Molecular understanding of sterically controlled compound release through an engineered channel protein (FhuA)

FhuA: From Iron-Transporting Transmembrane Protein to Versatile Scaffolds through Protein Engineering

ConspectusProtein engineering has emerged as a powerful methodology to tailor the properties of proteins. It empowers the design of biohybrid catalysts and materials, thereby enabling the convergence of materials science, chemistry, and medicine. The choice of a protein scaffold is an important factor for performance and potential applications. In the past two decades, we utilized the ferric hydroxamate uptake protein FhuA. FhuA is, from our point of view, a versatile scaffold due to its comparably large cavity and robustness toward temperature as well as organic cosolvents. FhuA is a natural iron transporter located in the outer membrane of Escherichia coli (E. coli). Wild-type FhuA consists of 714 amino acids and has a β-barrel structure composed of 22 antiparallel β-sheets, closed by an internal globular "cork" domain (amino acids 1-160). FhuA is robust in a broad pH range and toward organic cosolvents; therefore, we envisioned FhuA to be a suitable platform for various applications in (i) biocatalysis, (ii) materials science, and (iii) the construction of artificial metalloenzymes.(i) Applications in biocatalysis were achieved by removing the globular cork domain (FhuA_Δ1-160), thereby creating a large pore for the passive transport of otherwise difficult-to-import molecules through diffusion. Introducing this FhuA variant into the outer membrane of E. coli facilitates the uptake of substrates for downstream biocatalytic conversion. Furthermore, removing the globular "cork" domain without structural collapse of the ß-barrel protein allowed the use of FhuA as a membrane filter, exhibiting a preference for d-arginine over l-arginine.(ii) FhuA is a transmembrane protein, which makes it attractive to be used for applications in non-natural polymeric membranes. Inserting FhuA into polymer vesicles yielded so-called synthosomes (i.e., catalytic synthetic vesicles in which the transmembrane protein acted as a switchable gate or filter). Our work in this direction enables polymersomes to be used in biocatalysis, DNA recovery, and the controlled (triggered) release of molecules. Furthermore, FhuA can be used as a building block to create protein-polymer conjugates to generate membranes.(iii) Artificial metalloenzymes (ArMs) are formed by incorporating a non-native metal ion or metal complex into a protein. This combines the best of two worlds: the vast reaction and substrate scope of chemocatalysis and the selectivity and evolvability of enzymes. With its large inner diameter, FhuA can harbor (bulky) metal catalysts. Among others, we covalently attached a Grubbs-Hoveyda-type catalyst for olefin metathesis to FhuA. This artificial metathease was then used in various chemical transformations, ranging from polymerizations (ring-opening metathesis polymerization) to enzymatic cascades involving cross-metathesis. Ultimately, we generated a catalytically active membrane by copolymerizing FhuA and pyrrole. The resulting biohybrid material was then equipped with the Grubbs-Hoveyda-type catalyst and used in ring-closing metathesis.The number of reports on FhuA and its various applications indicates that it is a versatile building block to generate hybrid catalysts and materials. We hope that our research will inspire future research efforts at the interface of biotechnology, catalysis, and material science in order to create biohybrid systems that offer smart solutions for current challenges in catalysis, material science, and medicine.

Engineered P450 BM3 and cpADH5 coupled cascade reaction for β-oxo fatty acid methyl ester production in whole cells

Hydroxy- or ketone- functionalized fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs) are important compounds for production of pharmaceuticals, vitamins, cosmetics or dietary supplements. Biocatalysis through enzymatic cascades has drawn attention to the efficient, sustainable, and greener synthetic processes. Furthermore, whole cell catalysts offer important advantages such as cofactor regeneration by cell metabolism, omission of protein purification steps and increased enzyme stability. Here, we report the first whole cell catalysis employing an engineered P450 BM3 variant and cpADH5 coupled cascade reaction for the biosynthesis of hydroxy- and keto-FAMEs. Firstly, P450 BM3 was engineered through the KnowVolution approach yielding P450 BM3 variant YE_M1_2, (R47S/Y51W/T235S/N239R/I401 M) which exhibited boosted performance toward methyl hexanoate. The initial oxidation rate of YE_M1_2 toward methyl hexanoate was determined to be 23-fold higher than the wild type enzyme and a 1.5-fold increase in methyl 3-hydroxyhexanoate production was obtained (YE_M1_2; 2.75 mM and WT; 1.8 mM). Subsequently, the whole cell catalyst for the synthesis of methyl 3-hydroxyhexanoate and methyl 3-oxohexanoate was constructed by combining the engineered P450 BM3 and cpADH5 variants in an artificial operon. A 2.06 mM total product formation was achieved by the whole cell catalyst including co-expressed channel protein, FhuA and co-solvent addition. Moreover, the generated whole cell biocatalyst also accepted methyl valerate, methyl heptanoate as well as methyl octanoate as substrates and yielded ω-1 ketones as the main product.

Chiral separation of d/l-arginine with whole cells through an engineered FhuA nanochannel

Downstream processing to obtain enantiopure compounds from a racemic mixture relies mainly on crystallization. Natural transporters can specifically translocate enantiomers through membranes. Here a β-barrel transmembrane protein FhuA is re-engineered into a chiral channel protein (FhuAF4) to resolve racemic mixtures of d-/l-arginine. The engineered FhuAF4 variant exhibits an enantioselectivity (E-value) of 1.92 and an enantiomeric excess percentage (ee%) of 23.91 at 52.39% conversion. OmniChange mutant libraries at the computationally identified "filter-regions" likely help to identify FhuA variants for enantiomeric separation of other compounds.

Biomimetic Strategy To Reversibly Trigger Functionality of Catalytic Nanocompartments by the Insertion of pH-Responsive Biovalves

We describe an innovative strategy to generate catalytic compartments with triggered functionality at the nanoscale level by combining pH-reversible biovalves and enzyme-loaded synthetic compartments. The biovalve has been engineered by the attachment of stimuli-responsive peptides to a genetically modified channel porin, enabling a reversible change of the molecular flow through the pores of the porin in response to a pH change in the local environment. The biovalve functionality triggers the reaction inside the cavity of the enzyme-loaded compartments by switching the in situ activity of the enzymes on/off based on a reversible change of the permeability of the membrane, which blocks or allows the passage of substrates and products. The complex functionality of our catalytic compartments is based on the preservation of the integrity of the compartments to protect encapsulated enzymes. An increase of the in situ activity compared to that of the free enzyme and a reversible on/off switch of the activity upon the presence of a specific stimulus is achieved. This strategy provides straightforward solutions for the development of catalytic nanocompartments efficiently producing desired molecules in a controlled, stimuli-responsive manner with high potential in areas, such as medicine, analytical chemistry, and catalysis.

2-Methyl-2,4-pentanediol (MPD) boosts as detergent-substitute the performance of ß-barrel hybrid catalyst for phenylacetylene polymerization

Covering hydrophobic regions with stabilization agents to solubilize purified transmembrane proteins is crucial for their application in aqueous media. The small molecule 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol (MPD) was used to stabilize the transmembrane protein Ferric hydroxamate uptake protein component A (FhuA) utilized as host for the construction of a rhodium-based biohybrid catalyst. Unlike commonly used detergents such as sodium dodecyl sulfate or polyethylene polyethyleneglycol, MPD does not form micelles in solution. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed the effect and position of stabilizing MPD molecules. The advantage of the amphiphilic MPD over micelle-forming detergents is demonstrated in the polymerization of phenylacetylene, showing a ten-fold increase in yield and increased molecular weights.

Nano-thin walled micro-compartments from transmembrane protein-polymer conjugates

The high interfacial activity of protein-polymer conjugates has inspired their use as stabilizers for Pickering emulsions, resulting in many interesting applications such as synthesis of templated micro-compartments and protocells or vehicles for drug and gene delivery. In this study we report, for the first time, the stabilization of Pickering emulsions with conjugates of a genetically modified transmembrane protein, ferric hydroxamate uptake protein component A (FhuA). The lysine residues of FhuA with open pore (FhuA ΔCVF^tev) were modified to attach an initiator and consequently controlled radical polymerization (CRP) carried out via the grafting-from technique. The resulting conjugates of FhuA ΔCVF^tev with poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAAm) and poly((2-dimethylamino)ethyl methacrylate) (PDMAEMA), the so-called building blocks based on transmembrane proteins (BBTP), have been shown to engender larger structures. The properties such as pH-responsivity, temperature-responsivity and interfacial activity of the BBTP were analyzed using UV-Vis spectrophotometry and pendant drop tensiometry. The BBTP were then utilized for the synthesis of highly stable Pickering emulsions, which could remain non-coalesced for well over a month. A new UV-crosslinkable monomer was synthesized and copolymerized with NIPAAm from the protein. The emulsion droplets, upon crosslinking of polymer chains, yielded micro-compartments. Fluorescence microscopy proved that these compartments are of micrometer scale, while cryo-scanning electron microscopy and scanning force microscopy analysis yielded a thickness in the range of 11.1 ± 0.6 to 38.0 ± 18.2 nm for the stabilizing layer of the conjugates. Such micro-compartments would prove to be beneficial in drug delivery applications, owing to the possibility of using the channel of the transmembrane protein as a gate and the smart polymer chains as trigger switches to tune the behavior of the capsules.

First insights on organic cosolvent effects on FhuA wildtype and FhuA Δ1-159

Circular dichroism (CD) and deconvolution were used to study the structural integrity of a "plugged" and an "open" FhuA transmembrane channel protein in the presence of varied concentrations of tetrahydrofuran (THF), ethanol (EtOH) and chloroform/methanol (C/M). FhuA is an Escherichia coli outer membrane protein (78.9 kDa) consisting of 22 β-sheets and an internal globular cork domain which acts as an iron transporter. FhuA and the deletion variant FhuA Δ1-159 showed comparable and remarkable resistance in the presence of THF (≤40 vol%) and EtOH (≤10 vol%). In C/M, significant differences in structural resistance were observed (FhuA stable ≤10 vol%; FhuA Δ1-159 ≤1 vol%). Deconvolution of CD-spectra for FhuA and FhuA Δ1-159 yielded β-sheet contents of 61 % (FhuA) and 58% (FhuA Δ1-159). Interestingly, FhuA and FhuA Δ1-159 had comparable β-sheet contents in the presence and absence of all three organic cosolvents. Additionally, precipitated FhuA and FhuA Δ1-159 (in 40 vol% C/M or 65 vol% THF) redissolved by supplementing the detergent n-octyl-oligo-oxyethylene (oPOE).

Structural and dynamical analysis of an engineered FhuA channel protein embedded into a lipid bilayer or a detergent belt

Engineered channel proteins are promising nano-components with applications in nanodelivery and nanoreactors technology. Because few of the engineered channel proteins have been crystallized, solution studies based on Neutron Scattering, Circular Dichroism and NMR play a major role. Consequently, the understanding of membrane proteins dynamics in water/detergent solutions or when embedded in a lipid membrane, can clarify how the environment affects protein behavior. In this study, molecular dynamics simulations of the FhuA Escherichia coli outer membrane channel protein and its engineered FhuA Δ1-159 variant have been performed in two different environments: a DNPC (1,2-dinervonyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) lipid bilayer and a water/OES (N-octyl-2-hydroxyethyl sulfoxide) detergent solution. Furthermore the FhuA Δ1-159 variant has been simulated in the open and closed states, the last induced by the presence of six 3-(2-pyridyldithio)-propionic-acid in the channel inner core. Differences in protein structural and dynamical behavior between the two environments have been found. Considering the FhuA protein characterized by an elliptical-cylindrical symmetry: (a) neither variations on the secondary structure nor axial deformation have been observed in any of the systems; (b) the ellipticity of the channel section (open state) and its fluctuations are enhanced in presence of water/OES, while diminished or suppressed in the DNPC bilayer; (c) the insertion of hydrophobic pyridyl groups into the FhuA Δ1-159 channel (closed state) induces a higher ellipticity in water/OES solution, while shifting to a circular section in the DNPC membrane; (d) the cork domain represented by the first 159 amino acids does not play a major role for protein stability.

Engineering of an E. coli outer membrane protein FhuA with increased channel diameter

Background

Channel proteins like FhuA can be an alternative to artificial chemically synthesized nanopores. To reach such goals, channel proteins must be flexible enough to be modified in their geometry, i.e. length and diameter. As continuation of a previous study in which we addressed the lengthening of the channel, here we report the increasing of the channel diameter by genetic engineering.

Results

The FhuA Δ1-159 diameter increase has been obtained by doubling the amino acid sequence of the first two N-terminal β-strands, resulting in variant FhuA Δ1-159 Exp. The total number of β-strands increased from 22 to 24 and the channel surface area is expected to increase by ~16%. The secondary structure analysis by circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy shows a high β-sheet content, suggesting the correct folding of FhuA Δ1-159 Exp. To further prove the FhuA Δ1-159 Exp channel functionality, kinetic measurement using the HRP-TMB assay (HRP = Horse Radish Peroxidase, TMB = 3,3',5,5'-tetramethylbenzidine) were conducted. The results indicated a 17% faster diffusion kinetic for FhuA Δ1-159 Exp as compared to FhuA Δ1-159, well correlated to the expected channel surface area increase of ~16%.

Conclusion

In this study using a simple "semi rational" approach the FhuA Δ1-159 diameter was enlarged. By combining the actual results with the previous ones on the FhuA Δ1-159 lengthening a new set of synthetic nanochannels with desired lengths and diameters can be produced, broadening the FhuA Δ1-159 applications. As large scale protein production is possible our approach can give a contribution to nanochannel industrial applications.

Molecular dynamics simulations of DNA within a nanopore: arginine-phosphate tethering and a binding/sliding mechanism for translocation

Protein nanopores show great potential as low-cost detectors in DNA sequencing devices. To date, research has largely focused on the staphylococcal pore α-hemolysin (αHL). In the present study, we have developed simplified models of the wild-type αHL pore and various mutants in order to study the translocation dynamics of single-stranded DNA under the influence of an applied electric field. The model nanopores reflect the experimentally measured conductance values in planar lipid bilayers. We show that interactions between rings of cationic amino acids and DNA backbone phosphates result in metastable tethering of nucleic acid molecules within the pore, leading us to propose a "binding and sliding" mechanism for translocation. We also observe folding of DNA into nonlinear conformational intermediates during passage through the confined nanopore environment. Despite adopting nonlinear conformations, the DNA hexamer always exits the pore in the same orientation as it enters (3' to 5') in our simulations. The observations from our simulations help to rationalize experimentally determined trends in residual current and translocation efficiency for αHL and its mutants.

Engineering of the E. coli outer membrane protein FhuA to overcome the hydrophobic mismatch in thick polymeric membranes

Background

Channel proteins like the engineered FhuA Δ1-159 often cannot insert into thick polymeric membranes due to a mismatch between the hydrophobic surface of the protein and the hydrophobic surface of the polymer membrane. To address this problem usually specific block copolymers are synthesized to facilitate protein insertion. Within this study in a reverse approach we match the protein to the polymer instead of matching the polymer to the protein.

Results

To increase the FhuA Δ1-159 hydrophobic surface by 1 nm, the last 5 amino acids of each of the 22 β-sheets, prior to the more regular periplasmatic β-turns, were doubled leading to an extended FhuA Δ1-159 (FhuA Δ1-159 Ext). The secondary structure prediction and CD spectroscopy indicate the β-barrel folding of FhuA Δ1-159 Ext. The FhuA Δ1-159 Ext insertion and functionality within a nanocontainer polymeric membrane based on the triblock copolymer PIB₁₀₀₀-PEG₆₀₀₀-PIB₁₀₀₀ (PIB = polyisobutylene, PEG = polyethyleneglycol) has been proven by kinetic analysis using the HRP-TMB assay (HRP = Horse Radish Peroxidase, TMB = 3,3',5,5'-tetramethylbenzidine). Identical experiments with the unmodified FhuA Δ1-159 report no kinetics and presumably no insertion into the PIB₁₀₀₀-PEG₆₀₀₀-PIB₁₀₀₀ membrane. Furthermore labeling of the Lys-NH₂ groups present in the FhuA Δ1-159 Ext channel, leads to controllability of in/out flux of substrates and products from the nanocontainer.

Conclusion

Using a simple "semi rational" approach the protein's hydrophobic transmembrane region was increased by 1 nm, leading to a predicted lower hydrophobic mismatch between the protein and polymer membrane, minimizing the insertion energy penalty. The strategy of adding amino acids to the FhuA Δ1-159 Ext hydrophobic part can be further expanded to increase the protein's hydrophobicity, promoting the efficient embedding into thicker/more hydrophobic block copolymer membranes.