Utility of Homologous Recombination Deficiency Biomarkers Across Cancer Types

DNA damage response in brain tumors: A Society for Neuro-Oncology consensus review on mechanisms and translational efforts in neuro-oncology

DNA damage response (DDR) mechanisms are critical to maintenance of overall genomic stability, and their dysfunction can contribute to oncogenesis. Significant advances in our understanding of DDR pathways have raised the possibility of developing therapies that exploit these processes. In this expert-driven consensus review, we examine mechanisms of response to DNA damage, progress in development of DDR inhibitors in IDH-wild-type glioblastoma and IDH-mutant gliomas, and other important considerations such as biomarker development, preclinical models, combination therapies, mechanisms of resistance and clinical trial design considerations.

Homologous Recombination Deficiency Unrelated to Platinum and PARP Inhibitor Response in Cell Line Libraries

While large publicly available cancer cell line databases are invaluable for preclinical drug discovery and biomarker development, the association between homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) and drug sensitivity in these resources remains unclear. In this study, we comprehensively analyzed molecular profiles and drug screening data from the Cancer Cell Line Encyclopedia. Unexpectedly, gene alterations in BRCA1/2 or homologous recombination-related genes, HRD scores, or mutational signature 3 were not positively correlated with sensitivity to platinum agents or PARP inhibitors. Rather, higher HRD scores and mutational signature 3 were significantly associated with resistance to these agents in multiple assays. These findings were consistent when analyzing exclusively breast and ovarian cancer cell lines and when using data from the COSMIC Cell Line Project. Collectively, the existing data from established cancer cell lines do not reflect the expected association between HRD status and drug response to platinum agents and PARP inhibitors in clinical tumors. This discrepancy may extend to other tumor characteristics, highlighting the importance of recognizing potential limitations in cell line data for researchers.

Liquid biopsy in ovarian cancer in China and the world: current status and future perspectives

Ovarian cancer (OC) is the eighth most common cancer in women, but the mild, non-specific clinical presentation in early stages often prevents diagnosis until progression to advanced-stage disease, contributing to the high mortality associated with OC. While serum cancer antigen 125 (CA-125) has been successfully used as a blood-borne marker and is routinely monitored in patients with OC, CA-125 testing has limitations in sensitivity and specificity and does not provide direct information on important molecular characteristics that can guide treatment decisions, such as homologous recombination repair deficiency. We comprehensively review the literature surrounding methods based on liquid biopsies, which may provide improvements in sensitivity, specificity, and provide valuable additional information to enable early diagnosis, monitoring of recurrence/progression/therapeutic response, and accurate prognostication for patients with OC, highlighting applications of this research in China.

Combination of genomic instability score and TP53 status for prognosis prediction in lung adenocarcinoma

The genomic instability (GI) /homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) score, calculated as the sum of the events of loss of heterozygosity (LOH), large-scale state transition (LST) and telomere allele imbalance (TAI), is used to guide the choice of treatment in several cancers, but its relationship with genomic features, clinicopathological characteristics and prognosis in lung cancer is poorly understood, which could lead to population bias in prospective studies. We retrospectively analyzed 1011 lung cancer patients whose tumor samples were successfully profiled by high-throughput sequencing panel including GI/HRD score. Alterations of many cancer suppressor genes were associated with higher GI/HRD scores, biallelic inactivation of TP53 was correlated with a high GI/HRD score. A combination of two gene alterations exhibited a higher GI/HRD scores than single gene alterations. The GI/HRD score was associated with advanced stages in lung adenocarcinoma but not in lung squamous cell carcinoma. Furthermore, patients with higher GI/HRD scores had significantly shorter overall survival and progression-free survival than patients with lower GI/HRD scores. Finally, patients with a combination of a higher GI/HRD scores and TP53 alteration exhibited an extremely poor prognosis compared with patients with a lower GI/HRD scores and wild-type TP53 (overall survival, training cohort, hazard ratio (HR) = 8.56, P < 0.001; validation cohort, HR = 6.47, P < 0.001; progression-free survival, HR = 4.76, P < 0.001). Our study revealed the prognostic value of the GI/HRD score in lung adenocarcinoma, but not for all lung cancer. Moreover, the combination of the GI/HRD score and TP53 status could be a promising strategy to predict the prognosis of patients with lung adenocarcinoma.

Relationship among DDR gene mutations, TMB and PD-L1 in solid tumour genomes identified using clinically actionable biomarker assays

The DNA damage response (DDR) pathway regulates DNA repair and cell survival, and inactivating mutations in DDR genes can increase tumour mutational burden (TMB), a predictive biomarker of treatment benefit from anti-PD-1/PD-L1 immunotherapies. However, a better understanding of the relationship among specific DDR mutations, TMB and PD-L1 expression is needed to improve translational strategies. Here, we determined genomic alteration frequencies in selected DDR genes that are clinically actionable biomarkers and investigated their association with TMB and PD-L1 in bladder, colorectal, non-small cell lung, ovarian and prostate cancers using the FoundationInsights® web portal. Our results not only confirm known associations, such as mismatch repair and POLE gene mutations with high TMB, but also identify significant associations between mutations in the SWI/SNF chromatin remodelling genes ARID1A and SMARCA4 and high TMB in multiple tumour types. Mutations in the ATR gene were associated with high TMB in colorectal and prostate cancers; however, associations between individual DDR mutations and high PD-L1 expression were uncommon and tumour-type specific. Finally, we found that high TMB and high PD-L1 expression were poorly associated, emphasising their independence as predictive biomarkers for immune checkpoint inhibitor use.

Selection of maintenance therapy during first-line treatment of advanced ovarian cancer based on pharmacologic characteristics

INTRODUCTION

Maintenance therapy with bevacizumab and the poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) inhibitors olaparib and niraparib after first-line treatment of advanced ovarian cancer has been approved. However, it is not clear which one should be used for which patients.

AREAS COVERED

This paper presents a detailed analysis of data from phase 3 trials in ovarian cancer evaluating bevacizumab (ICON7, GOG-0218), olaparib (SOLO1, PAOLA-1), and niraparib (PRIMA, PRIME). We will discuss how the results of these trials relate to the 'rebound effect,' in which the risk of progression increases after discontinuation of bevacizumab in patients receiving bevacizumab, and to the significant difference in tissue permeability between olaparib and niraparib.

EXPERT OPINION

In patients with homologous recombination deficiency and no macroscopic residual disease (R0) after primary debulking surgery (PDS), the combination of bevacizumab plus olaparib seems to be the best regimen. Olaparib monotherapy is suitable for patients with BRCA mutations other than PDS R0. Bevacizumab is most useful in cases with a short duration of the rebound effect, i.e. short survival. Niraparib is useful in others but may be more useful in Asians.

Clinical efficacy of PARP inhibitors in breast cancer

BRCA1 and BRCA2 are key tumor suppressor genes that are essential for the homologous recombination DNA repair pathway. Loss of function mutations in these genes result in hereditary breast and ovarian cancer syndromes, which comprise approximately 5% of cases. BRCA1/2 mutations are associated with younger age of diagnosis and increased risk of recurrences. The concept of synthetic lethality led to the development of PARP inhibitors which cause cell cytotoxicity via the inhibition of PARP1, a key DNA repair protein, in cells with germline BRCA1/2 mutations. Although still poorly understood, the most well-acknowledged proposed mechanisms of action of PARP1 inhibition include the inhibition of single strand break repair, PARP trapping, and the upregulation of non-homologous end joining. Olaparib and talazoparib are PARP inhibitors that have been approved for the management of HER2-negative breast cancer in patients with germline BRCA1/2 mutations. This review article highlights the clinical efficacy of PARP inhibitors in patients with HER2-negative breast cancer in early and advanced settings.

Prognostic relevance of HRDness gene expression signature in ovarian high-grade serous carcinoma; JGOG3025-TR2 study

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to evaluate the homologous recombination repair pathway deficiency (HRD) in ovarian high-grade serous carcinoma (HGSC).

METHODS

In the ovarian cancer data from The Cancer Genome Atlas, we identified genes differentially expressed between tumours with and without HRD genomic scars and named these genes "HRDness signature". We performed SNP array, RNA sequencing, and methylation array analyses on 274 HGSC tumours for which targeted sequencing of 51 genes and clinical data were available to generate JGOG3025-TR2 dataset. The HRDness signature was tested on external datasets, including the JGOG3025-TR2 cohort, by computational scoring and machine-learning prediction.

RESULTS

High scores and positive predictions of the HRDness signature were significantly associated with BRCA alterations, genomic scar scores, and better survival. On the other hand, among cases with high scores and/or positive predictions, those with BRCA1 methylation showed poorer survival. In the JGOG3025-TR2 cohort, HRD status was significantly associated with the use of olaparib after relapse and progression-free survival after its initiation.

CONCLUSIONS

The HRDness gene expression signature is associated with a good prognosis, while BRCA1 methylation is associated with a poor prognosis. The newly generated JGOG3025-TR2 dataset will be useful in future HGSC studies.

ATM mutation in aggressive uterine adenosarcoma in which systemic chemotherapies had remarkable effects

Uterine adenosarcoma is a rare gynecologic malignancy, and 10-25% of the cases exhibit clinically aggressive behaviors. Although TP53 mutations are frequently identified in high-grade adenosarcomas of the uterus, definitive gene alterations have not been identified in uterine adenosarcomas. Specifically, no reports have described mutations in homologous recombination deficiency-related genes in uterine adenosarcomas. This study presents a case of uterine adenosarcoma without sarcomatous overgrowth but with TP53 mutation that exhibited clinically aggressive behaviors. The patient had an ATM mutation, which is a gene associated with homologous recombination deficiency, and exhibited a good response against platinum-based chemotherapy and possible therapeutic target by poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase inhibitors.

Direct prediction of Homologous Recombination Deficiency from routine histology in ten different tumor types with attention-based Multiple Instance Learning: a development and validation study

Background

Homologous Recombination Deficiency (HRD) is a pan-cancer predictive biomarker that identifies patients who benefit from therapy with PARP inhibitors (PARPi). However, testing for HRD is highly complex. Here, we investigated whether Deep Learning can predict HRD status solely based on routine Hematoxylin & Eosin (H&E) histology images in ten cancer types.

Methods

We developed a fully automated deep learning pipeline with attention-weighted multiple instance learning (attMIL) to predict HRD status from histology images. A combined genomic scar HRD score, which integrated loss of heterozygosity (LOH), telomeric allelic imbalance (TAI) and large-scale state transitions (LST) was calculated from whole genome sequencing data for n=4,565 patients from two independent cohorts. The primary statistical endpoint was the Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic curve (AUROC) for the prediction of genomic scar HRD with a clinically used cutoff value.

Results

We found that HRD status is predictable in tumors of the endometrium, pancreas and lung, reaching cross-validated AUROCs of 0.79, 0.58 and 0.66. Predictions generalized well to an external cohort with AUROCs of 0.93, 0.81 and 0.73 respectively. Additionally, an HRD classifier trained on breast cancer yielded an AUROC of 0.78 in internal validation and was able to predict HRD in endometrial, prostate and pancreatic cancer with AUROCs of 0.87, 0.84 and 0.67 indicating a shared HRD-like phenotype is across tumor entities.

Conclusion

In this study, we show that HRD is directly predictable from H&E slides using attMIL within and across ten different tumor types.

The Landscape and Therapeutic Targeting of BRCA1, BRCA2 and Other DNA Damage Response Genes in Pancreatic Cancer

Genes participating in the cellular response to damaged DNA have an important function to protect genetic information from alterations due to extrinsic and intrinsic cellular insults. In cancer cells, alterations in these genes are a source of genetic instability, which is advantageous for cancer progression by providing background for adaptation to adverse environments and attack by the immune system. Mutations in BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes have been known for decades to predispose to familial breast and ovarian cancers, and, more recently, prostate and pancreatic cancers have been added to the constellation of cancers that show increased prevalence in these families. Cancers associated with these genetic syndromes are currently treated with PARP inhibitors based on the exquisite sensitivity of cells lacking BRCA1 or BRCA2 function to inhibition of the PARP enzyme. In contrast, the sensitivity of pancreatic cancers with somatic BRCA1 and BRCA2 mutations and with mutations in other homologous recombination (HR) repair genes to PARP inhibitors is less established and the subject of ongoing investigations. This paper reviews the prevalence of pancreatic cancers with HR gene defects and treatment of pancreatic cancer patients with defects in HR with PARP inhibitors and other drugs in development that target these molecular defects.

Histopathological subtyping of high-grade serous ovarian cancer using whole slide imaging

OBJECTIVE

We have established 4 histopathologic subtyping of high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC) and reported that the mesenchymal transition (MT) type has a worse prognosis than the other subtypes. In this study, we modified the histopathologic subtyping algorithm to achieve high interobserver agreement in whole slide imaging (WSI) and to characterize the tumor biology of MT type for treatment individualization.

METHODS

Four observers performed histopathological subtyping using WSI of HGSOC in The Cancer Genome Atlas data. As a validation set, cases from Kindai and Kyoto Universities were independently evaluated by the 4 observers to determine concordance rates. In addition, genes highly expressed in MT type were examined by gene ontology term analysis. Immunohistochemistry was also performed to validate the pathway analysis.

RESULTS

After algorithm modification, the kappa coefficient, which indicates interobserver agreement, was greater than 0.5 (moderate agreement) for the 4 classifications and greater than 0.7 (substantial agreement) for the 2 classifications (MT vs. non-MT). Gene expression analysis showed that gene ontology terms related to angiogenesis and immune response were enriched in the genes highly expressed in the MT type. CD31 positive microvessel density was higher in the MT type compared to the non-MT type, and tumor groups with high infiltration of CD8/CD103 positive immune cells were observed in the MT type.

CONCLUSION

We developed an algorithm for reproducible histopathologic subtyping classification of HGSOC using WSI. The results of this study may be useful for treatment individualization of HGSOC, including angiogenesis inhibitors and immunotherapy.

Homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) score in aggressive prostatic adenocarcinoma with or without intraductal carcinoma of the prostate (IDC-P)

BACKGROUND

Intraductal carcinoma of the prostate (IDC-P) is a subtype of prostate cancer featured by poor prognosis. Previous studies suggested IDC-P could have a potentially unstable genome. Homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) score is a result-oriented method to describe the genomic instability status. This study investigates the association of HRD scores with IDC-P and other clinicopathological factors and the prognostic implication of HRD scores in an aggressive prostate cancer cohort.

METHODS

This study involved 123 PCa patients, including high-risk localized (M0) and de novo metastatic (M1) diseases. HRD score is calculated based on over 10,000 single-nucleotide polymorphisms distributed across the human genome. We explored the association between HRD scores and clinicopathological characteristics, genomic alterations, and patients' prognoses using rank-sum tests, chi-square tests, Kaplan-Meier curves, and Cox proportional hazards method.

RESULTS

The median HRD score of this cohort is 21.0, with 65 (52.8%) patients showing HRD score≥21. Tumors with IDC-P displayed higher HRD scores than adenocarcinoma (P=0.002); other high HRD score-related factors included M1 (P =0.008) and high ISUP grades (4-5) (P=0.001). MYC mutations were associated with high HRD scores (P<0.001) in the total cohort. TP53 mutations (P=0.010) and HRR pathway mutations (P=0.028) corresponded to high HRD scores in IDC-P positive and non-IDC-P patients, respectively, but not vice versa. HRD scores higher than 21 indicated significantly worse survival in the total cohort.

CONCLUSIONS

M1, high Gleason score, and IDC-P pathology represent higher HRD scores in PCa. Tumors with IDC-P might have different driven mechanisms for high HRD scores than non-IDC-P. HRD score displayed prognostic value in this aggressive prostate cancer cohort.

A comprehensive literature review and meta-analysis of the prevalence of pan-cancer BRCA mutations, homologous recombination repair gene mutations, and homologous recombination deficiencies

There is significant improvement in the outcomes following treatment with PARP inhibitors among patients with certain tumors that have BRCA mutations (BRCAm), homologous recombination repair (HRR) gene mutations, or homologous recombination deficiency (HRD) positivity. We performed a literature review and meta-analysis to evaluate the prevalence of BRCA1/2m, HRR gene mutations, and HRD positivity across multiple cancers. There were 265 publications on BRCA1/2 mutation prevalence, 189 on HRR gene mutation prevalence, and 7 on HRD positivity prevalence. The prevalences of germline BRCA1m and BRCA2m were 7.8% and 5.7% for breast cancer, 13.5% and 6.6% for ovarian cancer, 0.5% and 3.5% for prostate cancer, and 1.1% and 4.1% for pancreatic cancer, respectively. The prevalences of somatic BRCA1m and BRCA2m were 3.4% and 2.7% for breast cancer, 4.7% and 2.9% for ovarian cancer, 5.7% and 3.2% for prostate cancer, and 1.2% and 2.9% for pancreatic cancer, respectively. We identified 189 studies with over 418,649 samples across 25 tumor types that examined mutations in one or more HRR genes other than BRCA1/2. The prevalence of mutations among HRR genes remained low (less than 1%), with ATM (5.2%), CHEK2 (1.6%), and PALB2 (0.9%) exhibiting the highest prevalence. Seven studies evaluated HRD positivity in breast, ovarian, and prostate cancer patients. The prevalence of HRD positivity was 56% overall (95% CI = 48%-64%). The understanding of biomarker prevalence across tumor types and standardization of biomarker assays could have important clinical implications.