Developmental variation and the evolution of distyly in Hedyotis caerulea (Rubiaceae)

How to build distylous flowers: comparative floral development and evolution of distylous species across the angiosperms

PREMISE

Distyly, a plant breeding system characterized by two floral morphs that have reciprocal positioning of anthers and stigmas, is known from at least 27 angiosperm families, making it an excellent example of convergent evolution. The various manners in which patterns of floral development produce the distinct anther and stigma heights in each morph remain largely unexplored from developmental and evolutionary perspectives.

METHODS

In 15 species representing at least 12 origins of distyly, heights and lengths of floral organs in each morph throughout development were examined using light microscopy. Patterns of floral organ development were determined and compared among species. Family-level phylogenies of distylous species and relatives were reconstructed, and patterns of ancestral herkogamy were resolved.

RESULTS

Differences in floral development between morphs resulted in 12 patterns leading to the anther and stigma positions characterizing distyly. Distylous species evolved from ancestors with different types of herkogamy, with approach herkogamy and lack of herkogamy resolved most frequently.

CONCLUSIONS

Seven of the 12 patterns of floral development are known from only one species, with three other patterns described among pairs of close relatives. The most common pattern of floral development, described from at least seven genera, involves for anther heights, distinct intermorph growth rates and for stigma heights, growth rates that differ between morphs only during later development. This pattern is common among subclass Lamiidae, suggesting canalized development within the taxon. Among distylous species, the same type of ancestral herkogamy can give rise to different patterns of floral development.

Floral development at multiple spatial scales in Polygonum jucundum (Polygonaceae), a distylous species with broadly open flowers

Distyly, a special polymorph, has evolved in many groups of angiosperms and has attracted attention since Darwin's time. Development studies on distylous taxa have helped us to understand the evolutionary process of this polymorph, but most of these studies focus on species with narrowly tubular corolla. Here, we studied the floral development of Polygonum jucundum, a distylous species with broadly open flowers, at multiple spatial scales. Results showed that the difference in stigma height between flowers of the two morphs was caused by differences in style growth throughout the entire floral development process. The observed difference in anther heights between the two morphs was because the filaments grew faster in short-styled (SS) than in long-styled (LS) flowers in the later stages of floral development. In addition, the longer styles in LS flowers than in SS flowers was because of faster cell division in the early stages of floral development. However, SS flowers had longer filaments than LS flowers primarily because of greater cell elongation. These results indicate that floral development in P. jucundum differs from that of distylous taxa with floral tubes shown in previous studies. Further, we conclude that the presence of distyly in species with open flowers is a result of convergent evolution.