Dietary profile of patients with Stargardt's disease and Retinitis Pigmentosa: is there a role for a nutritional approach?

Natural History of Stargardt Disease: The Longest Follow-Up Cohort Study

Long-term natural history studies are important in rare disease research. This study aimed to assess electrophysiological and fundus autofluorescence (FAF) progression rate in 18 genetically confirmed Stargardt disease (STGD1) patients with a minimum follow-up of 10 years. Age at the first and last exams, age at onset, Snellen decimal visual acuity (VA), electroretinography (ERG), and FAF images were evaluated. Patients were classified into four Fishman stages and three electroretinography groups, and areas of definitely decreased autofluorescence (DDAF) were measured. Patients were further substratified based on genotype, and phenotype-genotype correlations were performed. The median follow-up was 18 (range 10-26) years. The median yearly VA loss was 0.009 (range 0.002-0.071), while the median progression rate of the DDAF area was 0.354 (range 0.002-4.359) mm² per year. Patients harbouring p.(Gly1961Glu) or p.(Asn1868Ile) allele had significantly slower DDAF area progression when compared to patients with other genotypes (0.07 mm² vs. 1.03 mm², respectively), as well as significantly later age at onset (20 years vs. 13 years, respectively). Results showed that structural and functional parameters, together with genotype, should be considered when counselling patients regarding prognosis and monitoring disease progression. Patients harbouring hypomorphic variants p.(Gly1961Glu) or p.(Asn1868Ile) presented with overall milder disease than patients with other genotypes.

Retinitis Pigmentosa: Current Clinical Management and Emerging Therapies

Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) comprises a group of inherited retinal dystrophies characterized by the degeneration of rod photoreceptors, followed by the degeneration of cone photoreceptors. As a result of photoreceptor degeneration, affected individuals experience gradual loss of visual function, with primary symptoms of progressive nyctalopia, constricted visual fields and, ultimately, central vision loss. The onset, severity and clinical course of RP shows great variability and unpredictability, with most patients already experiencing some degree of visual disability in childhood. While RP is currently untreatable for the majority of patients, significant efforts have been made in the development of genetic therapies, which offer new hope for treatment for patients affected by inherited retinal dystrophies. In this exciting era of emerging gene therapies, it remains imperative to continue supporting patients with RP using all available options to manage their condition. Patients with RP experience a wide variety of physical, mental and social-emotional difficulties during their lifetime, of which some require timely intervention. This review aims to familiarize readers with clinical management options that are currently available for patients with RP.

Vitamin A, systemic T-cells, and the eye: Focus on degenerative retinal disease

The first discovered vitamin, vitamin A, exists in a range of forms, primarily retinoids and provitamin carotenoids. The bioactive forms of vitamin A, retinol and retinoic acid, have many critical functions in body systems including the eye and immune system. Vitamin A deficiency is associated with dysfunctional immunity, and presents clinically as a characteristic ocular syndrome, xerophthalmia. The immune functions of vitamin A extend to the gut, where microbiome interactions and nutritional retinoids and carotenoids contribute to the balance of T cell differentiation, thereby determining immune status and contributing to inflammatory disease around the whole body. In the eye, degenerative conditions affecting the retina and uvea are influenced by vitamin A. Stargardt's disease (STGD1; MIM 248200) is characterised by bisretinoid deposits such as lipofuscin, produced by retinal photoreceptors as they use and recycle a vitamin A-derived chromophore. Age-related macular degeneration features comparable retinal deposits, such as drusen featuring lipofuscin accumulation; and is characterised by parainflammatory processes. We hypothesise that local parainflammatory processes secondary to lipofuscin deposition in the retina are mediated by T cells interacting with dietary vitamin A derivatives and the gut microbiome, and outline the current evidence for this. No cures exist for Stargardt's or age-related macular degeneration, but many vitamin A-based therapeutic approaches have been or are being trialled. The relationship between vitamin A's functions in systemic immunology and the eye could be further exploited, and further research may seek to leverage the interactions of the gut-eye immunological axis.

NUTRARET: Effect of 2-Year Nutraceutical Supplementation on Redox Status and Visual Function of Patients With Retinitis Pigmentosa: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial

Oxidative stress plays a major role in the pathogenesis of retinitis pigmentosa (RP). The main goal of this study was to evaluate the effect of 2-year nutritional intervention with antioxidant nutraceuticals on the visual function of RP patients. Secondly, we assessed how nutritional intervention affected ocular and systemic redox status. We carried out a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Thirty-one patients with RP participated in the study. RP patients randomly received either a mixture of nutraceuticals (NUT) containing folic acid, vitamin B6, vitamin A, zinc, copper, selenium, lutein, and zeaxanthin or placebo daily for 2 years. At baseline and after 2-year of the nutritional supplementation, visual function, dietetic-nutritional evaluations, serum concentration of nutraceuticals, plasma and aqueous humor concentration of several markers of redox status and inflammation were assessed. Retinal function and structure were assessed by multifocal electroretinogram (mfERG), spectral domain-optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) and automated visual field (VF) tests. Nutritional status was estimated with validated questionnaires. Total antioxidant capacity, extracellular superoxide dismutase (SOD3), catalase (CAT), and glutathione peroxidase (GPx) activities, protein carbonyl adducts (CAR) content, thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS) formation (as indicator of lipid peroxidation), metabolites of the nitric oxide (NOX) and cytokine (interleukin 6 and tumor necrosis factor alpha) concentrations were assessed by biochemical and immunological techniques in aqueous humor or/and blood. Bayesian approach was performed to determine the probability of an effect. Region of practical equivalence (ROPE) was used. At baseline, Bayesian analysis revealed a high probability of an altered ocular redox status and to a lesser extent systemic redox status in RP patients compared to controls. Twenty-five patients (10 in the treated arm and 15 in the placebo arm) completed the nutritional intervention. After 2 years of supplementation, patients who received NUT presented better retinal responses (mfERG responses) compared to patients who received placebo. Besides, patients who received NUT showed better ocular antioxidant response (SOD3 activity) and lower oxidative damage (CAR) than those who received placebo. This study suggested that long-term NUT supplementation could slow down visual impairment and ameliorate ocular oxidative stress.

The Role of Vitamin A in Retinal Diseases

Vitamin A is an essential fat-soluble vitamin that occurs in various chemical forms. It is essential for several physiological processes. Either hyper- or hypovitaminosis can be harmful. One of the most important vitamin A functions is its involvement in visual phototransduction, where it serves as the crucial part of photopigment, the first molecule in the process of transforming photons of light into electrical signals. In this process, large quantities of vitamin A in the form of 11-cis-retinal are being isomerized to all-trans-retinal and then quickly recycled back to 11-cis-retinal. Complex machinery of transporters and enzymes is involved in this process (i.e., the visual cycle). Any fault in the machinery may not only reduce the efficiency of visual detection but also cause the accumulation of toxic chemicals in the retina. This review provides a comprehensive overview of diseases that are directly or indirectly connected with vitamin A pathways in the retina. It includes the pathophysiological background and clinical presentation of each disease and summarizes the already existing therapeutic and prospective interventions.

Clinical Observation and Genotype-Phenotype Analysis of ABCA4- Related Hereditary Retinal Degeneration before Gene Therapy

BACKGROUND

Hereditary retinal degeneration (HRD) is an irreversible eye disease that results in blindness in severe cases. It is most commonly caused by variants in the ABCA4 gene. HRD presents a high degree of clinical and genetic heterogeneity. We determined genotypic and phenotypic correlations, in the natural course of clinical observation, of unrelated progenitors of HRD associated with ABCA4.

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the relationship between the phenotypes and genotypes of ABCA4 variants.

METHODS

A retrospective clinical study of five cases from the ophthalmology department of the People's Hospital of Wuhan University from January 2019 to October 2020 was conducted. We tested for ABCA4 variants in the probands. We performed eye tests, including the best-corrected visual acuity, super-wide fundus photography and spontaneous fluorescence photography, optical coherence tomography, and electrophysiological examination.

RESULTS

Disease-causing variants were identified in the ABCA4 genes of all patients. Among these, seven ABCA4 variants were novel. All patients were sporadic cases; only one patient had parents who were relatives, and the other four patients were offspring of unrelated parents. Two patients presented with Stargardt disease, mainly with macular lesions, two presented with retinitis pigmentosa (cone-rod type), and one presented with cone dystrophy. The visual acuity and visual field of the five patients showed varying degrees of deterioration and impairment.

CONCLUSION

The same ABCA4 mutation can lead to different clinical phenotypes, and there is variation in the degree of damage to vision, visual field, and electrophysiology among different clinical phenotypes. Clinicians must differentiate between and diagnose pathologies resulting from this mutation.

Stargardt misdiagnosis: How ocular genetics helps

Ocular Genetics at Wills Eye Hospital sees a wide range of rare disorders for accurate diagnosis. To demonstrate how focused consultation and genetic testing results in precise diagnoses, we investigated false diagnosis rates for patients referred with a diagnosis of Stargardt disease. This is a retrospective review of patients over a 3 year period referred to our Ocular Genetics clinic for possible Stargardt disease, or already holding a diagnosis of Stargardt disease. Results of diagnostic and genetic testing were compared to standard definition of Stargardt. Of 40 patients, 14 (35%) had been misdiagnosed. Four had non-Stargardt phenotype of which three had ABCA4 pathogenic variants with phenotypes inconsistent with Stargardt disease. Two of those with pathogenic ABCA4 variants were related. Nine had pathogenic variants in other different genes with overlapping features of Stargardt disease. One had Thioridazine maculopathy. Our study highlights the essential role of the subspecialty field of ocular genetics in obtaining accurate diagnoses for the delivery of correct counseling and interventional trial eligibility assessment.

A Ketogenic & Low-Protein Diet Slows Retinal Degeneration in rd10 Mice

Purpose

Treatments that delay retinal cell death regardless of genetic causation are needed for inherited retinal degeneration (IRD) patients. The ketogenic diet is a high-fat, low-carbohydrate diet, used to treat epilepsy, and has beneficial effects for neurodegenerative diseases. This study aimed to determine whether the ketogenic diet could slow retinal degeneration.

Methods

Early weaned, rd10 and wild-type (WT) mice were placed on either standard chow, a ketogenic diet, or a ketogenic & low-protein diet. From postnatal day (PD) 23 to PD50, weight and blood β-hydroxybutyrate levels were recorded. Retinal thickness, retinal function, and visual performance were measured via optical coherence tomography, electroretinography (ERG), and optokinetic tracking (OKT). At PD40, serum albumin, rhodopsin protein, and phototransduction gene expression were measured.

Results

Both ketogenic diets elicited a systemic induction of ketosis. However, rd10 mice on the ketogenic & low-protein diet had significant increases in photoreceptor thickness, ERG amplitudes, and OKT thresholds, whereas rd10 mice on the ketogenic diet showed no photoreceptor preservation. In both rd10 and WT mice, the ketogenic & low-protein diet was associated with abnormal weight gain and decreases in serum albumin levels, 27% and 56%, respectively. In WT mice, the ketogenic & low-protein diet was also associated with an ∼20% to 30% reduction in ERG amplitudes.

Conclusions

The ketogenic & low-protein diet slowed retinal degeneration in a clinically relevant IRD model. In WT mice, the ketogenic & low-protein diet was associated with a decrease in phototransduction and serum albumin, which could serve as a protective mechanism in the rd10 model. Although ketosis was associated with protection, its role remains unclear.

Translational Relevance

Neuroprotective mechanisms associated with the ketogenic & low-protein diet have potential to slow retinal degeneration.

The Impact of Inherited Retinal Diseases in the Republic of Ireland (ROI) and the United Kingdom (UK) from a Cost-of-Illness Perspective

To date, there has been a global lack of data regarding the prevalence of conditions falling under the Inherited Retinal Diseases (IRD) classification, the impact on the individuals and families affected, and the cost burden to economies. The absence of an international patient registry, and equitable access to genetic testing, compounds this matter. The resulting incomplete knowledge of the impact of IRDs hinders the development and commissioning of clinical services, provision of treatments, and planning and implementation of clinical trials. Thus, there is a need for stronger evidence to support value for money to regulatory bodies for treatments approved, and progressing through clinical trials. To ensure a strategic approach to future research and service provision, it is necessary to learn more about the IRD landscape. This review highlights two recent cost-of-illness reports on the socio-economic impact of 10 IRDs in the Republic of Ireland (ROI) and the United Kingdom (UK), which demonstrate the comprehensive impact of IRDs on individuals affected, their families, friends and society. Total costs attributable to IRDs in the ROI were estimated to be £42.6 million in 2019, comprising economic (£28.8 million) and wellbeing costs (£13.8 million). Wellbeing costs were estimated using the World Health Organization (WHO) burden of disease methodology, a non-financial approach, where pain, suffering and premature mortality are measured in terms of disability-adjusted-life-years (DALYs). In the UK, wellbeing costs attributable to IRDs were £196.1 million, and economic costs were £327.2 million amounting to £523.3 million total costs in 2019. Accounting for over one-third of total costs, the wellbeing burden of persons affected by IRDs should be emphasized and factored into reimbursement processes for therapies and care pathways. This targeted review presents the most current and relevant data on IRD prevalence in the ROI and the UK, and the impacts (financial and non-financial) of IRDs in terms of diagnosis, wellbeing, employment, formal and informal care, health system costs, deadweight losses and issues surrounding payers and reimbursement. This review demonstrates IRD patients and their families have common issues including, the need for timely equitable access to genetic testing and counselling, equality in accessing employment, and a revision of the assessment process for reimbursement of therapies currently focused on the cost-of-illness to the healthcare system. This review reveals that IRD patients do not frequently engage the healthcare system and as such suggests a cost-of-illness model from a societal perspective may be a better format.

Highly Variable Disease Courses in Siblings with Stargardt Disease

PURPOSE

To investigate intersibling phenotypic concordance in Stargardt disease (STGD1).

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

PARTICIPANTS

Siblings with genetically confirmed STGD1 and at least 1 available fundus autofluorescence (FAF) image of both eyes.

METHODS

We compared age at onset within families. Disease duration was matched to investigate differences in best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) and compared the survival time for reaching severe visual impairment (<20/200 Snellen or >1.0 logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution [logMAR]). Central retinal atrophy area was quantified independently by 2 experienced graders using semiautomated software and compared between siblings. Both graders performed qualitative assessment of FAF and spectral-domain (SD) OCT images to identify phenotypic differences.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Differences in age at onset, disease duration-matched BCVA, time to severe visual impairment development, FAF atrophy area, FAF patterns, and genotypes.

RESULTS

Substantial differences in age at onset were present in 5 of 17 families, ranging from 13 to 39 years. Median BCVA at baseline was 0.60 logMAR (range, -0.20 to 2.30 logMAR; Snellen equivalent, 20/80 [range, 20/12-hand movements]) in the right eye and 0.50 logMAR (range, -0.20 to 2.30 logMAR; Snellen equivalent, 20/63 [range, 20/12-hand movements]) in the left eye. Disease duration-matched BCVA was investigated in 12 of 17 families, and the median difference was 0.41 logMAR (range, 0.00-1.10 logMAR) for the right eye and 0.41 logMAR (range, 0.00-1.08 logMAR) for the left eye. We observed notable differences in time to severe visual impairment development in 7 families, ranging from 1 to 29 years. Median central retinal atrophy area was 11.38 mm² in the right eye (range, 1.98-44.78 mm²) and 10.59 mm² in the left eye (range, 1.61-40.59 mm²) and highly comparable between siblings. Similarly, qualitative FAF and SD OCT phenotypes were highly comparable between siblings.

CONCLUSIONS

Phenotypic discordance between siblings with STGD1 carrying the same ABCA4 variants is a prevalent phenomenon. Although the FAF phenotypes are highly comparable between siblings, functional outcomes differ substantially. This complicates both sibling-based prognosis and genotype-phenotype correlations and has important implications for patient care and management.

Treatments for dry age-related macular degeneration and Stargardt disease: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is the leading cause of visual loss in older people. Advanced AMD takes two forms, neovascular (wet) and atrophic (dry). Stargardt disease (STGD) is the commonest form of inherited macular dystrophy.

OBJECTIVE

To carry out a systematic review of treatments for dry AMD and STGD, and to identify emerging treatments where future NIHR research might be commissioned.

DESIGN

Systematic review.

METHODS

We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science and The Cochrane Library from 2005 to 13 July 2017 for reviews, journal articles and meeting abstracts. We looked for studies of interventions that aim to preserve or restore vision in people with dry AMD or STGD. The most important outcomes are those that matter to patients: visual acuity (VA), contrast sensitivity, reading speed, ability to drive, adverse effects of treatment, quality of life, progression of disease and patient preference. However, visual loss is a late event and intermediate predictors of future decline were accepted if there was good evidence that they are strong predictors of subsequent visual outcomes. These include changes detectable by investigation, but not necessarily noticed by people with AMD or STGD. ClinicalTrials.gov, the World Health Organization search portal and the UK Clinical Trials gateway were searched for ongoing and recently completed clinical trials.

RESULTS

The titles and abstracts of 7948 articles were screened for inclusion. The full text of 398 articles were obtained for further screening and checking of references and 112 articles were included in the final report. Overall, there were disappointingly few good-quality studies (including of sufficient size and duration) reporting useful outcomes, particularly in STGD. However we did identify a number of promising research topics, including drug treatments, stem cells, new forms of laser treatment, and implantable intraocular lens telescopes. In many cases, research is already under way, funded by industry or governments.

LIMITATIONS

In AMD, the main limitation came from the poor quality of much of the evidence. Many studies used VA as their main outcome despite not having sufficient duration to observe changes. The evidence on treatments for STGD is sparse. Most studies tested interventions with no comparison group, were far too short term, and the quality of some studies was poor.

FUTURE WORK

We think that the topics on which the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Efficacy Mechanism and Evaluation (EME) programmes might consider commissioning primary research are in STGD, a HTA trial of fenretinide (ReVision Therapeutics, San Diego, CA, USA), a visual cycle inhibitor, and EME research into the value of lutein and zeaxanthin supplements, using short-term measures of retinal function. In AMD, we suggest trials of fenretinide and of a potent statin. There is epidemiological evidence from the USA that the drug, levodopa, used for treating Parkinson's disease, may reduce the incidence of AMD. We suggest that similar research should be carried out using the large general practice databases in the UK. Ideally, future research should be at earlier stages in both diseases, before vision is impaired, using sensitive measures of macular function. This may require early detection of AMD by screening.

STUDY REGISTRATION

This study is registered as PROSPERO CRD42016038708.

FUNDING

The National Institute for Health Research HTA programme.

The uncommon occurrence of two common inherited disorders in a single patient: a mini case series

BACKGROUND

Inherited eye disorders are genetically determined conditions that are present from birth and usually manifest early, although some may develop later in life. Despite their low incidence, they are a common etiology of pediatric blindness. The occurrence of more than one such disease in a patient is very rare.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Case series of two unrelated patients with simultaneous Stargardt disease (STGD1) as well as Stickler's Syndrome (SS), both genetically confirmed.

RESULTS

Patient 1: 13-year-old girl was referred for unexplained bilateral decreased vision for 6 months. She had a clinical diagnosis of SS, same as her mother. Her visual acuity was 20/200 with high myopia in both eyes. Her fundus showed foveal/perifoveal atrophy, retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) changes and beaded vitreous. Goldman visual fields (GVF) revealed enlarged blind spots with central depression. A macular dystrophy was suspected. Genetic testing revealed SS, COL11A1 gene mutation; and STGD1, ABCA4 gene mutation. Patient 2: 67-year-old female with a history of hearing loss, cleft palate, strabismus and myopia, same as her daughter and granddaughters. Her visual acuity was 20/400 and 20/250 with high myopia in both eyes. Her fundus showed macular pigment clumping and RPE atrophy with no vitreous abnormality. GVF revealed a relative central scotoma with generalized constriction. Genetic testing revealed SS, COL11A2 gene mutation; and STGD1, ABCA4 gene mutation.

CONCLUSIONS

If a patient's signs/symptoms cannot be explained by the working/known diagnosis, additional work up should be pursued for concomitant diseases. SS and STGD1 are commonly diagnosed inherited eye disorders and can coexist in one patient on rare occasions.

Vitamin A in Stargardt disease-an evidence-based update

BACKGROUND

High intake of vitamin A is suspected to be a risk factor for the progression of Stargardt disease (STGD1) and many health authorities recommend Stargardt patients not to use oral vitamin A supplements outside that provided naturally in the food. The present study provides the first systematic review of the current level of evidence regarding the role of supplementary vitamin A in STGD1.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted a systematic scientific literature search in the Pubmed database on studies reporting on the effect of oral vitamin A or serum retinol on visual function.

RESULTS

In animal studies neither high nor low serum retinol in an Abca4 knockout mouse model of Stargardt showed any effect on electroretinography (ERG). In humans, significantly better visual function was reported in a cross-sectional study of patients with a low dietary intake of vitamin A, whereas a prospective study did not find any correlation between vitamin A supplementation and visual acuity. A newly introduced vitamin A substitute (C20-D(3)-vitamin A) has shown promising effects on ERG in a Stargardt mouse model.

CONCLUSIONS

There are few studies on the effect of vitamin A in STGD1. The scarcity and inconclusiveness of evidence available impel further research efforts to reach a more confident conclusion. Currently, recommendations to avoid vitamin A dietary supplementation rely mainly on a theoretical background. Animal studies on vitamin A substitute as a possible therapeutic approach in preventing or slowing vision loss in STGD1 seems promising but further clinical trials are needed to verify the results.