Transoral Chondrolaryngoplasty: Scarless Reduction of the Adam's Apple

Transoral Feminizing Chondrolaryngoplasty: Development and Deployment of a Novel Approach in 77 Patients

Importance: Transgender patients who desire a gender-congruent neck contour may forego transcutaneous procedures due to the risk of neck scar stigmata related to such procedures. Objective: To describe the development and experience with the first 77 cases of a novel gasless transvestibular technique for gender-affirming surgery of the laryngeal prominence. Design, Setting, Participants: Video and narrative description of a novel surgical technique, and case series describing the consecutive first 77 patients to undergo transoral chondrolaryngoplasty (TCLP) at a quaternary transgender referral center. Results: Between November 2019 and April 2022, 77 patients underwent the novel surgery of TCLP. Median follow-up was 8.74 months (range: 1-30 months). Four patients suffered surgical complications (two laryngotomy, two skin necrosis), and three patients requested revision surgery. Conclusions and Relevance: TCLP is reported in the largest published series to date offering hidden incision for gender-affirming care. With further prospective outcome investigations, TCLP may prove to be a reliable approach of performing chondrolaryngoplasty while avoiding visible neck incisions.

Outcome of isolated and combined direct feminization laryngochondroplasty: Our first 20 cases

This retrospective study describes the surgical outcomes of our first 20 transgender women to undergo feminization thyroid laryngochondroplasty (FLC) by a direct transvestibular FLC (DTV-FLC) approach from December 2019 to October 2023. The medical records of all patients were retrieved and reviewed. Data on the operative, postoperative, and follow-up courses, complications, and functional and cosmetic outcomes were retrieved. The cosmetic results were evaluated by four independent facial plastic surgeons. Thirteen patients underwent DTV-FLC combined with genioplasty or genioplasty with mandibular angle reduction and seven underwent isolated DTV-FLC. DTV-FLC was feasible in all planned cases. Complications (skin flap perforation, thyroid cartilage fracture, mental hypoesthesia, hematoma, dehiscence of the vestibular incision, vestibular scar adhesions, and anemia) were minor and resolved spontaneously. The preoperative grade of thyroid cartilage protrusion was 1.9 ± 0.9 on a scale from 1 to 3. The postoperative cosmetic results of 18 patients were judged as having improved (a score of 2.1 ± 0.8 on a scale from -1 to 3). Eighteen patients were satisfied with the cosmetic result, one was dissatisfied (the revision surgery patient), and one was lost to follow-up. In conclusion, DTV-FTLC is a valid surgical approach for FLC, yielding high patient satisfaction and good cosmetic results.

Optimizing Safety and Aesthetics in Facial Feminization: Laryngoscopic-Assisted Chondrolaryngoplasty (2019-2023)

INTRODUCTION

The thyroid cartilage, an androgen-sensitive structure, enlarges during puberty in individuals assigned male at birth, often resulting in a pronounced neck protuberance. This feature can exacerbate gender dysphoria in transfeminine patients. Chondrolaryngoplasty, commonly known as tracheal shave, is a procedure incorporated into facial feminization surgery (FFS) to address this issue. This study reports on the implementation of an endoscopic-assisted chondrolaryngoplasty technique, its safety, and the outcomes observed.

METHODS

The authors conducted a retrospective review of chondrolaryngoplasty cases at our center, examining patient outcomes and procedural safety. The analysis included a breakdown of concurrent gender-affirming surgeries performed. An endoscopic-guided technique was utilized, and its procedural steps were documented in a video.

RESULTS

In the past five years, 32 patients received chondrolaryngoplasty at our facility. Postoperative complications were minimal, with no infections, wound separations, or surgical site complications reported. Only one patient experienced temporary hoarseness, which resolved within 6 weeks without intervention. The procedure was frequently combined with other surgical interventions, with the average patient undergoing 3 additional procedures, the most common being augmentation mammaplasty, brow lifting, and frontal bone reduction.

CONCLUSIONS

Tracheal shave is an effective surgical technique for alleviating gender dysphoria in transfeminine patients. Keys to its success include the accurate identification of thyroid cartilage, especially in patients with enlarged cricoid cartilages, intraoperative coordination with anesthesia for laryngoscopic vocal cord visualization, sub-perichondrial cartilage excision to minimize the risk of bleeding and damage near the vocal cords, and carefully layered closure to optimize scar healing.

Direct Transvestibular Feminization Thyroid Laryngochondroplasty

BACKGROUND

Feminization laryngochondroplasty (FLC) methods have evolved from using a midcervical incision to a submental, less visible incision. The scar may be unacceptable to the patient because it signals gender reassignment surgery. An endoscopic transoral approach to FLC inspired by transoral endoscopic thyroidectomy was recently suggested to avoid the neck scar; however, it requires special equipment and has a long learning curve. A vestibular incision is used to approach the chin in lower-third facial feminization surgery. The authors propose that this incision may be extended to the thyroid cartilage in performing direct FLCs. The authors describe their experience with a novel, minimally invasive, direct transvestibular use of the chin-reshaping incision.

METHODS

The medical records of all patients who underwent direct transvestibular FLC (DTV-FLC) from December of 2019 to September of 2021 were retrieved and reviewed for this retrospective cohort study. Data on the operative, postoperative, and follow-up courses, complications, and functional and cosmetic results were retrieved.

RESULTS

Nine transgender women were included. Seven DTV-FLCs were performed during lower-third facial feminization surgery, and two were isolated DTV-FLCs. One was a revision DTV-FLC. Transient minor complications were encountered and resolved by the postoperative visit at 1 to 2 months. Vocal fold function and voice quality remained intact. Eight available patients were satisfied with the surgical results. A blinded assessment by eight plastic surgeons determined that seven procedures were successful.

CONCLUSION

The novel DTV-FTLC approach either in isolation or as part of lower-third facial feminization surgery facilitated scar-free FLC with satisfactory cosmetic and functional results.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, IV.

Morphometric Analysis and Observer Perceptions Following Transvestibular Chondrolaryngoplasty

OBJECTIVES

To assess novel morphometric measurement strategies and observer perception ratings as potential metrics for evaluating gender-affirming transvestibular chondrolaryngoplasty in reducing contour protrusion of the neck.

METHODS

High-resolution preoperative and 3-month postoperative photographs of a pilot series of 10 patients (n = 10) who underwent endoscopic transvestibular chondrolaryngoplasty were collected. Morphometric measurements of "light reflex" and lateral view thyroid protrusion angles of the neck contours were analyzed. Pre- and postoperative photographs were presented in random order in a survey to 17 untrained judges and rated on perceived masculinity/femininity and thyroid notch protrusion on a 7-point scale. A pre- to postoperative change in morphometric angles and subjective ratings was assessed using paired t-tests and Wilcoxon signed-rank tests.

RESULTS

Mean light reflex angles were reduced after surgery from 78.6° to 40.5° in the anterior neutral view (P = .0003), from 45.2° to 24.4° in the anterior extended view (P = .003), and from 7.03° to 4.32° in the lateral view (P = .006). Median survey ratings of neck photographs were improved after surgery, from 4 to 3 in gender perception toward more feminine perception (P < .0001) and from 4 to 2 in thyroid protrusion toward less protrusive perception (P < .0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Morphometric analysis in anterior and lateral views as well as subjective gender perception and contour protrusion measures following feminization chondrolaryngoplasty by endoscopic transvestibular scarless approach demonstrate encouraging possibilities as outcome evaluation measures for chondrolaryngoplasty.

Diagnosis and Management of Vocal Complications after Chondrolaryngoplasty

OBJECTIVE

Transfeminine patients (transwomen/feminine nonbinary folks assigned male at birth) can undergo chondrolaryngoplasty ("tracheal shave") to feminize their neck appearance. While isolated cases of vocal complications have been reported following the procedure, aggregated outcomes have not been quantitatively studied. We present acoustic and stroboscopic data to describe a patient cohort with vocal complications after chondrolaryngoplasty and discuss reparative surgical technique.

METHODS

Subjective and objective data, including videostroboscopy, were collected from patients with voice complaints after chondrolaryngoplasty. Dislocated anterior commissures were reconstructed with feminization laryngoplasty. Postoperative voice data were recorded and statistically compared to preoperative data using paired t-tests.

RESULTS

On consecutive chart review, of the 94 transfeminine women with prior outside history of chondrolaryngoplasty, 27 (29%) reported chronic postoperative hoarseness, deepened pitch, or loss of upper register. On endoscopy, short, lax vocal folds with persistent anterior glottic gap and phase asymmetry were commonly noted; anterior commissure dislocation was confirmed in-office by using needle localization through absent thyroid cartilage. After open resuspension of the anterior commissure with feminization laryngoplasty, post-repair modal-speaking, minimum, and maximum fundamental frequencies (F0) increased on average by 7, 8, and 5 semitones, respectively (p < 0.01), when compared to pre-repair values. On average, perioperative maximum phonation time did not change significantly (p = 0.15). Average self-assessment of vocal femininity increased by 48% (p < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

Anterior commissure dislocation should be suspected with signs of vocal impairment after chondrolaryngoplasty. Following proper diagnosis, resuspension of the anterior commissure via feminization laryngoplasty approach can be an effective reparative technique.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

This work represents a 2011 OCEBM Level 4 evidence as a case series Laryngoscope, 133:2301-2307, 2023.

Chondrolaryngoplasty

Chondrolaryngoplasty is a surgical procedure that reduces the prominence of the thyroid notch. Although frequently performed on transgender (man to woman) women, anyone wishing to reduce the prominence of their thyroid notch for aesthetic purposes may consider undergoing a chondrolaryngoplasty. Direct visualization of the vocal cords with flexible laryngoscopy and intraoperative needle localization of the anterior commissure directs the extent of resection, helps increase safety, and avoids devastating postoperative voice complications. This procedure can be safely performed in combination with other facial feminization surgeries.

Scarless Neck Feminization by Transoral Endoscopic Vestibular Approach Chondrolaryngoplasty: A Prospective Cohort

OBJECTIVE

Chondrolaryngoplasty (laryngeal-prominence reduction) is a gender affirmation surgery for transgender women, or for cisgender people desiring an esthetic correction. Up until recently, chondrolaryngoplasty required a visible neck scar. The transoral endoscopic vestibular approach (TOEVA) is gaining widespread use as a scarless alternative for thyroid/parathyroid surgeries. This study aims to describe the feasibility, safety, and outcomes of TOEVA-chondrolaryngoplasty, based on the first-ever performed cases.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective cohort.

SETTING

An academic referral center.

METHODS

Adult patients interested in chondrolaryngoplasty underwent scarless TOEVA-chondrolaryngoplasty between 2019 and 2022, according to the described protocol. Video stroboscopy was recorded pre-and postoperatively. Surgical data, adverse events, and complications were recorded. Patients' satisfaction was measured using an outcome instrument for esthetic chondrolaryngoplasty.

RESULTS

Twelve patients (10 transgender women, a cisgender man, and a woman) were included. The mean age was 26.7 ± 6.5 years, ranging from 19 to 37. The average operative time was 3:01 ± 0:51 hours. The thyroid cartilage and laryngeal prominence were easily and safely approached and reduced, with no adverse events or major complications. All patients were discharged on postoperative day 1. A single patient had a temporary mental nerve hypoesthesia that resolved spontaneously. Otherwise, no other complications were encountered. Vocal folds' function remained unchanged in all patients. Patients were very much to completely satisfied with the surgical results as measured by the outcome instrument; median (interquartile range), 25 (21-27.75).

CONCLUSION

In this first reported cohort of scarless TOEVA-chondrolaryngoplasty, this approach was proven to be safe and feasible, with no adverse events or major complications, and with high patient satisfaction.

Chondrolaryngoplasty

Chondrolaryngoplasty is a well-described surgical procedure most commonly performed as part of facial feminization surgery for transgender patients with a diagnosis of gender dysphoria. A complete understanding of relevant neck anatomy and laryngeal function is critical to optimizing surgical outcomes. The overall goal of the procedure is to maximally reduce the thyroid cartilage prominence while preserving laryngeal integrity and minimizing the risk of external scarring. Among available approaches, the bronchoscopic-assisted technique with intraoperative needle localization has been demonstrated to reliably lead to safe and effective surgical outcomes while minimizing the risk of postoperative complications.