Dose calibration of Gafchromic EBT3 film for Ir-192 brachytherapy source using 3D-printed PLA and ABS plastics

Comparison of single catheter versus dual catheter-based EBT3 film calibration for the Ir-192 beam energy

Purpose. Films and TLDs have been the common choices for passivein-vivodose measurement in radiotherapy. In the brachytherapy applications, it is very difficult to report and verify the dose at multiple localized high dose gradient regions and also the dose to organ at risk. This study was carried out to introduce a new and accurate calibration method for GafChromic EBT3 films irradiated using Ir-192 photon energy from miniature High Dose Rate (HDR) Brachytherapy source.Materials and methods. Film holder made of Styrofoam was used to hold the EBT3 film at its center. It was placed inside the mini water phantom and the films were irradiated by Ir-192 source of microSelectron HDR afterloading brachytherapy system. Two different setups: Single catheter-based film exposure and dual catheter-based film exposure were compared. The films scanned on a flatbed scanner were analysed in three different color channels: red, green, and blue using Image J software. The dose calibration graphs were generated using the third-order polynomial equations fitted on the data points from two different methods of calibration procedure. Maximum and mean dose difference between TPS calculated and measured was analyzed.Results. The measured dose difference from the TPS calculated doses were evaluated for the three groups of dose ranges (low, medium and high). In the high dose range, standard uncertainty of dose difference are ±2.3%, ±2.9%, and ±2.4% respectively for the red, green, and blue color channel when the TPS calculated dose was compared with single catheter based film calibration equation. Whereas it is observed as 1.3%, 1.4% and 3.1% for the red, green, and blue color channels respectively when compared with the dual catheter based film calibration equation. A test film was exposed to a TPS calculated dose of 666 cGy to validate the calibration equations, single catheter based film calibration equation estimated the dose difference as -9.2%, -7.8% and -3.6% respectively in the red, green, and blue color channels whereas the same were observed as 0.1%, 0.2% and 6.1% respectively when dual catheter based film calibration equation was applied.Conclusion.Source miniature size, reproducible positioning of the film and catheter system inside water medium are the major challenges in the film calibration with Ir-192 beam. To overcome these situations dual catheter-based film calibration was found more accurate and reproducible as compare to the single catheter based film calibration.

Validation of an individualized home-made superficial brachytherapy mold applied for deep nonmelanoma skin cancer

Background

This study was conducted to evaluate the effect of brachytherapy (BT) customized mold [Condensation silicone elastomer (Protesil^TM)] and its thickness on the dose distribution pattern of deep nonmelanoma skin cancers (NMSC).

Materials and methods

Four blocks of mold material were constructed in 5, 10, 15, and 20 mm thickness and 100 × 100 mm² area by a plastic cast. The high dose rate (HDR) plus treatment planning system (TPS) (Version 3, Eckert & Ziegler BEBIG Gmbh, Berlin, Germany) with a ⁶⁰Co source (model: Co0.A86, EZAG BEBIG, Berlin, Germany) as an high dose rate brachytherapy (HDR-BT) source was used. Solid phantom and MOSFET^TM and GAFCHROMIC^TM EBT3 film dosimeters were used for experimental dosimetry of the different thicknesses (up to 20 mm) of BT customized mold. Skin dose and dose to different depths were evaluated.

Result

The TPS overestimated the calculated dose to the surface. Skin dose can be reduced from 250% to 150% of the prescription dose by increasing mold thickness from 5 mm to 20 mm. There was a 7.7% difference in the calculated dose by TPS and the measured dose by MOSFET. There was a good agreement between film dosimetry, MOSFET detector, and TPS' results in depths less than 5 mm.

Conclusion

Each BT department should validate any individualized material chosen to construct the customized surface BT mold. Increasing the mold thickness can treat lesions without overexposing the skin surface. Superficial BT can be recommended as an appropriate treatment option for some deep NMSC lesions (up to 20 mm) with pre-planning considerations employing thicker molds.

Evaluating dosimetric accuracy of the 6 MV calibration on EBT3 film in the use of Ir-192 high dose rate brachytherapy

Purpose

To evaluate the dosimetric accuracy of EBT3 film calibrated with a 6 MV beam for high dose rate brachytherapy and propose a novel method for direct film calibration with an Ir‐192 source.

Methods

The 6 MV calibration was performed in water on a linear accelerator (linac). The Ir‐192 calibration was accomplished by irradiating the film wrapped around a cylinder applicator with an Ir‐192 source. All films were scanned 1‐day post‐irradiation to acquire calibration curves for all three (red, blue, and green) channels. The Ir‐192 calibration films were also used for single‐dose comparison. Moreover, an independent test film under a H.A.M. applicator was irradiated and the 2D dose distribution was obtained separately for each calibration using the red channel data. Gamma analysis and point‐by‐point profile comparison were performed to evaluate the performance of both calibrations. The uncertainty budget for each calibration system was analyzed.

Results

The red channel had the best performance for both calibration systems in the single‐dose comparison. We found a significant 4.89% difference from the reference for doses <250 cGy using the 6 MV calibration, while the difference was only 0.87% for doses >600 cGy. Gamma analysis of the 2D dose distribution showed the Ir‐192 calibration had a higher passing rate of 91.9% for the 1 mm/2% criterion, compared to 83.5% for the 6 MV calibration. Most failing points were in the low‐dose region (<200 cGy). The point‐by‐point profile comparison reported a discrepancy of 2%–3.6% between the Ir‐192 and 6 MV calibrations in this low‐dose region. The linac‐ and Ir‐192‐based dosimetry systems had an uncertainty of 4.1% (k = 2) and 5.66% (k = 2), respectively.

Conclusions

Direct calibration of EBT3 films with an Ir‐192 source is feasible and reliable, while the dosimetric accuracy of 6 MV calibration depends on the dose range. The Ir‐192 calibration should be used when the measurement dose range is below 250 cGy.

3D-printed surface applicators for brachytherapy: a phantom study

PURPOSE

Brachytherapy is a great alternative for restrictive surgical procedures in facial cancers. Moreover, dose distribution is more beneficial compared with teleradiotherapy during treatment of lesions located on anatomical curves. However, repetitiveness of application is the main issue associated with using commercial applicators. The risk of its displacement is very unfavorable due to large dose gradients in brachytherapy. The aim of this study was to develop a process of preparation of applicators using 3D printing technology.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In planning system, circular volumes near the nose, eye, and ear were determined on transverse layers of an anthropomorphic phantom. Next, boluses with a thickness of 5 mm and 10 mm were designed for each of the layers. Channels in the 10 mm bolus were designed in such a way to place the catheters into the layers. Prepared applicators were printed using polylactic acid (PLA) filament. Plans to irradiate the films for their calibration and plans for treatment prepared in the treatment planning system were conducted. A special phantom was created to calibrate the radiochromic films. Dose distribution around the designed applicators was measured in an anthropomorphic phantom using films within the layers of phantom. Comparison of doses was performed with two-dimensional gamma analysis using OmniPro I'mRT software.

RESULTS

The obtained results confirmed compliance of the planned and measured doses in 92%; the analysis of gamma parameter showed 1%/1 mm for acceptability level of 95%. Moreover, the initial dosimetric analysis for gamma criteria with 2%/2 mm showed compliance at 99%.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present study confirm potential clinical usefulness of the applicators obtained with the use of 3D printing for brachytherapy.

Additive manufacturing (3D printing) in superficial brachytherapy

The aim of this work is to provide an overview of the current state of additive manufacturing (AM), commonly known as 3D printing, within superficial brachytherapy (BT). Several comprehensive database searches were performed to find publications linked to AM in superficial BT. Twenty-eight core publications were found, which can be grouped under general categories of clinical cases, physical and dosimetric evaluations, proof-of-concept cases, design process assessments, and economic feasibility studies. Each study demonstrated a success regarding AM implementation and collectively, they provided benefits over traditional applicator fabrication techniques. Publications of AM in superficial BT have increased significantly in the last 5 years. This is likely due to associated efficiency and consistency benefits; though, more evidences are needed to determine the true extent of these benefits.

Dosimetric assessment of the impact of low-cost materials used in stereolithography in high-dose-rate brachytherapy

PURPOSE

3D printing has become a popular and widely available technique of rapid prototyping. The impact of used materials on the dose distribution has been studied for high energy sources. However, brachytherapy sources emit lower energy photons, and materials used in 3D printing may differ. This study was conducted to analyze the influence of common materials (polylactic acid - PLA and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene - ABS) used in stereolithography.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A 3D-printed phantom was designed, printed, and used to calibrate Gafchromic films. In the next step, a range of 1 mm thick plates of PLA and ABS (from zero to thirty) were inserted between source and detector to measure the impact of studied materials on delivered dose. Measurements were performed using a calibrated radiochromic film and Farmer ionization chamber in water.

RESULTS

No statistically significant correlation (p = 0.4854) between the thickness of inserted PLA and the dose delivered to the film was obtained. With ionization chamber, Spearman's rank order test showed a significant correlation (p = 0.00004); however, the correlation was found weak. In case of ABS measurement, a statistically significant (p = 0.0159), yet weak negative correlation was found between the thickness of used material and the dose delivered to the film. On the other hand, a weak statistically significant (p = 0.0212) but positive correlation was found when the dose was measured with Farmer ionization chamber. We find these correlations false, as all measured doses were within the measurement uncertainty range (film ±8.0%, Farmer ±8.8%) from 100% of the prescribed dose.

CONCLUSIONS

According to obtained results, with the accuracy of measurement under clinical conditions, the impact of highly filled PLA and ABS printed objects on the dose distribution from an 192Ir source in water can be omitted.

Manufacturing and evaluation of multi-channel cylinder applicator with 3D printing technology

Purpose

This study was designed to assess dosimetric characteristics of 3D-printed personalized multi-channel cylinder applicator (MCCA).

Material and methods

UnionTech RS Pro 600 (UnionTech, Inc., Shanghai, China) 3D printer was used for manufacturing MCCA. The geometry of MCCA was designed with Fusion 360 v.2.0.5827 (Autodesk, Inc.) software. The designed file was exported to Meshmixer v.3.5 (Autodesk, Inc.) to create three-dimensional model in stereolithography (STL) file format, which is the common file format for inputting data to 3D printers. We used high-temp resin, FLHTAM02 model (Formlabs Inc., MA, USA), as material in 3D printing process. This resin model has good resistance to high temperature and compatibility with various solvents. We created a simple cubic shape phantom for dosimetric evaluation of the applicator with Gafchromic EBT3 films. Also, Monte Carlo method was applied to simulate MCCA in the same configuration as in experimental test.

Results

The mean ± standard deviation (SD) difference between measured and calculated doses in treatment planning system (TPS) for all control points was 0.0860 ±0.0393 Gy, corresponding to 4.01 ±1.21%. The mean ±SD difference between doses calculated by Monte Carlo simulation and TPS for all control points was 0.0996 ±0.0471 Gy, corresponding to 4.58 ±1.05%. The mean ±SD of dose difference between film measurement and Monte Carlo simulation for all control points was 0.0136 ±0.0200 Gy, corresponding to 0.60 ±0.69%. P-value for dose difference between film measurement and TPS, Monte Carlo and TPS, and film measurement and Monte Carlo were 0.7, 0.66, and 0.95, respectively.

Conclusions

Dosimetric results and mechanical accuracy of MCCA show that high-temp resin with SLA 3D printing technique can be used for producing patient-specific MCCA in brachytherapy.

Absorbed dose distributions from beta-decaying radionuclides: Experimental validation of Monte Carlo tools for radiopharmaceutical dosimetry

PURPOSE

This study aims to experimentally validate the Monte Carlo generated absorbed doses from the beta particles emitted by ⁹⁰ Y and ¹⁷⁷ Lu using radiochromic EBT3 film-based dosimetry.

METHODS

Line sources of ⁹⁰ Y and ¹⁷⁷ Lu were inserted longitudinally through blocks of low-density polyethylene and tissue-equivalent slabs of cortical bone and lung equivalent plastics. Radiochromic film (Gafchromic EBT3) was laser cut to accommodate orthogonal line sources of radioactivity, and the film was sandwiched intimately between the rectangular blocks to achieve charged particle equilibrium. Line sources consisted of plastic capillary tube of length (13 ± 0.1) cm, with 0.42-mm inner diameter and a wall thickness of 0.21 mm. ⁹⁰ Y line sources were prepared from a solution of dissolved ⁹⁰ Y resin microspheres. ¹⁷⁷ Lu line sources were prepared from an aliquot of ¹⁷⁷ Lu-DOTATATE. Film exposures were conducted for durations ranging from 10 min to 38 h. Radiochromic film calibration was performed by irradiation with 6-MV-bremsstrahlung x rays from a calibrated linear accelerator, in accordance with literature recommendations. Experimental geometries were precisely simulated within the GATE Monte Carlo toolkit, which has previously been used for the generation of dose point kernels.

RESULTS

The mean percentage difference between measured and simulated absorbed doses were 5.04% and 7.21% for ⁹⁰ Y and ¹⁷⁷ Lu beta absorbed dose in the range of (0.1-10) Gy. Additionally, 1D gamma analysis using a local 10%/1 mm gamma criterion was performed to compare the absorbed dose distributions. The percentage of measurement points passing the gamma criterion, averaged over all tests, was 93.5%.

CONCLUSIONS

We report the experimental validation of Monte Carlo derived beta absorbed dose distributions for ⁹⁰ Y and ¹⁷⁷ Lu, solidifying the validity of using Monte Carlo-based methods for estimating absorbed dose from beta emitters. Overall, excellent agreement was observed between the experimental beta absorbed doses in the linear region of the radiochromic film and the GATE Monte Carlo simulations demonstrating that radiochromic film dosimetry has sufficient sensitivity and spatial resolution to be used as a tool for measuring beta decay absorbed dose distributions.