Cost and yield considerations when expanding recruitment for genetic studies: the primary open-angle African American glaucoma genetics study

The Role of Genetic Ancestry as a Risk Factor for Primary Open-angle Glaucoma in African Americans

Purpose

POAG is the leading cause of irreversible blindness in African Americans. In this study, we quantitatively assess the association of autosomal ancestry with POAG risk in a large cohort of self-identified African Americans.

Methods

Subjects recruited to the Primary Open-Angle African American Glaucoma Genetics (POAAGG) study were classified as glaucoma cases or controls by fellowship-trained glaucoma specialists. POAAGG subjects were genotyped using the MEGA Ex array (discovery cohort, n = 3830; replication cohort, n = 2135). Population structure was interrogated using principal component analysis in the context of the 1000 Genomes Project superpopulations.

Results

The majority of POAAGG samples lie on an axis between African and European superpopulations, with great variation in admixture. Cases had a significantly lower mean value of the ancestral component q0 than controls for both cohorts (P = 6.14-4; P = 3-6), consistent with higher degree of African ancestry. Among POAG cases, higher African ancestry was also associated with thinner central corneal thickness (P = 2-4). Admixture mapping showed that local genetic ancestry was not a significant risk factor for POAG. A polygenic risk score, comprised of 23 glaucoma-associated single nucleotide polymorphisms from the NHGRI-EBI genome-wide association study catalog, was significant in both cohorts (P < 0.001), suggesting that both known POAG single nucleotide polymorphisms and an omnigenic ancestry effect influence POAG risk.

Conclusions

In sum, the POAAGG study population is very admixed, with a higher degree of African ancestry associated with an increased POAG risk. Further analyses should consider social and environmental factors as possible confounding factors for disease predisposition.

Evaluation of a multimedia marketing campaign to engage African American patients in glaucoma screening

Our objective was to determine which messaging approaches from a marketing campaign were most effective in recruiting African American individuals to a glaucoma screening and research study. We conducted a multimedia marketing campaign in Philadelphia from 01/31/2018 to 06/30/2018. Messaging approaches included radio advertisements and interviews (conducted in partnership with a local radio station with a large African American listener base), print materials, event tables, and online postings. Participants received free glaucoma screenings and the opportunity to enroll in our glaucoma genetics study. These screenings allowed individuals with glaucoma to receive a full examination and treatment plan with a glaucoma specialist, as well as to contribute to future efforts to identify genetic variants underlying this disease. We compared inquiry, enrollment, and cost yield for each messaging approach. Our campaign resulted in 154 unique inquiries, with 98 patients receiving glaucoma screenings (64%) and 60 patients enrolling in our study (39%). Commercials on WURD radio yielded the highest number of inquiries (62%) and enrollments (62%), but at relatively high cost ($814/enrolled patient). The most inexpensive approach that yielded more than five enrollments was postcards ($429/enrolled patient). Our campaign suggests that high-frequency commercials and postcards distributed at targeted healthcare locations are particularly effective and affordable options for connecting with the African American community. Our findings can help to inform recruitment efforts for other understudied diseases in minority populations.

Evaluation of the cost and effectiveness of diverse recruitment methods for a genetic screening study

PURPOSE

Recruitment of participants from diverse backgrounds is crucial to the generalizability of genetic research, but has proven challenging. We retrospectively evaluated recruitment methods used for a study on return of genetic results.

METHODS

The costs of study design, development, and participant enrollment were calculated, and the characteristics of the participants enrolled through the seven recruitment methods were examined.

RESULTS

A total of 1118 participants provided consent, a blood sample, and questionnaire data. The estimated cost across recruitment methods ranged from $579 to $1666 per participant and required a large recruitment team. Recruitment methods using flyers and staff networks were the most cost-efficient and resulted in the highest completion rate. Targeted sampling that emphasized the importance of Latino/a participation, utilization of translated materials, and in-person recruitments contributed to enrolling a demographically diverse sample.

CONCLUSIONS

Although all methods were deployed in the same hospital or neighborhood and shared the same staff, each recruitment method was different in terms of cost and characteristics of the enrolled participants, suggesting the importance of carefully choosing the recruitment methods based on the desired composition of the final study sample. This analysis provides information about the effectiveness and cost of different methods to recruit adults for genetic research.

The eMERGE genotype set of 83,717 subjects imputed to ~40 million variants genome wide and association with the herpes zoster medical record phenotype

The Electronic Medical Records and Genomics (eMERGE) network is a network of medical centers with electronic medical records linked to existing biorepository samples for genomic discovery and genomic medicine research. The network sought to unify the genetic results from 78 Illumina and Affymetrix genotype array batches from 12 contributing medical centers for joint association analysis of 83,717 human participants. In this report, we describe the imputation of eMERGE results and methods to create the unified imputed merged set of genome‐wide variant genotype data. We imputed the data using the Michigan Imputation Server, which provides a missing single‐nucleotide variant genotype imputation service using the minimac3 imputation algorithm with the Haplotype Reference Consortium genotype reference set. We describe the quality control and filtering steps used in the generation of this data set and suggest generalizable quality thresholds for imputation and phenotype association studies. To test the merged imputed genotype set, we replicated a previously reported chromosome 6 HLA‐B herpes zoster (shingles) association and discovered a novel zoster‐associated loci in an epigenetic binding site near the terminus of chromosome 3 (3p29).

Family History in the Primary Open-Angle African American Glaucoma Genetics Study Cohort

PURPOSE

To determine the relationship between positive family history (FH) and primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) diagnosis and clinical presentation in the Primary Open-Angle African American Glaucoma Genetics (POAAGG) cohort.

METHODS

FH of POAG in first-degree relatives was assessed in 2365 subjects in the POAAGG cohort. A standardized interview was used to assess FH of glaucoma, demographic characteristics, lifestyle choices, and medical and ocular comorbidities.

RESULTS

Positive FH was associated with increased risk of POAG (age-adjusted odds ratio and 95% confidence interval 3.4 [2.8, 4.1]). In age-adjusted analysis among POAG cases, positive FH was associated with younger age (P < .001), female sex (P < .001), hypertension (P = .006), use of hypertension medication (P = .03), and prior glaucoma surgery (P = .02). Cases with positive FH also had thicker retinal nerve fiber layers (P = .03).

CONCLUSIONS

The risk conferred by positive FH suggests strong genetic underpinnings for some patients with this disease, which will be investigated by genome-wide association studies and whole exome sequencing. NOTE: Publication of this article is sponsored by the American Ophthalmological Society.

Establishment of the Alabama Hereditary Cancer Cohort - strategies for the inclusion of underrepresented populations in cancer genetics research

BACKGROUND

Historically, groups that are most susceptible to health and healthcare disparities have been underrepresented in medical research. It is imperative to explore approaches that can facilitate the recruitment of underrepresented individuals into research studies.

METHODS

Two approaches, hospital and community-based recruitment (CBR), were developed and implemented over 36 months to study the genetics of hereditary breast cancer and associated cancers in Alabama, a medically underserved state with double the national percentage of self-identifying African Americans, establishing the Alabama Hereditary Cancer Cohort.

RESULTS

Overall, 242 individuals enrolled. This included 84 cancer probands through hospital recruitment, as well as 76 probands and 82 family members through CBR. Eighty-one percent of the study participants' counties of residence are completely medically underserved. Furthermore, African Americans represent 26% of the hospital probands compared to 49% and 70% of the probands and family members who, respectively, enrolled through CBR.

CONCLUSION

Although both recruitment mechanisms were instrumental, the unique trust building, educational, and traveling components of CBR facilitated the enrollment of African Americans resulting in large families for genetic analyses. The ultimate goal is to gain insight from these rudimentary efforts in order to expand recruitment and accrue a unique resource for cancer genetics research.