Do maternal cells trigger or perpetuate autoimmune diseases in children?

How does age determine the development of human immune-mediated arthritis?

Does age substantially affect the emergence of human immune-mediated arthritis? Children do not usually develop immune-mediated articular inflammation during their first year of life. In patients with juvenile idiopathic arthritis, this apparent ‘immune privilege’ disintegrates, and chronic inflammation is associated with variable autoantibody signatures and patterns of disease that resemble adult arthritis phenotypes. Numerous mechanisms might be involved in this shift, including genetic and epigenetic predisposing factors, maturation of the immune system with a progressive modulation of putative tolerogenic controls, parallel development of microbial dysbiosis, accumulation of a pro-inflammatory burden driven by environmental exposures (the exposome) and comorbidity-related drivers. By exploring these mechanisms, we expand the discussion of three (not mutually exclusive) hypotheses on how these factors can contribute to the differences and similarities between the loss of immune tolerance in children and the development of established immune-mediated arthritis in adults. These three hypotheses relate to a critical window in genetics and epigenetics, immune maturation, and the accumulation of burden. The varied manifestation of the underlying mechanisms among individuals is only beginning to be clarified, but the establishment of a framework can facilitate the development of an integrated understanding of the pathogenesis of arthritis across all ages.

In this Review, the authors discuss age-related arthropathy and the similarities and differences between childhood loss of immune tolerance and adult development of immune-mediated arthritis, and develop three hypotheses describing age-related mechanisms that contribute to the onset of arthritis.

The arthritis-free ‘immune privilege’ of early childhood is overridden by multiple mechanisms, progressively and age-dependently, generating recognizable patterns of chronic inflammatory arthritis.

The emergence of arthritis involves interconnected mechanisms related to immune priming, to a situational susceptibility and to the accumulation of an inflammatory burden.

The accumulation of epigenetic drift may contribute to differences across ages.

The exposome is expected to contribute to arthritis emergence in adults as well as in children.

Ethnic variation in the incidence of biliary atresia correlates with the frequency of the most prevalent haplotype in its population

The cause of biliary atresia (BA) remains an enigma. However, an ethnic diversity in the incidence of BA is so unique that anthropological approach may provide some etiopathogenetic implications in the disease mechanism. We previously reported that an association of maternal microchimerism (MMc) in BA and a significant compatibility of HLA-A between the patient with BA and their mother. Across the 10 countries (Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Philippines, New Zealand (Maori population), UK, France, Germany, Norway, and Sweden), we determined the frequency of the most prevalent HLA haplotypes of each country from Allele Frequency Database and found that it was significantly correlated with the incidence of BA of the respective country (p = 0.0126). This observation better fits the MMc theory as an etiopathogenesis, that is, maternal effector cells are likely to migrate into the fetus in a relatively homogenous population and may damage the developing bile duct structure and portal vein endothelium, depending on materno-fetal tolerance and immunity.

Chimeric maternal cells in offspring do not respond to renal injury, inflammatory or repair signals

Maternal microchimerism (MMc) can persist for years in a child, and has been implicated in the pathogenesis of chronic inflammatory autoimmune diseases. Chimeric cells may either contribute to disease by acting as immune targets or expand in response to signals of injury, inflammation or repair. We investigated the role of maternal cells in tissue injury in the absence of autoimmunity by quantifying MMc by quantitative PCR in acute and chronic models of renal injury: (1) reversible acute renal injury, inflammation and regeneration induced by rhabdomyolysis and (2) chronic injury leading to fibrosis after unilateral ureteral obstruction. We found that MMc is common in the mouse kidney. In mice congenic with their mothers neither acute nor chronic renal injury with fibrosis influenced the levels or prevalence of MMc. Maternal cells expressing MHC antigens not shared by offspring (H2(b/d)) were detected at lower levels in all groups of homozygous H2(b/b) or H2(d/d) offspring, with or without renal injury, suggesting that partial tolerance to low levels of alloantigens may regulate the homeostatic levels of maternal cells within tissues. Maternal cells homozygous for H2(b) were lost in H2(b/d) offspring only after acute renal failure, suggesting that an inflammatory stimulus led to loss of tolerance to homozygous maternal cells. The study suggests that elevated MMc previously found in association with human autoimmune diseases may not be a response to non-specific injury or inflammatory signals, but rather a primary event integral to the pathogenesis of autoimmunity.

Early-onset chronic inflammatory disease associated with maternal microchimerism

Maternal microchimerism (mMc) refers to the presence of a small population of cells originating from the mother. Whether mMc leads to autoimmune responses in children remains controversial. We describe here an 11-year-old boy with persistent fever and elevated levels of C-reactive protein from infancy onward. During infancy, the patient presented with high fever, skin rashes, and hepatic dysfunction. Careful examination including a liver biopsy failed to reveal the cause. At 4 years old, petechiae developed associated with thrombocytopenia and positive anti-dsDNA autoantibodies. Steroid pulse therapy was effective, but the effect of low-dose prednisone was insufficient. At age 9, an extensive differential diagnosis was considered especially for infantile onset autoinflammatory disorders but failed to make a definitive diagnosis. On admission, the patient exhibited short stature, hepatosplenomegaly, generalized superficial lymphadenopathy, and rashes. Laboratory findings revealed anemia, elevated levels of inflammation markers, and hypergammaglobulinemia. Serum complement levels were normal. Serum levels of IL-6 and B-cell activating factor were elevated. Viral infections were not identified. Although HLA typing revealed no noninherited maternal antigens in lymphocytes, female cells were demonstrated in the patient's skin and lymph nodes, suggesting that maternal microchimerism might be involved in the pathogenesis of fever without source in infants.

Immunological tolerance during fetal development: from mouse to man

The development of the adaptive immune system has been studied in the mouse primarily because it is easier to access fetal tissues and because there exists a rich array of probes for analysis of various components of the immune system. While much has been learned from this exercise, it is also clear that different species show substantial temporal variation in the development of the immune system during early life. In mice, for instance, mature α/β T cells first appear in the periphery during the final stages of fetal gestation and only increase in number after birth (Friedberg and Weissman, 1974); in humans, on the other hand, the first mature α/β T cells are seen in peripheral tissues at 10-12 gestational weeks (g.w.) and are circulating in significant numbers by the end of the second trimester (Ceppellini et al., 1971; Haynes et al., 1988; Hayward and Ezer, 1974; Kay et al., 1970). Although the functional implications of these differences remain unclear, it is likely that there are significant biological consequences associated with the relatively early development of the peripheral adaptive immune system in humans, for example, with respect to the development of peripheral tolerance as well as to the response to antigens that might cross the placenta from the mother (e.g., cells bearing noninherited maternal alloantigens, infectious agents, food antigens, and the like). Here, we will review studies of immune system ontogeny in the mouse and in humans, and then focus on the possible functional roles of fetal T cell populations during development and later in life in humans.

Influence of the mother's preceding pregnancies on fetal development and postnatal survival of the neonate, in normal pregnancy. An immunological phenomenon?

OBJECTIVES

The objective of this study is to test for an association between the sex of conceptuses of the mother's preceding pregnancies and fetal development and early neonatal survival in normal pregnancy.

METHODS

A population of 27,243 neonates, including a subsample of 7,773 "newborn/mother/placenta units" were divided into cohorts according to the sex of the neonate and the sex and number of conceptuses of the mother's preceding pregnancies. The average birth weight, placenta weight and early neonatal mortality rate were measured for each cohort and compared. The "dose effect" of preceding pregnancy was tested by linear and quadratic regression analysis, and by chi-square trend test for linearity of proportions.

RESULTS

The results have shown an association between these three variables and the preceding pregnancies of the mother. Fetal development and early survival of the neonate are positively associated with the mother's preceding pregnancies of same sex as the neonate, and negatively associated with the preceding pregnancies of opposite sex to the neonate. The strength of the phenomenon increases with parity, at least for the first three parities. The association is statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

The association between fetal development and neonatal survival and preceding pregnancies of the mother would be compatible with the action of male and female specific antigens capable of affecting selective implantation of blastocysts, which commands subsequent fetal development as well as early neonatal survival.

The role of fetal microchimerism in autoimmune disease

Fetal microchimerism occurs in normal human reproduction and is a relatively new discovery in biology. Recent data in the scientific and medical literature indicates that some of the autoimmune diseases that show a predilection for women in their child-bearing years and beyond are linked to fetal microchimerism from previous pregnancies. The pathological role of fetal microchimeric progenitor immature T cells in autoimmune disease in women is explored. Fetal microchimerism is increased in women who had a termination of pregnancy and may be associated with the development of autoimmune disease later on in life. Furthermore, the consistently rising incidence of autoimmune diseases in women over the past four decades may be attributed to the increase in the utilization of abortion.

High-resolution, high-throughput HLA genotyping by next-generation sequencing

The human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I and class II loci are the most polymorphic genes in the human genome. Hematopoietic stem cell transplantation requires allele-level HLA typing at multiple loci to select the best matched unrelated donors for recipient patients. In current methods for HLA typing, both alleles of a heterozygote are amplified and typed or sequenced simultaneously, often making it difficult to unambiguously determine the sequence of the two alleles. Next-generation sequencing methods clonally propagate in parallel millions of single DNA molecules, which are then also sequenced in parallel. Recently, the read lengths obtainable by one such next-generation sequencing method (454 Life Sciences, Inc.) have increased to >250 nucleotides. These clonal read lengths make possible setting the phase of the linked polymorphisms within an exon and thus the unambiguous determination of the sequence of each HLA allele. Here we demonstrate this capacity as well as show that the throughput of the system is sufficiently high to enable a complete, 7-locus HLA class I and II typing for 24 or 48 individual DNAs in a single GS FLX sequencing run. Highly multiplexed amplicon sequencing is facilitated by the use of sample-specific internal sequence tags (multiplex identification tags or MIDs) in the primers that allow pooling of samples yet maintain the ability to assign sequences to specific individuals. We have incorporated an HLA typing software application developed by Conexio Genomics (Freemantle, Australia) that assigns HLA genotypes for these 7 loci (HLA-A, -B, -C, DRB1, DQA1, DQB1, DPB1), as well as for DRB3, DRB4, and DRB5 from 454 sequence data. The potential of this HLA sequencing system to analyze chimeric mixtures is demonstrated here by the detection of a rare HLA-B allele in a mixture of two homozygous cell lines (1/100), as well as by the detection of the rare nontransmitted maternal allele present in the blood of a severe combined immunodeficiency disease syndrome (SCIDS) patient.

Fetal-maternal exchange of multipotent stem/progenitor cells: microchimerism in diagnosis and disease

The biological concept of microchimerism, the bidirectional trafficking and stable long-term persistence of small numbers of allogeneic (fetal and maternal) cells in a genetically different organ, has gained considerable attention. Microchimerism is a common phenomenon in many species, including humans, and microchimeric cells can modify immunological recognition or tolerance, affect the course and outcome of various diseases and demonstrate stem cell-like or regenerative potential. Here, we review current knowledge of the biology of microchimerism and show how long-term allogeneic co-existence within an organism can impact on existing paradigms in chronic disease, cancer biology, regenerative medicine and fetal-maternal immunology. We discuss diagnostic challenges, clinical applications and future research directions in this exciting and rapidly emerging field of allogeneic fetal-maternal cell exchange.

Quantitative monitoring of multi-donor chimerism: a systematic, validated framework for routine analysis

Despite therapeutic advantages, double-donor (DD) HSCTs present technical problems for molecular chimerism (CHM) monitoring. These DD chimeras contain three matched DNAs, so that the genomes of donor(s) and recipient often share the same alleles. In the STR assay, shared recipient/donor alleles are common and have identical physico-chemical properties. As a consequence of the latter, they co-migrate in the same band ('shared peak'), which prevents measuring each allele separately. Without individual allelic measurements, the direct calculation of the chimeric recipient/donor DNA ratio is precluded. This is the first study to document and systematically examine these problems. Its goal was to provide a validated framework for accurate, routine monitoring based on a stepwise analytic paradigm for approximating percent CHM (%CHM) from shared STR-alleles. Analysis of STR-DNA from DD loci showed that at least four of six alleles were typically shared. Despite such extensive allelic sharing, we show how simple arithmetic procedures can be applied for standardized calculation of %CHM based on peak measurements. Criteria for selecting loci suitable for such analysis are provided. Validation of the computational results required analyzing 18 'informative' loci with pre-established reference values for %CHM. In all cases, the results for %CHM, calculated from peak measurements, were +/-5% of the reference value. The conclusions of the study are as follows: (1) Multi-donor chimeras, with shared alleles, can be accurately and simply analyzed within the usual limits of STR measurement error; (2) by examining these various facets of DD CHM analysis, this novel study has provided a basis for standardized, routine quantitative monitoring using the STR/VNTR assay.

Chimeric maternal cells with tissue-specific antigen expression and morphology are common in infant tissues

Maternal microchimerism (MMc) has been purported to play a role in the pathogenesis of autoimmunity, but how a small number of foreign cells could contribute to chronic, systemic inflammation has not been explained. Reports of peripheral blood cells differentiating into tissue-specific cell types may shed light on the problem in that chimeric maternal cells could act as target cells within tissues. We investigated MMc in tissues from 7 male infants. Female cells, presumed maternal, were characterized by simultaneous immunohistochemistry and fluorescence in situ hybridization for X- and Y-chromosomes. Maternal cells constituted 0.017% to 1.9% of parenchymal cells and were found in all infants in liver, pancreas, lung, kidney, bladder, skin, and spleen. Maternal cells were differentiated: maternal hepatocytes in liver, renal tubular cells in kidney, and beta-islet cells in pancreas. Maternal cells were not found in areas of tissue injury or inflammatory infiltrate. Maternal hematopoietic cells were found only in hearts from patients with neonatal lupus. Thus, differentiated maternal cells are present in multiple tissue types and occur independently of inflammation or tissue injury. Loss of tolerance to maternal parenchymal cells could lead to organ-specific "auto" inflammatory disease and elimination of maternal cells in areas of inflammation.

Are pediatric autoimmune diseases primarily genetic diseases?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Powerful new methods are allowing identification of genetic risk factors in large populations of adults with autoimmune diseases. In this review, we describe the advantages and limitations of genetic methodologies, and how these methods have been used to discover candidate genes in smaller populations of pediatric patients. We also introduce novel concepts for nontraditional modes of genetic inheritance that may be important in the pathogenesis of autoimmunity.

RECENT FINDINGS

Candidate genes identified by linkage analyses and genome-wide association scans in adult populations have led to focused genetic studies in pediatric populations. Some genes are associated with subsets of both adult and pediatric patients; others appear to be age specific. Novel concepts in genetics have uncovered potential contributions of maternal compared with paternal transmission, noninherited maternal alleles that may work through maternal microchimerism, and sex-specific epigenetic mechanisms of immunoregulation.

SUMMARY

Advancing methods are leading to the discovery of genes associated with childhood autoimmune diseases. However, the genetic contribution to disease risk for any one gene remains less than 30% for most diseases, suggesting that pediatric autoimmunity is not primarily genetic in a classical sense. A combinatorial approach considering the contributions of multiple genes, mode of inheritance, and environmental influences will be required to fully understand the mechanisms of pathogenesis in pediatric autoimmune disease.

Chimerism occurs in thyroid, lung, skin and lymph nodes of women with sons

Chimerism indicates the presence of cells from one individual in another. Pregnancy and blood transfusions are considered the main sources for chimerism. Chimeric cells have been attributed a pathogenic role in various autoimmune diseases. However, data on the occurrence of chimeric cells in normal organs are scarce. In order to gain insight into the possible pathogenic potential of chimeric cells in autoimmune disease, it is necessary to determine the prevalence of chimeric cells in organs not affected by autoimmune disease. In situ hybridization for the Y-chromosome was performed on organs obtained at autopsy of 51 women. We investigated 44 thyroid, 38 lung, 21 skin and 7 lymph node samples. All women had sons, and data from their blood transfusion histories were retrieved for at least 10 years before death. Slides were scored semi-quantitatively for chimerism as low (1-3 Y-chromosome-positive cells per slide), moderate (4-10 positive cells per slide) or high (more than 10 positive cells per slide). Y-chromosome-positive cells were found in 8 thyroid, 10 lung, 3 skin and 1 lymph node samples of 18 women. There was no association between the presence of chimeric cells and blood transfusion history. Most organs in which chimerism was present contained a small to moderate level. Thus, chimerism can occur in normal organs of women without autoimmune disease. Our results indicate that chimerism is not necessarily associated with disease.