Postoperative radiation therapy for epithelial ovarian cancer: the curative role based on a 24-year experience

Ovarian Cancer Radiosensitivity: What Have We Understood So Far?

Radiotherapy has been increasingly considered as an active treatment to combine with other approaches (i.e., surgery, chemotherapy, and novel target-based drugs) in ovarian cancers to palliate symptoms and/or to prolong chemotherapy-free intervals. This narrative review aimed to summarize the current knowledge of the radiosensitivity/radioresistance of ovarian cancer which remains the most lethal gynecological cancer worldwide. Indeed, considering the high rate of recurrence in and out of the radiotherapy fields, in the era of patient-tailored oncology, elucidating the mechanisms of radiosensitivity and identifying potential radioresistance biomarkers could be crucial in guiding clinical decision-making.

Treatment-interval associated effect of irradiation on locoregionally-relapsed ovarian cancer

Recurrent ovarian cancer following chemotherapy is usually incurable, particularly when the tumor acquires a drug resistance. The present study aimed to define the effect of irradiation on locoregional recurrences and the impact of the factors on the efficacy. The study retrospectively reviewed the clinical records of 61 patients with epithelial ovarian cancer who received irradiation following repeated chemotherapy between 1997 and 2006. A positive-irradiation response was designated as complete response, partial response, minor response or no change (NC). Due to the possible synergistic effect of chemotherapy and irradiation, and the cross-resistance to chemotherapeutic drugs and radiation, the focus was on the treatment break between chemotherapy and radiation, and patients were classified into 3 categories: Category I, ≤1 month; II, 1-6 months; and III, >6 months. The effect of irradiation was analyzed in association with histology, treatment break, recurrent site, irradiation dose and chemosensitivity. The post-irradiation survival time was analyzed by the irradiation response and treatment category. The median biological-effective dose was 60.0 Gy (range, 15.6-72.0 Gy). The sites irradiated included nodal recurrence (36), abdominal (six) and pelvic cavity (five cases). Histologically, serous adenocarcinoma was the most common type of the disease (23 cases) compared to mucinous (four), endometrioid (three), and clear-cell types (six cases). The median survival times were 4.5 months in the radiation responders (13 cases) and 15.3 months in the non-responders (37) (P=0.004). The positive-irradiation response was significantly associated with the treatment break (P=0.026) and chemosensitivity (P=0.007). In conclusion, irradiation for recurrent ovarian cancer produced an improved survival benefit when applied to chemoresponsive, locoregional-recurrent tumors immediately following chemotherapy.

Epithelial Ovarian Cancer: A Review of Current Management

Epithelial ovarian cancer is the most lethal gynaecological cancer among women worldwide, with 6000 new cases diagnosed in the UK each year. Most women present with advanced disease, but, despite a good initial response to treatment, most relapse. The overall 5-year survival rate is 46%, although this drops to about 13% in women with advanced disease. Transvaginal ultrasound and the tumour marker CA125 are being investigated for screening in ongoing randomised trials. Treatment of ovarian cancer is dependent on clinical stage, and should always be managed within a multidisciplinary team. Most cases will require a pelvic clearance and adjuvant chemotherapy. Current guidelines by the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) recommend that first-line chemotherapy should include a platinum-based regimen with or without paclitaxel. Relapsed ovarian cancer is incurable; however, chemotherapy can improve quality of life and survival. Gene therapy, immunotherapy and signal transduction inhibitors are all potential future therapies, and are being investigated in ongoing clinical research. In this paper we review the literature on the epidemiology, pathology, clinical features and the current treatment options in epithelial ovarian cancer.

Twenty-five year outcome of sequential abdominal radiotherapy and melphalan:implications for future management of epithelial carcinoma of the ovary

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the present study is evaluation of the long-term efficacy of sequential abdominopelvic radiotherapy and melphalan in the management of ovarian carcinoma.

METHODS

From 1970 to 1976, 94 women with stages I-III epithelial ovarian carcinoma enrolled in a prospective nonrandomized clinical trial were prescribed 20 Gy to the upper abdomen and 50 Gy to the pelvis followed by courses of melphalan (1 mg/kg/course). Primary endpoints were survival, recurrence, and toxicity.

RESULTS

There were 19 stage I, 25 stage II, and 50 stage III patients. For all stages, overall survival was 42% at 5 years, 30% at 10 years, and 17% at 25 years. Median follow-up of the survivors was 24 years. Disease-free survival was 48% at 5 years and remained at 45% from 10 to 25 years. All but two recurrences occurred within the first 27 months. No recurrence or treatment-related death occurred after 8 years. No recurrence was salvaged. All but one initial recurrence was within the peritoneal cavity. Of the 31 patients undergoing a second-look surgical procedure, 84% were free of tumor. Only 8% of patients recurred after a negative second look. Stage and the presence of palpable postoperative disease were significant prognostic factors. Disease-free survivals were 95% from 5 to 25 years for stage I, 70% at 5 years and 60% at 25 years for stage II, and 20% from 5 to 25 years for stage III (P < 0.0001). Although no patient with postoperative palpable tumor was cured, 25% lived beyond 2 years. Stage III patients without postoperative palpable tumor achieved a 47% 25-year disease-free survival. Acute toxicity was acceptable, and 98% of patients completed radiation therapy. Chronic toxicity included a 12% small bowel obstruction rate and a 3% fatal second malignancy/hematological toxicity rate (two cases of acute myelocytic leukemia, one case of thrombocytopenia).

CONCLUSIONS

The long-term disease-free survival obtained with abdominopelvic radiotherapy followed by single alkylating agent chemotherapy has not been exceeded by three subsequent decades of multiagent chemotherapy trials. Abdominal radiotherapy may be useful to consolidate complete responses following therapy multiagent chemotherapy, particularly with the upper abdominal dose escalation provided by intensity modulated radiation therapy and possibly in conjunction with chemotherapy.

Whole-abdomen, single-dose consolidation radiotherapy in patients with pathologically confirmed complete remission of advanced ovarian epithelial carcinoma: a long-term survival analysis

The value of consolidation therapy in advanced epithelial ovarian carcinoma patients is controversial. The aim of the present study was to assess the long-term survival of patients with a pathologically confirmed complete remission who had consolidation by single-dose, whole-abdominopelvic radiotherapy. Of 96 histologically confirmed stage II-IV epithelial ovarian carcinoma patients who underwent cytoreductive surgery followed by high-dose, platin-based chemotherapy, 57 were in complete clinical remission at the end of therapy and 50 underwent a second-look laparotomy. The study group comprises 32 consecutive patients who had no pathological evidence of disease and who received 800 cGy single-dose, whole-abdominal radiotherapy by an 8 MEV linear accelerator in a single fraction. The absolute 5-year survival and the actuarial 10-year survival were 78.7 and 63.3%, respectively. The survival was significantly better in patients who had < or =2 cm residual disease at the completion of the original operation. No severe postradiation complications were encountered. Mild complications were seen in three (9.4%) patients. Our data indicate a favorable long-term survival of patients with a negative second-look laparotomy who had consolidation with single-dose, whole-abdominal radiotherapy. These results seem to suggest that a collaborative, prospective, randomized multiarm study is indicated to solve the controversial issue of consolidation therapy.

A Randomized Study of Epithelial Ovarian Cancer: Is Chemotherapy Useful after Complete Remission?

Objective. The aim of this study is to verify whether consolidation chemotherapy with Cisplatin improves disease-free survival and/or overall survival in patients affected by epithelial ovarian cancer.Methods. A multicenter study examined 122 randomized patients in complete remission as judged by laparoscopy or laparotomy following first-line chemotherapy consisting of ACy (Adriamycin + Cyclophosphamide), PCy (Cisplatin + Cyclophosphamide), or Mitoxantrone + Carboplatin. Sixty-one of these patients were treated with 3 cycles of 5-Fluorouracil (FU) 500 mg/m2 for 5 days followed by Cisplatin at 100 mg/m2 on the 6th or 7th day every 28 days; the other 61 received no further treatment (nihil group).Results. Sixty patients in the Cisplatin arm were evaluable. There were 36 relapses in the FU+Cisplatin arm and 30 in the nihil arm. Peritoneal relapses were 25% for Cisplatin treatment vs. 16.4 % for nihil. There were 29 deaths in the Cisplatin arm vs. 27 for nihil. Median overall survival time (95 months with Cisplatin vs. 96 months in the nihil group) and median disease-free survival (66 months with Cisplatin vs. 73 in the nihil group) were similar in both arms (p=0.66 and p=0.41, respectively). There were no significant differences in tumor stage and grade between the two arms. Seven patients presented a second neoplasm during follow-up: six in the nihil arm, but only one patient in the Cisplatin arm. Death in these patients was due to the second neoplasm and not to progression of ovarian cancer.Conclusion. Three courses of additional platinum+FU treatment after five cycles of first-line chemotherapy without FU produced no increase in overall survival or disease-free survival.

High-dose whole abdominal and pelvic irradiation for treatment of ovarian carcinoma: long-term toxicity and outcomes

PURPOSE

To evaluate the role of high-dose whole abdominal and pelvic irradiation (WART) in the treatment of epithelial ovarian carcinoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A retrospective review was performed on 71 patients with Stage I-III ovarian carcinoma who were treated with WART using an open field technique after total abdominal hysterectomy and bilateral oophorectomy with or without omentectomy. Whole abdominal doses greater than typically recommended were used in a series of patients to enhance local control and to decrease abdominal recurrence. None of the patients had received chemotherapy before RT. Thirty-one patients received Alkeran or cyclophosphamide and two received cisplatin-based chemotherapy after WART. The median whole abdominal dose was 36 Gy (range 9-45.5), delivered in a median of 30 fractions (range 8-46). A pelvic boost was delivered using AP-PA fields during whole abdominal RT to a total midline pelvic dose of 200 cGy/d. The median pelvic dose was 51 Gy (range 16-59). The right lobe and a portion of the left lobe of the liver were shielded with custom blocks at a median dose of 25 Gy (range 9-41). The kidneys were shielded either AP-PA or PA from the first day of RT. The median dose to the kidneys was 19 Gy (range 4-30).

RESULTS

The 5-year overall survival rate was 93%, 48%, and 29% for Stage I, II, and III patients, respectively. On multivariate analysis, stage and the extent of residual disease were independent prognostic factors. The 5- and 10-year overall survival rate for the 46 patients in the intermediate-risk group was 61% and 54%, respectively. For this group, a total abdominal dose of > or /=36 Gy was associated with a longer overall survival independent of stage, grade, and the amount of residual disease. This was most likely due to a significant reduction in the incidence of abdominal recurrence in patients receiving >36 Gy to the whole abdomen (18% vs. 49%, p = 0.006). Multivariate analysis revealed that grade (p = 0.023) and abdominal dose (p = 0.018) were independent factors influencing the rate of abdominal recurrence. Pelvic recurrence was rare as a first site of failure (6%). Twenty-one percent (n = 15) of the patients developed Grade 3 or 4 (Radiation Therapy Oncology Group [RTOG] criteria) chronic small or large bowel toxicity. Eleven percent of all patients had a small bowel obstruction requiring surgery. A whole abdominal dose >30 Gy and a pelvic dose >50 Gy were associated with a significant increase in small bowel obstruction (p = 0.01) independent of other factors. Chronic Grade 3 or 4 (Common Toxicity Criteria) anemia, thrombocytopenia, and leukopenia were seen in 7%, 1%, and 4% of the patients, respectively. Transient liver enzyme elevation was common (62%). Two patients had Grade 3 (RTOG) hepatic toxicity. Grade 3 or 4 renal toxicity (RTOG) was observed in 4%, and 2 patients (3%) were diagnosed with pelvic insufficiency fractures that were managed conservatively.

CONCLUSION

Survival after RT for ovarian carcinoma rivals that achieved with systemic chemotherapy. The results of this study suggest a possible dose-control relationship between the whole abdominal dose and the risk of abdominal recurrence; however, a higher rate of small bowel obstruction was observed when greater abdominal doses and greater pelvic doses were combined. Careful attention to balancing toxicity and efficacy is imperative if RT is to have a future role in the treatment of this disease.

Improved outcome at 10 years for serous-papillary/clear cell or high-risk endometrial cancer patients treated by adjuvant high-dose whole abdomino-pelvic irradiation

PURPOSE

The aim of the study was to evaluate the 10-year treatment outcome of utilizing adjuvant high-dose whole abdominal irradiation (WAPI technique) with a pelvic/vaginal boost in patients with stage I-III endometrial carcinoma at high risk for intra-abdominopelvic recurrence, including serous-papillary and clear cell histologies.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In a prospective nonrandomized trial, 132 patients were treated with adjuvant WAPI between November 1981 and October 2001. Forty-three patients (32%) were 1998 FIGO stage I-II and 89 (68%) were stage III. Pathological features included the following: 66 (52%) with deep myometrial invasion, 50 (38%) with positive peritoneal cytology, 89 (67%) with high-grade lesions, 25 (19%) with positive pelvic/para-aortic lymph nodes, and 58 (45%) with serous-papillary or clear cell histology.

RESULTS

The mean follow up was 6.4 years (range 0.6-16.1). For the entire group, the 5- and 10-year cause-specific survival (CSS) was 77 and 72%, whereas the disease-free survival (DFS) was 55 and 45%. When stratified by histology the 5- and 10-year CSS for adenocarcinoma was 75 and 70%, while serous-papillary/clear cell was 80 and 74% (P = 0.314). The 5- and 10-year DFS for adenocarcinoma was 59 and 49%, whereas serous-papillary/clear cell was 49 and 38% (P = 0.563). For surgical stages I-II, the 5-year CSS was 83% for adenocarcinoma and 89% for serous-papillary (P = 0.353). For stage III, it was 73 and 62% (P = 0.318), respectively. Forty-six patients (35%) relapsed. The first site of failure was the abdomen/pelvis in 27/46 (59%). When stratified by histologic variant, 34% of patients with adenocarcinoma and 41% with serous-papillary developed recurrent disease. In multivariate regression analysis only advancing age was of prognostic significance for CSS (P = 0.025) and DFS (P = 0.026). Chronic grade 3/4 GI toxicity was seen in 14%, and 2% of patients developed grade 3 renal toxicity.

CONCLUSION

High-dose adjuvant WAPI is very effective treatment with excellent 10-year results for stage I-III endometrial carcinoma with risk factors for intra-abdominopelvic recurrence, including serous-papillary or clear cell histology. The low long-term complication rate with high CSS makes high-dose WAPI the treatment of choice for these patients with significant comorbidities.

Integrating radiation therapy in the curative management of ovarian cancer: current issues and future directions

Although important advances in surgery, chemotherapy (CT), and radiation therapy (RT) have been made, overall survival for patients with ovarian cancer (OC) has not changed significantly. Despite its long history in the treatment of OC and its proven curative role in patients with microscopic or minimal residual disease, the proper role of RT in the management of OC is not clearly established. Although the use of primary adjuvant RT (whole abdominal irradiation) has declined in the last 15 years, there has been a resurgence of interest in RT as part of a combined modality approach and as salvage therapy for patients with small-volume persistent disease after primary cytoreductive surgery and platinum-based CT. This article reviews the evidence supporting the use of RT alone or combined with chemotherapy as primary adjuvant therapy or in the salvage setting. Current issues in the radiotherapeutic management are discussed along with ideas for future clinical research directions.

The prognostic significance of peritoneal seeding and size of postsurgical residual in patients with stage III epithelial ovarian cancer treated with surgery, chemotherapy, and high-dose radiotherapy

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to retrospectively analyze the prognostic importance of age, histologic type and grade, ascites, lymph node status, size and type of postoperative residual disease, and radiation dose on disease-specific (DSS) and progression-free survival (PFS) in stage III epithelial ovarian cancer patients who had been treated with radical surgery, postoperative chemotherapy, and high-dose radiotherapy.

METHODS

Consolidation radiotherapy including whole abdominal radiation, pelvic, and upper abdominal boosts was employed in 46 patients who showed no evidence of residual or progressive disease after completion of multiagent chemotherapy. The median follow-up for all patients was 36 months and 103 months for patients at risk. The prognostic impact of pretreatment and treatment parameters on DSS and PFS was tested in univariate and multivariate analyses.

RESULTS

The 5-year DSS and PFS rates for all patients were 38 and 33%, and for patients with 0-< or =2 cm residual tumor 65 and 61%, respectively. In univariate analysis, initial peritoneal seeding (both: P = 0.02), ascites (P = 0.03; 0.01), size of residual (0-< or =2 cm vs >2 cm), and residual miliary subdiaphragmatic (MDS) and localized peritoneal seeding (LPS) in the upper abdomen (P = 0.0002; 0.0003) were significantly correlated with DSS and PFS. Dose of radiation (< or =30 vs >30 Gy) correlated with DSS only (P = 0.02). In multivariate analysis size of residual disease (0-< or =2 cm vs >2 cm and/or MDS or LPS) remained the only independent prognostic factor for DSS and PFS (both; P = 0. 001).

CONCLUSION

Patients with localized peritoneal seeding who were rendered free of disease elsewhere had an outcome equally poor as that of patients with gross residuals (>2 cm) in the upper abdomen. If our findings can be confirmed, attempted resection of all localized seeding in patients who are otherwise cytoreducible to no or minimal residual disease may be considered in combination with Taxol-containing regimens as are now being utilized for patients with gross disease.

[Tolerance and role of irradiation in the treatment of epithelial cancer of the ovary]

PURPOSE

In a retrospective analysis, our aim was to evaluate the immediate tolerance and the early and late complications of abdomino-pelvic radiotherapy in the Centre Alexis-Vautrin (France).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From 1st January 1983 to 31st December 1993, 117 patients were treated at Centre Alexis Vautrin in Nancy for epithelial ovarian cancer by abdominal and/or pelvic irradiation after surgery. They were aged from 24 to 85 with a median of 56 years. There were ten patients with stage I (9%), 28 patients with stage II (24%), 60 patients with stage III (61%) and 19 patients with stage IV (16%) disease. Results of surgery were determined as follows: satisfactory with absence of tumoral residuum in 26% cases (30 patients) and with residuum inferior to 20 mm in 46% cases (52 patients; incomplete in 26% cases (31 patients) either because of residuum superior in 20 mm and/or incomplete surgery; and not evaluable in 3% cases (four patients). Seventy-seven patients were sent to the Centre for postoperative treatment (66% patients of the series), 48 of them (62.4%) after non-satisfactory surgery, 29 after satisfactory surgery (37.6%). Chemotherapy was administered to only 104 patients (89% cases), and contained platinum salts and cyclophosphamid for 87% of these patients. Fourteen patients (12%) received a single irradiation dose after surgery: three in stage I, three with poor evaluation of the disease in the initial stage, three with medical contraindications to chemotherapy treatment, six with contraindications due to advanced age (?? Makes 15 ). Histologically, 46% of patients had a serous adenocarcinoma, 9% a mucinous adenocarcinoma, 11% an endometrioid adenocarcinoma, 2% a clear cell adenocarcinoma, 1% an undifferentiated adenocarcinoma, and 31% an epithelial carcinoma without any other indication. The histological grade which was recently introduced was rarely indicated. Complementary radiotherapeutic treatment consisted of pelvic irradiation for 14 patients (12%), abdomino-pelvic irradiation for 63 patients (54%), and total abdominal irradiation with a pelvic boost for 40 patients (34%).

RESULTS

The immediate tolerance to irradiation can be considered as globally satisfactory since 9% of the patients (ten cases) had no problems and 64% of the patients developed a minor intolerance easily controlled by symptomatic treatments. There were also digestive complications: nausea, vomiting and diarrhea for 66% of the patients (50 cases); to a lesser extent, 20% of the cases experienced associated digestive and hematological complications (15 patients); 9% isolated hematological troubles such as anemia (seven patients); 4% digestive complications (three patients) and 1% hematological and urinary digestive troubles (one patients). Late irradiation sequelae were evaluated for 89 patients with a follow-up lasting from 4 months to 11 years. Sixty-six patients had no sequelae, eleven patients had minor tolerability problems--mainly digestive for more than half of them. Five patients presented severe complications, including hematological problems such as chronic thrombopenia in two cases, urinary-problems in two other cases, and one patient presented with a case of histologically proven malabsorption. Two patients presented major problems; one case of radic cystitis and one of radic bowel. Two patients died of iatrogenic causes: one of induced leukemia, the other of treatment-induced digestive and renal complications. The overall survival rate was 30% at 5 years and 22% at 10 years. It was 90% at 5 and 10 years for stage I patients, 60% at 5 years and 30% at 10 years for stage II patients, 22% at 5 years and 8% at 10 years for stage III patients, and finally 10% at 5 years for stage IV patients.

CONCLUSION

In this retrospective analysis of 117 epithelial ovarian cancers, treated over 10 years and which all received pelvic and/or abdominal irradiation, we can conclude that this treatment is globally well tolerated and that it yields a

Palliative benefit of external-beam radiation in the management of platinum refractory epithelial ovarian carcinoma

In vitro studies and clinical experience have suggested that patients with platinum-refractory epithelial ovarian carcinoma exhibit cross-resistance to radiation. Salvage with radiation in these patients is rare. However, radiation is often utilized to palliate symptoms caused by these chemotherapy-resistant tumors. Forty-seven patients with platinum-refractory epithelial ovarian carcinoma were referred for palliative radiation and 33 (70%) were evaluable for response. One to four regimens of platinum-based chemotherapy (median 2.7) were given to each patient prior to radiation therapy. Of the 33 evaluable patients, 23 (69.7%) had a complete resolution of symptoms after radiation, 8 (24%) had a partial resolution, and 2 were unassessable because of unrelated medical complications. The median duration of response was 11 months (range 1-86) and closely approximated their survival. Thirteen of 33 patients (39%) obtained relief of symptoms for greater than 12 months, with 10 of 33 (30%) having symptoms controlled for 6 to 12 months. In only 10 patients (30%) was the duration of palliation less than or equal to 6 months. Four patients required reirradiation to the same area for recurrence of their symptom. External-beam radiation therapy can provide effective and durable palliation of symptoms in platinum-refractory epithelial ovarian carcinoma patients.

WART revisited: the treatment of epithelial ovarian cancer by whole abdominal radiotherapy

The present study investigated outcomes for 78 women with epithelial ovarian carcinoma treated by whole abdominal radiotherapy (WART) after cyto-reductive surgery at Westmead Hospital between 1980 and 1993. These patients had 5-year relapse-free and overall survival rates of 52 and 55%, respectively. The median follow-up was 7.5 years. Fifty-eight of the 78 women fulfilled the criteria as defined by the Princess Margaret Hospital's intermediate risk' category. These patients had both a relapse-free and overall survival rate of 62% at 5 years (P = 0.001 as compared with the remaining 20 women). Mild gastrointestinal upset was common during radiotherapy. Five women did not complete treatment. Late toxicity (grade 3 or more, using the Radiotherapy Oncology Group (RTOG) system) occurred in eight women, and five women required surgery for intestinal complications (6.4%). There were no deaths due to late side effects. In conclusion the results are consistent with those of other series in the treatment of epithelial ovarian cancer by adjuvant WART. When compared to a similar-stage disease treated with cisplatin-based chemotherapy, there is no evidence to support the exclusive use of chemotherapy.

Ovarian cancer

This synthesis of the literature on radiotherapy for cancer originating in the ovaries is based on 74 scientific articles, including 12 randomized studies, 18 prospective studies, and 36 retrospective studies. These studies involve 6,140 patients. Treatment for patients at early stages of ovarian cancer (stages I and II) is surgery. The value of adjuvant treatment, ie, chemotherapy or radiotherapy, is not demonstrated. Tumor volume is decisive to the success of radiotherapy. Microscopic or small macroscopic cancer residuals, remaining after surgery, may respond to radiotherapy, thereby promoting survival. The importance of radiotherapy for advanced ovarian cancer is controversial, and studies frequently show contradictory results. Two studies have shown the favorable role played by radiotherapy in consolidation treatment of patients if they become cancer-free at advanced stages. The role of radiotherapy in treating larger volumes of residual cancer has not been demonstrated, except for strictly palliative treatment.

Abdomino pelvic irradiation after second-look laparotomy for stage III ovarian carcinoma

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this retrospective analysis of 34 patients with stage III ovarian carcinoma was to review results and morbidity of whole abdominal irradiation after surgery and chemotherapy.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

All of the 34 patients had reached a complete clinical remission after first cytoreductive surgery and chemotherapy. After second-look laparotomy each patient underwent whole abdominal irradiation. Except for two patients with chronic myelosuppression, the dose administered was of 22.5 Gy to the abdominal cavity with a boost of 22.5 Gy added to the pelvis.

RESULTS

Three and 5-year overall survival rates were 62% and 43%, respectively. Three and 5-year disease-free survival rates were 53% and 38%. Twenty-three patients (68%) developed local relapse or local disease progression. Metastasis occurred in five cases and were always associated with an abdominal cavity recurrence. Residual disease after first cytoreductive surgery appeared as a prognostic factor in univariate analysis. Patients with unresected residuum had a 5-year survival probability of 35% versus 83% for patients without residual disease. We observed 12% grade-3 intestinal toxicities and one fatal case of radiation enteritis.

CONCLUSION

Despite its curative potential, the long term benefit of whole abdominal irradiation in the multimodality treatment of advanced ovarian carcinoma must be evaluated in well designed controlled trials.

Evaluation of whole abdominal irradiation in ovarian carcinoma with a four orthogonal fields technique

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the toxicity and the results of abdominopelvic irradiation with a four orthogonal field's technique in patients with ovarian carcinoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between May 1981 and December 1990, 167 patients with ovarian carcinoma have been treated with whole abdominal irradiation: 62 patients with no or minimal residual disease < 2 cm after initial surgery (group 1) and 105 patients with no residual disease or macroscopic residual disease < 2 cm assessed by second-look surgery after incomplete debulking surgery and cisplatin-based polychemotherapy (group 2). Irradiation was performed by a four orthogonal field's technique. Thirty grays were given with a 25 MV photon beam (1.5 Gy/fraction/day, 20 fractions over 30 days). Boosts were performed in 50 cases (median dose of 15 Gy).

RESULTS

With a median follow-up of 68 months, the 5-year actuarial survival rate was 50% in the entire group, 67% in group 1, 40% in group 2, and 84% in T1, 61.5% in T2, 38% in T3. Five-year actuarial survival was analyzed according to the residuum: (a) after initial surgery (no residual disease: 70%, residual disease: 36.5%), (b) after second-look surgery: 76% in patients with a negative second look, 66% in patients with microscopic residual disease, 22% in patients with macroscopic residual disease and secondary surgical reduction, and 10% in patients with small unresectable nodules. Nine percent of the patients failed to complete irradiation acute side effects related. Five percent required surgery for bowel obstruction.

CONCLUSION

The abdominopelvic irradiation with this four orthogonal field's technique was associated with tolerable acute toxicity and a low risk of serious late complications. Similar late results to have been reported whole abdominal irradiation with chemotherapy in patients with negative or microscopic residual disease after surgery. Randomized trials comparing these two adjuvant treatments are warranted.

Role of radiotherapy in the treatment of cancer of the ovary

The initial management of carcinoma of the ovary is surgical. The need for further treatment is determined by a consideration of tumor stage, grade, and the presence of residual disease. Approximately one-third of patients are suitably managed by primary post-operative radiotherapy directed to the entire abdomen and pelvis with curative intent. Patients are mainly derived from stages I and II. Stage III patients are also included if the tumor is of low grade and there is no pelvic residuum. The dose which can be safely delivered to the upper abdomen is limited by normal tissue tolerance. Curative radiation is inappropriate for patients with upper abdominal disease and/or more than small volume residuum in the pelvis. These patients are best managed with chemotherapy. Suitably selected patients have a ten-year relapse-free survival of 68% following radiotherapy. Acute gastrointestinal symptoms are common during the treatment, but are usually amenable to symptomatic management. Long term morbidity is infrequent, and with modern techniques the incidence of treatment-related small bowel obstruction is around 5%. Radiotherapy to the abdomen and pelvis has also a potential role as consolidative treatment in patients with advanced disease, following a favourable response to chemotherapy.

Therapeutic advances in radiologic treatment of cancer

In 1993, roughly 1,170,000 new cases of invasive cancer will be diagnosed in the United States. A considerable portion of these patients who die will do so because of uncontrolled local and/or regional disease. Numerous advances in the radiologic treatment of cancer have led to improved local and regional control, as well as survival. These advances include improved radiologic imaging techniques, improved techniques of radiation therapy, innovative brachytherapeutic techniques, intraoperative electron beam therapy techniques, and stereotaxic radiosurgical techniques. In this paper, the authors discuss these techniques with specific attention to how they have lead to improved local and regional control, as well as cancer cure with organ preservation.

Salvage whole abdomen radiation therapy: its role in ovarian cancer

PURPOSE

In spite of high initial response rates, many patients with epithelial ovarian carcinoma eventually fail their primary treatment. Further treatment with second-line regimens has been ineffective in producing durable responses. Thus, whole abdomen radiation therapy was evaluated as a salvage therapeutic modality as to its feasibility, efficacy, and toxicity.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between June 1983 and June 1990, 44 patients who failed one or more chemotherapeutic regimens were treated with whole abdomen radiation therapy. Forty patients had epithelial carcinoma of the ovary and the remaining had primary adenocarcinoma of the peritoneal cavity. Radiation was delivered with an open-field technique and 2500 cGy were planned to the whole abdomen, with a boost when indicated. Prior to radiation, the amount of residual disease after debulking was noted to be microscopic in one-half of the patients and macroscopic in the other half. Pelvis alone was the site of residual disease in 14 patients, and upper abdominal involvement was found in 30.

RESULTS

Five patients (11%) were unable to complete the planned therapy secondary to acute toxicity. The 4-year actuarial survival and recurrence-free survival rates for the entire group were 23% and 22%, respectively. The survival and recurrence-free survival rates for the group with microscopic residual disease at 37% and 42% were significantly better than those for the patients with macroscopic residual disease at 9% and 5% (p < 0.005; p < 0.001) at 4 years, respectively. Patients with disease limited to pelvis only had a recurrence-free survival of 56% compared to 0% when the upper abdomen was involved (p < 0.005). The abdomino-pelvic cavity was the first site of recurrence in 28 of 31 patients in whom the site of recurrence could be determined. Eight patients (18%) experienced bowel complications, of whom five needed surgical intervention.

CONCLUSIONS

Whole abdomen radiation therapy with a pelvic boost is feasible with acceptable acute and late toxicity. It is effective in patients with minimal residual disease.

Long-term survival with adjuvant whole abdominopelvic irradiation for uterine papillary serous carcinoma

BACKGROUND

The optimum management of uterine papillary serous carcinoma (UPSC), a clinically aggressive histologic variant of endometrial adenocarcinoma, is a controversial issue.

METHODS

Ten patients with UPSC were reviewed who received whole abdominopelvic irradiation (WAP) as adjuvant therapy after a staging laparotomy and debulking surgery.

RESULTS

Nine patients had clinical Stage I disease; the tumors in eight of them were upstaged based on laparotomy findings. There was greater than a 50% invasion of the myometrium in four of the hysterectomy specimens, and vascular space invasion was noted in seven patients. Peritoneal washings were positive in three of the nine specimens obtained; two others showed atypical cells. Five patients are alive with no evidence of disease at 102-133 months. Four patients are dead, and one patient is alive with disease. All recurrences were observed within 30 months of the initial diagnosis and were more common in the presence of deep myometrial invasion and vascular space involvement. Three of the four patients who died had pleural effusions that did not respond to hormonal and/or chemotherapy. Local irradiation produced long-term control of recurrences in two patients, including one with supraclavicular lymph node metastases who had no evidence of disease 117 months after radiation treatment to the involved nodes.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that WAP be considered as an adjuvant therapy in the management of UPSC. The patients with the greatest benefit were those with early disease by surgical staging with or without positive peritoneal cytologic findings. For patients at high risk for pleural effusions and pulmonary metastasis, additional adjuvant therapy, such as innovative chemotherapy or low-dose lung irradiation, needs to be considered.

Integrating radiation therapy into the management of ovarian cancer

Several studies during the last 15 years have elucidated the role of postoperative external beam radiation therapy as curative management of some subsets of patients with ovarian cancer. Despite this, the use of radiation therapy in patients with ovarian cancer has remained a controversial subject. Substantially improved cure rates have not been realized during the past decade despite the early promise of high response rates to cisplatin chemotherapy. Thus, it is important that all currently effective therapies be used for maximum therapeutic gain. This article will review the evidence that radiation therapy is curative in ovarian cancer and highlight the criteria, including stage and grade of disease and tumor residuum, by which patients suitable for such therapy are selected. The rationale for the use of whole abdominopelvic irradiation rather than pelvic or lower abdominal treatment will be discussed, as will the optimal radiation technique and its attendant morbidity. Limited data pertinent to the controversy over the use of radiation therapy versus chemotherapy in early disease, will be reviewed. The possible benefits of consolidation abdominopelvic radiation therapy after chemotherapy in highly selected patients with well-differentiated microscopic residual disease at second-look laparotomy or with no residual disease but high a risk for relapse will be considered.

External beam radiotherapy in the management of ovarian carcinoma

Between 1970 and 1983, 345 patients with ovarian cancer clinical stage I, II, and III were irradiated postoperatively. Five-year NED survival was achieved in 41.7% of patients. The most important prognostic factors were histological grade and clinical stage of cancer. Postoperative external beam radiotherapy appeared to be highly efficient for the patients with microscopic residual disease, giving 70% 5-year survival, and moderately efficient for patients with small, i.e. < or = 3 cm in diameter residual disease, giving 40% 5-year survival. The optimal technique of irradiation appeared to be the irradiation given to the entire abdominal cavity with additional irradiation coned down to the pelvis. External beam radiotherapy was ineffective in patients with gross residual disease, i.e. > 3 cm in diameter, and useless as palliative treatment given to patients with inoperable cancer of the ovary.

Radiotherapy of malignant subdiaphragmatic implants in advanced ovarian carcinoma: a new technique

We report the development of a new technique using remote afterloading intraoperative radiation therapy to deliver a tumoricidal dose to diaphragmatic tumor implants. A multi-positional lucite applicator was designed based on anatomic studies of the diaphragmatic surface to accommodate a high dose rate iridium source in a series of needles placed 1.5 cm apart. The applicator curvature can vary from planar to full accommodation of the diaphragmatic surface with a constant source to surface distance of 0.5 cm. The applicator has been piloted in three patients with ovarian carcinoma with residual subdiaphragmatic disease found at second look laparotomy, to deliver a dose of 1,500 to 2,000 cGy at 0.5 cm. Tolerance of the diaphragm and hepatic surface has been excellent. There were no postoperative complications and no deterioration in liver function studies. The additional postoperative external beam irradiation directed with the aid of surgically placed clips and gated to respiratory movements permits achievement of a tumoricidal dose while limiting the treated volume and related toxicities.

Analysis of complications in patients treated with abdomino-pelvic radiation therapy for ovarian carcinoma

Between 1971 and 1985, 598 patients with ovarian carcinoma were treated with abdomino-pelvic radiation therapy. Acute complications included nausea and vomiting in 364 patients (61%) which were severe in 36, and diarrhea in 407 patients (68%), severe in 35. Leukopenia (less than 2.0 x 10(9) cells/liter) and thrombocytopenia (less than 100 x 10(9) cells/liter) occurred in 64 patients (11%) each. Treatment interruptions occurred in 136 patients (23%), and 62 patients (10%) did not complete treatment. In both situations the most common cause was myelosuppression. Late complications included chronic diarrhea in 85 patients (14%), transient hepatic enzyme elevation in 224 (44%), and symptomatic basal pneumonitis in 23 (4%). Serious late bowel complications were infrequent: 25 patients (4.2%) developed bowel obstruction and 16 required operation. Multivariate analysis was unable to determine any significant prognostic factors for bowel obstruction; however, the moving-strip technique of radiation therapy was associated with a significantly greater risk of developing chronic diarrhea, pneumonitis, and hepatic enzyme elevation than was the open beam technique. We conclude that abdomino-pelvic radiation therapy as used in these patients is associated with modest acute complications and a low risk of serious late toxicity.

Epithelial ovarian cancer: the role of radiotherapy

Although several studies during the last 10-15 years have served to clarify the role of postoperative external beam radiotherapy in patients with ovarian cancer, the subject remains controversial. This paper will review the following topics: 1. Stage I Ovarian Cancer. 2. The rationale for selecting whole abdominopelvic radiotherapy over other forms of radiotherapy, such as pelvic or lower abdominal radiotherapy. 3. The choice of radiation technique. 4. The evidence that radiotherapy is curative in ovarian cancer. 5. The toxicity of abdominopelvic radiotherapy. 6. The criteria by which patients are selected for abdominopelvic radiotherapy. 7. Radiotherapy versus chemotherapy in early disease. 8. Consolidation radiotherapy after chemotherapy in advanced disease.

Cell kinetic perturbations after irradiation and caffeine in the BG-1 ovarian carcinoma cell line

The treatment of ovarian carcinoma includes maximum surgical removal of the tumor tissue followed by irradiation or chemotherapy. In this study, the effects of caffeine on cell cycle traverse have been studied over a 168-hr period after X irradiation in BG-1 cells, an ovarian carcinoma cell line. The results were obtained with dual-parameter flow cytometric measurements of DNA and nuclear protein, using propidium iodide and fluorescein isothiocyanate. After radiation alone, a dose-related arrest of cells in G2 phase and cell kill were observed. Irradiating BG-1 cells with 5 Gy produced an accumulation of the cells in G2 at 24-72 hr postirradiation. When G2 was divided into low nuclear protein (G2A) and high nuclear protein (G2B) compartments, there was a G2A peak accumulation at 24 hr and a G2B peak accumulation at 48-72 hr. The addition of 1 mM caffeine to the culture media, starting immediately postirradiation, prevented G2 arrest, promoting a rapid traverse of cells through G2A to G2B to G1, which was associated with diminished survival.

Whole abdomen radiation therapy after a short chemotherapy course and second-look laparotomy in advanced ovarian cancer

From April 1983 through December 1989, 42 consecutive patients with diagnosis of epithelial ovarian carcinoma were initially managed by aggressive surgery and three courses of endoperitoneal cis-platinum-based chemotherapy followed by an alternating combination chemotherapy and second-look laparotomy. Patients with residual tumor less than or equal to 2 cm subsequently received whole abdominal radiation therapy (WAR). Twenty-eight patients (42% with no residual disease, 21% with microscopic disease, and 36% with residual disease less than 2 cm) were eligible for WAR. WAR was delivered using an open-field technique up to 22 Gy in 20 fractions followed by a pelvic boost of 18 Gy in 10 fractions. The kidneys were shielded posteriorly at 1100 cGy; hepatic shields were not added. One patient did not complete WAR for lung metastases after 5 radiotherapy fractions. The complete treatment program lasted 8 months (range, 6.8-11). The median follow-up of the 28 patients entered into the study was 50 months. Eight patients are alive and disease-free at 5 years. The overall and disease-free survival rates at 5 years are 45 and 30%, respectively. All but 2 patients relapsed within the abdominopelvic cavity and 3 developed brain metastases. Toxic effects, during WAR, required treatment interruption in all but 4 patients: 3 developed a small bowel obstruction requiring surgery and 1 died of surgical complications in complete remission. The poor disease-free survival and the severe toxicity encountered have been valid indications that WAR should be discontinued as a treatment modality in advanced ovarian cancer at our department.

Delayed split whole abdominal irradiation in the combined modality treatment of ovarian cancer

Fifty-eight patients with ovarian malignancies have been treated using a delayed split whole abdominal irradiation technique (DSA) allowing the entire tumor volume to be irradiated with tumoricidal fractional doses without undue toxicity. The lower hemiabdomen was irradiated with 2 Gy per fraction to a total dose of 40 Gy. A 2-6 hour delay was used between the irradiation of each half of the abdomen to avoid excessive acute gastrointestinal toxicity. The upper hemiabdomen was irradiated with 1.5 Gy per fraction to a total dose of 30 Gy. The acute toxicity was acceptable, with 53 of 58 patients able to complete the prescribed course of treatment. Three patients (5%) experienced grade 3 or greater acute gastrointestinal toxicity. Fourteen of 60 patients (24%) required treatment breaks because of thrombocytopenia. Nadir platelet counts were lower in patients who had received previous chemotherapy than in previously untreated patients (80,000 vs 118,000; p = .02). However, only 4 out of 60 patients were unable to complete DSA because of prolonged thrombocytopenia. In addition to DSA, patients were also treated with intraperitoneal 32P (52 patients), intraperitoneal human ovarian antitumor serum (14 patients), and prior (14 patients) or subsequent (32 patients) chemotherapy. Granulocytopenia was more severe among patients who had received prior chemotherapy (mean nadir 900 vs 2200). Seven patients (11.5%) developed delayed bowel obstruction in the absence of recurrence. There was one death caused by hepatitis, presumably related to colloidal 32P and DSA. Twenty-five percent of Stage III optimally cytoreduced patients were disease-free at 5 years; these patients had a median survival of 45 months. DSA irradiation is an acceptable technique for delivering a high fractional dose of radiation to the entire peritoneal cavity. Shielding of the iliac crests spares bone marrow allowing DSA irradiation to be integrated into an aggressive combined modality treatment plan.

Radiation therapy in stage III ovarian cancer following surgery and chemotherapy: prognostic factors, patterns of relapse, and toxicity: a preliminary report

Twenty patients with FIGO stage III epithelial ovarian cancer who had undergone maximum cytoreductive surgery (including pelvic and paraaortic lymph node dissection) and combination chemotherapy (4-10 cycles, median 6) were treated with irradiation to the abdomen and pelvis with 30 Gy followed by diaphragmatic/paraaortic and pelvis boost fields to 42 and 51.6 Gy, respectively. Second-look laparotomy was not performed. Seventeen of 20 patients completed the planned course of radiation. In 2 cases, failure to complete treatment was related to acute hematologic toxicity, and 1 patient refused further treatment. Five patients (29%) required treatment breaks ranging from 8 to 16 days (median, 12 days) due to pancytopenia. Actuarial overall survival and relapse-free survival at 3 years for the 17 patients who completed radiation was 69 and 47%, respectively, with follow-up ranging from 19 to 53 months (median: 24, mean: 27.6 months). Seven patients (41%) relapsed within the abdomen alone and 2 patients developed extraabdominal lymph node metastasis as their sole site of failure. The prognostic factors evaluated for correlation with relapse-free survival included histologic subtype, grade, amount of residual disease at the time of surgery, and nodal involvement; only residual tumor at surgery (none vs less than or equal to 2 cm or greater than 2 cm) was found to be statistically significant (P less than 0.01). Three-year overall survival correlated with amount of residual disease following the initial cytoreductive surgery. It was 100% for patients with no residual disease, 66.7% for less than or equal to 2 cm, and 26.7% for those with greater than 2 cm residual disease, respectively. Radiation treatment was well tolerated, with only one patient developing treatment-related bowel obstruction 7 months after radiation therapy. The results of this planned trimodality treatment approach compare favorably with those reported following surgery and chemotherapy, particularly in patients who have been maximally cytoreduced.

Chylous ascites after whole-abdomen irradiation for gynecologic malignancy

From November 1981 through December 1987, 207 patients received whole-abdomen irradiation (WAI) for gynecologic malignancies at the Mayo Clinic. In seven (3%) of these patients, chylous ascites subsequently developed; one additional patient with chylous ascites after WAI for a gynecologic malignancy was referred to us from another institution. In these eight patients, irradiation was done either adjuvantly (five patients) or as salvage therapy after chemotherapy failure (three patients). Chylous ascites was confirmed by laboratory analysis in six cases and was presumed based on the clinical course in two cases. Mean cumulative radiation doses were 2,925 and 5,122 cGy to the abdomen and pelvis, respectively, with para-aortic boosts administered in six cases to a mean cumulative dose of approximately 4,200 cGy. The mean time from completion of WAI to development of ascites was 12 months (range, 6 to 18 months). In six patients, therapy was conservative-observation and diuretics. Two other patients required multiple paracenteses for relief of abdominal distention. Parenteral nutrition was given to two patients who had associated radiation enteritis. The ascites resolved in all eight cases at a mean of 18 months (range, 8 to 30 months) after development. At a mean follow-up of 57 months after initial diagnosis and 16 months after resolution of the ascites, seven patients are without evidence of disease and one patient died of recurrent carcinoma. Distinguishing this clinical entity from recurrent carcinoma is important because of its benign course and its resolution with conservative management.

A pilot study investigating intraoperative electron beam irradiation in the treatment of ovarian malignancies

Intraoperative electron beam radiation therapy (IOEBRT) in the treatment of ovarian malignancies was investigated at the Clement O. Miniger Radiation Oncology Center (COMROC). Nine patients were operated in the COMROC IOEBRT operating amphitheater and five were found to have disease sufficiently limited to allow for IOEBRT. The patients' ages ranged from 13 to 80 (median 53) years. Five patients had serous cystadenocarcinoma, one papillary adenocarcinoma, one mixed germ cell tumor, one squamous cell carcinoma, and one granular cell tumor of the ovary. The median survival of the non-IOEBRT group was 13 (range 12-29) months, while the IOEBRT group's median survival was 14 (range 18-46) months. All of the patients tolerated IOEBRT well without addition to the surgical morbidity.

Randomized study of whole-abdomen irradiation versus pelvic irradiation plus cyclophosphamide in treatment of early ovarian cancer

From 1 September 1981 to 1 January 1987, 118 patients with FIGO Stage IB, IC, IIA, IIB, and IIC epithelial ovarian cancer were randomized to abdominal irradiation or pelvic irradiation + cyclophosphamide. There was no difference between the regimens with respect to recurrence-free survival (55%) and 4-year overall survival (63%). At routine second-look laparotomy, 16% of patients without clinical detectable tumor showed recurrence. Twenty-five percent of the patients treated with pelvic irradiation + cyclophosphamide had hemorrhagic cystitis, probably caused by radiation damage and cyclophosphamide cystitis. Eight percent had late gastrointestinal symptoms requiring surgery.

Whole-abdomen radiation therapy in ovarian carcinoma: its role as a salvage therapeutic modality

A significant proportion of patients with epithelial ovarian carcinoma eventually fail after initial responses to chemotherapy. Further treatment with chemotherapy consisting of either the same combination or second-line regimens has been ineffective in producing durable responses. Thus, between June 1983 and June 1987, thirty patients with epithelial ovarian carcinoma who failed one or more chemotherapeutic regimens were treated with whole-abdominopelvic-cavity radiation therapy. Prior to the radiation the amount of residual disease after debulking was noted to be microscopic in 16 patients and macroscopic in 14 patients. Radiation was delivered with an open-field technique that extended from the domes of the diaphragm to the obturator foramina. Doses of 2500 cGy were planned to the whole abdomen, with a boost of another 2500 cGy to the pelvic and or paraaortic nodes when indicated. Higher doses were delivered to the areas of gross disease in the pelvis. Only 2 patients were unable to complete the planned therapy. Another 26% of the patients required interruption of the therapy secondary to hematologic toxicity but eventually completed the treatment. With an overall median follow-up of 14 months, 56% of the patients remain alive. Two-year actuarial survival and recurrence-free survival rates are 47 and 32%, respectively. The survival and recurrence-free survival rates for the group with microscopic residual disease--61 and 33%, respectively--are better than those for the patients with macroscopic residual disease--36 and 18%. The abdominopelvic cavity was the first site of failure in all but one of the 17 patients who have failed. In spite of the higher doses, pelvic failure alone or as a component occurred in 54% of the patients. Small bowel obstruction necessitating surgical intervention as a complication of therapy was seen in 13% of the patients.

Whole abdominal irradiation following chemotherapy in patients with minimal residual disease after second look surgery in ovarian carcinoma

From January 1981 through December 1985, 65 patients with epithelial carcinoma of the ovary were treated with the following protocol: surgery, combination chemotherapy, second-look surgery documenting tumor less than or equal to 2 cm, and whole abdominal irradiation. Chemotherapy consisted of a combination of cyclophosphamide, adriamycin, and cisplatinum in 89% of the patients. The median number of cycles was eleven. Second-look surgery documented no residual tumor in 23 patients, microscopic disease in three patients, and macroscopic disease less than or equal to 2 cm in 39 patients. Whole abdominal irradiation was given with an open field technique up to 20 Gy without renal or hepatic shield. A pelvic boost of 15-30 Gy was subsequently added in 17 patients with macroscopic disease in the pelvis at the time of second-look surgery. Fifteen patients received complementary chemotherapy mostly hexamethylmelamine. All but two patients completed whole abdominal irradiation: one refused further radiotherapy after 3 Gy and one developed disease progression with bowel obstruction after 1 Gy. The median follow-up was 69 months. The 3-year and 6-year no evidence of disease survival rates were 60% (95% CI: 48-71) and 33% (95% CI: 21-46), respectively. The 3-year and 6-year recurrence rates were 33% (95% CI: 22-45) and 54% (95% CI: 40-67), respectively. The 3-year and 6-year metastasis rates were 22% (95% CI: 13-34) and 43% (95% CI: 30-58), respectively. A multivariate analysis showed that residual disease after second-look surgery was the only significant prognostic factor with a relative risk of death or local or distant failure of 4.2 (95% CI: 1.9-9.5, p less than 10(-4)). Two patients developed mean-term gastrointestinal complications (small bowel obstructions requiring surgery). Survival remains poor with high level of failure even with aggressive multimodal treatment.

Intraperitoneal radioimmunotherapy for ovarian cancer

Twenty-eight patients with assessable residual ovarian cancer after cytoreductive surgery and chemotherapy received intraperitoneal I-131 labelled monoclonal antibodies. There was no response in eight patients with tumour nodules greater than 2 cm, a partial response in two of the 15 patients with tumour nodules less than 2 cm, and a complete response in three of the other five patients with positive peritoneal washings. A further six patients received Y-90 labelled monoclonal antibodies for residual ovarian cancer. There was no response in one patient with nodules greater than 2 cm, and a partial response in one of the other five patients with tumour nodules less than 2 cm. The non-specific radiation dose in the peritoneal cavity from the infused isotope was measured by lithium fluoride thermoluminescent dosimetry (TLD). The radiation dose received by the peritoneal serosa was less than 500 cGy and was not sufficient to account for the observed tumour response. Significant bone marrow suppression was observed with I-131 activities greater than 120 mCi and with Y-90 activities greater than 13 mCi. The haemopoietic bone marrow is the dose-limiting organ in patients receiving radioimmunotherapy.

The role of postoperative alkylating agent therapy in early-stage epithelial ovarian cancer

Forty-six patients with early (Stage I and II) ovarian cancer referred as free of residual disease after primary surgery, selected for high-risk features, were treated with adjuvant single-agent alkylating therapy comprising either intravenous cyclophosphamide (1 g/m2) in 36 patients, or oral melphalan (0.2 mg/kg daily for 5 days) in eight. Cyclophosphamide was repeated every 3 weeks for 10 cycles and melphalan every 6 weeks for 12 cycles. With a median follow-up of 36+ months, 18 patients have relapsed. The actuarial 5-year relapse-free survival was 48% and the overall 5-year survival was 54%; median survival was 84 months. Pretreatment FIGO stage was the single most important predictor of relapse-free and overall survival duration. For patients with Stage IA and IB tumours the 5-year actuarial relapse-free survival was 89%; for patients with stage IC and II (all substages), the 5-year relapse-free survival was 24% (P = 0.001). For this latter group adjuvant single alkylating agent therapy was not adequate and alternative therapeutic regimens are required. The problem of suboptimal primary surgical staging is also addressed.

Toxicity of open-field whole abdominal irradiation as primary postoperative treatment in gynecologic malignancy

Between June 1979 and March 1985, 77 patients received whole abdominal radiation as the sole postoperative treatment for gynecologic malignancy. With an open-field technique of irradiation, a median of 3,000 cGy was delivered to the entire abdominal contents with partial liver and kidney shielding; the total dose to the pelvis after boosts was 5,100 cGy, and that to the sub-diaphragmatic and para-aortic nodal regions was 4,200 cGy. The primary sites of malignancy were the endometrium in 41 patients, ovary in 25, uterus in 5, fallopian tube in 4, and cervix in 2. Seven patients (9%), all older than 60 years, experienced acute gastrointestinal toxicity that interrupted treatment, only one of whom failed to complete the prescribed course as a result. Hematologic toxicity was sufficient to interrupt therapy in 21 patients (27%), 1 of whom failed to complete therapy as a result. Hematologic toxicity was not increased in elderly patients. All patients were followed up for a minimum of 30 months (median, 43 months) or until death. Six patients experienced a treatment-related bowel obstruction (two of whom had concomitant progressive intra-abdominal disease); the 3-year actuarial risk for a treatment-related bowel obstruction was 9%. This risk was significantly increased by high-dose boosting for residual disease. Only one instance of clinical radiation pneumonitis occurred, and no cases of clinical hepatitis were noted; however, subclinical evidence of pulmonary and hepatic radiation effect was frequent. Whole abdominal irradiation as described has modest toxicity for patients with gynecologic cancer who are at high risk for intra-abdominal failure.

Sequential cisplatin/cyclophosphamide chemotherapy and abdominopelvic radiotherapy in the management of advanced ovarian cancer

Forty-six previously untreated patients with advanced ovarian cancer were treated with combination chemotherapy comprising cisplatin 80 mg m-2 i.v. and cyclophosphamide 1 gm-2 i.v. every 28 days for 5 cycles. Eighty-five percent of patients received more than 75% of the calculated doses, and of 43 evaluable patients, a complete response was achieved in 31 (72%), a partial response in 4 (9.3%) and 8 patients had static or progressive disease. The actuarial survival of the whole group is 60% at a median follow-up of 2 years. Twenty-four patients in complete clinical or pathological remission were then treated with whole abdominal radiotherapy 2,500 cGy followed by a pelvic boost of 2,000 cGy. The pelvic boost was omitted in 3 patients, and the overall radiotherapy treatment time extended in a further 4 patients on account of myelosuppression. The actuarial survival of the 24 patients receiving both treatments at a median of 30 months follow-up is 75%. In the 10 patients with negative second-look procedures completing both treatments there have been no tumour related deaths at a median follow-up of 33 months.

Total abdominal and pelvic radiotherapy in the management of early stage ovarian carcinoma

In a prospective study, 57 women with early stage ovarian carcinoma received total abdominal and pelvic radiotherapy (TAPR) following radical surgery. The whole abdomen received 22.5 Gy m.p.d. by large opposed fields in 18 fractions over 4 1/2 weeks, with 8 MeV X rays, followed by a further 22.5 Gy in 10 fractions over 2 weeks to the pelvis alone, using a dosage and technique similar to that described from the Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto. The actuarial 5-year relapse-free and overall survival figures were 49 and 57% respectively, which appear to be significantly worse than those reported from Toronto (73% and 75%). The incidence of severe bowel toxicity (7%) was higher. There was no correlation between survival and FIGO stage at laparotomy, but a significant correlation with histological grade. These data do not seem to support the idea of a "curative" role for post-operative irradiation at this dosage in these patients.

Hyperfractionated split-course whole abdominal radiotherapy for ovarian carcinoma: tolerance and toxicity

Whole abdominal irradiation after chemotherapy and second look laparotomy for advanced ovarian carcinoma is poorly tolerated because of hematologic toxicity that frequently necessitates interruption or abandonment of treatment. A new treatment strategy using a hyperfractionated split course schedule to deliver a total of 30 Gy in 30 fractions over 6 weeks was designed in an attempt to overcome this problem, while not compromising the tolerance of late reacting normal tissues. Of 23 patients treated between August 1984 and June 1986, only one failed to complete therapy as scheduled. Six patients with gross residual disease also received a limited field boost of 15 Gy in 15 fractions after completion of treatment to the whole abdomen. None of these six patients achieved disease control, and five required surgery for intestinal obstruction with pathologic evidence of radiation bowel injury. Of the 17 patients who received no boost, five developed gut obstructions associated with tumor recurrence and not attributable to irradiation. We conclude that whole abdominal irradiation using the hyperfractionated split course schedule without a boost is safe and feasible but its therapeutic efficacy appears confined to subsets of patients with no visible residual disease at the time of second look laparotomy, or in whom all visible residual tumor can be resected.

Whole abdominal irradiation following chemotherapy in advanced ovarian carcinoma

One hundred and sixteen patients with advanced ovarian carcinoma, who underwent primary cytoreductive surgery, received 6-11 courses of chemotherapy by cis-platin (50 mg/m2) and adriamycin (50 mg/m2) every 21 days. This was followed by second look laparotomy in 66 patients with no clinical evidence of disease. Consolidation abdominal irradiation was administered to 43 patients. Two techniques of irradiation were employed: between 1980-1983 whole abdominal irradiation was used and patients were to receive 3000 cGy in 4 weeks (Schedule I). Due to myelosuppression only 13 of 26 patients (50%) completed the planned dose of radiation. Between 1983-1985 the target volume was divided into upper and lower parts. First, the lower abdomen received 3000 cGy in 3 weeks, and then the upper abdomen received the same dose (Schedule II). Sixteen of seventeen patients (94%) thus treated, completed the planned dose of radiation. The actuarial survival for all 116 patients was 28% of 5 years. Irradiated patients with negative second look laparotomy had a survival probability of 100% at 24 months. Irradiated patients with microscopic disease at second look operation had an actuarial 5-year survival of 66%. Patients with minimal residual disease at second look laparotomy, receiving consolidation abdominal irradiation, had an actuarial survival of 5% only at 36 months. It is concluded that consolidation radiotherapy is effective in patients with negative or microscopic residual disease at second-look laparotomy. In regard to bone marrow tolerance, split field technique of irradiation is preferred.

The treatment of advanced stage ovarian carcinoma with a combination of chemotherapy, radiotherapy, and radiosensitizer: report of a pilot study from the National Cancer Institute

Twenty-eight patients with Stage III or IV ovarian carcinoma were treated with combined chemotherapy-radiotherapy employing a unique protocol. Four cycles of cyclophosphamide and hexamethylmelamine alternated with four cycles of concurrent cisplatin, whole abdominal radiotherapy, and intraperitoneal misonidazole. The entire treatment program lasted six months. Clinical complete responses were seen in 50% of the patients with an overall response rate of 61%. Pathologic complete response (PCR) confirmed at second look surgery occurred in 18% of the group (5 patients). Median survival of the entire group was 15.2 months with all PCR's alive NED. This outcome was no different than our previous experience with combination chemotherapy alone. Toxicities seen included leukopenia, thrombocytopenia, nausea, vomiting, and weight loss. However, these side effects were manageable. Two non-tumor deaths occurred. This study demonstrates the feasibility of combining drug and radiation therapy concurrently in the treatment of ovarian cancer; further research is needed to explore different sequencing and dose levels that could improve the outcome.

Advanced epithelial ovarian cancer: toxicity of whole abdominal irradiation after operation, combination chemotherapy, and reoperation

Thirty-five patients with advanced ovarian cancer have received, as salvage therapy, irradiation consisting of 30 Gy to the entire abdominal contents with partial liver/kidney shielding and boosts to 42 and 51 Gy for the paraaortic/diaphragmatic and pelvic regions, respectively. These patients had received 6 to 25 cycles (median, 11 cycles) of prior combination chemotherapy (included cisplatin in 30), with "second-look" laparotomy performed in 33; 24 (68%) had three or more laparotomies. Acute gastrointestinal toxicity was generally mild. Significant hematologic toxicity (leukocytes less than 2000/mm3; or platelets less than 100,000/mm3) was seen in 19 (54%); platelet suppression occurred in 18 of these 19. Nine patients failed to complete the prescribed course of therapy; in seven, this was secondary to hematologic toxicity. Amount of prior chemotherapy and advanced age correlated with degree of hematologic toxicity. Five patients without evidence of disease (laparotomy confirmed) have developed treatment-related bowel obstruction. No other chronic toxicity of clinical significance has been observed. Seven patients have developed bowel obstruction associated with progressive neoplasm. Irradiation was well tolerated symptomatically, but hematologic toxicity associated with prior chemotherapy prevented its completion in 20% of patients. Clinical manifestations of radiation bowel toxicity have been moderate to date and should be interpreted in the context of the aggressive combined modality program.