Target Validation Using PROTACs: Applying the Four Pillars Framework

Transforming the Discovery of Targeted Protein Degraders: The Translational Power of Predictive PK/PD Modeling

Targeted protein degraders (TPDs), an emerging therapeutic modality, are attracting considerable interest with the promise to address disease-related proteins that are not druggable with conventional small molecule inhibitors. Despite their novel mechanism of action, the PK/PD relationship of degraders is still approached with a mindset deeply rooted in inhibitor drugs. Here, we establish how predictive mechanistic modeling specifically tailored to TPDs can significantly enhance the value of the available information during lead generation and optimization. By integrating the results from in vitro assays with routinely collected PK data, modeling accurately predicts degradation in vivo. These predictions transform the prioritization of compounds for in vivo studies as well as the selection of optimal dose schedules and most informative measurement time points with the least number of animals. Moreover, the comprehensive modeling framework (1) identifies the PK/PD driver of targeted protein degradation and subsequent downstream pharmacodynamic effects, and (2) uncovers the fundamental difference between degrader and inhibitor PK/PD relationships. The practical utility of our predictive modeling is demonstrated with relevant use cases. This framework will allow researchers to transition from current, mostly serendipity-based approaches to more sound model-informed decision making. Going forward, the presented predictive PK/PD modeling framework lays out a rational path to incorporate inter-species differences in the pharmacology and thus promises to help with getting the dose right in clinical trials.

Transcriptome-Wide, Unbiased Profiling of Ribonuclease Targeting Chimeras

Various approaches have been developed to target RNA and modulate its function with modes of action including binding and cleavage. Herein, we explored how small molecule binding is correlated with cleavage induced by heterobifunctional ribonuclease targeting chimeras (RiboTACs), where RNase L is recruited to cleave the bound RNA target, in a transcriptome-wide, unbiased fashion. Only a fraction of bound targets was cleaved by RNase L, induced by RiboTAC binding. Global analysis suggested that (i) cleaved targets generally form a region of stable structure that encompasses the small molecule binding site; (ii) cleaved targets have preferred RNase L cleavage sites nearby small molecule binding sites; (iii) RiboTACs facilitate a cellular interaction between cleaved targets and RNase L; and (iv) the expression level of the target influences the extent of cleavage observed. In one example, we converted a binder of LGALS1 (galectin-1) mRNA into a RiboTAC. In MDA-MB-231 cells, the binder had no effect on galectin-1 protein levels, while the RiboTAC cleaved LGALS1 mRNA, reduced galectin-1 protein abundance, and affected galectin-1-associated oncogenic cellular phenotypes. Using LGALS1, we further assessed additional factors including the length of the linker that tethers the two components of the RiboTAC, cellular uptake, and the RNase L-recruiting module on RiboTAC potency. Collectively, these studies may facilitate triangulation of factors to enable the design of RiboTACs.

Chemo-proteomics in antimalarial target identification and engagement

Humans have lived in tenuous battle with malaria over millennia. Today, while much of the world is free of the disease, areas of South America, Asia, and Africa still wage this war with substantial impacts on their social and economic development. The threat of widespread resistance to all currently available antimalarial therapies continues to raise concern. Therefore, it is imperative that novel antimalarial chemotypes be developed to populate the pipeline going forward. Phenotypic screening has been responsible for the majority of the new chemotypes emerging in the past few decades. However, this can result in limited information on the molecular target of these compounds which may serve as an unknown variable complicating their progression into clinical development. Target identification and validation is a process that incorporates techniques from a range of different disciplines. Chemical biology and more specifically chemo-proteomics have been heavily utilized for this purpose. This review provides an in-depth summary of the application of chemo-proteomics in antimalarial development. Here we focus particularly on the methodology, practicalities, merits, and limitations of designing these experiments. Together this provides learnings on the future use of chemo-proteomics in antimalarial development.

Clinical Translation of Targeted Protein Degraders

Targeted protein degradation (TPD) has emerged as a potentially transformational therapeutic modality with considerable promise. Molecular glue degraders remodel the surface of E3 ligases inducing interactions with neosubstrates resulting in their polyubiquitination and proteasomal degradation. Molecular glues are clinically precedented and have demonstrated the ability to degrade proteins-of-interest (POIs) previously deemed undruggable due to the absence of a traditional small molecule binding pocket. Heterobifunctional proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs) possess ligands for an E3 complex and the POIs, which are chemically linked together, and similarly hijack the ubiquitin machinery to deplete the target. There has been a recent surge in the number of degraders entering clinical trials, particularly directed toward cancer. Nearly all utilize CRL4CRBN as the E3 ligase, and a relatively limited diversity of POIs are currently targeted. In this review, we provide an overview of the degraders in clinical trials and provide a perspective on the lessons learned from their development and emerging human data that will be broadly useful to those working in the TPD field.

How many kinases are druggable? A review of our current understanding

There are over 500 human kinases ranging from very well-studied to almost completely ignored. Kinases are tractable and implicated in many diseases, making them ideal targets for medicinal chemistry campaigns, but is it possible to discover a drug for each individual kinase? For every human kinase, we gathered data on their citation count, availability of chemical probes, approved and investigational drugs, PDB structures, and biochemical and cellular assays. Analysis of these factors highlights which kinase groups have a wealth of information available, and which groups still have room for progress. The data suggest a disproportionate focus on the more well characterized kinases while much of the kinome remains comparatively understudied. It is noteworthy that tool compounds for understudied kinases have already been developed, and there is still untapped potential for further development in this chemical space. Finally, this review discusses many of the different strategies employed to generate selectivity between kinases. Given the large volume of information available and the progress made over the past 20 years when it comes to drugging kinases, we believe it is possible to develop a tool compound for every human kinase. We hope this review will prove to be both a useful resource as well as inspire the discovery of a tool for every kinase.

The rise of degrader drugs

The cancer genomics revolution has served up a plethora of promising and challenging targets for the drug discovery community. The field of targeted protein degradation (TPD) uses small molecules to reprogram the protein homeostasis system to destroy desired target proteins. In the last decade, remarkable progress has enabled the rational development of degraders for a large number of target proteins, with over 20 molecules targeting more than 12 proteins entering clinical development. While TPD has been fully credentialed by the prior development of immunomodulatory drug (IMiD) class for the treatment of multiple myeloma, the field is poised for a "Gleevec moment" in which robust clinical efficacy of a rationally developed novel degrader against a preselected target is firmly established. Here, we endeavor to provide a high-level evaluation of exciting developments in the field and comment on steps that may realize the full potential of this new therapeutic modality.

Catalytic Degraders Effectively Address Kinase Site Mutations in EML4-ALK Oncogenic Fusions

Heterobifunctional degraders, known as proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs), theoretically possess a catalytic mode-of-action, yet few studies have either confirmed or exploited this potential advantage of event-driven pharmacology. Degraders of oncogenic EML4-ALK fusions were developed by conjugating ALK inhibitors to cereblon ligands. Simultaneous optimization of pharmacology and compound properties using ternary complex modeling and physicochemical considerations yielded multiple catalytic degraders that were more resilient to clinically relevant ATP-binding site mutations than kinase inhibitor drugs. Our strategy culminated in the design of the orally bioavailable derivative CPD-1224 that avoided hemolysis (a feature of detergent-like PROTACs), degraded the otherwise recalcitrant mutant L1196M/G1202R in vivo, and commensurately slowed tumor growth, while the third generation ALK inhibitor drug lorlatinib had no effect. These results validate our original therapeutic hypothesis by exemplifying opportunities for catalytic degraders to proactively address binding site resistant mutations in cancer.

Delivering on the promise of protein degraders

Over the past 3 years, the first bivalent protein degraders intentionally designed for targeted protein degradation (TPD) have advanced to clinical trials, with an initial focus on established targets. Most of these clinical candidates are designed for oral administration, and many discovery efforts appear to be similarly focused. As we look towards the future, we propose that an oral-centric discovery paradigm will overly constrain the chemical designs that are considered and limit the potential to drug novel targets. In this Perspective, we summarize the current state of the bivalent degrader modality and propose three categories of degrader designs, based on their likely route of administration and requirement for drug delivery technologies. We then describe a vision for how parenteral drug delivery, implemented early in research and supported by pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic modelling, can enable exploration of a broader drug design space, expand the scope of accessible targets and deliver on the promise of protein degraders as a therapeutic modality.

Advancing targeted protein degrader discovery by measuring cereblon engagement in cells

Measurement of target engagement in cells is critical to understand the molecular pharmacology of drugs and chemical probes. Many targeted protein degraders engage the E3 ligase CRL4^CRBN and induce proximity with target neosubstrates resulting in their polyubiquitination and subsequent proteasomal degradation. Here we describe the development of a sensitive and robust cellular NanoBRET-based assay that measures occupancy of the CRBN ligand binding site. The assay is based on a bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) between NanoLuc luciferase tagged CRBN and a BODIPY-lenalidomide tracer which can be competed out by CRBN ligands, including PROTACs and molecular glues. The assay is compatible with a 384-well plate setup, does not require transfections and can be performed in a single day with only 3-4h of laboratory time. The protocols can be used to design other NanoLuc fusion engagement assays based on BODIPY tracers.

A Mechanistic Pharmacodynamic Modeling Framework for the Assessment and Optimization of Proteolysis Targeting Chimeras (PROTACs)

The field of targeted protein degradation is growing exponentially. Yet, there is an unmet need for pharmacokinetic/pharmacodynamic models that provide mechanistic insights, while also being practically useful in a drug discovery setting. Therefore, we have developed a comprehensive modeling framework which can be applied to experimental data from routine projects to: (1) assess PROTACs based on accurate degradation metrics, (2) guide compound optimization of the most critical parameters, and (3) link degradation to downstream pharmacodynamic effects. The presented framework contains a number of first-time features: (1) a mechanistic model to fit the hook effect in the PROTAC concentration-degradation profile, (2) quantification of the role of target occupancy in the PROTAC mechanism of action and (3) deconvolution of the effects of target degradation and target inhibition by PROTACs on the overall pharmacodynamic response. To illustrate applicability and to build confidence, we have employed these three models to analyze exemplary data on various compounds from different projects and targets. The presented framework allows researchers to tailor their experimental work and to arrive at a better understanding of their results, ultimately leading to more successful PROTAC discovery. While the focus here lies on in vitro pharmacology experiments, key implications for in vivo studies are also discussed.

Biologics-based degraders - an expanding toolkit for targeted-protein degradation

Targeted protein degradation (TPD) is a broadly useful proteome editing tool for biological research and therapeutic development. TPD offers several advantages over functional inhibition alone, including the ability to target previously undruggable proteins and the substantial and sustained knockout of protein activity. A variety of small molecule approaches hijack endogenous protein degradation machinery, but are limited to proteins with a cytosolic domain and suitable binding pocket. Recently, biologics-based methods have expanded the TPD toolbox by allowing access to extracellular and surface-exposed proteins and increasing target specificity. Here, we summarize recent advances in the use of biologics to deplete proteins through either the ubiquitin-proteasome system or the lysosomal degradation pathway, and discuss routes to their effective delivery as potential therapeutic interventions.

Emerging degrader technologies engaging lysosomal pathways

Targeted protein degradation (TPD) provides unprecedented opportunities for drug discovery. While the proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC) technology has already entered clinical trials and changed the landscape of small-molecule drugs, new degrader technologies harnessing alternative degradation machineries, especially lysosomal pathways, have emerged and broadened the spectrum of degradable targets. We have recently proposed the concept of autophagy-tethering compounds (ATTECs) that hijack the autophagy protein microtubule-associated protein 1A/1B light chain 3 (LC3) for targeted degradation. Other groups also reported degrader technologies engaging lysosomal pathways through different mechanisms including AUTACs, AUTOTACs, LYTACs and MoDE-As. In this review, we analyse and discuss ATTECs along with other lysosomal-relevant degrader technologies. Finally, we will briefly summarize the current status of these degrader technologies and envision possible future studies.

PROTACs: Current Trends in Protein Degradation by Proteolysis-Targeting Chimeras

In the recent past, proteolysis-targeting chimera (PROTAC) technology has received enormous attention for its ability to overcome the limitations of protein inhibitors and its capability to target undruggable proteins. The PROTAC molecule consists of three components, a ubiquitin E3 ligase ligand, a linker, and a target protein ligand. The application of this technology is rapidly gaining momentum, especially in cancer therapy. In this review, we first look at the history of degraders, followed by a section on the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS) and E3 ligases used in PROTAC development. PROTACs are dependent on the UPS for degradation of target proteins. We further discuss the scope and design of degraders and mitigation strategies for overcoming the hook effect seen with degraders. As PROTACs do not follow Lipinski's 'Rule of 5', these molecules face drug metabolism and pharmacokinetic challenges. A detailed section on absorption, distribution, metabolism, and excretion of degraders is provided wherein we discuss methodologies and strategies to surmount the challenges faced by these molecules. For understanding PROTAC-mediated degradation, the characterization and measurement of protein levels in cells is important. Currently used techniques and recent advancements in assessment tools for degraders are discussed. Furthermore, we examine the challenges and emerging technologies that need to be focused on in order to competently develop potent degraders. Many companies are working in this area of emerging new modality and a few PROTACs have already entered clinical trials; the details of the trials are included in this review.

Monobodies as tool biologics for accelerating target validation and druggable site discovery

Despite increased investment and technological advancement, new drug approvals have not proportionally increased. Low drug approval rates, particularly for new targets, are linked to insufficient target validation at early stages. Thus, there remains a strong need for effective target validation techniques. Here, we review the use of synthetic binding proteins as tools for drug target validation, with focus on the monobody platform among several advanced synthetic binding protein platforms. Monobodies with high affinity and high selectivity can be rapidly developed against challenging targets, such as KRAS mutants, using protein engineering technologies. They have strong tendency to bind to functional sites and thus serve as drug-like molecules, and they can serve as targeting ligands for constructing bio-PROTACs. Genetically encoded monobodies are effective "tool biologics" for validating intracellular targets. They promote crystallization and help reveal the atomic structures of the monobody-target interface, which can inform drug design. Using case studies, we illustrate the potential of the monobody technology in accelerating target validation and small-molecule drug discovery.

Intelligent host engineering for metabolic flux optimisation in biotechnology

Optimising the function of a protein of length N amino acids by directed evolution involves navigating a 'search space' of possible sequences of some 20N. Optimising the expression levels of P proteins that materially affect host performance, each of which might also take 20 (logarithmically spaced) values, implies a similar search space of 20P. In this combinatorial sense, then, the problems of directed protein evolution and of host engineering are broadly equivalent. In practice, however, they have different means for avoiding the inevitable difficulties of implementation. The spare capacity exhibited in metabolic networks implies that host engineering may admit substantial increases in flux to targets of interest. Thus, we rehearse the relevant issues for those wishing to understand and exploit those modern genome-wide host engineering tools and thinking that have been designed and developed to optimise fluxes towards desirable products in biotechnological processes, with a focus on microbial systems. The aim throughput is 'making such biology predictable'. Strategies have been aimed at both transcription and translation, especially for regulatory processes that can affect multiple targets. However, because there is a limit on how much protein a cell can produce, increasing kcat in selected targets may be a better strategy than increasing protein expression levels for optimal host engineering.

Unifying Catalysis Framework to Dissect Proteasomal Degradation Paradigms

Diverging from traditional target inhibition, proteasomal protein degradation approaches have emerged as novel therapeutic modalities that embody distinct pharmacological profiles and can access previously undrugged targets. Small molecule degraders have the potential to catalytically destroy target proteins at substoichiometric concentrations, thus lowering administered doses and extending pharmacological effects. With this mechanistic premise, research efforts have advanced the development of small molecule degraders that benefit from stable and increased affinity ternary complexes. However, a holistic framework that evaluates different degradation modes from a catalytic perspective, including focusing on kinetically favored degradation mechanisms, is lacking. In this Outlook, we introduce the concept of an induced cooperativity spectrum as a unifying framework to mechanistically understand catalytic degradation profiles. This framework is bolstered by key examples of published molecular degraders extending from molecular glues to bivalent degraders. Critically, we discuss remaining challenges and future opportunities in drug discovery to rationally design and phenotypically screen for efficient degraders.

Reviewing the toolbox for degrader development in oncology

The field of targeted protein degradation encompasses a growing number of modalities that achieve potent and selective knockdown of target proteins at the post-translational level. Among the most clinically advanced are bifunctional small-molecule degraders, also referred to as PROteolysis Targeting Chimeras, Degronimids, SNIPERs, or uSMITEs. Although applicable to many disease indications, oncology stands to be the first to benefit from this promising therapeutic approach, with the first investigational new drugs (INDs) filed in 2019 and a proliferation of research specifically focused on harnessing degraders for cancer treatment. In this review, we consider the toolbox of guidelines, reagents, and technologies that has evolved alongside the field to support degrader research and development.

A Phenotypic Approach for the Identification of New Molecules for Targeted Protein Degradation Applications

Targeted protein degradation is an emerging new strategy for the modulation of intracellular protein levels with applications in chemical biology and drug discovery. One approach to enable this strategy is to redirect the ubiquitin-proteasome system to mark and degrade target proteins of interest (POIs) through the use of proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs). Although great progress has been made in enabling PROTACs as a platform, there are still a limited number of E3 ligases that have been employed for PROTAC design. Herein we report a novel phenotypic screening approach for the identification of E3 ligase binders. The key concept underlying this approach is the high-throughput modification of screening compounds with a chloroalkane moiety to generate HaloPROTACs in situ, which were then evaluated for their ability to degrade a GFP-HaloTag fusion protein in a cellular context. As proof of concept, we demonstrated that we could generate and detect functional HaloPROTACs in situ, using a validated Von Hippel-Lindau (VHL) binder that successfully degraded the GFP-HaloTag fusion protein in living cells. We then used this method to prepare and screen a library of approximately 2000 prospective E3 ligase-recruiting molecules.