Non-thermal effects of 2 MHz ultrasound on the growth and cytology of Vicia faba roots

Biological effects of ultrasound: development of safety guidelines. Part I: personal histories

After the end of World War II, advances in ultrasound (US) technology brought improved possibilities for medical applications. The first major efforts in this direction were in the use of US to treat diseases. Medical studies were accompanied by experiments with laboratory animals and other model systems to investigate basic biological questions and to obtain better understanding of mechanisms. Also, improvements were made in methods for measuring and controlling acoustical quantities such as power, intensity and pressure. When diagnostic US became widely used, the scope of biological and physical studies was expanded to include conditions for addressing relevant safety matters. In this historical review, a major part of the story is told by 21 investigators who took part in it. Each was invited to prepare a brief personal account of his/her area(s) of research, emphasizing the "early days," but including later work, showing how late and early work are related, if possible, and including anecdotal material about mentors, colleagues, etc.

A review of in vitro bioeffects of inertial ultrasonic cavitation from a mechanistic perspective

This selective review of the biological effects of ultrasound presents a synopsis of our current understanding of how cells insonated in vitro are affected by inertial cavitation from the standpoint of physical and chemical mechanisms. The focus of this review is on the physical and chemical mechanisms of action of inertial cavitation which appear to be effective in causing biological effects. There are several fundamental conditions which must be satisfied before cavitation-related bioeffects may arise. First, bubbles must be created and then brought into proximity to cells. Exposure methods are critical in this regard, and simple procedures such as rotation of a vessel containing the cells during exposure can drastically alter the results. Second, once association is achieved between bubbles and cells, the former must interact with the latter to produce a bioeffect. It is not certain that the inertial event is the prime mechanism by which cells are lysed; there is evidence that the turbulence associated with bubble translation may cause lysis. Additionally, there appear to be chemical and other physical mechanisms by which inertial cavitation may affect cells; these include the generation of biologically effective sonochemicals and the apparent emission of ultraviolet (UV) and soft X-rays. The evidence for inertial cavitation occurring within cells is critically reviewed.

The response of normal and malignant cells to ultrasound in vitro

The effect of ultrasonic irradiation on the viability of normal and tumor cell cultures derived from human and mouse origins was investigated. The cells were irradiated with a frequency of 2 MHz and intensity of 0.33 W/cm2, up to 4 min and immediately tested for cell viability using four different parameters: vital staining for the determination of the rate of cell growth; [3H]-thymidine and [3H]-leucine incorporation as an indication of the rate of DNA and protein synthesis respectively; and cloning efficiency as a measurement of the cell ability to multiply. Two human normal cell lines used in our studies, FS11 foreskin fibroblasts and Wish cells, were relatively resistant to ultrasonic irradiation effect although the growth rate of the latter was somewhat affected, particularly after 2 or 4 min of irradiation. However, cells derived from either malignant melanoma or breast carcinoma were highly sensitive to irradiation as demonstrated by a reduction of 96% and 65%, respectively, in cloning efficiency even after irradiation for 1 min. A third tumor cell line derived from lung carcinoma was more resistant. Two normal clones derived from NIH/3T3 mouse fibroblasts were used. These clones revealed some degree of sensitivity, particularly after 4 min of irradiation. However, their murine-sarcoma-virus transformed counterparts were found to be even more sensitive at identical times of ultrasonic irradiation, although the differences are not as striking as demonstrated with cells from human origin.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A review of the ultrasonic bioeffects of microsonation, gas-body activation, and related cavitation-like phenomena

Ultrasonic exposures localized to regions smaller than a wavelength minimize the thermal mechanism, but promote nonthermal mechanisms of ultrasonic bioeffects. Microsonation experiments with vibrating needles or wires exploit this situation for the study of nonthermal mechanisms such as acoustic microstreaming flow. Shear stress in microstreaming flow, which is in excess of critical values for biomembranes, leads to cell lysis. Plane wave exposure of small bodies of gas also yields localized exposure, with further amplification of nonthermal mechanisms by resonance activation of oscillation. Gas body activation in vitro causes gathering of suspended cells by radiation forces, aggregation, cellular effects and lysis by microstreaming. When suitable gas bodies are present, these effects may occur at levels below the threshold for ultrasonic cavitation. In vivo, gas body activation generates intracellular microstreaming in Elodea leaves and disrupts the cells for super-critical shear stress levels. Similar phenomena seem to account for cell death, growth and mitotic index reductions in other plant tissues, and developmental abnormalities and delayed death in fruit flies. Only fragmentary and equivocal evidence presently exists on the medically relevant question of whether such subthreshold cavitation-like activity and bioeffects occur in vertebrates.

Ultrasonic effects on mammalian multicellular tumor spheroids

Mammalian multicellular tumor spheroids (MTS), grown in liquid culture medium, 0.23 to 0.32 mm in diameter and consisting of 4,500 to 12,100 cells, were exposed to three ultrasonic machines: a clinical diagnostic device with an emitted intensity of 13 mW/cm2, a therapeutic machine with emitted intensities of 1 to 3.5 W/cm2, and a laboratory emitting 12 to 50 W/cm2. (All intensities are temporal and spatial average.) Four measures of ultrasonic effect on MTS were made: decrease in diameter after treatment, damage to subsequent growth outright kill, and number of cells detached from the MTS. There was no loss in MTS size from diagnostic or therapeutic exposures. None of the exposures from any of the three machines caused any damage to subsequent growth or survival. There was no significant detachment of cells from the MTS by any of the diagnostic exposures (at 13 mW/cm2, out of 40 minutes). With the laboratory machine, a significant number of cells were detached, about 0.02% of the MTS (approximately one cell per MTS) per W/cm2 in a ten-minute exposure. Cells detached by therapeutic exposure increased linearly with exposure. On the average, 1 W/cm2 detaches about 0.5 cells per minute, per MTS, or about 0.006% of the cells in the MTS.

The role of ultrasound-induced cavitation in the 'in vitro' stimulation of collagen synthesis in human fibroblasts

Collagen synthesis by human embryonic fibroblasts in vitro was estimated using a collagenase-sensitivity assay. Collagen synthesis was stimulated by irradiation with ultrasound at a frequency of 3 MHz, a space-time peak intensity of 0.5 Wcm-2, pulsed at a mark-space ratio of 2:8 ms for 5 min at ambient pressure. This stimulation was suppressed by the application of a positive pressure of 2 atmospheres during irradiation of the cells. Increasing the pressure in the absence of ultrasound had no effect on the rate of collagen synthesis in control cells. This stimulation, therefore, appears to be due to ultrasound-induced cavitation, since it is unlikely that increasing the pressure could modify any other ultrasonic parameter. Collagen synthesis is apparently stimulated to the same extent as general protein synthesis.

Effect of 2 MHz ultrasound on DNA, RNA and protein synthesis in Pisum sativum root meristem cells

The amounts of DNA, RNA and protein synthesis were determined in Pisum sativum root meristem cells at various times after a 1 min exposure to 1 MHz ultrasound at a power density of 30 W/cm2. Immediate depressions in all three macromolecular syntheses occurred after sonication, followed by an apparent recovery several hours later. These events appear to correlate in time with the subsequent reduction and recovery in mitotic index in Pisum sativum root meristem cells exposed to 2 MHz ultrasound.

Classification and relationships of induced chromosomal structual changes

A detailed survey is given of the types and classification of primary structural changes that can be induced in chromosomes and observed at the first metaphase after the initial damage. Comments upon identification and scoring are given for the benefit of new workers. The annotation concludes with a brief discussion of the potential relationships between the primary types, and the secondary or derived types encountered in clinical studies.

Observations on the combined effect of ultrasound and x-rays on the growth of the roots of Zea mays

The roots of Zea mays seedlings were exposed to ultrasonic radiations (1 MHz) of intensities in the range of 0-1-0-8 W cm-2 (pulsed or continuous modes) for times between 2 and 60 min, together with an X-ray dose of 775 rad which was given before, after or simultaneously with the ultrasound. These experiments have shown that ultrasound and X-rays seem to act independently of each other, suggesting that the mechanism of damage due to X-rays is different from that due to ultrasound. An increase in the X-ray effectiveness under the action of ultrasound, as reported by various authors who worked with different tissues, has not been found.