Brainwave entrainment for the treatment of chronic pain: comment on Br J Pain 2020; 14: 161-70

How to entrain a selected neuronal rhythm but not others: open-loop dithered brain stimulation for selective entrainment

Objective.While brain stimulation therapies such as deep brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease (PD) can be effective, they have yet to reach their full potential across neurological disorders. Entraining neuronal rhythms using rhythmic brain stimulation has been suggested as a new therapeutic mechanism to restore neurotypical behaviour in conditions such as chronic pain, depression, and Alzheimer's disease. However, theoretical and experimental evidence indicate that brain stimulation can also entrain neuronal rhythms at sub- and super-harmonics, far from the stimulation frequency. Crucially, these counterintuitive effects could be harmful to patients, for example by triggering debilitating involuntary movements in PD. We therefore seek a principled approach to selectively promote rhythms close to the stimulation frequency, while avoiding potential harmful effects by preventing entrainment at sub- and super-harmonics.Approach.Our open-loop approach to selective entrainment, dithered stimulation, consists in adding white noise to the stimulation period.Main results.We theoretically establish the ability of dithered stimulation to selectively entrain a given brain rhythm, and verify its efficacy in simulations of uncoupled neural oscillators, and networks of coupled neural oscillators. Furthermore, we show that dithered stimulation can be implemented in neurostimulators with limited capabilities by toggling within a finite set of stimulation frequencies.Significance.Likely implementable across a variety of existing brain stimulation devices, dithering-based selective entrainment has potential to enable new brain stimulation therapies, as well as new neuroscientific research exploiting its ability to modulate higher-order entrainment.

The efficacy of sensory neural entrainment on acute and chronic pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Background

Changes to the power of neural oscillations in cortical and sub-cortical structures can change pain perception. Rhythmic sensory stimulation is a non-invasive method that can increase power in specific frequencies of neural oscillations. If the stimulation frequency targets those frequencies related to pain perception, such as alpha or theta frequencies, there can be a reduction in perceived pain intensity. Thus, sensory neural entrainment may provide an alternative to pharmacological intervention for acute and chronic pain. This review aimed to identify and critically appraise the evidence on the effectiveness of sensory entrainment methods for pain perception.

Methods

We undertook a systematic search across Medline, Embase, PsycInfo, Web of Science and Scopus in November 2020 to identify studies investigating the efficacy of sensory entrainment on adults. We assessed studies for their quality using the PRISMA checklist. A random-effects model was used in a meta-analysis to measure the effect of entrainment on pain perception.

Results

Our systematic review yielded nine studies fitting the search criteria. Studies investigated the effect of visual and auditory entrainment on pain intensity rating, electrophysiological markers of pain and amount of analgesia needed during surgery. The meta-analysis suggests that alpha (8–13 Hz) sensory entrainment is effective for acute pain perception, whereas theta (4–7 Hz) entrainment is effective for chronic pain.

Conclusions

Although there is heterogeneity in the current evidence, our review highlights the potential use of sensory entrainment to affect acute and chronic pain. Further research is required regarding the timing, duration and frequency of the stimulation to determine the best application for maximum efficacy.