Revisiting the question of nucleated versus enucleated erythrocytes in birds and mammals

Erythrocyte enucleation is thought to have evolved in mammals to support their energetic cost of high metabolic activities. However, birds face similar selection pressure yet possess nucleated erythrocytes. Current hypotheses on the mammalian erythrocyte enucleation claim that the absence of cell organelles allows erythrocytes to 1) pack more hemoglobin into the cells to increase oxygen carrying capacity and 2) decrease erythrocyte size for increased surface area-to-volume ratio, and improved ability to traverse small capillaries. In this article, we first empirically tested current hypotheses using both conventional and phylogenetically informed analysis comparing literature values of mean cell hemoglobin concentration (MCHC) and mean cell volume (MCV) between 181 avian and 194 mammalian species. We found no difference in MCHC levels between birds and mammals using both conventional and phylogenetically corrected analysis. MCV was higher in birds than mammals according to conventional analysis, but the difference was lost when we controlled for phylogeny. These results suggested that avian and mammalian erythrocytes may employ different strategies to solve a common problem. To further investigate existing hypotheses or develop new hypothesis, we need to understand the functions of various organelles in avian erythrocytes. Consequently, we covered potential physiological functions of various cell organelles in avian erythrocytes based on current knowledge, while making explicit comparisons to their mammalian counterparts. Finally, we proposed by taking an integrative and comparative approach, using tools from molecular biology to evolutionary biology, would allow us to better understand the fundamental physiological functions of various components of avian and mammalian erythrocytes.

ATP-induced reversed thermal sensitivity of O2 binding in both major haemoglobin polymorphs of the non-endothermic Atlantic cod, Gadus morhua

Atlantic cod is a species that is affected by climate change, with some populations being exposed to higher temperatures than others. The two polymorphs of its major haemoglobin type (HbI) show an inverse change in frequency along a latitudinal temperature cline in the North East Atlantic, which has been associated with differences in population performance and behavioural traits. An earlier study at the northern distribution limit of the species reported differential temperature sensitivities of red blood cell oxygen (O₂) affinity between the northern cold-water HbI-2 polymorph and its southern, warm-water HbI-1 counter-part, which has since widely been held as adaptive for the species across its distributional range. The present study critically re-examined this hypothesis by comparing the thermal sensitivity of O₂ binding in both purified HbI polymorphs from the southern, high-temperature distribution limit of the species under controlled conditions of allosteric modifiers of Hb function. Contrary to the prevailing view, the O₂ affinity of the major HbI polymorphs did not differ from each other under any of the tested conditions. Depending on pH and ATP concentration, the temperature-sensitive and temperature-insensitive Hb-O₂ affinity phenotypes - previously exclusively ascribed to HbI-1 and HbI-2, respectively - could be induced in both HbI polymorphs. These results are the first to establish a molecular mechanism behind a reversed temperature dependence of red blood cell O₂ affinity in a non-endotherm fish and lay the basis for future studies on alternative mechanisms behind the differences in distribution, performance and behavioural traits associated with the different HbI polymorphs of Atlantic cod.

Species-specific low plasma glucose in fish is associated with relatively high tissue glucose content and is inversely correlated with cardiac glycogen content

The relationship between plasma glucose concentration and intracellular glucose (liver, heart, brain, gill, gonad, intestine, kidney, spleen, white muscle) was determined in fish species with a range in plasma glucose (Atlantic cod, 5.06 mM; cunner, 3.8 mM; rainbow trout, 3.7 mM; lumpfish, 0.9 mM; short-horned sculpin, 0.6 mM; and winter flounder, 0.6 mM). The ratio of intracellular glucose/plasma glucose was always higher than one in liver for all species consistent with a diffusion gradient from the tissue to the plasma. In all other tissues in Atlantic cod, cunner, and rainbow trout the diffusion gradient was from the plasma to the intracellular space. In short-horned sculpin, the mean ratio in heart and white muscle exceeded one and in winter flounder the ratio was significantly greater than one at 5.97 and 2.92 for heart and muscle, respectively. The presence of an active glucose 6-phosphatase in white muscle could account for elevated amounts of free glucose. The white muscle of all species displayed phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase and in winter flounder the activity was as high in white muscle as in liver suggesting that gluconeogenesis may be associated with a relatively high-muscle glucose content. The glycogen content was highest in liver followed by heart with lower amounts in all other tissues. There was an inverse correlation between heart glycogen content and plasma glucose concentration when all species were included. It is contended that in species with low plasma glucose, heart glycogen is accumulated at a slow rate under normoxia, to be called upon under hypoxic conditions when the gradient for inward diffusion is unfavourable for high rates of glucose metabolism.

Low plasma glucose limits glucose metabolism by RBCs and heart in some species of teleosts

Within teleosts there is a species range in plasma glucose levels from undetectable to 20mM. At low plasma glucose levels the gradient from the extracellular to the intracellular space is decreased. The impact of this on glucose metabolism by RBCs and heart from species with different steady state levels of plasma glucose (Atlantic cod ~5mM; Atlantic salmon ~5mM, cunner ~1mM, lumpfish <1mM; short-horned sculpin <1mM) is the subject of this review. Under normoxia, at physiological levels of extracellular glucose, RBCs and heart produce lactate although the contribution of anaerobic metabolism to ATP production is small. Sustained lactate production from extracellular glucose appears to be the primary fate of extracellular glucose. In many cases, glycogen is not mobilized and the rate of glucose metabolism=two times the rate of lactate production. As such, alternative metabolic sources are required to fuel oxidative metabolism. Under hypoxia, hearts from Atlantic cod and rainbow trout increase rates of both glucose metabolism and lactate production, partially supported by glycogen reserves. But in lumpfish and short-horned sculpin hearts there is no change in rates of glucose metabolism. The most likely explanation is that glucose uptake is compromised in lumpfish and short-horned sculpin hearts due to a low diffusion gradient. Under these conditions rates of lactate production are well below that of Atlantic cod or rainbow trout. Energy demand must be reduced under hypoxia in lumpfish and short-horned sculpin hearts in order to maintain ATP balance.

Low levels of extracellular glucose limit cardiac anaerobic metabolism in some species of fish

There is a wide interspecific range in plasma glucose levels in teleosts from less than 0.5 to greater than 10 mmol l^-1 Here we assessed how glucose availability influences glucose metabolism in hearts of Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua), rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss), lumpfish (Cyclopterus lumpus) and short-horned sculpin (Myoxocephalus scorpius) under normoxic and hypoxic conditions. These species had plasma glucose levels of 5.1, 4.8, 0.9 and 0.5 mmol l^-1, respectively. Rates of glucose metabolism and lactate production were determined in isolated hearts perfused with medium containing physiological levels of glucose. Under normoxic conditions there was no significant difference in rates of either glucose metabolism (average 15 nmol g^-1 min^-1) or lactate production (average 30 nmol g^-1 min^-1) across species. Under hypoxia (12% of air saturation) there were significant increases in rates of glucose metabolism and lactate production in hearts from Atlantic cod (glucose-130; lactate-663 nmol g^-1 min^-1) and rainbow trout (glucose-103; lactate-774 nmol g^-1 min^-1); however, there was no change in rate of glucose metabolism in hearts from either lumpfish or short-horned sculpin and only increases in lactate production to rates much lower than the other species. Furthermore, Atlantic cod hearts perfused with medium containing low non-physiological levels of glucose (0.5 mmol l^-1) had the same rates of glucose metabolism under normoxic and hypoxic treatments. Anaerobic metabolism supported by extracellular glucose is compromised in fish with low levels of plasma glucose, which in turn may decrease performance under oxygen-limiting conditions at the whole-animal level.

High rates of glucose utilization in the gas gland of Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) are supported by GLUT1 and HK1b

The gas gland of physoclistous fish utilizes glucose to generate lactic acid that leads to the off-loading of oxygen from haemoglobin. This study addresses characteristics of the first two steps in glucose utilization in the gas gland of Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua). Glucose metabolism by isolated gas gland cells was 12- and 170-fold higher, respectively, than that in heart and red blood cells (RBCs) as determined by the production of (3)H2O from [2-(3)H]glucose. In the gas gland, essentially all of the glucose consumed was converted to lactate. Glucose uptake in the gas gland shows a very high dependence upon facilitated transport as evidenced by saturation of uptake of 2-deoxyglucose at a low extracellular concentration and a requirement for high levels of cytochalasin B for uptake inhibition despite the high efficacy of this treatment in heart and RBCs. Glucose transport is via glucose transporter 1 (GLUT1), which is localized to the glandular cells. GLUT1 western blot analysis from whole-tissue lysates displayed a band with a relative molecular mass of 52 kDa, consistent with the deduced amino acid sequence. Levels of 52 kDa GLUT1 in the gas gland were 2.3- and 33-fold higher, respectively, than those in heart and RBCs, respectively. Glucose phosphorylation is catalysed by hexokinase Ib (HKIb), a paralogue that cannot bind to the outer mitochondrial membrane. Transcript levels of HKIb in the gas gland were 52- and 57-fold more abundant, respectively, than those in heart and RBCs. It appears that high levels of GLUT1 protein and an unusual isoform of HKI are both critical for the high rates of glycolysis in gas gland cells.

Extracellular glucose supports lactate production but not aerobic metabolism in cardiomyocytes from both normoglycemic Atlantic cod and low glycemic short-horned sculpin

Fish exhibit a wide range of species-specific blood glucose levels. How this relates to glucose utilization is yet to be fully realized. Here, we assessed glucose transport and metabolism in myocytes isolated from Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) and short-horned sculpin (Myoxocephalus scorpius), species with blood glucose levels of 3.7 and 0.57 mmol l(-1), respectively. Glucose metabolism was assessed by the production of (3)H2O from [2-(3)H]glucose. Glucose metabolism was 3.5- to 6-fold higher by myocytes from Atlantic cod than by those from short-horned sculpin at the same level of extracellular glucose. In Atlantic cod myocytes, glucose metabolism displayed what appears to be a saturable component with respect to extracellular glucose, and cytochalasin B inhibited glucose metabolism. These features revealed a facilitated glucose diffusion mechanism that accounts for between 30% and 55% of glucose entry at physiological levels of extracellular glucose. Facilitated glucose diffusion appears to be minimal in myocytes for short-horned sculpin. Glucose entry by simple diffusion occurs in both cell types with the same linear relationship between glucose metabolism and extracellular glucose concentration, presumably due to similarities in membrane composition. Oxygen consumption by myocytes incubated in medium containing physiological levels of extracellular glucose (Atlantic cod 5 mmol l(-1), short-horned sculpin 0.5 mmol l(-1)) was similar in the two species and was not decreased by cytochalasin B, suggesting that these cells have the capability of oxidizing alternative on-board metabolic fuels. Cells produced lactate at low rates but glycogen levels did not change during the incubation period. In cells from both species, glucose utilization assessed by both simple chemical analysis of glucose disappearance from the medium and (3)H2O production was half the rate of lactate production and as such extracellular glucose was not available for oxidative metabolism. Overall, extracellular glucose makes only a minor contribution to ATP production but a sustained glycolysis may be necessary to support Ca(2+) transport mechanisms at either the sarcoplasmic reticulum or the sarcolemmal membrane.