Efficacy of customised foot orthoses in the treatment of Achilles tendinopathy: study protocol for a randomised trial

Physical modalities with eccentric exercise are no better than eccentric exercise alone in the treatment of chronic achilles tendinopathy: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

To investigate the available evidence and conduct a systematic review with meta-analysis to determine the effectiveness of physical modalities combined with eccentric exercise (PMEE) with eccentric exercise (EE) alone for improvements in pain and function in individuals with chronic Achilles tendinopathy (AT) at short-term (4 weeks) and long-term (12-16 weeks) follow-ups.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A systematic literature review identified 8 papers (from 6404 possible inclusions) that allowed the comparison of PMEE with EE alone, in the treatment of chronic AT. We extracted the mean and standard deviations for Victorian Institute of Sports Assessment Achilles Tendinopathy (VISA-A), Numerical Pain Rating Scale (NPRS), and load-induced pain (NRS). Standardized mean difference (SMD) of the included variables was presented, and all the studies had low risk of bias.

RESULTS

Non-significant results were achieved for short-term (pooled SMD = 0.03; 95% CI= -0.46 to 0.53, p = 0.89, I2 = 60%) and long- term follow-ups (pooled SMD =0.43; 95% CI= -0.05 to 0.92, p = 0.08, I2 = 82%) of VISA-A. Short-term (pooled SMD = -0.16; 95% CI= -0.72 to 0.40, p = 0.57, I2 = 40%) and long-term (pooled SMD = -0.39;95% CI= -1.11 to 0.32, p = 0.28, I2 = 62%) follow-up analysis of NPRS and long-term(pooled SMD = -0.46; 95% CI= -1.08 to 0.15, p = 0.14, I2 = 74%) follow-up of load induced pain also demonstrated non-significant improvements when comparing two groups.

CONCLUSION

Meta- analysis of the results published in the 8 papers that met theinclusion criteria showed no significant differences between PMEE and EE, in terms of load-induced pain (NRS) and numerical pain rating scales (NPRS) at 4 and 12-16 weeks. Thus, the meta-analysis reflects the other cited published work that PMEE shows no greater advantage than EE in the treatment of Chronic Achilles Tendinopathy.

Ultrasound-guided hyaluronic acid injection for the treatment of insertional Achilles tendinopathy: A prospective case series

BACKGROUND

Heel pain is a common condition and often involves the Achilles tendon and is classified as insertional or non-insertional. Several operative and non-operative treatments have been described, but there is no consensus on the most effective therapy. The aim of this study is to evaluate a case series of patients with insertional Achilles tendinopathy refractory to conservative treatment submitted to a single-dose ultrasound-guided injection of hyaluronic acid (40 mg/2.0 mL).

METHODS

We prospectively included 25 patients (29 feet) who underwent a single ultrasound-guided injection of hyaluronic acid after conservative treatment failure. Clinical outcomes such as pain (using the Visual Analog Scale - VAS), function (using the American Orthopedic Foot & Ankle Society - AOFAS score), personal satisfaction, and complications were evaluated. Statistical analysis was performed using the R software.

RESULTS

Most patients were female (80%) and there was a right-side predominance (55%). The median VAS was 8 points [range 4-10] at baseline, decreasing to 3 points [range 0-8] at the six-month follow-up, with statistical significance (p < .001). The median AOFAS score was 71 points [range 38-87] at baseline, increasing to 90 points [range 48-100] at the six-month follow-up (p < .001). The personal satisfaction level was 69%, and 48% of patients considered the result excellent. There were no Achilles tendon ruptures, infections, or allergic reactions post injection.

CONCLUSION

Single-dose injection of hyaluronic acid is a safe treatment option, improving function and reducing pain for six months in patients with insertional Achilles tendinopathy after conservative treatment failure.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, case series.

Optical-electrical characteristic of green based on GaN micro-LED arrays

A detailed theoretical derivation and calculation method of the difference coefficient between a light distribution pattern of a 30×20µm² green micro-LED array and Lambert source is proposed first in this paper, to the best of our knowledge, which establishes an accurate relationship between external quantum efficiency and current efficiency (cd/A). The variation of capacitance with voltage and wavelength blueshift is illustrated by a carrier recombination mechanism. The current efficiency reaches 132.5 cd/A for the 60×50µm² and 121.7 cd/A for the 25×15µm² arrays, and the mechanism caused by size dependence is analyzed in detail combined with the classical ABC model.

Exercise, orthoses and splinting for treating Achilles tendinopathy: a systematic review with meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

To assess the efficacy of exercise, orthoses and splinting on function, pain and quality of life (QoL) for the management of mid-portion and insertional Achilles tendinopathy, and to compare different types, applications and modes of delivery within each intervention category.

DESIGN

Systematic review and meta-analysis.

DATA SOURCES

Medline, CINAHL, Embase, AMED, WHO ICTRP, Web of Science, PEDro and Cochrane Library from inception to October 2017. Citation tracking of published studies and conference proceedings and contacting experts in the field.

STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA

Controlled clinical trials evaluating either exercise, orthoses or splinting for the management of Achilles tendinopathy.

METHODS

Independent reviewers undertook searches, screening and risk of bias appraisal. Primary outcomes of interest were function, pain and QoL.

RESULTS

Twenty-two studies were included (1137 participants). Moderate level evidence favoured eccentric exercise over control for improving pain and function in mid-portion tendinopathy. Moderate level evidence favoured eccentric exercise over concentric exercise for reducing pain. There was moderate level evidence of no significant difference in pain or function between eccentric exercise and heavy slow resistance exercise. There was low level evidence that eccentric exercise was not superior to stretching for pain or QoL. There was moderate level evidence that a combined exercise protocol was not superior to a lower dosage protocol for improving functional performance. There was moderate to low level evidence of a significant difference in pain (mean difference (MD) 6.3 mm, 95% CI -4.45 to 17.04, moderate) or function (MD 1.83 Victoria Institute of Sport Assessment points, 95% CI -7.47 to 11.12, low) between high-dose and low-dose eccentric training. There was high to moderate level evidence of no difference in pain (moderate) or function (high) between orthoses and control. There was low level evidence of no significant benefit in adding a night splint to an eccentric exercise programme for function, and moderate level evidence for no reduction in pain (MD -3.50, 95% CI -10.49 to 3.48). Eccentric exercise was not superior to splinting for pain (moderate evidence) or function (low level evidence).

SUMMARY

We conditionally recommend exercise for improving pain and function in mid-portion Achilles tendinopathy. The balance of evidence did not support recommendation of one type of exercise programme over another. We conditionally recommend against the addition of a splint to an eccentric exercise protocol and we do not recommend the use of orthoses to improve pain and function in Achilles tendinopathy.

Comparative effectiveness research for the clinician researcher: a framework for making a methodological design choice

Comparative effectiveness research compares two active forms of treatment or usual care in comparison with usual care with an additional intervention element. These types of study are commonly conducted following a placebo or no active treatment trial. Research designs with a placebo or non-active treatment arm can be challenging for the clinician researcher when conducted within the healthcare environment with patients attending for treatment.

A framework for conducting comparative effectiveness research is needed, particularly for interventions for which there are no strong regulatory requirements that must be met prior to their introduction into usual care. We argue for a broader use of comparative effectiveness research to achieve translatable real-world clinical research. These types of research design also affect the rapid uptake of evidence-based clinical practice within the healthcare setting.

This framework includes questions to guide the clinician researcher into the most appropriate trial design to measure treatment effect. These questions include consideration given to current treatment provision during usual care, known treatment effectiveness, side effects of treatments, economic impact, and the setting in which the research is being undertaken.

Danish VISA-A questionnaire with validation and reliability testing for Danish-speaking Achilles tendinopathy patients

The VISA-A questionnaire has proven to be a valid and reliable tool for assessing severity of Achilles tendinopathy (AT). The aim was to translate and cross-culturally adapt the VISA-A questionnaire for a Danish-speaking AT population, and subsequently perform validity and reliability tests. Translation and following cross-cultural adaptation was performed as translation, synthesis, reverse translation, expert review, and pretesting. The final Danish version (VISA-A-DK) was tested for reliability on healthy controls (n = 75) and patients (n = 36). Tests for internal consistency, validity, and structure were performed on 71 patients. VISA-A-DK showed good reliability for patients (r = 0.80 ICC = 0.79) and healthy individuals (r = 0.98 ICC = 0.97). Internal consistency was 0.73 (Cronbach's alpha). The mean VISA-A-DK score in AT patients was 51 [47-55]. This was significantly lower than healthy controls with a score of 93 (90-95). Criterion validity was considered good when comparing the scores of the Danish version with the original version in both healthy individuals and patients. VISA-A-DK is a valid and reliable instrument and has shown compatible to the original version in assessment of AT patients. VISA-A-DK is a useful tool in the assessment of AT, both in research and in a clinical setting.

Effectiveness of orthotic devices in the treatment of Achilles tendinopathy: a systematic review

Orthotic devices such as foot orthoses, splints, taping and bracing are recommended for Achilles tendinopathy (AT). This systematic review was conducted to review the current evidence for the effectiveness of orthotic devices for the treatment of mid-portion or insertional AT. Electronic bibliographic databases (MEDLINE, EMBASE, Current Contents, CINAHL and SPORTDiscus) were searched in May 2014. The methodological quality of included studies was evaluated using the Quality Index. Where possible, effects were determined using standardised mean differences. The strength of evidence for each intervention was determined according to the quality and number of studies. Twelve studies satisfied the inclusion criteria; nine studies investigated mid-portion AT, whilst three studies did not distinguish between mid-portion and insertional pathology. Weak evidence showed that foot orthoses were equivalent to physical therapy, and equivalent to no treatment. Very weak evidence supported the use of adhesive taping alone or when combined with foot orthoses. Moderate evidence showed that the AirHeel™ brace was as effective as a calf muscle eccentric exercise programme, and weak evidence showed that this intervention was not beneficial when added to a calf muscle eccentric exercise programme. Weak evidence showed that an ankle joint dorsiflexion night splint was equally effective to a calf muscle eccentric exercise programme, and strong evidence showed that this intervention was not beneficial when added to a calf muscle eccentric exercise programme. These findings may aid clinical decision making in the context of AT, however further high-quality studies are required.

The effect of customised and sham foot orthoses on plantar pressures

Background

The effectiveness of foot orthoses has been evaluated in many clinical trials with sham foot orthoses used as the control intervention in at least 10 clinical trials. However, the mechanical effects and credibility of sham orthoses has been rarely quantified. This study aimed to: (i) compare the effects on plantar pressures of three sham foot orthoses to a customised foot orthosis, and (ii) establish the perceived credibility and the expected benefit of each orthotic condition.

Methods

Thirty adults aged between 18 and 51 participated in this study. At 0 and 4 weeks, plantar pressure data were collected for the heel, midfoot and forefoot using the pedar^®-X in-shoe system for the following five randomly assigned conditions: (i) shoe alone, (ii) customised foot orthosis, (iii) contoured polyethylene sham foot orthosis, (iv) contoured EVA sham foot orthosis, and (v) flat EVA sham foot orthosis. At the initial data collection session, each participant completed a Credibility/Expectancy Questionnaire (CEQ) to determine the credibility and expected benefit of each orthotic condition.

Results

Compared to the shoe alone at week 0, the contoured polyethylene sham orthosis was the only condition to not significantly effect peak pressure at any region of the foot. In contrast, the contoured EVA sham orthosis, the flat EVA sham orthosis and the customised orthosis significantly reduced peak pressure at the heel. At the medial midfoot, all sham orthoses provided the same effect as the shoe alone, which corresponded to effects that were significantly different to the customised orthosis. There were no differences in peak pressure between conditions at the other mask regions, the lateral midfoot and forefoot. When the conditions were compared at week 4, the differences between the conditions were generally similar to the findings observed at week 0. With respect to credibility and expected benefit, all orthotic conditions were considered the same with the exception of the contoured polyethylene sham orthosis, which was perceived as being less credible and less likely to provide benefits.

Conclusion

The findings of this study indicate that all of the sham orthoses tested provided the same effect on plantar pressures at the midfoot and forefoot as a shoe alone. However, the contoured EVA sham orthosis and the flat EVA sham orthosis significantly reduced peak pressure under the heel, which was similar to the customised orthosis. In contrast, the contoured polyethylene sham orthosis had no significant effect on plantar pressure and was comparable to the shoe alone at all regions of the foot. Hence, lower plantar pressures were found under the heel with some sham orthoses, but not with others. Importantly, participants perceived the polyethylene sham orthosis – the sham that had no effect on plantar pressure – to be the least credible orthosis and the least likely to provide benefits. This may be critical for the design of future clinical trials as it may introduce confounding effects that produce inaccurate results. These findings provide some evidence for the mechanical effects, treatment credibility and expected benefit of sham foot orthoses, which should be considered when they are used as a control intervention in a clinical trial.

The volume of the neovascularity and its clinical implications in achilles tendinopathy

Thirty-seven pathologic Achilles tendons from 27 patients were investigated by a three-dimensional (3-D) power Doppler ultrasound system. Both the volume of the neovascularity (VON) and the volume of Achilles tendon (VOAT) were investigated. VON-VOAT index (VVI), as the normalization of the neovascularization, was accordingly calculated. Patient's clinical indications were assessed using the visual analog scale for pain (VAS) and Victorian Institute of Sport Assessment Achilles (VISA-A). Relationships between VAS and VON, VISA-A and VON, VAS and VOAT, VISA-A and VOAT, VAS and VVI, and VISA-A and VVI, were statistically analyzed. The vascular mapping within and surrounding the symptomatic Achilles tendons was investigated. 97.3% of the Achilles tendons were found to have neovascularization. In 55.6% of these Achilles, the neovascularity was associated with the location of thickening. The VAS was found to be positively correlated with the VON and the VVI, the VON was found to be independent from the VOAT.

The effect of different depths of medial heel skive on plantar pressures

Background

Foot orthoses are often used to treat lower limb injuries associated with excessive pronation. There are many orthotic modifications available for this purpose, with one being the medial heel skive. However, empirical evidence for the mechanical effects of the medial heel skive modification is limited. This study aimed to evaluate the effect that different depths of medial heel skive have on plantar pressures.

Methods

Thirty healthy adults (mean age 24 years, range 18–46) with a flat-arched or pronated foot posture and no current foot pain or deformity participated in this study. Using the in-shoe pedar-X® system, plantar pressure data were collected for the rearfoot, midfoot and forefoot while participants walked along an 8 metre walkway wearing a standardised shoe. Experimental conditions included a customised foot orthosis with the following 4 orthotic modifications: (i) no medial heel skive, (ii) a 2 mm medial heel skive, (iii) a 4 mm medial heel skive and (iv) a 6 mm medial heel skive.

Results

Compared to the foot orthosis with no medial heel skive, statistically significant increases in peak pressure were observed at the medial rearfoot – there was a 15% increase (p = 0.001) with the 4 mm skive and a 29% increase (p < 0.001) with the 6 mm skive. No significant change was observed with the 2 mm medial heel skive. With respect to the midfoot and forefoot, there were no significant differences between the orthoses.

Conclusions

This study found that a medial heel skive of 4 mm or 6 mm increases peak pressure under the medial rearfoot in asymptomatic adults with a flat-arched or pronated foot posture. Plantar pressures at the midfoot and forefoot were not altered by a medial heel skive of 2, 4 or 6 mm. These findings provide some evidence for the effects of the medial heel skive orthotic modification.

A novel 3-D power Doppler ultrasound approach to the quantification of achilles tendon neovascularity

To investigate the amount of neovascularization in the symptomatic Achilles tendon, we developed a novel three-dimensional (3-D) power Doppler ultrasound scanning system to prospectively examine 10 patients with 12 symptomatic Achilles tendons, as well as 20 asymptomatic Achilles tendons as a control group. The mean volume of neovascularity (VON) in the whole Achilles tendon was calculated during the phase of the cardiac cycle displaying maximum vascularity and also during the phase of the cardiac cycle displaying the minimum. The mean VONs in the control group were found to be 0.41 mm(3) (maximum) and 0.02 mm(3) (minimum), respectively. The mean VONs in patients with painful Achilles tendon were 380 mm(3) (maximum) and 70.3 mm(3) (minimum), respectively. The initial results showed that the 3-D power Doppler ultrasound system could be used to measure the mean VON in controls and in patients with symptomatic Achilles tendinopathy. The results demonstrated a significantly greater VON in the maximum phase compared with the minimum phase as well as in the patient group compared with that in the control group. The system was therefore capable of defining the degree of vascularity in the Achilles tendon.

Effectiveness of trigger point dry needling for plantar heel pain: study protocol for a randomised controlled trial

Background

Plantar heel pain (plantar fasciitis) is a common and disabling condition, which has a detrimental impact on health-related quality of life. Despite the high prevalence of plantar heel pain, the optimal treatment for this disorder remains unclear. Consequently, an alternative therapy such as dry needling is increasingly being used as an adjunctive treatment by health practitioners. Only two trials have investigated the effectiveness of dry needling for plantar heel pain, however both trials were of a low methodological quality. This manuscript describes the design of a randomised controlled trial to evaluate the effectiveness of dry needling for plantar heel pain.

Methods

Eighty community-dwelling men and woman aged over 18 years with plantar heel pain (who satisfy the inclusion and exclusion criteria) will be recruited. Eligible participants with plantar heel pain will be randomised to receive either one of two interventions, (i) real dry needling or (ii) sham dry needling. The protocol (including needling details and treatment regimen) was formulated by general consensus (using the Delphi research method) using 30 experts worldwide that commonly use dry needling for plantar heel pain. Primary outcome measures will be the pain subscale of the Foot Health Status Questionnaire and "first step" pain as measured on a visual analogue scale. The secondary outcome measures will be health related quality of life (assessed using the Short Form-36 questionnaire - Version Two) and depression, anxiety and stress (assessed using the Depression, Anxiety and Stress Scale - short version). Primary outcome measures will be performed at baseline, 2, 4, 6 and 12 weeks and secondary outcome measures will be performed at baseline, 6 and 12 weeks. Data will be analysed using the intention to treat principle.

Conclusion

This study is the first randomised controlled trial to evaluate the effectiveness of dry needling for plantar heel pain. The trial will be reported in accordance with the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials and the Standards for Reporting Interventions in Clinical Trials of Acupuncture guidelines. The findings from this trial will provide evidence for the effectiveness of trigger point dry needling for plantar heel pain.

Trial registration

Australian New Zealand 'Clinical Trials Registry'. ACTRN12610000611022.