Expanding the phenotype of BICD2 mutations toward skeletal muscle involvement

Microscopic and Biochemical Hallmarks of BICD2-Associated Muscle Pathology toward the Evaluation of Novel Variants

BICD2 variants have been linked to neurodegenerative disorders like spinal muscular atrophy with lower extremity predominance (SMALED2) or hereditary spastic paraplegia (HSP). Recently, mutations in BICD2 were implicated in myopathies. Here, we present one patient with a known and six patients with novel BICD2 missense variants, further characterizing the molecular landscape of this heterogenous neurological disorder. A total of seven patients were genotyped and phenotyped. Skeletal muscle biopsies were analyzed by histology, electron microscopy, and protein profiling to define pathological hallmarks and pathogenicity markers with consecutive validation using fluorescence microscopy. Clinical and MRI-features revealed a typical pattern of distal paresis of the lower extremities as characteristic features of a BICD2-associated disorder. Histological evaluation showed myopathic features of varying severity including fiber size variation, lipofibromatosis, and fiber splittings. Proteomic analysis with subsequent fluorescence analysis revealed an altered abundance and localization of thrombospondin-4 and biglycan. Our combined clinical, histopathological, and proteomic approaches provide new insights into the pathophysiology of BICD2-associated disorders, confirming a primary muscle cell vulnerability. In this context, biglycan and thrombospondin-4 have been identified, may serve as tissue pathogenicity markers, and might be linked to perturbed protein secretion based on an impaired vesicular transportation.

Clinical genetics of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease

Recent research in the field of inherited peripheral neuropathies (IPNs) such as Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) disease has helped identify the causative genes provided better understanding of the pathogenesis, and unraveled potential novel therapeutic targets. Several reports have described the epidemiology, clinical characteristics, molecular pathogenesis, and novel causative genes for CMT/IPNs in Japan. Based on the functions of the causative genes identified so far, the following molecular and cellular mechanisms are believed to be involved in the causation of CMTs/IPNs: myelin assembly, cytoskeletal structure, myelin-specific transcription factor, nuclear related, endosomal sorting and cell signaling, proteasome and protein aggregation, mitochondria-related, motor proteins and axonal transport, tRNA synthetases and RNA metabolism, and ion channel-related mechanisms. In this article, we review the epidemiology, genetic diagnosis, and clinicogenetic characteristics of CMT in Japan. In addition, we discuss the newly identified novel causative genes for CMT/IPNs in Japan, namely MME and COA7. Identification of the new causes of CMT will facilitate in-depth characterization of the underlying molecular mechanisms of CMT, leading to the establishment of therapeutic approaches such as drug development and gene therapy.

Muscle "islands": An MRI signature distinguishing neurogenic from myopathic causes of early onset distal weakness

Muscle MRI has an increasing role in diagnosis of inherited neuromuscular diseases, but no features are known which reliably differentiate myopathic and neurogenic conditions. Using patients presenting with early onset distal weakness, we aimed to identify an MRI signature to distinguish myopathic and neurogenic conditions. We identified lower limb MRI scans from patients with either genetically (n = 24) or clinically (n = 13) confirmed diagnoses of childhood onset distal myopathy or distal spinal muscular atrophy. An initial exploratory phase reviewed 11 scans from genetically confirmed patients identifying a single potential discriminatory marker concerning the pattern of fat replacement within muscle, coined "islands". This pattern comprised small areas of muscle tissue with normal signal intensity completely surrounded by areas with similar intensity to subcutaneous fat. In the subsequent validation phase, islands correctly classified scans from all 12 remaining genetically confirmed patients, and 12/13 clinically classified patients. In the genetically confirmed patients MRI classification of neurogenic/myopathic aetiology had 100% accuracy (24/24) compared with 65% accuracy (15/23) for EMG, and 79% accuracy (15/19) for muscle biopsy. Future studies are needed in other clinical contexts, however the presence of islands appears to highly suggestive of a neurogenic aetiology in patients presenting with early onset distal motor weakness.

Neurogenic arthrogryposis and the power of phenotyping

In this article we review the commonest cause of neurogenic arthrogryposis, termed Spinal Muscular Atrophy Lower Extremity Dominant (SMALED), due to variants in DYNC1H1 and BICD2. We discuss the characteristic clinical and radiological phenotype of this disorder and how this has facilitated the identification of the genetic cause of SMALED2. We also review the similarities and differences between the human SMALED phenotype and mouse models and how this has informed our understanding of the potential mechanisms governing motor neuron loss in these disorders.

Bi-allelic truncating mutations in VWA1 cause neuromyopathy

The von Willebrand Factor A domain containing 1 protein, encoded by VWA1, is an extracellular matrix protein expressed in muscle and peripheral nerve. It interacts with collagen VI and perlecan, two proteins that are affected in hereditary neuromuscular disorders. Lack of VWA1 is known to compromise peripheral nerves in a Vwa1 knock-out mouse model. Exome sequencing led us to identify bi-allelic loss of function variants in VWA1 as the molecular cause underlying a so far genetically undefined neuromuscular disorder. We detected six different truncating variants in 15 affected individuals from six families of German, Arabic, and Roma descent. Disease manifested in childhood or adulthood with proximal and distal muscle weakness predominantly of the lower limbs. Myopathological and neurophysiological findings were indicative of combined neurogenic and myopathic pathology. Early childhood foot deformity was frequent, but no sensory signs were observed. Our findings establish VWA1 as a new disease gene confidently implicated in this autosomal recessive neuromyopathic condition presenting with child-/adult-onset muscle weakness as a key clinical feature.

Fetal early motor neuron disruption and prenatal molecular diagnosis in a severe BICD2-opathy

BICD2 (BICD Cargo Adaptor 2, MIM*609797) mutations are associated with severe prenatal-onset forms of spinal muscular atrophy, lower extremity-predominant 2B (SMALED2B MIM 618291) or milder forms with childhood-onset (SMALED2A MIM 615290). Etiopathogenesis is not fully clarified and a wide spectrum of phenotypic presentations is reported, ranging from extreme prenatal forms with adverse outcome, to slow progressive late-onset forms. We report a fetus at 22 gestational weeks with evidence of Arthrogryposis Multiplex Congenita on ultrasound, presenting with fixed extended lower limbs and flexed upper limbs, bilateral clubfoot and absent fetal movements. A trio-based prenatal Exome Sequencing was performed, disclosing a de novo heterozygous pathogenic in frame deletion (NM_015250.3: c.1636_1638delAAT; p.Asn546del) in BICD2. After pregnancy termination, quantitative analysis on NeuN immunostained spinal cord sections of the ventral horns, revealed that neuronal density was markedly reduced compared to the one of an age-matched normal fetus and an age-matched type-I Spinal Muscular Atrophy sample, used as a comparative model. The present case, the first prenatally diagnosed and neuropathologically characterized, showed an early motor neuron loss in SMALED2B, providing further insight into the pathological basis of BICD2-opathies.

Functional characterization of novel alpha-helical rod domain desmin (DES) pathogenic variants associated with dilated cardiomyopathy, atrioventricular block and a risk for sudden cardiac death

BACKGROUND

Desmin is the major intermediate filament (IF) protein in human heart and skeletal muscle. So-called 'desminopathies' are disorders due to pathogenic variants in the DES gene and are associated with skeletal myopathies and/or various types of cardiomyopathies. So far, only a limited number of DES pathogenic variants have been identified and functionally characterized.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Using a Sanger- and next generation sequencing (NGS) approach in patients with various types of cardiomyopathies, we identified two novel, non-synonymous missense DES variants: p.(Ile402Thr) and p.(Glu410Lys). Mutation carriers developed dilated (DCM) or arrhythmogenic cardiomyopathy (ACM), and cardiac conduction disease, leading to spare out the exercise-induced polymorphic ventricular tachycardia; we moved this variant to data in brief. To investigate the functional impact of these four DES variants, transfection experiments using SW-13 and H9c2 cells with native and mutant desmin were performed and filament assembly was analyzed by confocal microscopy. The DES_p.(Ile402Thr) and DES_p.(Glu410Lys) cells showed filament assembly defects forming cytoplasmic desmin aggregates. Furthermore, immunohistochemical and ultrastructural analysis of myocardial tissue from mutation carriers with the DES_p.(Glu410Lys) pathogenic variant supported the in vitro results.

CONCLUSIONS

Our in vitro results supported the classification of DES_p.(Ile402Thr) and DES_p.(Glu410Lys) as novel pathogenic variants and demonstrated that the cardiac phenotypes associated with DES variants are diverse and cell culture experiments improve in silico analysis and genetic counseling because the pathogenicity of a variant can be clarified.

SMALED2 with BICD2 gene mutations: Report of two cases and portrayal of a classical phenotype

The spinal muscular atrophies (SMA) affect lower motor neurons leading to important muscle atrophy and paralysis. Some cases of SMA affect mostly the lower limbs and are called autosomal dominant spinal muscular atrophy, lower extremity predominant (SMALED). So far, two genes have been identified to cause this phenotype, DYNC1H1 (SMALED1) and BICD2 (SMALED2). This pathology is rare, but patients exhibit classical features which should be recognised by physicians. We present two unrelated cases of SMALED2 with previously described c.320C>T BICD2 mutations. Our cases exhibit non-progressive weakness and atrophy of the lower limbs associated with contractures and unique muscle MRI findings suggestive of classical SMALED2. We also performed an extensive review of the literature to present the classical and atypical phenotypes of BICD2. Indeed, some features appear to be highly suggestive of the disease, including upper limb sparing, sparing of the adductors muscles on physical examination and MRI, congenital contractures and normal nerve conductions studies.

Loss of BICD2 in muscle drives motor neuron loss in a developmental form of spinal muscular atrophy

Autosomal dominant missense mutations in BICD2 cause Spinal Muscular Atrophy Lower Extremity Predominant 2 (SMALED2), a developmental disease of motor neurons. BICD2 is a key component of the cytoplasmic dynein/dynactin motor complex, which in axons drives the microtubule-dependent retrograde transport of intracellular cargo towards the cell soma. Patients with pathological mutations in BICD2 develop malformations of cortical and cerebellar development similar to Bicd2 knockout (-/-) mice. In this study we sought to re-examine the motor neuron phenotype of conditional Bicd2-/- mice. Bicd2-/- mice show a significant reduction in the number of large calibre motor neurons of the L4 ventral root compared to wild type mice. Muscle-specific knockout of Bicd2 results in a similar reduction in L4 ventral axons comparable to global Bicd2-/- mice. Rab6, a small GTPase required for the sorting of exocytic vesicles from the Trans Golgi Network to the plasma membrane is a major binding partner of BICD2. We therefore examined the secretory pathway in SMALED2 patient fibroblasts and demonstrated that BICD2 is required for physiological flow of constitutive secretory cargoes from the Trans Golgi Network to the plasma membrane using a VSV-G reporter assay. Together, these data indicate that BICD2 loss from muscles is a major driver of non-cell autonomous pathology in the motor nervous system, which has important implications for future therapeutic approaches in SMALED2.

Novel insights into SMALED2: BICD2 mutations increase microtubule stability and cause defects in axonal and NMJ development

Bicaudal D2 (BICD2) encodes a highly conserved motor adaptor protein that regulates the dynein-dynactin complex in different cellular processes. Heterozygous mutations in BICD2 cause autosomal dominant lower extremity-predominant spinal muscular atrophy-2 (SMALED2). Although, various BICD2 mutations have been shown to alter interactions with different binding partners or the integrity of the Golgi apparatus, the specific pathological effects of BICD2 mutations underlying SMALED2 remain elusive. Here, we show that the fibroblasts derived from individuals with SMALED2 exhibit stable microtubules. Importantly, this effect was observed regardless of where the BICD2 mutation is located, which unifies the most likely cellular mechanism affecting microtubules. Significantly, overexpression of SMALED2-causing BICD2 mutations in the disease-relevant cell type, motor neurons, also results in an increased microtubule stability which is accompanied by axonal aberrations such as collateral branching and overgrowth. To study the pathological consequences of BICD2 mutations in vivo, and to address the controversial debate whether two of these mutations are neuron or muscle specific, we generated the first Drosophila model of SMALED2. Strikingly, neuron-specific expression of BICD2 mutants resulted in reduced neuromuscular junction size in larvae and impaired locomotion of adult flies. In contrast, expressing BICD2 mutations in muscles had no obvious effect on motor function, supporting a primarily neurological etiology of the disease. Thus, our findings contribute to the better understanding of SMALED2 pathology by providing evidence for a common pathomechanism of BICD2 mutations that increase microtubule stability in motor neurons leading to increased axonal branching and to impaired neuromuscular junction development.

The unfolding spectrum of inherited distal myopathies

Distal myopathies are a group of rare muscle diseases characterized by distal weakness at onset. Although acquired myopathies can occasionally present with distal weakness, the majority of distal myopathies have a genetic etiology. Their age of onset varies from early-childhood to late-adulthood while the predominant muscle weakness can affect calf, ankle dorsiflexor, or distal upper limb muscles. A spectrum of muscle pathological changes, varying from nonspecific myopathic changes to rimmed vacuoles to myofibrillar pathology to nuclei centralization, have been noted. Likewise, the underlying molecular defect is heterogeneous. In addition, there is emerging evidence that distal myopathies can result from defective proteins encoded by genes causative of neurogenic disorders, be manifestation of multisystem proteinopathies or the result of the altered interplay between different genes. In this review, we provide an overview on the clinical, electrophysiological, pathological, and molecular aspects of distal myopathies, focusing on the most recent developments in the field. Muscle Nerve 59:283-294, 2019.

Targeted sequencing with expanded gene profile enables high diagnostic yield in non-5q-spinal muscular atrophies

Spinal muscular atrophies (SMAs) are a heterogeneous group of disorders characterized by muscular atrophy, weakness, and hypotonia due to suspected lower motor neuron degeneration (LMND). In a large cohort of 3,465 individuals suspected with SMA submitted for SMN1 testing to our routine diagnostic laboratory, 48.8% carried a homozygous SMN1 deletion, 2.8% a subtle mutation, and an SMN1 deletion, whereas 48.4% remained undiagnosed. Recently, several other genes implicated in SMA/LMND have been reported. Despite several efforts to establish a diagnostic algorithm for non-5q-SMA (SMA without deletion or point mutations in SMN1 [5q13.2]), data from large-scale studies are not available. We tested the clinical utility of targeted sequencing in non-5q-SMA by developing two different gene panels. We first analyzed 30 individuals with a small panel including 62 genes associated with LMND using IonTorrent-AmpliSeq target enrichment. Then, additional 65 individuals were tested with a broader panel encompassing up to 479 genes implicated in neuromuscular diseases (NMDs) with Agilent-SureSelect target enrichment. The NMD panel provided a higher diagnostic yield (33%) than the restricted LMND panel (13%). Nondiagnosed cases were further subjected to exome or genome sequencing. Our experience supports the use of gene panels covering a broad disease spectrum for diseases that are highly heterogeneous and clinically difficult to differentiate.

Phenotypic extremes of BICD2-opathies: from lethal, congenital muscular atrophy with arthrogryposis to asymptomatic with subclinical features

Heterozygous variants in BICD cargo adapter 2 (BICD2) cause autosomal dominant spinal muscular atrophy, lower extremity-predominant 2 (SMALED2). The disease is usually characterized by a benign or slowly progressive, congenital or early onset muscle weakness and atrophy that mainly affects the lower extremities, although some affected individuals show involvement of the arms and the shoulder girdle. Here we report unusual extremes of BICD2-related diseases: A severe form of congenital muscular atrophy with arthrogryposis multiplex, respiratory insufficiency and lethality within four months. This was caused by three BICD2 variants, (c.581A>G, p.(Gln194Arg)), (c.1626C>G, p.(Cys542Trp)) and (c.2080C>T, p.(Arg694Cys)), two of which were proven to be de novo. Affected individuals showed reduced fetal movement, weak muscle tone and sparse or no spontaneous activity after birth. Despite assisted ventilation, the condition led to early death. At the other extreme, we identified an asymptomatic woman with a known BICD2 variant (c.2108C>T, p.(Thr703Met)). Radiological examination showed fatty degeneration of selected thigh and calf muscles without clinical consequences. Instead, her son carrying the same variant is affected by a mild childhood onset disease with myopathic and neurogenic features. Mechanisms leading to variable expressivity and onset of BICD2-related disease may include alterations in molecular interactions of BICD2 and suggest the presence of genetic modifiers that may act in a protective fashion to ameliorate or abrogate disease. Our data define an additional severe disease type caused by BICD2 and emphasize a possibly variable etiology of BICD2-opathies with regard to primary muscle and neuronal involvement.

Inherited Paediatric Motor Neuron Disorders: Beyond Spinal Muscular Atrophy

Paediatric motor neuron diseases encompass a group of neurodegenerative diseases characterised by the onset of muscle weakness and atrophy before the age of 18 years, attributable to motor neuron loss across various neuronal networks in the brain and spinal cord. While the genetic underpinnings are diverse, advances in next generation sequencing have transformed diagnostic paradigms. This has reinforced the clinical phenotyping and molecular genetic expertise required to navigate the complexities of such diagnoses. In turn, improved genetic technology and subsequent gene identification have enabled further insights into the mechanisms of motor neuron degeneration and how these diseases form part of a neurodegenerative disorder spectrum. Common pathophysiologies include abnormalities in axonal architecture and function, RNA processing, and protein quality control. This review incorporates an overview of the clinical manifestations, genetics, and pathophysiology of inherited paediatric motor neuron disorders beyond classic SMN1-related spinal muscular atrophy and describes recent advances in next generation sequencing and its clinical application. Specific disease-modifying treatment is becoming a clinical reality in some disorders of the motor neuron highlighting the importance of a timely and specific diagnosis.

Expanding the phenotypic spectrum associated with mutations of DYNC1H1

Autosomal dominant mutations of DYNC1H1 cause a range of neurogenetic diseases, including mental retardation with cortical malformations, hereditary spastic paraplegia and spinal muscular atrophy. Using SNP array, linkage analysis and next generation sequencing, we identified two families and one isolated proband sharing a known spinal muscular atrophy, lower extremity predominant (SMALED) causing mutation DYNC1H1 c.1792C>T, p.Arg598Cys, and another family harbouring a c.2327C>T, p.Pro776Leu mutation. Here, we present a detailed clinical and pathological examination of these patients, and show that patients with DYNC1H1 mutations may present with a phenotype mimicking a congenital myopathy. We also highlight features that increase the phenotypic overlap with BICD2, which causes SMALED2. Serial muscle biopsies were available for several patients, spanning from infancy and early childhood to middle age. These provide a unique insight into the developmental and pathological origins of SMALED, suggesting in utero denervation with reinnervation by surrounding intact motor neurons and segmental anterior horn cell deficits. We characterise biopsy features that may make diagnosis of this condition easier in the future.