Evaluation of classical swine fever E2 (CSF-E2) subunit vaccine efficacy in the prevention of virus transmission and impact of maternal derived antibody interference in field farm applications

Recombinant bivalent subunit vaccine combining truncated VP4 from P[7] and P[23] induces protective immunity against prevalent porcine rotaviruses

Porcine rotaviruses (PoRVs) cause severe economic losses in the swine industry. P[7] and P[23] are the predominant genotypes circulating on farms, but no vaccine is yet available. Here, we developed a bivalent subunit PoRV vaccine using truncated versions (VP4*) of the VP4 proteins from P[7] and P[23]. The vaccination of mice with the bivalent subunit vaccine elicited more robust neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) and cellular immune responses than its components, even at high doses. The bivalent subunit vaccine and inactivated bivalent vaccine prepared from strains PoRVs G9P[7] and G9P[23] were used to examine their protective efficacy in sows and suckling piglets after passive immunization. The immunized sows showed significantly elevated NAbs in the serum and colostrum, and the suckling piglets acquired high levels of sIgA antibodies from the colostrum. Challenging subunit-vaccinated or inactivated-vaccinated piglets with homologous virulent strains did not induce diarrhea, except in one or two piglets, which had mild diarrhea. Immunization with the bivalent subunit vaccine and inactivated vaccine also alleviated the microscopic lesions in the intestinal tissues caused by the challenge with the corresponding homologous virulent strain. However, all the piglets in the challenged group displayed mild to watery diarrhea and high levels of viral shedding, whereas the feces and intestines of the piglets in the bivalent subunit vaccine and inactivated vaccine groups had lower viral loads. In summary, our data show for the first time that a bivalent subunit vaccine combining VP4*P[7] and VP4*P[23] effectively protects piglets against the diarrhea caused by homologous virulent strains.IMPORTANCEPoRVs are the main causes of diarrhea in piglets worldwide. The multisegmented genome of PoRVs allows the reassortment of VP4 and VP7 genes from different RV species and strains. The P[7] and P[23] are the predominant genotypes circulating in pig farms, but no vaccine is available at present in China. Subunit vaccines, as nonreplicating vaccines, are an option to cope with variable genotypes. Here, we have developed a bivalent subunit candidate vaccine based on a truncated VP4 protein, which induced robust humoral and cellular immune responses and protected piglets against challenge with homologous PoRV. It also appears to be safe. These data show that the truncated VP4-protein-based subunit vaccine is a promising candidate for the prevention of PoRV diarrhea.

Potential Pathogenicity and Genetic Characteristics of a Live-Attenuated Classical Swine Fever Virus Vaccine Derivative Variant

Classical swine fever (CSF), caused by CSF virus (CSFV), is a highly contagious disease affecting pigs and causing massive pig production losses with severe global economic recession. The immunization of live-attenuated vaccines is still one of the key measures to CSFV management in endemic countries. However, there are also strong controversies about the usage of live-attenuated vaccines, particularly in pregnant sows and young pigs, such as in Europe, where domestic pigs are routinely not vaccinated until severe outbreaks occur. Here, we report a CSF outbreak in a pig farm in China, which affected more than 90% of the delivery sows and led to ∼45% birth loss. Surprisingly, phylogenetic analysis showed that the CSFV isolate (named CSFV/HeNLY2022, GenBank No. OR195698) was clustered into subgenotype 1.1a, closely together with the live-attenuated vaccine strains. Further genomic analysis also revealed that the isolate CSFV/HeNLY2022 shared the highest nucleotide identity of 99.7% with the C/HVRI vaccine strain (C-strain, GenBank No. AY805221). Moreover, compared to the C/HVRI strain, a total of eight amino acid mutations, distributed in Erns (H436thY and S476thR), E1 (T502thI and P581thT), E2 (M979thK and A1061thS), NS5A (A2980thT), and NS5B (I3818thM), were characterized in the CSFV/HeNLY2022 isolate. Our results suggested that the CSF outbreak was most likely caused by the live-attenuated CSFV vaccine or its derivative. It raises concern that the unscientific application of CSFV vaccines could potentially lead to CSFV spread in pigs. It is needed to perform a more rigorous evaluation of the safety of the C-strain-derived vaccines in combination with other different live-attenuated vaccines.

Monitoring and evaluation of provincial classical swine fever immunization implementation with an E2 subunit vaccine in Jeju Island, South Korea

Purpose

Accidental vaccination with a live attenuated low-virulence strain of Miyagi (LOM) vaccine led to the reemergence of classical swine fever virus (CSFV) in Jeju province, South Korea in 2014. To control the continual outbreaks of LOM-derived CSFV, the provincial government launched a provincial mass vaccination project using a CSF-E2 subunit vaccine. We conducted this study to assess the herd immunity level and outcomes of E2 vaccine-based immunization in breeding and growing herds on Jeju Island during 2020-2021.

Materials and Methods

A large-scale vaccination trial using the Bayovac CSF-E2 vaccine investigated its efficacy in breeding and growing herds under farm application conditions (10 CSFV-affected and three CSFV-naïve swine farms).

Results

The level of herd immunity in each farm was classified into three (S1-S3) and six (G1-G6) profiles in breeding and growing herds, respectively. Immunity monitoring revealed a remarkable improvement in the herd immunity status in all farms. The majority (10/13) of farms, including CSFV-free farms, showed the S1G1 immunity profile in 2021, indicating the appropriate implementation of the advised vaccination regime. Moreover, there were significant decreases in Erns seropositivity from 100% to 50% and 25.9% to 4.3% at farm and pig levels, respectively. In particular, all farms were confirmed as CSFV free in the growing-finishing herds.

Conclusion

Our large-scale trial demonstrated the effectiveness of the E2 subunit vaccine in establishing herd immunity stabilization and eliminating CSFV circulation in the affected farms and highlighted the need for a provincial vaccination policy to regain the CSF-free status on Jeju Island.

Evaluation of an alternative method for determination of Protective Dose50 of Classical swine fever vaccines

Classical Swine Fever (CSF) is still one of the most economically important viral diseases of pigs. The disease is controlled by vaccination in the endemic countries. Hence, availability or supply of efficacious and potent vaccine in the field settings is of utmost importance. Currently, as per requirement of any Pharmacopoea, a CSF vaccine must contain 100 PD₅₀/dose which is determined by vaccinating pigs at 1/40^th and 1/160^th dilution of each dose followed by virulent challenge at 28 days post vaccination (dpv). Here, the control and the unprotected groups succumb to disease and need to be euthanized. Moreover, such challenge experiments are not feasible for each batch of the vaccine. In this communication, an alternate method of PD₅₀ dose calculation of live-attenuated CSF vaccines by measuring Serum Neutralizing Titre i.e Fluorescent Antibody Virus Neutralization (FAVN) titre of the vaccinated pigs at 28 dpv was established. This alternative method do not require the vaccinated pigs to be challenged. Serum samples, generated out of QC testing of eight batches of CSF vaccines in the laboratory, were tested and found that pigs having FAVN titre ≥10 were protected against challenge. Initially this test was optimized in serum samples of 12 animals and then validated with another 56 serum samples. It was found that the alternate method is 100% correlating with the challenge experiment. Thus, based on FAVN titre of the vaccinated animal serum, it can be predicted whether the pigs would or would not come through the challenge infection. Using the predicted status (protected/succumbed), PD50 can be calculated by applying Reed and Muench formula, hence alternate method can be used as routine QC test for potency of CSF vaccines. The newly developed assay was specific since no signal was observed in controls.

Seroprevalence Investigation of Classic Swine Fever Virus Before, During, and After African Swine Fever Virus Outbreak in Some Provinces of China from 2017 to 2021

Classic swine fever is a severe infectious and fatal disease in pigs caused by the classic swine fever virus (CSFV). Surveillance and investigation for CSFV seroprevalence contribute to knowing the immune efficiency of CSFV vaccines and reflect health status of swine herd, especially since the African swine fever virus (ASFV) outbreak in China in 2018. A total of 40,489 pig serum samples with related descriptive variables were obtained from 12 provinces and 2 cities of China from December 2017 to May 2021, covering before, during, and after three periods of ASFV outbreak. Pearson chi-square test and multivariable logistic regression analysis were used to identify impact factors related to variations in CSFV seroprevalence. Total CSFV seroprevalence was 60.40% (95% confidence interval: 59.92-60.88). Seroprevalence and antibody blocking rate mean of CSFV before outbreak of ASFV in China are higher and change gently compared with that after outbreak of ASFV. Serum collected from "summer and autumn," "north, southwest and northwest of China," "pig farm located in hill or mountain," " period before outbreak of ASFV," "PRRSV negative farm," and "replacement gilts, multiparous sows and boars" show high seroprevalence of CSFV. These results show trends in prevalence of CSFV antibody in recent years in China, especially when ASFV entered China. Identified impact factors provide references for improving immune efficiency of CSFV vaccine and benefit for prevention of CSFV.