Both maternal and embryonic exposure to mild hypoxia influence embryonic development of the intertidal gastropod Littorina littorea

There is growing evidence that maternal exposure to environmental stressors can alter offspring phenotype and increase fitness. Here, we investigate the relative and combined effects of maternal and developmental exposure to mild hypoxia (65 and 74% air saturation, respectively) on the growth and development of embryos of the marine gastropod Littorina littorea Differences in embryo morphological traits were driven by the developmental environment, whereas the maternal environment and interactive effects of maternal and developmental environment were the main driver of differences in the timing of developmental events. While developmental exposure to mild hypoxia significantly increased the area of an important respiratory organ, the velum, it significantly delayed hatching of veliger larvae and reduced their size at hatching and overall survival. Maternal exposure had a significant effect on these traits, and interacted with developmental exposure to influence the time of appearance of morphological characters, suggesting that both are important in affecting developmental trajectories. A comparison between embryos that successfully hatched and those that died in mild hypoxia revealed that survivors exhibited hypertrophy in the velum and associated pre-oral cilia, suggesting that these traits are linked with survival in low-oxygen environments. We conclude that both maternal and developmental environments shape offspring phenotype in a species with a complex developmental life history, and that plasticity in embryo morphology arising from exposure to even small reductions in oxygen tensions affects the hatching success of these embryos.

Influence of chronic hyperoxia on the developmental time course of the hypoxic ventilatory response relative to other traits in rats

Newborn mammals exhibit a biphasic hypoxic ventilatory response (HVR) in which an initial increase in ventilation is followed by a decline back toward baseline levels. The magnitude of the secondary decline diminishes with postnatal age, but this transition occurs earlier in rat pups reared in moderate hyperoxia. This pattern is consistent with heterokairy, a form of developmental plasticity in which environmental factors alter the timing of developmental events. The present study investigated whether this plasticity is specific to the HVR or if hyperoxia instead accelerates overall development. Rat pups reared in 60 % O₂ (Hyperoxia) exhibited a less biphasic ventilatory response to 12 % O₂ than pups reared in 21 % O₂ (Control) at 4 days of age (P4) and transitioned to a sustained HVR by P10-11; Control rats exhibited a biphasic HVR at both ages. However, the average ages at which pups attained other key developmental milestones (i.e., fur development at P5, incisor eruption at P9, and eye opening at P15) were similar between treatment groups. Moreover, growth rates and maturation of the metabolic response to cooling were not accelerated, and may have been delayed slightly, relative to Control rats. For example, the capacity for pups to increase their metabolic rate at low ambient temperatures increased with age, but this thermogenic capacity tended to be reduced in Hyperoxia pups at both P4 and P10-11 (i.e., lower CO₂ production rates below the lower critical temperature). Collectively, these data support the conclusion that hyperoxia specifically advances the age at which rat pups exhibit a sustained HVR, altering the relative timing of developmental events rather than compressing the entire period of development.

Differences in the respiratory response to temperature and hypoxia across four life-stages of the intertidal porcelain crab Petrolisthes laevigatus

For aquatic breathers, hypoxia and warming can act synergistically causing a mismatch between oxygen supply (reduced by hypoxia) and oxygen demand (increased by warming). The vulnerability of these species to such interactive effects may differ during ontogeny due to differing gas exchange systems. This study examines respiratory responses to temperature and hypoxia across four life-stages of the intertidal porcelain crab Petrolisthes laevigatus. Eggs, megalopae, juveniles and adults were exposed to combinations of temperatures from 6 to 18 °C and oxygen tensions from 2 to 21 kPa. Metabolic rates differed strongly across life-stages which could be partly attributed to differences in body mass. However, eggs exhibited significantly lower metabolic rates than predicted for their body mass. For the other three stages, metabolic rates scaled with a mass exponent of 0.89. Mass scaling exponents were similar across all temperatures, but were significantly influenced by oxygen tension (the highest at 9 and 14 kPa, and the lowest at 2 kPa). Respiratory responses across gradients of oxygen tension were used to calculate the response to hypoxia, whereby eggs, megalopae and juveniles responded as oxyconformers and adults as oxyregulators. The thermal sensitivity of the metabolic rates (Q₁₀) were dependent on the oxygen tension in megalopae, and also on the interaction between oxygen tension and temperature intervals in adults. Our results thus provide evidence on how the oxygen tension can modulate the mass dependence of metabolic rates and demonstrate changes in respiratory control from eggs to adults. In light of our results indicating that adults show a good capacity for maintaining metabolism independent of oxygen tension, our study highlights the importance of assessing responses to multiple stressors across different life-stages to determine how vulnerability to warming and hypoxia changes during development.

Heterokairy: a significant form of developmental plasticity?

There is a current surge of research interest in the potential role of developmental plasticity in adaptation and evolution. Here we make a case that some of this research effort should explore the adaptive significance of heterokairy, a specific type of plasticity that describes environmentally driven, altered timing of development within a species. This emphasis seems warranted given the pervasive occurrence of heterochrony, altered developmental timing between species, in evolution. We briefly review studies investigating heterochrony within an adaptive context across animal taxa, including examples that explore links between heterokairy and heterochrony. We then outline how sequence heterokairy could be included within the research agenda for developmental plasticity. We suggest that the study of heterokairy may be particularly pertinent in (i) determining the importance of non-adaptive plasticity, and (ii) embedding concepts from comparative embryology such as developmental modularity and disassociation within a developmental plasticity framework.