The protective effects of thiopental on brain stem ischemia

Neuroprotective effects of propofol, thiopental, etomidate, and midazolam in fetal rat brain in ischemia-reperfusion model

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to investigate the neuroprotective effects of propofol, thiopental, etomidate, and midazolam as anesthetic drugs in fetal rat brain in the ischemia-reperfusion (IR) model.

METHODS

Pregnant rats of day 19 were randomly allocated into eight groups. Fetal brain ischemia was induced by clamping the utero-ovarian artery bilaterally for 30 min and reperfusion was achieved by removing the clamps for 60 min. In the control group, fetal rat brains were obtained immediately after laparotomy. In the sham group, fetal rat brains were obtained 90 min after laparotomy. In the IR group, IR procedure was performed. No treatment was given in the IR group. One milliliter intralipid solution, 40 mg/kg propofol, 3 mg/kg thiopental, 0.1 mg/kg etomidate, and 3 mg/kg midazolam was administered intraperitoneally in the vehicle group, propofol group, thiopental group, etomidate group, and midazolam group, respectively, 20 min before IR procedure. At the end of the reperfusion period, the whole brains of the fetal rats were removed for evaluation of thiobarbituric acid reactive substances and for examination by electron microscopy.

RESULTS

According to lipid peroxidation data, all the anesthetic drugs provide neuroprotection; however, ultrastructural findings and mitochondrial scoring confirms that only propofol and midazolam provides a strong neuroprotective effect.

CONCLUSIONS

Propofol and midazolam may be used to protect fetal brain in case of acute fetal distress and hypoxic injury as a first choice anesthetic drug in cesarean delivery.

Anaesthetic-related neuroprotection: intravenous or inhalational agents?

In designing the anaesthetic plan for patients undergoing surgery, the choice of anaesthetic agent may often appear irrelevant and the best results obtained by the use of a technique or a drug with which the anaesthesia care provider is familiar. Nevertheless, in those surgical procedures (cardiopulmonary bypass, carotid surgery and cerebral aneurysm surgery) and clinical situations (subarachnoid haemorrhage, stroke, brain trauma and post-cardiac arrest resuscitation) where protecting the CNS is a priority, the choice of anaesthetic drug assumes a fundamental role. Treating patients with a neuroprotective agent may be a consideration in improving overall neurological outcome. Therefore, a clear understanding of the relative degree of protection provided by various agents becomes essential in deciding on the most appropriate anaesthetic treatment geared to these objectives. This article surveys the current literature on the effects of the most commonly used anaesthetic drugs (volatile and gaseous inhalation, and intravenous agents) with regard to their role in neuroprotection. A systematic search was performed in the MEDLINE, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINHAL®) and Cochrane Library databases using the following keywords: 'brain' (with the limits 'newborn' or 'infant' or 'child' or 'neonate' or 'neonatal' or 'animals') AND 'neurodegeneration' or 'apoptosis' or 'toxicity' or 'neuroprotection' in combination with individual drug names ('halothane', 'isoflurane', 'desflurane', 'sevoflurane', 'nitrous oxide', 'xenon', 'barbiturates', 'thiopental', 'propofol', 'ketamine'). Over 600 abstracts for articles published from January 1980 to April 2010, including studies in animals, humans and in vitro, were examined, but just over 100 of them were considered and reviewed for quality. Taken as a whole, the available data appear to indicate that anaesthetic drugs such as barbiturates, propofol, xenon and most volatile anaesthetics (halothane, isoflurane, desflurane, sevoflurane) show neuroprotective effects that protect cerebral tissue from adverse events--such as apoptosis, degeneration, inflammation and energy failure--caused by chronic neurodegenerative diseases, ischaemia, stroke or nervous system trauma. Nevertheless, in several studies, the administration of gaseous, volatile and intravenous anaesthetics (especially isoflurane and ketamine) was also associated with dose-dependent and exposure time-dependent neurodegenerative effects in the developing animal brain. At present, available experimental data do not support the selection of any one anaesthetic agent over the others. Furthermore, the relative benefit of one anaesthetic versus another, with regard to neuroprotective potential, is unlikely to form a rational basis for choice. Each drug has some undesirable adverse effects that, together with the patient's medical and surgical history, appear to be decisive in choosing the most suitable anaesthetic agent for a specific situation. Moreover, it is important to highlight that many of the studies in the literature have been conducted in animals or in vitro; hence, results and conclusions of most of them may not be directly applied to the clinical setting. For these reasons, and given the serious implications for public health, we believe that further investigation--geared mainly to clarifying the complex interactions between anaesthetic drug actions and specific mechanisms involved in brain injury, within a setting as close as possible to the clinical situation--is imperative.

Pre- or Postinsult Administration of Lidocaine or Thiopental Attenuates Cell Death in Rat Hippocampal Slice Cultures Caused by Oxygen-Glucose Deprivation

Lidocaine and thiopental improve recovery when administrated during hypoxia and ischemia; however, the effect of pre- or postinsult treatment alone is unknown. We applied either lidocaine or thiopental to hippocampal slice cultures from 20-day-old rats either before or after 10 min of oxygen-glucose deprivation (OGD). Propidium iodide (PI) fluorescence was used as an indicator of neuronal death for 7 days after OGD. OGD-induced neuronal death, in both the Cornus Ammonis 1 (CA1) and the dentate gyrus regions, peaked the first day after ischemia. Preinsult administration of either lidocaine (10, 100 microM) or thiopental (250, 600 microM) significantly reduced the damage measured on the first and second days after OGD; these drugs also significantly decreased the summed daily post-OGD PI fluorescence in both regions. Postinsult administration of lidocaine (10, 100 microM) or thiopental (250, 600 microM) significantly decreased the PI fluorescence on the first day after OGD; postinsult administration of these drugs also attenuated the summed daily post-OGD PI. These data indicate that the administration of lidocaine or thiopental either before or directly after OGD reduced neuronal damage in this in vitro model of cerebral ischemia. Postischemic administration is frequently the first opportunity for treatment.

IMPLICATIONS

Lidocaine or thiopental applied either 10 min before or 10 min directly after oxygen-glucose deprivation reduced neuronal cell death in rat hippocampal slice cultures. Postinsult administration is often the first opportunity for treatment after stroke; lidocaine and thiopental reduced damage caused by oxygen-glucose deprivation, an in vitro model of stroke.

Thiopental attenuates hypoxic changes of electrophysiology, biochemistry, and morphology in rat hippocampal slice CA1 pyramidal cells

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Thiopental has been shown to protect against cerebral ischemic damage; however, it has undesirable side effects. We have examined how thiopental alters histological, physiological, and biochemical changes during and after hypoxia. These experiments should enable the discovery of agents that share some of the beneficial effects of thiopental.

METHODS

We made intracellular recordings and measured ATP, sodium, potassium, and calcium concentrations from CA1 pyramidal cells in rat hippocampal slices subjected to 10 minutes of hypoxia with and without 600 micromol/L thiopental.

RESULTS

Thiopental delayed the time until complete depolarization (21+/-3 versus 11+/-2 minutes for treated versus untreated slices, respectively) and attenuated the level of depolarization at 10 minutes of hypoxia (-33+/-6 versus -12+/-5 mV). There was improved recovery of the resting potential after 10 minutes of hypoxia in slices treated with thiopental (89% versus 31% recovery). Thiopental attenuated the changes in sodium (140% versus 193% of prehypoxic concentration), potassium (62% versus 46%), and calcium (111% versus 197%) during 10 minutes of hypoxia. There was only a small effect on ATP (18% versus 8%). The percentage of cells showing clear histological damage was decreased by thiopental (45% versus 71%), and thiopental improved protein synthesis after hypoxia (75% versus 20%).

CONCLUSIONS

Thiopental attenuates neuronal depolarization, an increase in cellular sodium and calcium concentrations, and a decrease in cellular potassium and ATP concentrations during hypoxia. These effects may explain the reduced histological, protein synthetic, and electrophysiological damage to CA1 pyramidal cells after hypoxia with thiopental.

Nitric oxide-induced cytotoxicity attenuation by thiopentone sodium but not pentobarbitone sodium in primary brain cultures

1. We describe the effects of barbiturates on the neurotoxicity induced by nitric oxide (NO) on foetal rat cultured cortical and hippocampal neurones. Cessation of cerebral blood flow leads to an initiation of a neurotoxic cascade including NO and peroxynitrite. Barbiturates are often used to protect neurones against cerebrovascular disorders clinically. However, its neuroprotective mechanism remains unclear. 2. In the present experiment, we established a new in vitro model of brain injury mediated by NO with an NO-donor, 1-hydroxy-2-oxo-3-(3-aminopropyl)-3-isopropyl-1-triazene (NOC-5) on grid tissue culture wells. We also investigated the mechanisms of protection of CNS neurones from NO-induced neurotoxicity by thiopentone sodium, which contains a sulphydryl group (SH-) in the medium, and pentobarbitone sodium, which does not contain SH-. 3. Primary cultures of cortical and hippocampal neurones (prepared from 16-day gestational rat foetuses) were used after 13-14 days in culture. The cells were exposed to NOC-5 at the various concentrations for 24 h in the culture to evaluate a dose-dependent effect of NOC-5. 4. To evaluate the role of the barbiturates, neurones were exposed to 4, 40 and 400 microM of thiopentone sodium or pentobarbitone sodium with or without 30 microM NOC-5. In addition, superoxide dismutase (SOD) at 1000 u ml(-1) and 30 microM NOC-5 were co-administered for 24 h to evaluate the role of SOD. 5. Exposure to NOC-5 induced neural cell death in a dose-dependent manner in both cortical and hippocampal cultured neurones. Approximately 90% of the cultured neurones were killed by 100 microM NOC-5. 6. This NOC-5-induced neurotoxicity was significantly attenuated by high concentrations of thiopentone sodium (40 and 400 microM) as well as SOD, but not by pentobarbitone sodium. The survival rates of the cortical neurones and hippocampal neurones that were exposed to 30 microM NOC-5 were 11.2+/-4.2% and 37.2+/-3.0%, respectively, and in the presence of 400 microM thiopentone sodium, the survival rate increased to 65.3+/-3.5% in the cortical neurones and 74.6+/-2.2% in the hippocampal neurones. 7. These findings demonstrate that thiopentone sodium, which acts as a free radical scavenger, protects the CNS neurones against NO-mediated cytotoxicity in vitro. In conclusion, thiopentone sodium is one of the best of the currently available pharmacological agents for protection of neurones against intraoperative cerebral ischaemia.

Thiopental induced cerebral protection during ischemia in gerbils

Temporary interruption or reduction of cerebral blood flow during cerebrovascular surgery may rapidly result in ischemia or cerebral infarction. Thiopental has been shown to have cerebroprotective effects. However, the cerebroprotective dose of thiopental causes burst suppression of the EEG, thus this parameter cannot be used continuously for the detection of metabolic changes in the brain during thiopental anaesthesia. This study was performed in order to examine whether the multiparametric assembly (MPA), which measures energy metabolism CBF and mitochondrial (NADH) as well as extracellular ion concentrations (K+), can shed light on the mechanism of the cerebroprotective effects of thiopental. The MPA was placed on the brain of Mongolian gerbils and burst suppression of the ECoG was induced by thiopental. Cerebral ischemia was induced by occlusion of carotid arteries after burst suppression. Burst suppression of the ECoG was accompanied by a significant decrease in cerebral blood flow. In animals that received thiopental prior to ischemia, NADH increased to a lesser degree and extracellular potassium ion concentration increased to a lesser degree than in the control animals, indicating that thiopental affords protection of the brain under ischemic conditions due to improved energy metabolism. This study also demonstrates that the MPA can monitor changes occurring in the cerebral cortex even after the ECoG can no longer be used. Those findings have a significant value in the development of a new clinical monitoring device.

Effects of volatile anesthetics on hippocampal slice metabolism, response to anoxia with and without glucose

Anesthetics attenuate ischemic damage and so are often not used when preparing hippocampal slices for studies of ischemic or anoxic damage. In this study, we tested whether halothane, ether or isoflurane, when used briefly during slice preparation, have persistent effects on slice ATP metabolism, protein synthesis or morphology. We also tested the effects of anoxia with and without glucose on these slices. Five minutes of anoxia without glucose (anoxia-aglycemia) caused a dramatic depletion of ATP to less than 22% of control levels, a persistent inhibition of neuronal protein synthesis to less than 10% of control rates and severe morphological damage. Slices prepared using volatile anesthetics showed the same degree of damage due to anoxia-aglycemia, when compared with untreated tissue. In contrast, 5 min anoxia caused a 40% decrease in ATP levels in untreated tissue, but did not damage protein synthesis or morphology. While isoflurane-treated tissue responded identically to anoxia as untreated tissue, both halothane and ether prevented the anoxic ATP fall. These findings suggest that while halothane and ether may have persistent effects on slice responses to anoxia, isoflurane is a good candidate anesthetic for slice preparation procedures.

Hemodynamic ischemic stroke during carotid endarterectomy: an appraisal of risk and cerebral protection

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to validate the commonly accepted indicators of risk of ischemic stroke that indicate the necessity for cerebral protection during carotid endarterectomy (CEA), and to examine the efficacy of high-dose thiopentone sodium (thiopental) as a cerebral protection method in patients who are at high risk of intraoperative ischemic stroke.

METHOD

In a prospective study of 37 CEAs performed for symptomatic stenosis > 70%, functional and clinical indicators of risk of ischemic stroke during carotid cross-clamping were identified. Functional indicators of risk were the development of ischemic electro-encephalogram (EEG) changes and stump pressure < 25 mm Hg. Clinical indicators of risk were previous ischemic hemispheric stroke and severe bilateral disease. These indicators were correlated in all patients, some of whom had two or three coexisting indicators of risk. The EEG and stump pressure were monitored continuously during carotid occlusion in all operations. Carotid occlusion times were recorded. Intraluminal shunting was eliminated in favor of high-dose thiopental cerebral protection in all patients. Neurologic outcome was deemed to measure the efficacy of thiopental protection in patients who are identified to be at risk and, hence, in need of cerebral protection. The validity of the indicators used to identify risk of ischemic stroke during CEA was assessed.

RESULTS

The absolute stroke risk was found to be 29.7% for the whole group (37 patients) and 57.9% in 19 patients who had commonly accepted indications for protective shunting. The correlation of ischemic EEG changes with stump pressure < 25 mm Hg was only 27.3%, whereas the expected correlation based on well-documented reports in the literature was 100%. The lack of correlation may have been related to the prevention of ischemic EEG changes by thiopental. There were no neurologic deficits in the series.

CONCLUSIONS

The absence of neurologic deficit in the study indicated that thiopental protection was effective in preventing ischemic stroke in high-risk patients and safely replaced intraluminal shunting.

The protective effects of alpha-melanocyte stimulating hormone on canine brain stem ischemia

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the influence of alpha-melanocyte stimulating hormone (alpha-MSH), an anti-inflammatory antagonist of the production and action of proinflammatory cytokines, 26 dogs were divided into four groups and exposed to isolated, reversible brain stem ischemia in the presence or absence of alpha-MSH treatment.

METHODS

Brain stem auditory evoked potentials (BAEPs) and regional cerebral blood flow were measured during ischemia and for 5 hours after reperfusion. Group I was composed of five dogs that underwent surgical preparation only. Group II was composed of seven dogs that were exposed to 20 minutes of ischemia without treatment. Group III was comprised of seven dogs exposed to 20 minutes of ischemia with alpha-MSH treatment before and during ischemia. Group IV was composed of seven dogs exposed to 20 minutes of brain stem ischemia with alpha-MSH treatment only during reperfusion.

RESULTS

During the ischemic period, BAEPs were abolished in all animals within 10 minutes. With reperfusion, the BAEPs increased to approximately 36% of baseline in Group II dogs that received no treatment. However, this increase was approximately 63% in animals that received alpha-MSH both before and during ischemia (Group III). In Group IV dogs that received alpha-MSH only during reperfusion, BAEPs were increased approximately 10 to 14% more than in Group II during the late reperfusion period.

CONCLUSION

The improved recovery of BAEPs in dogs treated with alpha-MSH suggests that this peptide may have neuroprotective effects in brain stem ischemia and reperfusion injury. This effect may be caused by an antagonistic action of alpha-MSH on cytokine-induced ischemic brain damage.