Considerations for the Use of Scalp Cooling Devices in Black Patients

Availability of Cranial Prostheses for Black Patients at Comprehensive Cancer Centers

PURPOSE

For patients who seek to camouflage cancer-related hair loss, cranial prostheses such as wigs and hair pieces exist. We sought to determine the availability of yaki-textured, type IV curls, and afro wigs at boutiques in Comprehensive Cancer Centers (CCCs).

METHODS

The 56 CCCs in the United States were surveyed to see whether they had an affiliated wig boutique for patients experiencing hair loss. Boutique workers were then asked a series of seven questions regarding cranial prostheses options for patients seeking yaki-textured, type IV curls, and afro wigs. The availability of wigs was compared with US Census data on population size and density of Black residents.

RESULTS

Of the 56 CCCs, 27 (46%) institutions had active affiliated hair boutiques. We were able to reach 19 (70%) of the 27 boutiques, of which 53% (n = 10) offered yaki-textured wigs, 37% (n = 7) offered type IV curls or afro wigs, and 47% (n = 9) offered neither. Two additional boutiques offered in-store catalogs for Black patients who were interested in naturally appearing wigs. Although two institutions offered a wig bank that was free to all patients, neither had yaki-textured or afro wigs in stock. There was no significant relationship between population size or density of Black residents and availability of these wigs.

CONCLUSION

Many Black patients undergoing cancer treatment interested in cranial prosthesis do not have consistent access to wigs with textures comparable with type IV hair at CCCs. With increased inventory of racially inclusive wigs, partnerships with third-party vendors, and support for the previous authorization process, we can better support Black patients experiencing cancer-related hair loss.

Electric hand warmer versus observation to avoid discomfort during scalp cooling for chemotherapy-induced alopecia prevention: a randomized study

Chemotherapy-induced alopecia (CIA) is a challenge in the management of cancer patients. Scalp cooling (SC) leads to reduction in CIA, however it is associated with significant adverse events, leading to 3-13% discontinuation rates. This pilot study evaluated the role of Electric Hand Warmers (EHW) on thermal (TC), sensorial (SCo) and general comfort (GC) in patients with breast cancer (BC) undergoing chemotherapy and SC to reduce CIA. Patients were randomly assigned to EHW use or observation. TC, SCo and GC were evaluated after each chemotherapy infusion. Favorable outcomes in both TC and SCo defined a positive result on GC. We analysed the impact of age, alopecia, chemotherapy regimen and EHW use in the different comfort scales using a Logistic Regression (LR) model. Forty women with early breast cancer were randomly assigned to EHW (n = 20) or observation (n = 20) during neo(adjuvant) chemotherapy. Median age was 53 years. In the EHW arm, favorable thermal response was reported by 79% versus 50% in the control arm (odds ratio [OR] 3.79, p < 0.001). SCo was satisfactory in 82% in the EHW arm versus 74% in the control arm (OR 1.62, p = 0.1). Overall, 73% in the EHW arm had favorable GC versus 44% in the control arm (OR 3.4, p < 0.001). Age, alopecia, and chemotherapy regimen did not impact on comfort measures. Conclusion: Our study suggests that the use of an EHW has a consistent favorable impact on TC and GC of BC patients under SC technology to prevent CIA.

Addressing the Need for Diversity in Scalp Cooling Trials

This Viewpoint emphasizes the importance of diverse representation in research on scalp cooling to avoid hair loss during chemotherapy.

Minimal added value of wetting hair before scalp cooling to prevent chemotherapy-induced alopecia in cancer patients - results from the Dutch Scalp Cooling Registry

PURPOSE

Preventing chemotherapy-induced alopecia (CIA) is related to the degree of temperature reduction during scalp cooling. Wetting hair before scalp cooling reduces the scalp skin temperature. This observational study investigated the effects of wetting hair before scalp cooling on preventing CIA and on tolerance in cancer patients.

METHODS

This Dutch multi-center cohort study comprised 1825 patients receiving ≥1 cycle of docetaxel (D), 5-fluorouracil-epirubicin-cyclophosphamide (FEC), 5-fluorouracil-epirubicin-cyclophosphamide-docetaxel (FECD), paclitaxel (P), or paclitaxel-carboplatin (PC). Patients underwent scalp cooling with wet or dry hair. Primary and secondary outcomes were the effects of wetting hair on head cover use and tolerance, respectively.

RESULTS

None of the associations between wetting hair and head cover use in patients on D, FEC, P, or PC was significant; however, results all tended to be in favor of wetting hair. For FECD, univariate (p=0.005; OR=1.6; CI=1.1-2.1) and multivariable associations (p=0.007; OR=1.8; CI=1.2-2.6) were significant. Scalp cooling discontinuation due to intolerance differed significantly between groups that wetted hair or not (3% and 1% respectively; p=0.034).

CONCLUSION

In a large patient group with mainly a European hair type and a high hair mass, no convincing evidence was found whether wetting hair prior to scalp cooling contributes to better prevention of CIA. Since it is argued that a higher reduction in scalp skin temperature by wetting hair contributes positively to scalp cooling efficacy, only a randomized controlled trial can provide an ultimate conclusion at the highest level of evidence. Until that time, healthcare professionals have to take into account that wetting hair may introduce lower compliance to the scalp cooling procedure.

Dermatologic toxicities of chemotherapy: an educational intervention for skin of color women with breast cancer

Minority patients are more likely to require dose adjustments for chemotherapy, with cultural barriers and access to medical care cited as contributory factors.

Objective

We sought to pilot an educational intervention, in the form of a pamphlet, to evaluate the effectiveness of this tool in teaching skin of color (SoC) patients about potential dermatologic toxicities of chemotherapy that are relevant to their skin type.

Methods

At a chemotherapy infusion center, SoC patients (n = 26) who were receiving chemotherapy for breast cancer voluntarily consented to read an educational pamphlet and complete a series of survey questions before and after this educational intervention.

Results

Most participants identified as female (96%), African American/Black (81%), and non-Hispanic (85%); all respondents had obtained at least a high school degree. Survey responses revealed a significant increase in knowledge about the potential dermatologic effects of cancer treatment after this intervention. Notably, 100% of participants either agreed or strongly agreed that they would like to see other doctors use this educational tool as a form of patient education, that they would recommend this pamphlet to other patients who are starting cancer treatment, and that the pamphlet was easy to understand.

Limitations

Limitations of this study include small sample size and single-institution recruitment, which may limit generalizability. Furthermore, this study only included patients who are proficient in English.

Conclusion

This study pilots an effective educational tool that addresses dermatologic toxicities of chemotherapy that are relevant to SoC patients. Further multi-institutional studies with larger sample sizes and translation to other languages can overcome the limitations of this pilot study.

Hair loss during and after breast cancer therapy

For patients diagnosed with breast cancer, alopecia can be a distressing side effect of treatment. Major surgeries, cytotoxic chemotherapy, and endocrine therapy may result in several different types of alopecia. This article reviews the underlying mechanisms, etiology, prevention strategies, and treatment options for chemotherapy-induced alopecia, telogen effluvium, and endocrine-induced alopecia. Here, we aim to provide breast oncologists with a review of the types of hair loss related to cancer therapy and current preventative and treatment options to facilitate informative patient counseling.

Retrospective cohort study of scalp cooling in breast cancer patients

For patients with cancer, alopecia is a common side effect that negatively impacts personal identity, body image, self-esteem, quality of life, and medical decision-making. Scalp cooling is a technique used to prevent alopecia in patients undergoing chemotherapy in which patients wear a cooled cap during chemotherapy infusions, causing localized vasoconstriction of blood vessels on the scalp. Because of the recent emergence of scalp cooling, there is a need to explore further the reasons why patients pursue this treatment. A retrospective chart review of women with breast cancer treated at The Ohio State University was conducted to investigate how factors such as patient age, race, ethnicity, insurance status, stage of cancer, and chemotherapy regimen influenced patients' decisions to incorporate scalp cooling into their treatment plan as compared to those who did not. Findings revealed that patient age, race, insurance status, and chemotherapy regimen were predictors of a patient's likelihood to undergo scalp cooling. Patients diagnosed at younger age and those with private insurance were more likely to utilize scalp cooling. In comparison to White patients, non-White patients were less likely to choose scalp cooling. Furthermore, patients placed on the chemotherapy regimen of AC or AC-T were less likely to pursue scalp cooling than patients on PTCH or TC regimens. These findings provide background for the development of educational resources for both patients interested in this therapy and healthcare providers discussing this treatment option in dermatology and oncology settings.