Survival and outcome of neurosurgical patients requiring ventilatory support after intensive care unit stay

Health-Related Quality-of-Life and Cost Utility Analyses in Critical Care: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVES

Cost utility analyses compare the costs and health outcome of interventions, with a denominator of quality-adjusted life year, a generic health utility measure combining both quality and quantity of life. Cost utility analyses are difficult to compare when methods are not standardized. It is unclear how cost utility analyses are measured/reported in critical care and what methodologic challenges cost utility analyses pose in this setting. This may lead to differences precluding cost utility analyses comparisons. Therefore, we performed a systematic review of cost utility analyses conducted in critical care. Our objectives were to understand: 1) methodologic characteristics, 2) how health-related quality-of-life was measured/reported, and 3) what costs were reported/measured.

DESIGN

Systematic review.

DATA SOURCES

We systematically searched for cost utility analyses in critical care in MEDLINE, Embase, American College of Physicians Journal Club, CENTRAL, Evidence-Based Medicine Reviews' selected subset of archived versions of UK National Health Service Economic Evaluation Database, Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects, and American Economic Association electronic databases from inception to April 30, 2020.

SETTING

Adult ICUs.

PATIENTS

Adult critically ill patients.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Of 8,926 citations, 80 cost utility analyse studies were eligible. The time horizon most commonly reported was lifetime (59%). For health utility reporting, health-related quality-of-life was infrequently measured (29% reported), with only 5% of studies reporting baseline health-related quality-of-life. Indirect utility measures (generic, preference-based health utility measurement tools) were reported in 85% of studies (majority Euro-quality-of-life-5 Domains, 52%). Methods of estimating health-related quality-of-life were seldom used when the patient was incapacitated: imputation (19%), assigning fixed utilities for incapacitation (19%), and surrogates reporting on behalf of incapacitated patients (5%). For cost utility reporting transparency, separate incremental costs and quality-adjusted life years were both reported in only 76% of studies. Disaggregated quality-adjusted life years (reporting separate health utility and life years) were described in only 34% of studies.

CONCLUSIONS

We identified deficiencies which warrant recommendations (standardized measurement/reporting of resource use/unit costs/health-related quality-of-life/methodological preferences) for improved design, conduct, and reporting of future cost utility analyses in critical care.

Perioperative Treatment of Brain Arteriovenous Malformations Between 2006 and 2014: The Helsinki Protocol

Objective

We reviewed retrospectively the perioperative treatment of microsurgically resected brain arteriovenous malformations (bAVMs) at the neurosurgical department of Helsinki University Hospital between the years 2006 and 2014. We examined the performance of the treatment protocol and the incidence of delayed postoperative hemorrhage (DPH).

Methods

The Helsinki protocol for postoperative treatment of bAVMs was used for the whole patient cohort of 121. The patients who had subsequent DPH were reviewed in more detail.

Results

Five out of 121 (4.1%) patients had DPH. These patients had a higher Spetzler–Martin grade (SMG) (p = 0.043) and a more complex venous drainage pattern (p = 0.003) as compared to those who had no postoperative bleed. Patients with DPH had 43% larger intravenous fluid intake in the neurosurgical intensive care unit (p = 0.052); they were all male (p = 0.040) and had longer stay in the intensive care unit (p = 0.022).

Conclusions

The Helsinki protocol for postoperative treatment of bAVMs was found to produce comparable results to a more complex treatment algorithm. DPH was associated with high SMG, complex venous drainage pattern, male gender and high intravenous fluid intake. Our findings support the use of SMG in defining patient’s postoperative treatment as the DPHs in our study occurred in patients with grade 2–5.

Cost-Effectiveness Studies in the ICU: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVES

Cost-effectiveness analyses are increasingly used to aid decisions about resource allocation in healthcare; this practice is slow to translate into critical care. We sought to identify and summarize original cost-effectiveness studies presenting cost per quality-adjusted life year, incremental cost-effectiveness ratios, or cost per life-year ratios for treatments used in ICUs.

DESIGN

We conducted a systematic search of the English-language literature for cost-effectiveness analyses published from 1993 to 2018 in critical care. Study quality was assessed using the Drummond checklist.

SETTING

Critical care units.

PATIENTS OR SUBJECTS

Critical care patients.

INTERVENTIONS

Identified studies with cost-effectiveness analyses.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

We identified 97 studies published through 2018 with 156 cost-effectiveness ratios. Reported incremental cost-effectiveness ratios ranged from -$119,635 (hypothetical cohort of patients requiring either intermittent or continuous renal replacement therapy) to $876,539 (data from an acute renal failure study in which continuous renal replacement therapy was the most expensive therapy). Many studies reported favorable cost-effectiveness profiles (i.e., below $50,000 per life year or quality-adjusted life year). However, several therapies have since been proven harmful. Over 2 decades, relatively few cost-effectiveness studies in critical care have been published (average 4.6 studies per year). There has been a more recent trend toward using hypothetical cohorts and modeling scenarios without proven clinical data (2014-2018: 19/33 [58%]).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite critical care being a significant healthcare cost burden there remains a paucity of studies in the literature evaluating its cost effectiveness.

Health-related quality of life after general surgical intensive care

BACKGROUND

Impaired mental and physical health are common complications after intensive care that could influence the patient's health-related quality of life (HRQoL). Earlier research has mainly focused on HRQoL in mixed surgical and medical ICU populations. This study aimed to describe and analyze factors associated with HROoL after discharge from a general surgical ICU.

METHODS

A prospective cohort study was conducted in a general surgical ICU in Sweden between 2005 and 2012. Adult patients (≥18 years) with an ICU length of stay ≥96 hours were included. HRQoL was measured at 3, 6, and 12 months after discharge from the ICU using a questionnaire (SF-36). A linear mixed model was used to analyze changes over time and Wilcoxon Signed Rank Tests were used to compare the 12-months results to an age and gender matched reference population in Sweden. Linear regression analyses were performed to explore the impact on HRQoL from background variables.

RESULTS

Of 447 patients eligible for the study, 276 patients (62%) answered SF-36 at least once at 3, 6 or 12 months after ICU care and were included in the study. HRQoL improved over time but was still significantly lower at 12 months compared to the reference population. Female gender, age <75 years, living single, and ICU-stay of more than 14 days were associated with lower HRQoL.

CONCLUSION

General surgical ICU patients reports low HRQoL 1 year after ICU stay. The impaired HRQoL could be a long-lasting problem with major consequences for the individual, family, and society.

[Long-term course of patients in neurological rehabilitation Phase B. Results of the 6-year follow-up in a multicenter study]

BACKGROUND

After conclusion of emergency care for severe neurological diseases patients in Germany are admitted at an early stage to so-called Phase B rehabilitation. No studies have been carried out on the long-term course of these patients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

In a prospective study in 2002 patients in Phase B from 9 centers were included and follow-up investigations were carried out after 5 and 6 years. Assessment instruments used were the Barthel index, the Rankin scale and the EQ-5D. Factors for the risk of a poor outcome and the chances for a good outcome were evaluated using multivariate logistic regression.

RESULTS

A total of 1,280 patients were included in the study. A high age increased the risk of dying with a hazard quotient (HQ) of 1.05 (95% CI: 1.04-1.06) and high point counts in the coma remission scale (HQ 0.93; 95% CI: 0.92-0.96) and Barthel index (HQ 0.97; 95% CI: 0.97-0.98) on discharge reduced the risk of dying after 5 years. The factors swallowing impairment (OR 3.1; 95% CI: 1.7-5.5) and obligatory surveillance at the end of rehabilitation (OR 3.2; 95% CI: 1.2-8.6) increased the risk of a poor result in the Rankin scale 2-4 and the factors communication disorder (OR 5.0; 95% CI: 2.0-12.8) and PEG (percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy) (OR 19.7; 95% CI: 2.7-144.4) on discharge increased the risk of a reduced health-related quality of life (defined as EQ-5D VAS <70) after 6 years.

CONCLUSIONS

If support for bodily functions can be successfully reduced during Phase B rehabilitation, the patients will have a good outcome with respect to 5-year survival. If this is not successful the outcome is unfavorable with respect to survival and with respect to achieving self-sufficiency and health-related quality of life after 6 years.

Cost-effectiveness of decompressive craniectomy in non-traumatic neurological emergencies

BACKGROUND

Decompressive craniectomy is used regularly in traumatic brain injury (TBI) and malignant middle cerebral artery infarction. Its benefits for other causes of non-traumatic brain swelling, if any, are unclear, especially after a devastating primary event.

METHODS

We evaluated the outcomes as well as treatment costs of all emergency decompressive craniectomies performed between the 2000 and 2006 in a single institution to lower intractable intracranial pressure, excluding the standard indications TBI and malignant middle cerebral infarction. The health-related quality of life (HRQoL) was evaluated on the Euroqol (EQ-5D) scale, and cost of a quality-adjusted life year (QALY) calculated.

RESULTS

The overall 3-year mortality rate was 62% for subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH, 29 patients) and 31% for other neurological emergencies (13 patients). Patients with SAH were on average 13 years older than the other indications mean. Of the non-survivors, 45% died within a month and 95% within 1 year. Median EQ-5D index values were poor (0.15 for SAH and 0.62 for the other emergencies, versus 0.85 for the normal population), but of the survivors, 73% and 89% were able to live at home. The cost of neurosurgical treatment for one QALY was 11,000 € for SAH and 2000 € for other emergencies.

CONCLUSION

Mortality after non-traumatic neurological emergencies leading to decompressive craniectomy was high, and the HRQoL index of the survivors was poor. Most survivors were, however, able to live at home, and the cost of neurosurgical treatment for a QALY gained was acceptable.

Multimodal Cerebral Monitoring in Traumatic Brain Injury

Traumatic brain injury presents a significant impact on patients in terms of morbidity and mortality. Pathology is heterogeneous and is often associated with secondary deterioration. This paper reviews both clinical and research modes of monitoring to detect deterioration and compares what is available to the ideal. Intracranial pressure measurement, jugular venous oxygen saturation, microdialysis and cerebral oxygen monitoring are among the variables described and future research-based modalities are explored.