertional forces on the Achilles tendon.

Patient reported outcomes and ankle plantarflexor muscle performance following gastrocnemius recession for Achilles tendinopathy: A prospective case-control study

BACKGROUND

Prospective studies to guide the application of a gastrocnemius recession for Achilles tendinopathy are limited. Our aim was to prospectively evaluate patient reported outcomes and muscle performance.

METHODS

Patients with unilateral recalcitrant Achilles tendinopathy who received an isolated gastrocnemius recession (n=8) and a healthy control group (n=8) were included. Patient reported outcomes, ankle power during walking and stair ascent, and the heel rise limb symmetry index (total work) were collected.

RESULTS

Improvements in pain and self-reported function were observed (six months and two years). Sport participation scores reached 92% by two years. Patients demonstrated lower ankle power during stair ascent and decreased limb symmetry during heel rise six months following treatment (p≤.02).

CONCLUSIONS

Study findings regarding long-term improvements in patient pain, self-reported function and sport participation, and early preservation of ankle function during walking, can help refine patient selection, anticipated outcomes, and rehabilitation strategies.

Macroscopic changes in sural nerve after gastrocnemius recession: a cadaver study

BACKGROUND

Gastrocnemius recession is a common foot and ankle procedure and various techniques that have been utilized are mainly delineated by the anatomic position of the gastrocnemius transection; the 2 common ones are the Baumann and Strayer procedure. Both can adversely affect the sural nerve. The objective of this study was to evaluate the macroscopic changes in the sural nerve following gastrocnemius recession, and to compare the efficacy of the two procedures, regarding the improvement of maximal ankle dorsiflexion.

METHODS

Ten fresh-frozen, above knee cadaveric legs were assigned to one of two gastrocnemius recession techniques: Baumann (n = 5) or Strayer (n = 5). A goniometer was used to measure degree of ankle dorsiflexion before and after the surgery. The sural nerve was meticulously dissected and marked with two suture knots, 2 cm apart. The ankle was passively dorsiflexed from 90° to maximal dorsiflexion in 5° degree increments, and the distance between two suture knots was measured at each increment. The distance between the two cut ends of gastrocnemius muscle was measured with the ankle at 90° and at maximal dorsiflexion.

RESULTS

Overall, a mean increase in length between the suture knots on the sural nerve was 0.2 cm, from 90° to maximum ankle dorsiflexion (130°); both the Baumann and Strayer techniques resulted in 0.2 cm increase. The mean improvement in maximal ankle dorsiflexion in the Baumann and Strayer group was 22.6° and 22°, respectively. The mean change in distance between the two cut ends of the gastrocnemius muscle in the Baumann and Strayer group was 1.0 cm and 0.9 cm, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Increased dorsiflexion of the ankle following Strayer or Baumann gastrocnemius recession resulted in similar macroscopic change in the sural nerve, which may contribute to the development of sural neuritis. Further clinical studies are warranted to assess clinical implications of these findings.

Changes in Muscle Morphology Following Gastrocnemius Recession for Achilles Tendinopathy: A Prospective Cohort Imaging Study

Background. The purpose of this study was to evaluate changes in posterior compartment muscle volume and intramuscular fat content following gastrocnemius recession in people with Achilles tendinopathy (AT). Methods. Eight patients diagnosed with unilateral recalcitrant AT and an isolated gastrocnemius contracture participated in this prospective cohort study. Magnetic resonance imaging was performed on both limbs of each participant before and 6 months following an isolated gastrocnemius recession. Involved limb muscle volumes and fat fractions (FFs) of the medial gastrocnemius, lateral gastrocnemius, and soleus muscle were normalized to the uninvolved limb. Preoperative to postoperative comparisons were made with Wilcoxon signed-rank tests. Results. Soleus or lateral gastrocnemius muscle volumes or FFs were not significantly different between study time points. A significant difference was found in medial gastrocnemius muscle volume (decrease; P = .012) and FF (increase; P = .017). Conclusion. A major goal of the Strayer gastrocnemius recession, selective lengthening of the posterior compartment while preserving soleus muscle morphology, was supported. The observed changes isolated to the medial gastrocnemius muscle may reduce ankle plantarflexion torque capacity. Study findings may help inform selection of surgical candidates, refine anticipated outcomes, and better direct postoperative rehabilitation following gastrocnemius recession for AT.Levels of Evidence: Level IV: Prospective cohort study.

Meta-analysis of Noninsertional Achilles Tendinopathy

BACKGROUND

Achilles tendinopathy is a common clinical problem that can be either insertional or noninsertional. A variety of treatment methods have been described, although little consensus exists on an optimal method or methods. We sought to investigate the current evidence on different treatment methods for noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy, with a focus on functional outcomes.

METHODS

We performed a review of the available literature in PubMed and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials. Data from included studies were categorized according to treatment method and analyzed with respect to functional outcome and complication rate.

RESULTS

In total, 1420 abstracts were reviewed, of which 72 articles containing 3523 patients met inclusion criteria. Within the 72 studies included, 6 operative techniques and 19 nonoperative treatments were evaluated.

CONCLUSION

A wide variety of treatments are available for noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy, although newer treatments and most operative methods lack high-level evidence. Eccentric exercise is the most thoroughly studied and supported nonoperative treatment, while tenotomy and debridement is the operative procedure with the most evidence of efficacy. Platelet-rich plasma injections and extracorporeal shockwave therapy have proven to be viable second-line nonoperative treatments. Gastrocnemius recession and flexor hallucis longus transfer have shown benefit in case series.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II, systematic review.

A Radiographic Study of Biomechanical Relationship between the Achilles Tendon and Plantar Fascia

Background

Previously, scholars have concluded that the Achilles tendon and the plantar fascia were closely biomechanically related, although there is little clinical evidence of the relationship between the two. To investigate the biomechanical relationship between the Achilles tendon and the plantar fascia, the author used standing lateral ankle radiographs of patients with insertional Achilles tendonitis to determine the biomechanical relationship between the Achilles tendon and plantar fascia.

Methods

The author collected standing lateral ankle radiographs from patients with insertional Achilles tendonitis who accepted surgical treatment in the author's hospital from March 2009 to July 2018. According to whether there were bone spurs on the posterior side of the calcaneus, patients were divided into group A (spur present on the posterior side) and group B (spur not present on the posterior side). The positive rates of spurs on the plantar side of the calcaneus were determined in group A and group B. The chi-square test was used to compare the measurement results between the two groups.

Results

In group A, 13 heels were positive for calcaneal bone spurs, and the positive rate was 65.0%. In group B, 3 heels were positive for plantar calcaneal spurs, and the positive rate was 12%. Among all 16 patients with positive plantar calcaneal spurs, 13 had posterior calcaneal spurs (accounting for 81.3%), and 3 had negative results, accounting for 18.7%. There was a significant difference between the results in groups A and B (P < 0.05).

Conclusion

There is a relationship between posterior calcaneal spurs and plantar calcaneal spurs in patients with insertional Achilles tendonitis, which can be inferred as resulting from the increasing tension in the biomechanically complex relationship between the Achilles tendon and the plantar fascia.

[Insertional Achilles tendinopathy : Differentiated diagnostics and therapy]

Achilles tendinopathy at the calcaneal insertion is classified into insertional tendinopathy, retrocalcaneal and superficial bursitis. The aim of this study was to present the current evidence on conservative and surgical treatment of insertional tendinopathy of the Achilles tendon. Conservative first-line therapy includes reduction of activity levels, administration of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID), adaptation of footwear, heel wedges and orthoses or immobilization. In addition, further conservative therapy options are also available. Eccentric stretching exercises should be integral components of physiotherapy and can achieve a 40% reduction in pain. Extracorporeal shock wave therapy has been shown to reduce pain by 60% with a patient satisfaction of 80%. Due to the limited evidence, injections with platelet-rich plasma (PRP), dextrose (prolotherapy) or polidocanol (sclerotherapy) cannot currently be recommended. Operative therapy is indicated after 6 months of unsuccessful conservative therapy. Open debridement allows all pathologies to be addressed, including osseous abnormalities and intratendinous necrosis. The success rate of over 70% is contrasted by complication rates of up to 40%. The Achilles tendon should be reattached, if detached by >50%. No valid data are available for the transfer of the tendon of the flexor hallucis longus (FHL) muscle but it is frequently applied in cases of more than 50% debridement of the diameter of the Achilles tendon. Lengthening of the gastrocnemius muscle cannot be recommended because insufficient data are available. Tendoscopy is a promising treatment option for isolated retrocalcaneal bursitis and has shown similar success rates to open debridement with significantly lower complication rates.

Prevalence of Asymptomatic Achilles Tendinosis

BACKGROUND

Most patients who sustain Achilles tendon ruptures (ATRs) have no clinical symptoms prior to ATR. The objective of this study was to define the prevalence of ultrasound-detectable Achilles tendinopathy in asymptomatic patients in an at-risk group.

METHODS

This was a cross-sectional study that collected data from a group of volunteers. All participants were given IPAQ questionnaires to gauge daily activity level, in addition to a demographic form. Participants underwent a physical examination, Silfverskiold test, and an ultrasonographic examination to evaluate for presence of Achilles tendinopathy. Fifty-one volunteers (30 female, 21 male) and 102 Achilles tendons were assessed in this study. The mean age was 27.4±6.3, with an average BMI of 23.5±3.9. Ninety-two percent of participants were categorized as having moderate or high activity levels per the iPAQ questionnaire.

RESULTS

Sixteen tendons had at least 1 abnormality: 10 (9.8%) had hypoechoic foci, 9 (8.8%) had calcifications, 1 (0.9%) had increased vascularity, and 1 (0.9%) had a low-grade interstitial tear. Approximately 40% of patients were noted to have a gastroc equinus contracture on Silfverskiold testing. In addition, 14.7% of patients with a gastroc equinus had a hypoechoic focus compared to 8.6% of patients without gastroc equinus ( P = .5003). Logistic regression analysis demonstrated that an increased BMI was a significant risk factor for having an Achilles tendon abnormality on ultrasonography ( P < .01, odds ratio = 1.41).

CONCLUSION

In this study, 16% of the Achilles tendons were abnormal and had at least 1 abnormality on ultrasonography. This group of patients was generally young, healthy, and active, thus a group at risk for ATRs. Only 40% of patients had gastrocnemius equinus, although a slightly higher non-significant percentage of those with hypoechoic foci had gastrocnemius equinus. It may be advantageous to prophylactically treat these patients with rehabilitation exercises to minimize the risk of ATR.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II, comparative prognostic study.