Anterolateral minithoracotomy versus median sternotomy for the surgical treatment of atrial septal defects: a meta-analysis and systematic review

Minimal invasive approaches for pediatric & congenital heart surgery: safe, reproducible, more cosmetic than through sternotomy, and here to stay

Minimal invasive approaches through small thoracic incisions for the isolated repair of the most common congenital heart defects have been around for decades. However, the lack of belonging in established surgical training curriculums compared to the traditional median sternotomy, the requirement for more technical expertise and a certain learning curve, has limited their use, being routinely performed only by certain surgeons in specialized centers. More recently, through cumulated and increasingly mediatized shared experience, remote teaching potential through universally accessible surgical videos and simulation, the approach has gained traction and acceptance, and even established itself as the new norm in many centers. In this review, we present technically focused aspects of our own experience and protocols which have evolved over time, along with a brief overview of the literature pertaining to other right thoracic approaches, and some comparison to established results using the traditional median sternotomy. An increasing body of literature, produced more frequently and across all continents, seems to suggest that repairs of congenital heart defects through a minimal invasive right thoracic approach are becoming the new norm, as they are reported to be safe and reproducible, with excellent surgical results, and an obvious superior and more desirable cosmetic result. This comes at a cost of additional training and learning curve by surgeons, who are not offered the technique as part of their standard professional training curriculum.

Minimal-Access Atrial Septal Defect (ASD) Closure

Progress towards the development and adoption of minimally invasive techniques in cardiac surgery has been slower than that seen in other surgical specialties. Congenital heart disease (CHD) patients represent an important population within cardiac disease, of which atrial septal defect (ASD) is one of the most common diagnoses. Management of ASD encompasses a range of minimal-access and minimally invasive approaches, including transcatheter device closure, mini-sternotomy, thoracotomy, video-assisted, endoscopic, and robotic approaches. In this article, we will discuss the pathophysiology of ASD, along with diagnosis, management, and indications for intervention. We will review the current evidence supporting minimally invasive and minimal-access surgical ASD closure in the adult and paediatric patient, highlighting peri-operative considerations and areas for further research.

Mini right axillary thoracotomy for congenital heart defect repair can become a safe surgical routine

OBJECTIVE

Owing to its obvious cosmetic appeal, minimal invasive repair of congenital heart defects (CHDs) through the mini right axillary thoracotomy is becoming routine in many centres. Besides cosmesis, and before becoming a new norm, it is important to establish its outcomes as safe compared to repairs through traditional median sternotomy.

METHODS

Between 2013 and 2021, 116 consecutive patients underwent defect repairs through mini right axillary thoracotomy. Patient, operative data, and hospital outcomes were compared to contemporary mini right axillary thoracotomy and sternotomy series.

RESULTS

There was no mortality or need for approach conversion (mean age 4.3 years, range 0.17-17, mean weight 18.6 kg, range 4.8-74.4) in 118 repairs for atrial septal defect, ventricular septal defect, partial anomalous pulmonary venous return, partial atrioventricular canal with mitral cleft, scimitar syndrome, double-chambered right ventricle, cor triatriatum, and tricuspid valve repair. Protocol included on-table extubation, achieved in 97 children, with 23 outliers leading to 0.7 average hours of mechanical ventilation (range 0-66 hours), indwelling chest drain time of 2.6 days (range 1-9 days), intensive care stay of 1.8 days (range 1-10 days), and hospital stay of 3.9 days (range 2-18 days). Late revisions were required in one patient after scimitar repair for scimitar vein stenosis at 2 weeks, and in another for repair of superior caval vein stenosis after a Warden operation at 2 months; reoperations (5/116 = 4.3%) were successfully performed through the same mini right axillary incision.

CONCLUSIONS

While providing obvious cosmetic advantages, the minimally invasive right axillary thoracotomy approach for the surgical repair of common CHDs yields excellent results and is safe compared to the benchmark median sternotomy approach.