Y-90 SIRT: evaluation of TCP variation across dosimetric models

MIRD Pamphlet No. 29: MIRDy90-A 90Y Research Microsphere Dosimetry Tool

90Y-microsphere radioembolization has become a well-established treatment option for liver malignancies and is one of the first U.S. Food and Drug Administration-approved unsealed radionuclide brachytherapy devices to incorporate dosimetry-based treatment planning. Several different mathematical models are used to calculate the patient-specific prescribed activity of 90Y, namely, body surface area (SIR-Spheres only), MIRD single compartment, and MIRD dual compartment (partition). Under the auspices of the MIRDsoft initiative to develop community dosimetry software and tools, the body surface area, MIRD single-compartment, MIRD dual-compartment, and MIRD multicompartment models have been integrated into a MIRDy90 software worksheet. The worksheet was built in MS Excel to estimate and compare prescribed activities calculated via these respective models. The MIRDy90 software was validated against available tools for calculating 90Y prescribed activity. The results of MIRDy90 calculations were compared with those obtained from vendor and community-developed tools, and the calculations agreed well. The MIRDy90 worksheet was developed to provide a vetted tool to better evaluate patient-specific prescribed activities calculated via different models, as well as model influences with respect to varying input parameters. MIRDy90 allows users to interact and visualize the results of various parameter combinations. Variables, equations, and calculations are described in the MIRDy90 documentation and articulated in the MIRDy90 worksheet. The worksheet is distributed as a free tool to build expertise within the medical physics community and create a vetted standard for model and variable management.

The contest between internal and external-beam dosimetry: The Zeno's paradox of Achilles and the tortoise

Radionuclide therapy, also called molecular radiotherapy (MRT), has come of age, with several novel radiopharmaceuticals being approved for clinical use or under development in the last decade. External beam radiotherapy (EBRT) is a well-established treatment modality, with about half of all oncologic patients expected to receive at least one external radiation treatment over their disease course. The efficacy and the toxicity of both types of treatment rely on the interaction of radiation with biological tissues. Dosimetry played a fundamental role in the scientific and technological evolution of EBRT, and absorbed doses to the target and to the organs at risk are calculated on a routine basis. In contrast, in MRT the usefulness of internal dosimetry has long been questioned, and a structured path to include absorbed dose calculation is missing. However, following a similar route of development as EBRT, MRT treatments could probably be optimized in a significant proportion of patients, likely based on dosimetry and radiobiology. In the present paper we describe the differences and the similarities between internal and external-beam dosimetry in the context of radiation treatments, and we retrace the main stages of their development over the last decades.

Predictive value of 99mTc-MAA-based dosimetry in personalized 90Y-SIRT planning for liver malignancies

BACKGROUND

Selective internal radiation therapy with ⁹⁰Y radioembolization aims to selectively irradiate liver tumours by administering radioactive microspheres under the theragnostic assumption that the pre-therapy injection of ^99mTc labelled macroaggregated albumin (^99mTc-MAA) provides an estimation of the ⁹⁰Y microspheres biodistribution, which is not always the case. Due to the growing interest in theragnostic dosimetry for personalized radionuclide therapy, a robust relationship between the delivered and pre-treatment radiation absorbed doses is required. In this work, we aim to investigate the predictive value of absorbed dose metrics calculated from ^99mTc-MAA (simulation) compared to those obtained from ⁹⁰Y post-therapy SPECT/CT.

RESULTS

A total of 79 patients were analysed. Pre- and post-therapy 3D-voxel dosimetry was calculated on ^99mTc-MAA and ⁹⁰Y SPECT/CT, respectively, based on Local Deposition Method. Mean absorbed dose, tumour-to-normal ratio, and absorbed dose distribution in terms of dose-volume histogram (DVH) metrics were obtained and compared for each volume of interest (VOI). Mann-Whitney U-test and Pearson's correlation coefficient were used to assess the correlation between both methods. The effect of the tumoral liver volume on the absorbed dose metrics was also investigated. Strong correlation was found between simulation and therapy mean absorbed doses for all VOIs, although simulation tended to overestimate tumour absorbed doses by 26%. DVH metrics showed good correlation too, but significant differences were found for several metrics, mostly on non-tumoral liver. It was observed that the tumoral liver volume does not significantly affect the differences between simulation and therapy absorbed dose metrics.

CONCLUSION

This study supports the strong correlation between absorbed dose metrics from simulation and therapy dosimetry based on ⁹⁰Y SPECT/CT, highlighting the predictive ability of ^99mTc-MAA, not only in terms of mean absorbed dose but also of the dose distribution.

Voxel-S-Value based 3D treatment planning methods for Y-90 microspheres radioembolization based on Tc-99m-macroaggregated albumin SPECT/CT

Partition model (PM) for Y-90 microsphere radioembolization is limited in providing 3D dosimetrics. Voxel-S-Values (VSV) method has good agreement with Monte Carlo (MC) simulations for 3D absorbed dose conversion. We propose a new VSV method and compare its performance along with PM, MC and other VSV methods for Y-90 RE treatment planning based on Tc-99m MAA SPECT/CT. Twenty Tc-99m-MAA SPECT/CT patient data are retrospectively analyzed. Seven VSV methods are implemented: (1) local energy deposition; (2) liver kernel; (3) liver kernel and lung kernel; (4) liver kernel with density correction (LiKD); (5) liver kernel with center voxel scaling (LiCK); (6) liver kernel and lung kernel with density correction (LiLuKD); (7) proposed liver kernel with center voxel scaling and lung kernel with density correction (LiCKLuKD). Mean absorbed dose and maximum injected activity (MIA) obtained by PM and VSV are evaluated against MC results, and 3D dosimetrics generated by VSV are compared with MC. LiKD, LiCK, LiLuKD and LiCKLuKD have the smallest deviation in normal liver and tumors. LiLuKD and LiCKLuKD have the best performance in lungs. MIAs are similar by all methods. LiCKLuKD could provide MIA consistent with PM, and precise 3D dosimetrics for Y-90 RE treatment planning.

Voxel-S-value methods adapted to heterogeneous media for quantitative Y-90 microsphere radioembolization dosimetry

PURPOSE

The absorbed dose estimation from Voxel-S-Value (VSV) method in heterogeneous media is suboptimal as VSVs are calculated in homogeneous media. The aim of this study is to develop and evaluate new VSV methods in order to enhance the accuracy of Y-90 microspheres absorbed dose estimation in liver, lungs, tumors and lung-liver interface regions.

METHODS

Ten patients with Y-90 microspheres SPECT/CT and PET/CT data, six of whom had additional Tc-99m-macroaggregated albumin SPECT/CT data, were analyzed from the Deep Blue Data Repository. Seven existing VSV methods along with three newly proposed VSV methods were evaluated: liver and lung kernel with center voxel scaling (LiLuCK), liver kernel with density correction and lung kernel with center voxel scaling (LiKDLuCK), liver kernel with center voxel scaling and lung kernel with density correction (LiCKLuKD). Monte Carlo (MC) results were regarded as the gold standard. Absolute absorbed dose errors (%AADE) of these methods for the liver, lungs, tumors, upper liver, and lower lungs were assessed.

RESULTS

Liver and tumor's median %AADE of all methods were <3% for three types of imaging data. In the lungs, however, three recently proposed VSV methods provided median %AADEs of less than 7%, whereas the differences exceeded 20% for existing methods that did not use a lung kernel. LiCKLuKD could achieve median %AADE <2% in the liver, upper liver and tumors, and median %AADE <7% in the lungs and lower lungs in three types of data.

CONCLUSION

All methods are consistent with MC in the liver and tumors. Methods with tissue-specific kernel and effective correction achieve smaller errors in lungs. LiCKLuKD has comparable results with MC in absorbed dose estimation of Y-90 radioembolization for all target regions.

Combining External Beam Radiation and Radionuclide Therapies: Rationale, Radiobiology, Results and Roadblocks

The emergence of effective radionuclide therapeutics, such as radium-223 dichloride, [¹⁷⁷Lu]Lu-DOTA-TATE and [¹⁷⁷Lu]Lu-PSMA ligands, over the last 10 years is driving a rapid expansion in molecular radiotherapy (MRT) research. Clinical trials that are underway will help to define optimal dosing protocols and identify groups of patients who are likely to benefit from this form of treatment. Clinical investigations are also being conducted to combine new MRT agents with other anticancer drugs, with particular emphasis on DNA repair inhibitors and immunotherapeutics. In this review, the case is presented for combining MRT with external beam radiotherapy (EBRT). The technical and dosimetric challenges of combining two radiotherapeutic modalities have impeded progress in the past. However, the need for research into the specific radiobiological effects of radionuclide therapy, which has lagged behind that for EBRT, has been recognised. This, together with innovations in imaging technology, MRT dosimetry tools and EBRT hardware, will facilitate the future use of this important combination of treatments.