Biomechanical evaluation of a biomimetic spinal construct

Finite Element Modelling of a Synthetic Paediatric Spine for Biomechanical Investigation

Studies on paediatric spines commonly use human adult or immature porcine spines as specimens, because it is difficult to obtain actual paediatric specimens. There are quite obvious differences, such as geometry, size, bone morphology, and orientation of facet joint for these specimens, compared to paediatric spine. Hence, development of synthetic models that can behave similarly to actual paediatric spines, particularly in term of range of motion (ROM), could provide a significant contribution for paediatric spine research. This study aims to develop a synthetic paediatric spine using finite element modelling and evaluate the reliability of the model by comparing it with the experimental data under certain load conditions. The ROM of the paediatric spine was measured using a validated FE model at ±0.5 Nm moment in order to determine the moment required by the synthetic spine to achieve the same ROM. The results showed that the synthetic spine required two moments, ±2 Nm for lateral-bending and axial rotation, and ±3 Nm for flexion-extension, to obtain the paediatric ROM. The synthetic spine was shown to be stiffer in flexion-extension but more flexible in lateral bending than the paediatric FE model, possibly as a result of the intervertebral disc's simplified shape and the disc's weak bonding with the vertebrae. Nevertheless, the synthetic paediatric spine has promising potential in the future as an alternative paediatric spine model for biomechanical investigation of paediatric cases.

Biomechanical and clinical studies on lumbar spine fusion surgery: a review

Low back pain is associated with degenerative disc diseases of the spine. Surgical treatment includes fusion and non-fusion types. The gold standard is fusion surgery, wherein the affected vertebral segment is fused. The common complication of fusion surgery is adjacent segment degeneration (ASD). The ASD often leads to revision surgery, calling for a further fusion of adjacent segments. The existing designs of nonfusion type implants are associated with clinical problems such as subsidence, difficulty in implantation, and the requirement of revision surgeries. Various surgical approaches have been adopted by the surgeons to insert the spinal implants into the affected segment. Over the years, extensive biomechanical investigations have been reported on various surgical approaches and prostheses to predict the outcomes of lumbar spine implantations. Computer models have been proven to be very effective in identifying the best prosthesis and surgical procedure. The objective of the study was to review the literature on biomechanical studies for the treatment of lumbar spinal degenerative diseases. A critical review of the clinical and biomechanical studies on fusion spine surgeries was undertaken. The important modeling parameters, challenges, and limitations of the current studies were identified, showing the future research directions.

A biomechanical study shows the direction of compression influences the amount of lordosis gained in lumbar fusion

STUDY DESIGN

Biomechanical model study.

BACKGROUND

Lumbar lordosis is usually lost in the degenerative process, and when lumbar fusion is required, its restoration is one of the modern metrics of a successful operation. We sought to investigate the hypothesis that changing direction of compression during surgical fusion, would gain more lordosis.

METHODS

Using a biomechanical Sawbones™ model we inserted polyaxial pedicle screws from S1 to L4. A rod was placed in the screws without requiring reduction. Markers were attached to the spinous processes to allow photographic analysis of lordosis. Two methods were compared. Method A - caudal screws were locked first and compression proceeded in a cranial direction prior to locking. Method B - cranial screws were locked first and compression proceeded caudally. Increasing levels of surgical invasiveness were tested; intact, interbody cage, inferior facet resection, and Ponte resection and using different rods including: lordotic, hyperlordotic and straight.

FINDINGS

Method B demonstrated to be consistently superior to Method A, regardless of the type of rod used and for every level of surgical invasiveness performed. (P < 0.001).

INTERPRETATION

locking the top screws first was a consistently superior method of compression, gaining more lordosis. To explain this finding we suggest the following: During posterior compression of pedicle screws along a fixed rod, screw motion is limited by the conflict between the fixed lordotic rod position, and the need for the moving screw to move in a kyphotic arc which is determined by the cage which acts as a pivot point.

In Silico Meta-Analysis of Boundary Conditions for Experimental Tests on the Lumbar Spine

The study of the spine range of motion under given external load has been the object of many studies in literature, finalised to a better understanding of the spine biomechanics, its physiology, eventual pathologic conditions and possible rehabilitation strategies. However, the huge amount of experimental work performed so far cannot be straightforwardly analysed due to significant differences among loading set-ups. This work performs a meta-analysis of various boundary conditions in literature, focusing on the flexion/extension behaviour of the lumbar spine. The comparison among range of motions is performed virtually through a validated multibody model. Results clearly illustrated the effect of various boundary conditions which can be met in literature, so justifying differences of biomechanical behaviours reported by authors implementing different set-up: for example, a higher value of the follower load can indeed result in a stiffer behaviour; the application of force producing spurious moments results in an apparently more deformable behaviour, however the respective effects change at various segments along the spine due to its natural curvature. These outcomes are reported not only in qualitative, but also in quantitative terms. The numerical approach here followed to perform the meta-analysis is original and it proved to be effective thanks to the bypass of the natural variability among specimens which might completely or partially hinder the effect of some boundary conditions. In addition, it can provide very complete information since the behaviour of each functional spinal unit can be recorded. On the whole, the work provided an extensive review of lumbar spine loading in flexion/extension.

MagnetOs, Vitoss, and Novabone in a Multi-endpoint Study of Posterolateral Fusion: A True Fusion or Not?

STUDY DESIGN

This study was a multi-endpoint analysis of bone graft substitutes implanted as a standalone graft in a clinically relevant Ovine model of instrumented posterolateral spinal fusion (PLF).

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to obtain high-quality evidence on the efficacy of commercial bone graft substitutes compared with autograft in instrumented PLF using a state-of-the-art model with a complete range of assessment techniques.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Preclinical and clinical data on the quality of spinal fusions obtained with bone graft substitutes are often limited. Calcium phosphates with submicron topography have shown promising results in PLF, as these are able to induce bone formation in tissues distant from the host bone, which facilitates bony union.

METHODS

Nine female, skeletally mature sheep (4-5 y) underwent posterior pedicle screw/rods instrumented PLF at L2-L3 and L4-L5 using the following bone graft materials as a standalone graft per spinal segment: (1) biphasic calcium phosphate with submicron topography (BCP<µm), (2) 45S5 Bioglass (BG), and (3) collagen-β-tricalcium phosphate with a 45S5 Bioglass adjunct (TCP/BG). Autograft bone (AB) was used as a positive control treatment. Twelve weeks after implantation, the spinal segments were evaluated by fusion assessment (manual palpation, x-ray, micro-computed tomography, and histology), fusion mass volume quantification (micro-computed tomography), range of motion (ROM) testing, histologic evaluation, and histomorphometry.

RESULTS

Fusion assessment revealed equivalence between AB and BCP<µm by all fusion assessment methods, whereas BG and TCP/BG led to significantly inferior results. Fusion mass volume was highest for BCP<µm, followed by AB, BG, and TCP/BG. ROM testing determined equivalence for spinal levels treated with AB and BCP<µm, while BG and TCP/BG exhibited higher ROM. Histologic evaluation revealed substantial bone formation in the intertransverse regions for AB and BCP<µm, whereas BG and TCP/BG grafts contained fibrous tissue and minimal bone formation. Histologic observations were supported by the histomorphometry data.

CONCLUSIONS

This study reveals clear differences in efficacy between commercially available bone graft substitutes, emphasizing the importance of clinically relevant animal models with multiendpoint analyses for the evaluation of bone graft materials. The results corroborate the efficacy of calcium phosphate with submicron topography, as this was the only material that showed equivalent performance to autograft in achieving spinal fusion.

Validation of a custom spine biomechanics simulator: A case for standardization

Mechanical testing machines used in cadaveric spine biomechanics research vary between labs. It is a necessary first step to understand the capabilities and limitations in any testing machine prior to publishing experimental data. In this study, a reproducible protocol that uses a synthetic spine was developed and used to quantify the inherent rotation error and the ability to apply loads in a single physiologic plane (pure-moment) of a custom spine biomechanics simulator. Rotation error was evaluated by comparing data collected by the test machine and the data collected by an optical motion capture system. Pure-moment loading was assessed by comparing the out-of-plane loads to the primary plane load. Using synthetic functional spine units previously shown to have mechanics similar to the cadaveric human spine, the simulator was evaluated using a dynamic test protocol reflective of its future use in the study of cadaveric spine specimens. Rotation errors inherent in the test machine were <0.25° compared to motion capture. Out of plane loads were <4.0% of the primary plane load, which confirmed pure-moment loading. The authors suggest that a standard validation protocol for biomechanical spine testing machines is needed for transparency and accurate field-wide data interpretation and comparison. We offer recommendations based on the reproducible use of a synthetic spinal specimen for consideration.

A novel in vivo large animal model of lumbar spinal joint degeneration

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Degenerative disc disease (DDD) is a common, widespread socioeconomic problem. Appropriate large animal models of DDD are required for improved understanding and to serve as preclinical test beds for therapeutic strategies.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effects of short and medium duration immobilization on the sheep lumbar intervertebral disc (IVD) and facet joints (FJs), and to establish a large animal model for DDD research.

STUDY DESIGN

An in vivo sheep model evaluating the effect of short- and medium-term immobilization on disc degeneration.

METHODS

Eighteen sheep were equally randomized into three groups: short-term (6-week) immobilization (n=6), medium-term (26-week) immobilization (n=6), and control (no surgery) (n=6). Immobilization of L3-L4 was achieved with pedicle screw and rod implantation, the IVD was kept intact, and the annulus and end plates were not disrupted. The IVD and FJs were assessed with planar radiography, computerized tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), pure moment biomechanical testing, and histologic analysis.

RESULTS

Disc height was reduced for 6- and 26-week immobilization groups. The MRI and histologic analysis demonstrated significant disc degeneration for both immobilized groups compared with control, but no statistical difference was detected between short- and medium-term duration. Progressive degenerative changes in FJs were observed with micro-CT and histologic end points. Immobilization significantly reduced lateral bending and flexion-extension range of motion.

CONCLUSIONS

The mechanical environment set up by immobilization alone is capable of inducing lumbar disc degeneration at both 6 and 26 weeks in sheep. Longer duration immobilization did not advance disc degeneration process beyond of that found with short duration. The present model produces a degenerative disc with intact annulus and without acute injury, more closely representing the scenario common in human disc degeneration. This provides a suitable large animal in vivo model for the evaluation of the new therapies for disc degeneration. Further studies would do well to examine the effect of remobilization after immobilization in this model.

The Barrow Biomimetic Spine: Comparative Testing of a 3D-Printed L4-L5 Schwab Grade 2 Osteotomy Model to a Cadaveric Model

Introduction

The Barrow Biomimetic Spine project is an ongoing effort to develop a three-dimensional (3D)-printed synthetic spine model with high anatomical and biomechanical fidelity to human tissue. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the biomechanical performance of an L4-L5 3D-printed synthetic spine model in a lordotic correction test after Schwab grade 2 osteotomies as compared to human cadaveric spines that have undergone the same osteotomies and lordotic correction.

Methods

Ten different L4-L5 synthetic spine models were 3D printed. Each print varied in either the material used for the soft tissue components, the infill density of the bony and soft tissue structures, the pre-correction disc height, or the model orientation on the print bed. Each print was instrumented with pedicle screws and underwent a Schwab grade 2 osteotomy. Changes in disc height measurements and end-plate angle were compared against cadaveric data acquired using the same study method.

Results

A simple linear correlation analysis demonstrated that for horizontally printed models using PolyFlex (Polymaker, New York, NY, USA)(models 1-3, 8, 10), the pre-correction posterior disc height and lordotic correction were moderately correlated (r = 0.56), but this correlation did not achieve statistical significance (P = 0.12). Regression analysis demonstrated a very strong correlation between lordotic correction and change in posterior disc height (r = 0.92, P < 0.001). Models printed either vertically (models 4-6) or with low bone density and high soft tissue density (model 10) appeared to perform the most similarly to the cadaveric tissue.

Discussion

The 3D-printed synthetic spine models demonstrated predictable and reliable performance in a lordotic correction test based on their respective material qualities and print densities. The print variables tested further demonstrated that this model is capable of achieving high biomechanical fidelity to cadaveric tissue when subjected to the same lordotic correction test after Schwab grade 2 osteotomies.

Biomechanical effect of interspinous process distraction height after lumbar fixation surgery: An in vitro model

Pedicle screw fixation may induce abnormal activity at adjacent segment and accelerate the degeneration of lumbar vertebrae. Dynamic stabilizers could provide an intermediate solution between conservative treatment and fusion surgery. Lumbar vertebral segment cephalad to instrumented fixation was the most common localization of adjacent segment degeneration. The aim of this study is to explore the use of interspinous process devices in the lumbar vertebral segment cephalad to fixation segment in changing the mechanical distribution and limiting abnormal activity of the spine. Eight specimens were tested in the following groups: intact group, instability group (bilateral facetectomy at L3-L4), fixation group (bilateral facetectomy and pedicle screw fixation at L3-L4), and hybrid fixation group (fixation at L3-L4 and simulating interspinous device implantation of 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, and 18 mm at L2-L3). Range of motion, motion of vertebral body, and strain distribution change were recorded. The range of motion in extension with 16- and 18-mm hybrid constructs was significantly lower than intact, instability, and fixation groups. In flexion and lateral bending, the strain values of L4 inferior articular process with 18-mm hybrid construct have a significant difference compared with other groups. In axial rotation, under the condition of a contralateral state, the strain values of L2 superior articular process with 18-mm hybrid construct have a significant difference compared with intact and fixation groups. The strain value of the L4 inferior articular process had negative correlation with height distraction in three dimensions, except extension. A negative correlation between the strain value of the L2 superior articular process and distraction height was found in contralateral bending and contralateral axial rotation. Interspinous process devices above the fixation segment can change the mechanical distribution of the spine and limit activity in some of the segments of the spine, which may delay the degeneration of the adjacent segment.

Delayed lymphocele formation following lateral lumbar interbody fusion of the spine

PURPOSE

This paper aims to describe the rare post-operative complication of a lymphocele formation after lateral lumbar interbody fusion.

METHODS

The patient in this case was a 76-year-old lady with a 10 year history of low back pain and neurogenic claudication. She had previously underwent multiple spine surgeries for her condition. She presented to our institution for a recurrence of her low back pain and right anterior thigh pain. She then underwent surgery in two stages; first, a mini-open lateral interbody fusion at L3/4 and L4/5; second, posterior instrumentation of T3 to S1 with sagittal spinal deformity correction.

RESULTS

The patient recovered uneventfully in the initial post op period and was discharged within 8 days. However, she developed abdominal distension and discomfort 6 months after surgery. MRI and CT scan of her abdomen showed a retroperitoneal fluid collection compressing her left ureter, resulting in hydroureter and hydronephrosis. She was managed with a CT-guided drainage of the fluid collection. Fluid analysis was consistent with a lymphocele. Since the procedure, the patient has been asymptomatic for 2 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Delayed lymphocele formation is a potential complication of lateral lumbar interbody fusion. When present, it can be managed conservatively with good results. This case suggests that surgeons should have a low threshold to investigate for a lymphocele development post-anterior or lateral lumbar spine surgery. The authors recommend the placement of a post surgical retroperitoneal drain, as it might assist in the early detection of a lymphocele formation.