Nurse-led normalised advance care planning service in hospital and community health settings: a qualitative study

Interventions to promote readiness for advance care planning: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Advance care planning is recommended as part of standard medical services. Readiness, denoting stages of behavior change, exerts a substantial influence on its uptake. However, the characteristics and impacts of advance care planning interventions on readiness are not well-established.

METHOD

We systematically reviewed and conducted a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials assessing the effects of advance care planning interventions on readiness. Studies were appraised using Joanna Briggs Institute Critical Appraisal tools. Meta-analyses were performed using mean difference of continuous variables or risk ratios of binary variables and their 95 % confidence interval as the pooled effect sizes.

RESULTS

Eight studies were included in this review and were all rated low quality. Meta-analysis showed that interventions resulted in slight improvement in overall readiness (mean difference = 0.19, 95 % confidence interval: 0.02-0.36) for advance care planning. However, statistically significant effects of interventions were not identified for readiness in relation to specific behaviors (appointment of a healthcare proxy, talking to a healthcare proxy, talking to a medical practitioner about living wills, and signing a living will).

CONCLUSION

Our meta-analyses demonstrated that interventions can improve the overall readiness for advance care planning, suggesting the necessity to integrate readiness into future health policies and clinical practices. Nevertheless, the absence of significant effects on specific behavioral readiness underscores the requirement for additional refinement in intervention design, advanced technologies, and theoretical foundations.

REGISTRATION

Not registered.

Experiences and perspectives on the optimal timing for initiating advance care planning in patients with mild to moderate dementia: A meta-synthesis

BACKGROUND

Advance care planning is typically initiated during the last six months of a patient's life. However, due to the progressive decline in the decision-making process in individuals with dementia, their involvement in advance care planning is limited to the early stages of the disease. Currently, there is no consensus on the optimal timing for initiating advance care planning for people with dementia, and a comprehensive review of the literature addressing this matter is lacking.

OBJECTIVE

To explore the experiences and perspectives of people with dementia, their family caregivers, and health care professionals with regard to the optimal timing for initiating advance care planning.

DESIGN

A meta-synthesis was conducted.

DATA SOURCE

The following eight electronic databases were searched: PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, CINAHL and CNKI, WanFang and Vip.

REVIEW METHODS

This review uses thematic synthesis to systematically synthesize qualitative evidence and report findings according to The Enhancing Transparency in Reporting the Synthesis of Qualitative Research (ENTREQ) and the Joanna Briggs Institute Manual for Evidence Synthesis. Study selection and data extraction were conducted independently by two researchers, and quality was evaluated using the Joanna Briggs Institute's Qualitative Research Standard Assessment tool.

FINDINGS

Twenty-one studies were selected for this review. This review involved an overarching theme: The utilization of pivotal elements to transition from delayed initiation to comprehensive implementation. Three themes emerge, including the prerequisites for initiating advance care planning, not ready to start advance care planning and struggling along narrow roads. For health care professionals, the selection of an opportune moment to initiate advance care planning for people with dementia is not only a challenge but also a crucial prerequisite for the successful implementation of advance care planning. Health care professionals' experience, attitude toward advance care planning, trust relationship with patients, cultural differences among people with dementia and their caregivers, and economic disparities all influence health care professionals' judgment of the timing for initiating advance care planning.

CONCLUSIONS

Determining the optimal timing for initiating advance care planning is a complex process that requires a comprehensive consideration of the realities faced by health care professionals, people with dementia and their caregivers. Therefore, it is imperative to provide relevant training to health care professionals to ensure the successful implementation of advance care planning.

Psychometric evaluation of the Chinese version of advance care planning self-efficacy scale among clinical nurses

Background

Nurses are one of the most critical members of advance care planning (ACP) discussion. The evaluation of ACP self-efficacy is of great significance for developing targeted ACP interventions among clinical nurses and update their professional roles. However, there are few instruments to evaluate their ACP self-efficacy in mainland China. The purpose of this study was to translate the ACP self-efficacy scale into Chinese and evaluate its psychometric properties among clinical nurses.

Methods

A methodological study of the translation and validation of the ACP self-efficacy scale was conducted from January to March 2022. It involved three phases: (1) the translation and revision of the scale; (2) the exploration and evaluation of the item (n = 436); (3) the psychometric evaluation of the scale (n = 674).

Results

After a rigorous translation and revision, the ACP self-efficacy scale with three dimensions and 16 items was finally formed. In this study, the critical ratios of the item ranged from 8.226 to 17.499, and the item-total correlation coefficients ranged from 0.437 to 0.732, and the factor loadings of the item ranged from 0.638 to 0.882. The content validity index of the scale was 0.946. Supported by the eigenvalues, the three-factor structure explained the cumulative 61.131% of the overall variance. As the results of confirmatory factor analysis, all the recommended fitting indexes were appropriate. The average variance extracted values ranged from 0.570 to 0.756, and the composite reliability values ranged from 0.858 to 0.925. The total Cronbach's α coefficient, split-half reliability coefficient and test–retest reliability coefficient of the scale were 0.896, 0.767 and 0.939, respectively.

Conclusion

The Chinese version of ACP self-efficacy scale was successfully introduced into China, showing good psychometric properties among clinical nurses, and can effectively assess the ACP self-efficacy. Also, the scale can provide nursing educators with a significant strategy to develop ACP educational procedure and post-intervention measures for clinical nurses to improve nurse-led ACP practice.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12904-022-01064-6.

The development of a questionnaire to assess the willingness of Chinese community health workers to implement advance care planning

Background

To develop a questionnaire to evaluate the willingness of Chinese health care workers to implement an advance care planning (ACP) program for patients in a Chinese cultural context.

Methods

Guided by the framework of the theory of planned behavior (TPB), a literature analysis and semi-structured interviews were conducted to create a pool of questionnaire items, and then the initial assessment questionnaire was developed by two rounds of expert consultations. A random sampling method was used to pre-survey 204 health care workers in community health service centers (CHSCs) in three urban areas of Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province. The final questionnaire was derived from item analysis and exploratory factor analysis.

Results

Based on exploratory factor analysis, five common factors were identified from the questionnaire on community health care workers‘(CHWs) willingness to implement ACP. In general, the content validity of the questionnaire was 0.91, and the content validity of each of the entries ranged from 0.80 to 1.00, indicating acceptable overall questionnaire content validity. The total Cronbach coefficient for the questionnaire was 0.966, the Cronbach coefficient for each dimension ranged from 0.865 to 0.954, and the retest reliability was 0.856. The questionnaire produced a final draft containing five dimensions (behavioral attitudes, subjective norms, direct control, indirect control, and behavioral intentions) and 30 items.

Conclusion

The questionnaire on the willingness of CHWs to implement ACP was validated and found to be reliable.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12904-022-01046-8.

Die Sichtweise von Pflegefachpersonen auf ihre mögliche Rolle bei Advance Care Planning in der ambulanten Pflege

Zusammenfassung. Hintergrund: Beratung zu Advance Care Planning (ACP) ist als Aufgabenbereich der „Gesundheitlichen Versorgungsplanung“ unter anderem für Pflegefachpersonen in der stationären Langzeitversorgung in Deutschland vorgesehen. In der StAdPlan-Studie (DRKS0016886) wurde eine ACP-Intervention in die ambulante Pflege implementiert und evaluiert: Geschulte Pflegefachpersonen führten Beratung zu ACP mit Patient_innen durch. Teil der Studie war eine umfassende Prozessevaluation. Ziel: Ein Teilergebnis der Prozessevaluation war die Analyse der Sichtweise von Pflegefachpersonen auf ihre mögliche Rolle als ACP-Berater_innen. Methode: Leitfadengestützte Interviews mit Pflegefachpersonen und Pflegedienstleitungen ( n = 42) wurden vor der Implementierung der ACP-Intervention durchgeführt und inhaltsanalytisch ausgewertet. Ergebnis: Die Teilnehmenden schilderten die Bedeutung von ACP in der ambulanten Pflege, ihre persönliche Motivation und Kompetenz sowie notwendige Rahmenbedingungen. Pflegefachpersonen möchten Beratungen von Patient_innen anbieten, um sie nach deren Wünschen versorgen zu können. Für eine gute Beratung halten sie zusätzliches Wissen und zeitliche Ressourcen zu ACP sowie Gesprächskompetenz für notwendig. ACP-Beratung kann ein geeignetes Handlungsfeld für Pflegefachpersonen sein, da sie den Zugang und ein etabliertes Vertrauensverhältnis zu den Patient_innen haben. Schlussfolgerung: Die Rolle von Pflegefachpersonen als Beratende für ACP in der ambulanten Versorgung wurde als machbar und sinnvoll eingeschätzt. Voraussetzung sind die Finanzierung der Leistung sowie eine Schulung der Pflegefachpersonen.