Telepathology using Internet multimedia electronic mail: remote consultation on gastrointestinal pathology

Feasibility and diagnostic accuracy of Internet-based dynamic telepathology between Uganda and Germany

We assessed the feasibility and diagnostic accuracy of Internet-based telepathology compared with conventional microscopic examination. A total of 96 cases from the routine workload of the Department of Pathology at the Mulago Hospital in Uganda were examined by robotic telemicroscopy via the Internet at the Fuerth Hospital in Germany. The telepathology diagnoses were compared with those of conventional microscopy. Email and Skype telephony were used to exchange clinical and diagnostic information. The reference diagnosis (gold standard) was established by consensus between two or more experienced pathologists using both conventional microscopy and telemicroscopy; immunohistochemistry was used whenever it was necessary. It took approximately 30 min for a pathologist to learn to use the telepathology system and 4–25 min to read a case remotely. Internet speed was the main limiting factor. The images were of good quality and the pathologist at the remote site was able to navigate through the slide and change the magnification as necessary. In 92 of the specimens (97%), the pathologists at the two hospitals agreed exactly about the diagnosis. Agreement overall was moderate (kappa = 0.39). The discordant diagnoses were attributed to factors related to diseases morphologically difficult to diagnose, such as soft tissue sarcomas and primitive tumours. Internet-based conferencing systems offer an inexpensive method of obtaining a primary diagnosis by telepathology and consulting on cases that require subspecialty expertise.

Virtual slide telepathology workstation of the future: lessons learned from teleradiology

The clinical reading environment for the 21st century pathologist looks very different than it did even a few short years ago. Glass slides are quickly being replaced by digital "virtual slides," and the traditional light microscope is being replaced by the computer display. There are numerous questions that arise however when deciding exactly what this new digital display viewing environment will be like. Choosing a workstation for daily use in the interpretation of digital pathology images can be a very daunting task. Radiology went digital nearly 20 years ago and faced many of the same challenges so there are lessons to be learned from these experiences. One major lesson is that there is no "one size fits all" workstation so users must consider a variety of factors when choosing a workstation. In this article, we summarize some of the potentially critical elements in a pathology workstation and the characteristics one should be aware of and look for in the selection of one. Issues pertaining to both hardware and software aspects of medical workstations will be reviewed particularly as they may impact the interpretation process.

Telemedicine consultation for patients with upper extremity disorders is reliable

Telemedicine is a valuable resource for the delivery of health care to patients in underserved areas. The purpose of this study was to assess the reliability of asynchronous teleconsultation in the diagnosis and establishment of treatment plans for patients with disorders of the upper extremity. One hundred patients with disorders of the upper extremity were prospectively evaluated. Initial patient evaluations, done by an independent evaluator, involved a medical history, physical examination, digital images of the patient, and digitized radiographic studies. This patient information was presented electronically to two hand surgeons 6 months after one surgeon independently evaluated the patients in the outpatient clinic. The physicians formulated diagnosis and treatment plans for the patients based on the blinded electronic information. These findings then were compared with the treatment plans made by the physicians at the time of the patients' visits. Telemedicine consultation resulted in excellent agreement within observers (kappa = .92) and between observers (kappa = .86). Telemedicine consultation seems to be a reliable method for diagnosis and establishment of treatment plans in the management of upper extremity disorders.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Diagnostic study, Level I-1 (testing of previously developed diagnostic criteria in series of consecutive patients--with universally applied reference gold standard). See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Diagnostic accuracy of second-opinion diagnoses based on still images

Second opinion of histological specimens is an important part of the daily routine in anatomic pathology practices. Today, extramural second opinion can be easily obtained by sending still images via an electronic network. The aim of this study was to examine the diagnostic accuracy of second opinion diagnosis based on still images selected from glass slides of 90 archived cases originally referred for extramural second opinion. Two pathologists together diagnosed first the still images (phase 1) and then the glass slides (phase 2). Phase 1 and phase 2 diagnoses were compared with the original second opinion diagnoses (OSODs). The pathologists achieved the same diagnostic results in phase 1 and in phase 2 measured against the OSOD, 67.8% (n = 61) and 68.9% (n = 62) complete agreement, respectively. In 29 cases in phase 1, the diagnoses were discordant with the OSOD. Three cases had incorrect benign diagnoses and 8 cases had incorrect malignant diagnoses. There were 8 false-negative diagnoses regarding malignancy, 6 false-positive diagnoses regarding malignancy, and 4 other discordant diagnoses. Eleven of the 29 discordant diagnoses could have had clinical implications. In interpreting these results, it is important to acknowledge the observer variability in diagnostic histopathology in general. In conclusion, the results support the concept of using still images to obtain second opinion diagnosis.

Store-and-forward diagnostic telepathology of small biopsies by e-mail attachment: a feasibility pilot study with a view for future application in Thailand diagnostic pathology services

Diagnostic telepathology by electronic mail (e-mail) attachment is relatively simple and incurs minimal cost. We assessed its accuracy and practical aspects in routine diagnostic pathology. Using 100 small biopsy specimens, a total of 1,488 images were digitized by one pathologist and sent as e-mail attachments from Nara Medical University, Japan, to a pathologist at Rajavithi Hospital, Thailand. His diagnoses were compared with his conventional light microscopy interpretation at a later date. The average total turnaround time spent on each case was 215 minutes, far less than the several days required by conventional post. There were two clinically significant errors. One was a diagnostically difficult case of colonic dysplasia, which was called carcinoma with telepathology. The other was a signet ring cell carcinoma of the stomach which was undetected with telepathology. Microscopy objective magnification and digital image quality may have played a role in impairing interpretation in both cases. Store-and-forward telepathology provides acceptable efficacy, a comparatively faster turnaround time than post and could be applied in routine work within Thai pathology services.

Tuberculosis therapy and telemedicine

Directly observed therapy (DOT) ensures patient adherence through the administration of medications by trained health department personnel. This approach has been widely adopted in tuberculosis care. Unfortunately, DOT programs require a substantial commitment of scarce public health funds and personnel time. The application of telemedicine to DOT promises considerable cost and time savings.

Internet teleconferencing method for telepathology consultations from lung and heart transplant patients

Current Internet-based teleconferencing techniques allow a referring pathologist to transmit real-time images from a microscope to a consultant, while maintaining a verbal conversation using Internet telephony. In our study, 50 randomly selected transbronchial biopsies from lung allograft recipients and 58 randomly selected endomyocardial biopsies from heart transplant patients were diagnosed by consultant pathologists using Internet-based teleconferencing methods. The referring pathologists acquired the real-time video images from the biopsies using a light microscope equipped with a phototube adapter and a video camera. The consultant pathologists viewed the processed images on a video monitor at 800 x 600 resolution, using a standard microcomputer equipped with Netmeeting software, and directed the referring pathologist to move the slide under the microscopy and/or change image magnification. The validity of telepathology diagnoses was assessed with kappa coefficients. Consultations were completed in 5 to 15 minutes per case. Sound transmission was unreliable, and in approximately 25% of consultations the referring pathologist needed to "call back" to reestablish verbal communication. In all but 2 transbronchial biopsies there was agreement between the original diagnosis and the diagnosis by telepathology (kappa = 0.92). In 48 of 58 endomyocardial biopsies there was concordance between the 2 diagnoses (kappa = 0.692). Only 3 out of 10 of these discrepancies were clinically significant (kappa = 0.897). Internet-based teleconferencing techniques provide effective and relatively inexpensive tools for real time telepathology consultations. The technology is probably best suited for the study of small specimens from patients that require rapid diagnosis by a consultant.

Teleradiology in orthopaedic surgery: impact on clinical decision making for acute fracture management

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether teleradiology improved clinical decision making for the treatment of patients with acute fractures.

DESIGN

Prospective cohort.

SETTING

Level 1 trauma center.

PATIENTS

One-hundred eight consecutive patients with 123 acute fractures who visited our Level 1 trauma center, when the first author was the attending orthopedic surgeon on call, and had orthopaedic consultations were included.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

In each case, an orthopaedic junior resident performed the emergency department consultation. Radiographs were digitized and electronically transmitted to the attending orthopaedist. Treatment plans were formulated and recorded by the attending surgeon at three different times. The original plan was defined after traditional verbal communication of physical and radiographic findings. A revised plan was defined after the radiographic images were reviewed by the attending surgeon, and the final plan was defined after review of the original radiographs. Two different types of deviations from the original plan were distinguished. Changes in the acute management were defined as any emergency department procedures, emergent operative procedures, or dispositions that were not part of the original plan. Changes in the ultimate management were defined as changes to the original plan that did not affect emergency department treatment, emergent operative procedures, or the disposition of the patient.

RESULTS

In twenty-six of the 123 fractures (21 percent), the additional information provided by viewing electronically transmitted images of radiographs changed the acute management or the ultimate management. In none of the 123 cases did subsequent review of original radiographs result in any further changes to the treatment plan.

CONCLUSIONS

The routine use of electronically transmitted digitized radiographic images has the potential to improve clinical decision making for the care of patients with acute fractures.

Legal ethical and risk issues in telemedicine

This paper summarizes the main topics of discussion at a workshop hosted by the Centre for Law Ethics and Risk in Telemedicine at the 2nd International Conference on Advances in the Delivery of Care, held at the Institute of Health Sciences, City University, London from Wednesday 24 to Friday 26 March 1999. The workshop offered a unique opportunity for practitioners in the fields of telemedicine and shared care to discuss the legal, ethical and risk issues arising from the practice of medicine and healthcare from a distance using information and communication technologies ('ICTs') with a panel of experts from the fields of medicine, law, insurance and risk management. There was a broad consensus that many of the legal and ethical issues raised by those who dislike the idea of treating distant patients were not specific to telemedicine but to medicine and healthcare in general. It was agreed, however, that in those areas where telemedicine does create new clinical risks and responsibilities a much more proactive role should be taken by the professional associations and Royal Colleges in providing better education and guidance to their members about the practical and professional issues that will inevitably arise from the evolution of 'Hospitals Without Walls'.

Telemedicine: barriers and opportunities in the 21st century

This paper aims to examine how health telematics will develop in the first 10 years of the new millennium and, in particular, to assess what operational, ethical and legal barriers may lie in the way of this development. A description of the key principles and concepts involved in telemedicine and a short historical overview of telemedicine's evolution over the past century are followed by consideration of why empirical research into 'info-ethics' and other deontological and legal issues relating to telemedicine is being necessarily catalysed by, amongst others, the European Commission. Four evolving health telematics applications are examined in some detail: electronic health records; the transmission of visual media in disciplines such as teleradiology, teledermatology, telepathology and teleophthalmology; telesurgery and robotics and the use of call centres and decision-support software. These are discussed in the light of their moral, ethical and cultural implications for clinicians, patients and society at large. The author argues that telemedicine presents unique opportunities for both patients and clinicians where it is implemented in direct response to clear clinical needs, but warns against excessive reliance upon technology to the detriment of traditional clinician-patient relationships and against complacency regarding the risks and responsibilities - many of which are as yet unknown - that distant medical intervention, consultation and diagnosis carry.

Telepathology: a diagnostic tool for the millennium?

Many developments in science have their origins in science fiction and telepathology is no exception. The concept was first illustrated in 1924 in the magazine 'Radio News'. It was not until 1980, however, that the first working telepathology system was demonstrated. Although the system was shown to work, it required special hardware, dedicated software and special microwave transmission links to be installed. Little interest was shown worldwide because of the very high cost and the inability of many people to replicate such a system. Ten years later, the personal computer (PC) was able to provide more than adequate performance at low cost for both image display quality and speed, and the development of video technology had resulted in high quality images being produced by television cameras that were now easily affordable. Microscopes were also relatively cheaper. Thus, by 1993 or 1994, all the hardware necessary to produce a telepathology system was available at reasonable cost. Telepathology can now be used for remote primary diagnosis, remote referral to a specialist pathologist, remote teaching, remote presentation of post-mortem or microscopic findings, quality assurance image circulation and feedback, and consensus diagnosis for pathological review in clinical trials. There are two residual problems. The first concerns the speed of data transmission, commonly referred to as the bandwidth. The second is that the software provided by most of the manufacturers and suppliers of these systems is not entirely suitable to the task and the systems are not interoperable. It is clear that the approach of the manufacturers is at present unlikely to produce telepathology systems which pathologists feel comfortable in using. A somewhat different approach is illustrated by the accompanying article in this issue from the Berlin group, where a relatively simple Java-based applet and the Internet are used to allow single or multiple users to view slides on a robotic microscope. This could form the basis for a truly useful system, but still needs modification for some applications.

The Internet and healthcare--the future

Images

Telepathology applications of the Internet multimedia electronic mail

Telepathology is based on the sharing of medical images coming from the microscope, and comprises different applications: intra-operative telediagnosis, second opinion teleconsultation, reference case archives, remote data and image processing, quality assessment. Since the Internet is available worldwide, it can be of interest to define which of these tasks can be performed by means of some telepathology method based on it. This paper focuses particularly on the use of Internet multimedia electronic mail for exchanging multimedia cases. To test the validity of the proposed approach for transmission of multimedia cases, the first step is to evaluate its diagnostic accuracy. Trials involving the transmission of 299 cases have been carried out between two departments of Pathology in Italy (at the University of Udine and at the City Hospital of Trento, respectively) in order to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy as well as the time needed for acquisition and transmission. First results show that good diagnostic agreement can be reached, but the time needed for transmission, generally low, is not sufficiently affordable to be adopted in those cases where time is important. In particular, telepathology through multimedia e-mail can be adopted for second opinion consultation, remote image processing, quality assessment and continuing education possibly by means of software that integrates acquisition and delivery of cases with HIS functionalities.