Identification of deleterious variants in patients with male infertility due to idiopathic non-obstructive azoospermia

Utility of exome sequencing in primary spermatogenic disorders: From research to diagnostics

BACKGROUND

Primary spermatogenic disorders represent a severe form of male infertility whereby sperm production is impaired due to testicular dysfunction, leading to reduced quality or quantity of spermatozoa. Gene-centered research has certainly demonstrated the importance of the genetic factor in the etiology of both poor sperm morphology or motility and reduced sperm count. In the last decade, next-generation sequencing has expanded the research to whole exome which has transformed our understanding of male infertility genetics, but uncertainty persists in its diagnostic yield, especially in large unrelated populations.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the utility of exome sequencing in detecting genetic factors contributing to various traits of primary spermatogenic disorders, which is a crucial step before interpreting the diagnostic yield of the platform.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We manually curated 415 manuscripts and included 19 research studies that predominantly performed whole exome sequencing in cohorts of unrelated cases with primary spermatogenic defects.

RESULTS

The detection rate, defined as the fraction of cases with an identifiable genetic cause, typically remained below 25% for quantitative defects of spermatozoa, whereas improved rates were observed for traits of abnormal sperm morphology/motility and in populations enriched with consanguineous families. Unlike the quantitative defects, the genetic architecture of the qualitative issues of spermatozoa featured a small number of recurrent genes describing a large fraction of studied cases. These observations were also in line with the lower biological complexity of the pathways affected by the reported genes.

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

This review demonstrates the variability in detection rates of exome sequencing across semen phenotypes, which may have an impact on the expectations of the diagnostic yield in the clinical setting.

Whole exome sequencing analysis of 167 men with primary infertility

BACKGROUND

Spermatogenic failure is one of the leading causes of male infertility and its genetic etiology has not yet been fully understood.

METHODS

The study screened a cohort of patients (n = 167) with primary male infertility in contrast to 210 normally fertile men using whole exome sequencing (WES). The expression analysis of the candidate genes based on public single cell sequencing data was performed using the R language Seurat package.

RESULTS

No pathogenic copy number variations (CNVs) related to male infertility were identified using the the GATK-gCNV tool. Accordingly, variants of 17 known causative (five X-linked and twelve autosomal) genes, including ACTRT1, ADAD2, AR, BCORL1, CFAP47, CFAP54, DNAH17, DNAH6, DNAH7, DNAH8, DNAH9, FSIP2, MSH4, SLC9C1, TDRD9, TTC21A, and WNK3, were identified in 23 patients. Variants of 12 candidate (seven X-linked and five autosomal) genes were identified, among which CHTF18, DDB1, DNAH12, FANCB, GALNT3, OPHN1, SCML2, UPF3A, and ZMYM3 had altered fertility and semen characteristics in previously described knockout mouse models, whereas MAGEC1,RBMXL3, and ZNF185 were recurrently detected in patients with male factor infertility. The human testis single cell-sequencing database reveals that CHTF18, DDB1 and MAGEC1 are preferentially expressed in spermatogonial stem cells. DNAH12 and GALNT3 are found primarily in spermatocytes and early spermatids. UPF3A is present at a high level throughout spermatogenesis except in elongating spermatids. The testicular expression profiles of these candidate genes underlie their potential roles in spermatogenesis and the pathogenesis of male infertility.

CONCLUSION

WES is an effective tool in the genetic diagnosis of primary male infertility. Our findings provide useful information on precise treatment, genetic counseling, and birth defect prevention for male factor infertility.

Association between anti-Müllerian hormone concentrations and sperm retrieval outcomes in patients with idiopathic nonobstructive azoospermia: a systematic review and meta-analysis

ABSTRACT

Microdissection testicular sperm extraction (mTESE) is commonly performed to retrieve sperm in the testes for assisted reproductive techniques in patients with idiopathic nonobstructive azoospermia (iNOA). However, the success rate of sperm retrieval varies among individuals. We aim to investigate the association between clinical parameters and sperm retrieval outcomes in patients with iNOA. We searched PubMed, EMBASE, and Web of Science from database inception to August 2, 2023. The main measure was whether sperm retrieval was successful in patients with iNOA who underwent mTESE. Pooled estimates of the sperm retrieval rate and weighted mean differences were calculated using random-effects models. The overall sperm retrieval rate was 36.8% (95% confidence interval [CI]: 27.5%-46.0%, I2 = 95.0%) in nine studies comprising 1892 patients with iNOA. No significant differences were found in age, testicular volume, serum total testosterone concentrations, or inhibin B concentrations between positive and negative sperm retrieval outcomes. Lower anti-Müllerian hormone concentrations in patients with iNOA were associated with a positive outcome of mTESE (weighted mean differences: -2.70; 95% CI: -3.94--1.46, I2 = 79.0%). In conclusion, this study shows a significant relationship between anti-Müllerian hormone and sperm retrieval outcomes in patients with iNOA, while age, testicular volume, total testosterone, and inhibin B show no significant association. These findings have important implications for assessing the potential success of sperm retrieval and selecting appropriate treatment strategies in patients with iNOA.

Spermatocytes have the capacity to segregate chromosomes despite centriole duplication failure

Centrosomes are the canonical microtubule organizing centers (MTOCs) of most mammalian cells, including spermatocytes. Centrosomes comprise a centriole pair within a structurally ordered and dynamic pericentriolar matrix (PCM). Unlike in mitosis, where centrioles duplicate once per cycle, centrioles undergo two rounds of duplication during spermatogenesis. The first duplication is during early meiotic prophase I, and the second is during interkinesis. Using mouse mutants and chemical inhibition, we have blocked centriole duplication during spermatogenesis and determined that non-centrosomal MTOCs (ncMTOCs) can mediate chromosome segregation. This mechanism is different from the acentriolar MTOCs that form bipolar spindles in oocytes, which require PCM components, including gamma-tubulin and CEP192. From an in-depth analysis, we identified six microtubule-associated proteins, TPX2, KIF11, NuMA, and CAMSAP1-3, that localized to the non-centrosomal MTOC. These factors contribute to a mechanism that ensures bipolar MTOC formation and chromosome segregation during spermatogenesis when centriole duplication fails. However, despite the successful completion of meiosis and round spermatid formation, centriole inheritance and PLK4 function are required for normal spermiogenesis and flagella assembly, which are critical to ensure fertility.

Research progress on the fanconi anemia signaling pathway in non-obstructive azoospermia

Non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA) is a disease characterized by spermatogenesis failure and comprises phenotypes such as hypospermatogenesis, mature arrest, and Sertoli cell-only syndrome. Studies have shown that FA cross-linked anemia (FA) pathway is closely related to the occurrence of NOA. There are FA gene mutations in male NOA patients, which cause significant damage to male germ cells. The FA pathway is activated in the presence of DNA interstrand cross-links; the key step in activating this pathway is the mono-ubiquitination of the FANCD2-FANCI complex, and the activation of the FA pathway can repair DNA damage such as DNA double-strand breaks. Therefore, we believe that the FA pathway affects germ cells during DNA damage repair, resulting in minimal or even disappearance of mature sperm in males. This review summarizes the regulatory mechanisms of FA-related genes in male azoospermia, with the aim of providing a theoretical reference for clinical research and exploration of related genes.

Toward clinical exomes in diagnostics and management of male infertility

Infertility, affecting ∼10% of men, is predominantly caused by primary spermatogenic failure (SPGF). We screened likely pathogenic and pathogenic (LP/P) variants in 638 candidate genes for male infertility in 521 individuals presenting idiopathic SPGF and 323 normozoospermic men in the ESTAND cohort. Molecular diagnosis was reached for 64 men with SPGF (12%), with findings in 39 genes (6%). The yield did not differ significantly between the subgroups with azoospermia (20/185, 11%), oligozoospermia (18/181, 10%), and primary cryptorchidism with SPGF (26/155, 17%). Notably, 19 of 64 LP/P variants (30%) identified in 28 subjects represented recurrent findings in this study and/or with other male infertility cohorts. NR5A1 was the most frequently affected gene, with seven LP/P variants in six SPGF-affected men and two normozoospermic men. The link to SPGF was validated for recently proposed candidate genes ACTRT1, ASZ1, GLUD2, GREB1L, LEO1, RBM5, ROS1, and TGIF2LY. Heterozygous truncating variants in BNC1, reported in female infertility, emerged as plausible causes of severe oligozoospermia. Data suggested that several infertile men may present congenital conditions with less pronounced or pleiotropic phenotypes affecting the development and function of the reproductive system. Genes regulating the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis were affected in >30% of subjects with LP/P variants. Six individuals had more than one LP/P variant, including five with two findings from the gene panel. A 4-fold increased prevalence of cancer was observed in men with genetic infertility compared to the general male population (8% vs. 2%; p = 4.4 × 10-3). Expanding genetic testing in andrology will contribute to the multidisciplinary management of SPGF.

Systematic molecular analyses for 115 karyotypically normal men with isolated non-obstructive azoospermia

STUDY QUESTION

Do copy-number variations (CNVs) in the azoospermia factor (AZF) regions and monogenic mutations play a major role in the development of isolated (non-syndromic) non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA) in Japanese men with a normal 46, XY karyotype?

SUMMARY ANSWER

Deleterious CNVs in the AZF regions and damaging sequence variants in eight genes likely constitute at least 8% and approximately 8% of the genetic causes, respectively, while variants in other genes play only a minor role.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Sex chromosomal abnormalities, AZF-linked microdeletions, and monogenic mutations have been implicated in isolated NOA. More than 160 genes have been reported as causative/susceptibility/candidate genes for NOA.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

Systematic molecular analyses were conducted for 115 patients with isolated NOA and a normal 46, XY karyotype, who visited our hospital between 2017 and 2021.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

We studied 115 unrelated Japanese patients. AZF-linked CNVs were examined using sequence-tagged PCR and multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification, and nucleotide variants were screened using whole exome sequencing (WES). An optimized sequence kernel association test (SKAT-O), a gene-based association study using WES data, was performed to identify novel disease-associated genes in the genome. The results were compared to those of previous studies and our in-house control data.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Thirteen types of AZF-linked CNVs, including the hitherto unreported gr/gr triplication and partial AZFb deletion, were identified in 63 (54.8%) cases. When the gr/gr deletion, a common polymorphism in Japan, was excluded from data analyses, the total frequency of CNVs was 23/75 (30.7%). This frequency is higher than that of the reference data in Japan and China (11.1% and 14.7%, respectively). Known NOA-causative AZF-linked CNVs were found in nine (7.8%) cases. Rare damaging variants in known causative genes (DMRT1, PLK4, SYCP2, TEX11, and USP26) and hemizygous/multiple-heterozygous damaging variants in known spermatogenesis-associated genes (TAF7L, DNAH2, and DNAH17) were identified in nine cases (7.8% in total). Some patients carried rare damaging variants in multiple genes. SKAT-O detected no genes whose rare damaging variants were significantly accumulated in the patient group.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The number of participants was relatively small, and the clinical information of each patient was fragmentary. Moreover, the pathogenicity of identified variants was assessed only by in silico analyses.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

This study showed that various AZF-linked CNVs are present in more than half of Japanese NOA patients. These results broadened the structural variations of AZF-linked CNVs, which should be considered for the molecular diagnosis of spermatogenic failure. Furthermore, the results of this study highlight the etiological heterogeneity and possible oligogenicity of isolated NOA.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

This study was supported by Grants from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (21K19283 and 21H0246), the Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (22ek0109464h0003), the National Center for Child Health and Development, the Canon Foundation, the Japan Endocrine Society, and the Takeda Science Foundation. The results of this study were based on samples and patient data obtained from the International Center for Reproductive Medicine, Dokkyo Medical University Saitama Medical Center, Koshigaya, Japan. The authors have no conflicts of interest to disclose.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.

Achieving an optimal pregnancy outcome through the combined utilization of micro-TESE and ICSI in cryptorchidism associated with a non-canonical splicing variant in RXFP2

PURPOSE

To identify the genetic cause of a cryptorchidism patient carrying a non-canonical splicing variant highlighted by SPCards platform in RXFP2 and to provide a comprehensive overview of RXFP2 variants with cryptorchidism correlation.

METHODS

We identified a homozygous non-canonical splicing variant by whole-exome sequencing and Sanger sequencing in a case with cryptorchidism and non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA). As the pathogenicity of this non-canonical splicing variant remained unclear, we initially utilized the SPCards platform to predict its pathogenicity. Subsequently, we employed a minigene splicing assay to further evaluate the influence of the identified splicing variant. Microdissection testicular sperm extraction (micro-TESE) combined with intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) was performed. PubMed and Human Genome Variant Database (HGMD) were queried to search for RXFP2 variants.

RESULTS

We identified a homozygous non-canonical splicing variant (NM_130806: c.1376-12A > G) in RXFP2, and confirmed this variant caused aberrant splicing of exons 15 and 16 of the RXFP2 gene: 11 bases were added in front of exon 16, leading to an abnormal transcript initiation and a frameshift. Fortunately, the patient successfully obtained his biological offspring through micro-TESE combined with ICSI. Four cryptorchidism-associated variants in RXFP2 from 90 patients with cryptorchidism were identified through a literature search in PubMed and HGMD, with different inheritance patterns.

CONCLUSION

This is the first cryptorchidism case carrying a novel causative non-canonical splicing RXFP2 variant. The combined approach of micro-TESE and ICSI contributed to an optimal pregnancy outcome. Our literature review demonstrated that RXFP2 variants caused cryptorchidism in a recessive inheritance pattern, rather than a dominant pattern.

Genetic profiling of azoospermic men to identify the etiology and predict reproductive potential

PURPOSE

To identify germline mutations related to azoospermia etiology and reproductive potential of surgically retrieved spermatozoa, and to investigate the feasibility of predicting seminiferous tubule function of nonobstructive azoospermic men by transcriptomic profiling of ejaculates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Sperm specimens were obtained from 30 men (38.4 ± 6 years) undergoing epididymal sperm aspiration for obstructive azoospermia (OA, n = 19) acquired by vasectomy, or testicular biopsy for nonobstructive azoospermia (NOA, n = 11). To evaluate for a correlation with azoospermia etiology, DNAseq was performed on surgically retrieved spermatozoa, and cell-free RNAseq on seminal fluid (n = 23) was performed to predict spermatogenesis in the seminiferous tubule.

RESULTS

Overall, surgically retrieved sperm aneuploidy rates were 1.7% and 1.8% among OA and NOA cohorts, respectively. OA men carried housekeeping-related gene mutations, while NOA men displayed mutations on genes involved in crucial spermiogenic functions (AP1S2, AP1G2, APOE). We categorized couples within each cohort according to ICSI clinical outcomes to investigate genetic causes that may affect reproductive potential. All OA-fertile men (n = 9) carried mutations in ZNF749 (sperm production), whereas OA-infertile men (n = 10) harbored mutations in PRB1, which is essential for DNA replication. NOA-fertile men (n = 8) carried mutations in MPIG6B (stem cell lineage differentiation), whereas NOA-infertile individuals (n = 3) harbored mutations in genes involved in spermato/spermio-genesis (ADAM29, SPATA31E1, MAK, POLG, IFT43, ATG9B) and early embryonic development (MBD5, CCAR1, PMEPA1, POLK, REC8, REPIN1, MAPRE3, ARL4C). Transcriptomic assessment of cell-free RNAs in seminal fluid from NOA men allowed the prediction of residual spermatogenic foci.

CONCLUSIONS

Sperm genome profiling provides invaluable information on azoospermia etiology and identifies gene-related mechanistic links to reproductive performance. Moreover, RNAseq assessment of seminal fluid from NOA men can help predict sperm retrieval during testicular biopsies.

Mosaic variegated aneuploidy syndrome with tetraploid, and predisposition to male infertility triggered by mutant CEP192

In this study, we report on mosaic variegated aneuploidy (MVA) syndrome with tetraploidy and predisposition to infertility in a family. Sequencing analysis identified that the CEP192 biallelic variants (c.1912C>T, p.His638Tyr and c.5750A>G, p.Asn1917Ser) segregated with microcephaly, short stature, limb-extremity dysplasia, and reduced testicular size, while CEP192 monoallelic variants segregated with infertility and/or reduced testicular size in the family. In 1,264 unrelated patients, variant screening for CEP192 identified a same variant (c.5750A>G, p.Asn1917Ser) and other variants significantly associated with infertility. Two lines of Cep192 mice model that are equivalent to human variants were generated. Embryos with Cep192 biallelic variants arrested at E7 because of cell apoptosis mediated by MVA/tetraploidy cell acumination. Mice with heterozygous variants replicated the predisposition to male infertility. Mouse primary embryonic fibroblasts with Cep192 biallelic variants cultured in vitro showed abnormal morphology, mitotic arresting, and disruption of spindle formation. In patient epithelial cells with biallelic variants cultured in vitro, the number of cells arrested during the prophase increased because of the failure of spindle formation. Accordingly, we present mutant CEP192, which is a link for the MVA syndrome with tetraploidy and the predisposition to male infertility.

A novel missense variant in CDK5RAP2 associated with non-obstructive azoospermia

OBJECTIVE

The most severe type of male infertility is non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA), where there is no sperm in the ejaculate due to failure of spermatogenesis, affecting 10%-20% of infertile men with azoospermia. Genetic studies have identified dozens of NOA genes. The main aim of the present study is to identify a novel monogenic mutation that may cause NOA.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We studied the pedigree of a consanguineous family with three NOA and one fertile brother by a family-based exome-sequencing, segregation analysis, insilico protein modeling and single-cell RNA sequencing data analysis.

RESULTS

Bioinformatics analysis followed by sanger sequencing revealed that three NOA brothers were homozygous for a rare missense variant in Cyclin Dependent Kinase Regulatory Subunit Associated Protein 2 (Centrosomin) CDK5RAP2 (NM_018249:exon26:c.A4003T:p.R1335W, rs761196443). Protein modeling demonstrated that CDK5RAP2, Arg1335Trp resided nearby the Microtubule Associated Protein RP/EB Family Member 1 (EB1/MAPRE1) interaction site. As a consequence of the R1335W mutation, the positively charged Arginine was replaced by to the hydrophobic tryptophan residue, possibly leading to local instability in the structure and perturbation in the CDK5RAP2-MAPRE1 interaction.

CONCLUSION

Our study reports a novel missense variant of CDK5RAP2 that segregates in homozygosity with male infertility and NOA in a consanguineous family. In silico structural predictions and gene expression data indicate a potential role of the CDK5RAP2 variant in causing defective centrosomic maturation during spermatogenesis.

Genetic variants underlying spermatogenic arrests in men with non-obstructive azoospermia

Spermatogenic arrest is a severe form of non-obstructive azoospermia (NOA), which occurs in 10-15% of infertile men. Interruption in spermatogenic progression at premeiotic, meiotic, or postmeiotic stage can lead to arrest in men with NOA. Recent studies have intensively focused on defining genetic variants underlying these spermatogenic arrests by making genome/exome sequencing. A number of variants were discovered in the genes involving in mitosis, meiosis, germline differentiation and other basic cellular events. Herein, defined variants in NOA cases with spermatogenic arrests and created knockout mouse models for the related genes are comprehensively reviewed. Also, importance of gene panel-based screening for NOA cases was discussed. Screening common variants in these infertile men with spermatogenic arrests may contribute to elucidating the molecular background and designing novel treatment strategies.

Sertoli cell-only syndrome: advances, challenges, and perspectives in genetics and mechanisms

Male infertility can be caused by quantitative and/or qualitative abnormalities in spermatogenesis, which affects men's physical and mental health. Sertoli cell-only syndrome (SCOS) is the most severe histological phenotype of male infertility characterized by the depletion of germ cells with only Sertoli cells remaining in the seminiferous tubules. Most SCOS cases cannot be explained by the already known genetic causes including karyotype abnormalities and microdeletions of the Y chromosome. With the development of sequencing technology, studies on screening new genetic causes for SCOS are growing in recent years. Directly sequencing of target genes in sporadic cases and whole-exome sequencing applied in familial cases have identified several genes associated with SCOS. Analyses of the testicular transcriptome, proteome, and epigenetics in SCOS patients provide explanations regarding the molecular mechanisms of SCOS. In this review, we discuss the possible relationship between defective germline development and SCOS based on mouse models with SCO phenotype. We also summarize the advances and challenges in the exploration of genetic causes and mechanisms of SCOS. Knowing the genetic factors of SCOS offers a better understanding of SCO and human spermatogenesis, and it also has practical significance for improving diagnosis, making appropriate medical decisions, and genetic counseling. For therapeutic implications, SCOS research, along with the achievements in stem cell technologies and gene therapy, build the foundation to develop novel therapies for SCOS patients to produce functional spermatozoa, giving them hope to father children.

Profiling the male germline genome to unravel its reproductive potential

OBJECTIVE

To identify specific germline mutations related to sperm reproductive competence, in couples with unexplained infertility.

DESIGN

In this retrospective study, couples were divided according to whether they had successful intracytoplasmic sperm injection outcomes (fertile) or not (infertile). Ancillary sperm function tests were performed on ejaculates, and whole exome sequencing was performed on spermatozoal DNA. Sperm aneuploidy and gene mutation profiles were compared between the 2 cohorts as well as according to the specific reasons for reproductive failure.

SETTING

Center for reproductive medicine at a major academic medical center.

PATIENT(S)

Thirty-one couples with negative infertility workups and normal semen parameters.

INTERVENTION(S)

Couples with mutations on fertilization- or embryo development-related genes were subsequently treated by assisted gamete treatment or microfluidics, respectively.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection cycle outcomes including fertilization, clinical pregnancy, and delivery rates.

RESULT(S)

Sperm aneuploidy was lower in the fertile group (4.0% vs. 8.4%). Spermatozoa from both cohorts displayed mutations associated with sperm-egg fusion (ADAM3A) and acrosomal development (SPACA1), regardless of reproductive outcome. The infertile cohort was then categorized according to the reasons for reproductive failure: absent fertilization, poor early embryo development, implantation failure, or pregnancy loss. Spermatozoa from the fertilization failure subgroup (n = 4) had negligible PLCζ presence (10% ± 9%) and gene mutations (PLCZ1, PIWIL1, ADAM15) indicating a sperm-related oocyte-activating deficiency. These couples were successfully treated by assisted gamete treatment in their subsequent cycles. Spermatozoa from the poor early embryo development subgroup (n = 5) had abnormal centrosomes (45.9% ± 5%), and displayed mutations impacting centrosome integrity (HAUS1) and spindle/microtubular stabilization (KIF4A, XRN1). Microfluidic sperm processing subsequently yielded a term pregnancy. Spermatozoa from the implantation failure subgroup (n = 7) also had abnormal centrosomes (53.1% ± 13%) and carried mutations affecting embryonic implantation (IL9R) and microtubule and centrosomal integrity (MAP1S, SUPT5H, PLK4), whereas those from the pregnancy loss subgroup (n = 5) displayed mutations on genes involved in trophoblast development (NLRP7), cell cycle regulation (MARK4, TRIP13, DAB2IP, KIF1C), and recurrent miscarriage (TP53).

CONCLUSION(S)

By assessing the sperm genome, we identified specific germline mutations related to various reproductive processes. This information may clarify elusive factors underlying reproductive competence and enhance treatment for couples with unexplained infertility.

Correction: Identification of deleterious variants in patients with male infertility due to idiopathic non-obstructive azoospermia

An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via the original article.