Pilot studies of the effect of zoledronic acid (Zometa) on tumor-derived cells ex vivo in the ATP-based tumor chemosensitivity assay

There is debate regarding the direct effect of bisphosphonates against visceral metastases from solid tumors, despite their proven efficacy against the skeletal complications of metastasis. The aim of this study was to determine whether zoledronic acid showed direct activity against five ovarian cell lines and tumor-derived cells, and whether addition of zoledronic acid to cytotoxic agents increased their cytotoxicity. In this study we used a standardized ATP-based tumor chemosensitivity assay (ATP-TCA) to measure the activity of alendronate, clodronate and zoledronic acid in five ovarian carcinoma cell lines and human solid tumors (breast, lung, ovarian, unknown primary carcinoma, and cutaneous and uveal melanoma) (n=34). We also tested the combination of zoledronic acid with paclitaxel and cisplatin in tumor-derived cells. All five cell lines exhibited greater sensitivity to bisphosphonates than the tumor-derived cells and in all five the IC50 for zoledronic acid was less than 4 muM. In the tumor-derived cells, zoledronic acid showed concentration-dependent inhibition with a median IC50 for all tumors tested of 17 muM and evidence of apoptosis (caspase activation). Simultaneous addition of zoledronic acid to cisplatin or paclitaxel showed no major increase in cytotoxicity. We conclude that the activity of bisphosphonates was greater in cell lines than in tumor-derived cells. However, the pattern of activity of bisphosphonates was the same in cell lines and tumor derived cells. This study suggests a direct, or possibly an indirect, effect of zoledronic acid and other nitrogen-containing bisphosphonates against neoplastic cells, but simultaneous addition with cisplatin or paclitaxel does not substantially increase the activity of the cytotoxic agent.

Should oral bisphosphonates be standard of care in women with early breast cancer?

There is increasing evidence that oral clodronate has important clinical benefits in early breast cancer. Longer-term follow-up data from two out of three randomized studies have shown that adjuvant clodronate improves survival. This article outlines the results of these studies and discusses the potential role for other bisphosphonates, such as ibandronate and zoledronic acid, in the adjuvant treatment of breast cancer.