Physique as a risk factor for ulnar variance in elite female gymnasts

Wrist pain, distal radial physeal injury, and ulnar variance in the young gymnast

In gymnastics, the wrist joint is subjected to repetitive loading in a weightbearing fashion. In this setting, chronic wrist pain is quite common. Because gymnasts ordinarily enter the sport at very young ages and train for several years before skeletal maturity is attained, the growth plates of the wrist are at risk for injury. In addition, imaging studies have identified evidence of injury to the distal radial physis and the development of positive ulnar variance. Recent studies provide more information on the relationships between these findings, as well as factors that may predispose some gymnasts to wrist pain. This article provides a comprehensive review of these issues and offers suggestions for management, preventive measures, and future research.

Wrist pain, distal radial physeal injury, and ulnar variance in young gymnasts: does a relationship exist?

BACKGROUND

Chronic wrist pain affects up to 79% of young gymnasts. Distal radial growth plate injury and positive ulnar variance have also been reported in this population.

HYPOTHESIS

There is a relationship between wrist pain, radiographic findings of distal radial growth plate injury, and ulnar variance in skeletally immature young gymnasts.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

METHODS

Fifty-nine gymnasts (28 girls and 31 boys; average age, 9.3 years) completed a questionnaire detailing training and wrist pain symptoms. Each received a wrist examination, grip strength measurement, and bilateral wrist radiographs.

RESULTS

Wrist pain was reported by 56% of the gymnasts (33 of 59), with 45% (15 of 33) describing pain of at least 6 months' duration. Factors significantly associated with wrist pain included higher skill level, older age, and more years of training. For those between 10 and 14 years of age, 83% had wrist pain, compared with 44% for those outside of that age range. Fifty-one percent of the gymnasts (30 of 59) had findings of stress injury to the distal radial physis of at least a grade 2; 7% (4) had frank widening of the growth plate. Wrist pain prevalence was significantly related to the grade of radiographic injury. Mean ulnar variance was significantly more positive than established norms. Ulnar variance was not associated with wrist pain or radiographic injury of the distal radial physis.

CONCLUSIONS

Radiographic findings of distal radial physeal injury are associated with wrist pain among young nonelite gymnasts.