Reintegration of Women Post Obstetric Fistula Repair: Experience of Family Caregivers

The economic consequences of obstetric fistula: A systematic search and narrative review

BACKGROUND

Obstetric fistula develops from obstructed labor and is a devastating condition with significant consequences across several domains of a woman's life. This study presents a narrative review of the evidence on the economic consequences of obstetric fistula.

METHODS

Three databases were searched, and search results were limited to English language papers published after 2003. Search results were reviewed for relevance based on title and abstract followed by full text review using specific inclusion and exclusion criteria. Bibliographies of papers were also scanned to identify relevant papers for inclusion. Data were extracted under three categories (defined a priori): the economic consequences of having the condition, the economic consequences of seeking care, and the macroeconomic impacts.

RESULTS

The search returned 517 unique papers, 49 of which were included after screening. Main findings identified from the studies include women losing their jobs, becoming dependent on others, and losing financial support when relationships are lost. Seeking care was economically costly for families or unaffordable entirely. There were no studies describing the impact of fistula on national economies.

CONCLUSION

Economic consequences of obstetric fistula are multifaceted, pervasive, and are intertwined with the physical and psychosocial consequences of the condition. Understanding these consequences can help tailor existing fistula programs to better address the impacts of the condition. Further research to address the dearth of literature describing the macroeconomic impact of obstetric fistula will be critical to enhance the visibility of this condition on the health agendas of countries.

Women's sexual activity and experiences following female genital fistula surgery

BACKGROUND

Surgical repair has a transformative impact on the lives of women affected by female genital fistula; however, various physical, social, and economic challenges may persist postrepair and prevent complete reengagement in relationships and communities. Nuanced investigation of these experiences is needed to inform programming that aligns with women's reintegration needs.

AIM

We investigated the sexual activity resumption, experiences, and concerns of women in Uganda during the year following genital fistula repair surgery.

METHODS

Women were recruited from Mulago Hospital between December 2014 and June 2015. We collected data at baseline and 4 times postsurgery about sociodemographic characteristics and physical/psychosocial status; we also assessed sexual interest and satisfaction twice. We performed in-depth interviews with a subset of participants. We analyzed quantitative findings via univariate analyses, and qualitative findings were coded and analyzed thematically.

OUTCOMES

We assessed sexual readiness, fears, and challenges following surgical repair of female genital fistula using quantitative and qualitative measures of sexual activity, pain with sex, sexual interest/disinterest, and sexual satisfaction/dissatisfaction.

RESULTS

Among the 60 participants, 18% were sexually active at baseline, which decreased to 7% postsurgery and increased to 55% at 1 year after repair. Dyspareunia was reported by 27% at baseline and 10% at 1 year; few described leakage during sex or vaginal dryness. Qualitative findings showed wide variance of sexual experiences. Some reported sexual readiness quickly after surgery, and some were not ready after 1 year. For all, fears included fistula recurrence and unwanted pregnancy.

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest that postrepair sexual experiences vary widely and intersect meaningfully with marital and social roles following fistula and repair. In addition to physical repair, ongoing psychosocial support is needed for comprehensive reintegration and the restoration of desired sexuality.

HIGHLIGHTS

The social, economic, emotional, and physical experiences of caregivers for women with female genital fistula in Uganda: A qualitative study

ABSTRACTThis study aimed to explore the firsthand experiences of informal primary caregivers of women with female genital fistula in Uganda. Caregivers that accompanied women for surgery at Mulago National Teaching and Referral Hospital were recruited between January and September 2015. Caregivers participated in in-depth interviews and focus groups. Data were analysed thematically and informed adaptation of a conceptual framework. Of 43 caregivers, 84% were female, 95% family members, and most married and formally employed. Caregivers engaged in myriad personal care and household responsibilities, and described being on call for an average of 22.5 h per day. Four overlapping themes emerged highlighting social, economic, emotional, and physical experiences/consequences. The caregiving experience was informed by specific caregiver circumstances (e.g. personal characteristics, care needs of their patient) and dynamic stressors/supports within the caregiver's social context. These results demonstrate that caregivers' lived social, economic, emotional, and physical experiences and consequences are influenced by both social factors and individual characteristics of both the caregiver and their patient. This study may inform programmes and policies that increase caregiving supports while mitigating caregiving stressors to enhance the caregiving experience, and ultimately ensure its feasibility, particularly in settings with constrained resources.

A Quantitative Study on Stigma and Statistically Correlated Factors Among Women Living with Genital Fistula in Oromia Region, Ethiopia. Identification of Urgent Corrective Strategies

Background

Two-to-three million women worldwide live with a genital fistula, with Asian and sub-Saharan African countries including Ethiopia accounting for the greatest percentage. Genital fistula is a devastating health problem due to the stigma associated with constant incontinence and bad-odor. Thus, this study aimed to determine the magnitude of the stigma towards women living with genital fistula in Oromia region, Ethiopia, and to highlight the factors associated with it, identifying potential strategies for corrective interventions.

Methods

This quantitative study was conducted among 422 women living with genital fistula in five fistula treatment centers of Oromia region using a cross-sectional study design from August 30, 2019 to February 28, 2020. Data were collected by face-to-face interview using a structured questionnaire, entered into Epi-data version 4.2, and analyzed by SPSS version 23. Bivariate and multivariable logistic regression analysis was done. P-value <0.05 was used to ascertain statistical significance with an adjusted odds ratio at 95% confidence interval (CI). The results were presented by text and tables.

Results

The response rate for this study was 100%. The magnitude of perceived high stigma related to genital fistula was 178 (42.2%). The factors associated with it were the respondents’ father’s educational level of being able to write and read compared to unknown fathers’ educational level (AOR=0.09; 95% CI=0.03–0.34), and duration of living with a genital fistula of less than 2 years compared to living with a genital fistula for 5 years or more (AOR=0.52; 95% CI=0.31–0.86).

Conclusion

The perceived level of stigma among women living with a genital fistula in Oromia region was significantly high. To reduce the perceived level of stigma and therefore to prevent the severe negative consequences of it, fathers, but also mothers, husbands, family members, and all the persons close to women living with genital fistulas should provide care and psychological support and all the necessary means to strongly encourage them to seek health care quickly, and to make them feel that they are beloved, and that there is hope for a healthy life in their near future.

Social support for women after fistula repair: A scoping review

BACKGROUND

Obstetric fistula (OF) is a birth complication that largely affects women in developing countries. These women suffer constant incontinence, shame, social segregation, and health problems. Reconstructive surgery can usually repair OF, enabling the women to reintegrate back into their communities. However, pro repair does not necessarily equate with emotional recovery. Our objective was to explore women's experiences of social support after first time OF repair.

METHODS

An evidence synthesis was performed based on a systematic search of literature done between January and March 2020 in PubMed, CINAHL, ProQuest, and EMBASE databases using keywords including "obstetric fistula", "vesicovaginal fistula", "vesicovaginal", "fistula", and "social support". Inclusion criteria were primary peer reviewed articles addressing one or more study objectives, in English, on OF support, regardless of location. Two reviewers independently assessed eligibility of the studies and extracted the data. Disagreement between the reviewers were resolved by a third reviewer. The scoping review was based on a framework proposed by Arksey and O'Malley (2015).

RESULTS

The search resulted in 246 articles, of which 14 met inclusion/exclusion criteria. The synthesis of the studies was theoretically guided by Berkman's Model which emphasizes a link between social resources, social support, and disease. We found that support was either internal or external. Internal support constituted self-efficacy resulting in strengthened internal locus of control. Externally, women were supported by friends and family with material and financial resources. In some cases, the women were supported with educational opportunities and/or business start-up capital. Our review identified the need to support women with information about OF. Most post-OF repair women who were successfully re-integrated into their communities choose to support other women suffering from OF.

CONCLUSIONS

Social networks make a significant contribution to emotional and psychological recovery of women after a successful OF surgical repair. Lack of social networks were also found to be detrimental to emotional and psychological recovery of women. Most women were abandoned and not supported by their husbands. Restorative surgery is not sufficient making supportive and well organised social networks an integral component of full recovery post-OF repair.

"I am a person but I am not a person": experiences of women living with obstetric fistula in the central region of Malawi

BACKGROUND

The consequences of living with obstetric fistula are multifaceted and very devastating for women, especially those living in poor resource settings. Due to uncontrollable leakages of urine and/or feces, the condition leaves women with peeling of skin on their private parts, and the wetness and smell subject them to stigmatization, ridicule, shame and social isolation. We sought to gain a deeper understanding of lived experiences of women with obstetric fistula in Malawi, in order to recommend interventions that would both prevent new cases of obstetric fistula as well as improve the quality of life for those already affected.

METHODS

We conducted semi-structured interviews with 25 women with obstetric fistula at Bwaila Fistula Care Center in Lilongwe and in its surrounding districts. We interviewed twenty women at Bwaila Fistula Care Center; five additional women were identified through snowball sampling and were interviewed in their homes. We also interviewed twenty family members. To analyze the data, we used thematic analysis. Data were categorized using Nvivo 10. Goffman's theory of stigma was used to inform the data analysis.

RESULTS

All the women in this study were living a socially restricted and disrupted life due to a fear of involuntary disclosure and embarrassment. Therefore, "anticipated" as opposed to "enacted" stigma was especially prevalent among the participants. Many lost their positive self-image due to incontinence and smell. As a way to avoid shame and embarrassment, these women avoided public gatherings; such as markets, church, funerals and weddings, thus losing part of their social identity. Participants had limited knowledge about their condition.

CONCLUSION

The anticipation of stigma by women in this study consequently limited their social lives. This fear of stigma might have arisen from previous knowledge of social norms concerning bowel and bladder control, which do not take into account an illness like obstetric fistula. This misconception might have also arisen from lack of knowledge about causes of the condition itself. There is need therefore to create awareness and educate women and their communities about the causes of obstetric fistula, its prevention and treatment, which may help to prevent fistula as well as reduce all dimensions of stigma, and consequently increase dignity and quality of life for these women.