Long-term observation of mouse foot reaction after hyperthermia: hyperthermia may or may not be carcinogenic?

Radio frequency radiation of millimeter wave length: potential occupational safety issues relating to surface heating

Currently, technology is being developed that makes use of the millimeter wave (MMW) range (30-300 GHz) of the radio frequency region of the electromagnetic spectrum. As more and more systems come on line and are used in everyday applications, the possibility of inadvertent exposure of personnel to MMWs increases. To date, there has been no published discussion regarding the health effects of MMWs; this review attempts to fill that void. Because of the shallow depth of penetration, the energy and, therefore, heat associated with MMWs will be deposited within the first 1-2 mm of human skin. MMWs have been used in states of the former Soviet Union to provide therapeutic benefit in a number of diverse disease states, including skin disorders, gastric ulcers, heart disease and cancer. Conversely, the possibility exists that hazards might be associated with accidental overexposure to MMWs. This review attempts to critically analyze the likelihood of such acute effects as burn and eye damage, as well as potential long-term effects, including cancer.

Hyperthermia, radiation carcinogenesis and the protective potential of vitamin A and N-acetylcysteine

The in vivo carcinogenic risk of hyperthermia, alone or in combination with irradiation, and the anti-carcinogenic potential of vitamin A and N-acetylcysteine (AcCys) were investigated. Starting 1 month before treatment, 160 rats were divided into four diet groups: no additives, vitamin A-enriched diet, AcCys and the combination vitamin A + AcCys. In 10 animals per diet group, the hind leg was treated with either X-irradiation alone (16 Gy), hyperthermia alone (60 min at 43 degrees C), hyperthermia 5 h prior to irradiation or hyperthermia 5 h after irradiation. Animals were observed for 2 years after treatment with regard to the development of tumours either inside or outside the treated volume. After 16 Gy alone 12 +/- 5% of the animals developed a tumour. Tumour incidence increased to 37 +/- 9% (borderline significance P = 0.07 versus treatment with X-rays alone) when hyperthermia was applied prior to X-rays, and to 24 +/- 8% (NS) with hyperthermia after irradiation. The relative risk ratio (RRR) for tumour induction was increased to 2.4 by hyperthermia if combined with X-irradiation. Pathological characterization of induced tumours showed that these were of the fibrosarcoma, osteosarcoma and carcinoma type. Vitamin A alone or in combination with AcCys slightly protected against the induction of tumours by X-rays without or with hyperthermia (RRR of 0.4). However, morphological changes such as lipid accumulation in hepatocytes and damage to the parenchyma were noticed in livers from all animals that were given a vitamin-A-enriched diet (P < 0.0001). Data from the present and past reports show that hyperthermia alone is not carcinogenic, but that it may increase radiation carcinogenesis. Treatment temperature and time of exposure to heat in addition to the radiation dose applied are important factors in the carcinogenic process. The enhancement of radiation carcinogenesis seems to occur independently of the sequence and time interval between irradiation and hyperthermia. However, not all data are consistent with this interpretation.

In vitro purging of clonogenic leukemic cells from human bone marrow by heat: simulation experiments for autologous bone marrow transplantation

In order to apply a simple purging method by heat to autologous bone marrow transplantation (ABMT), we have revaluated the ability to purge clonogenic leukemic cells from the simulated marrow mixture of normal marrow cells and leukemic cell lines (HL-60, Molt-3 and HEL) in vitro by heat, using two different clonogenic assays for normal granulocyte-macrophage progenitors (CFU-GM) and leukemic cell lines. It appeared that in vitro hyperthermia (42 degrees C for 120 min) is able to selectively remove clonogenic leukemic cells from simulated tumor cell-normal marrow mixtures even when leukemic cell concentrations are increased up to 3 x 10(6) cells/ml in vitro, and results in a 4-6 log destruction of clonogenic leukemic cells/ml according to a limiting dilution assay, while leaving half of normal CFU-GM surviving. The hyperthermic purging of clonogenic leukemic cells was not affected in the presence of normal marrow cells in vitro. This high level of clonogenic leukemic cell depletion by heat correlated with that of immunologic and pharmacologic studies. These results suggest that in vitro hyperthermia could be applied effectively and safely for the elimination of residual clonogenic leukemic cells in autologous marrow grafts before ABMT.

Hyperthermia promotes the incidence of tumours following X-irradiation of the rat cervical cord region

The cervical region of the rat, including the spinal cord (cervical 5-thoracic 2) was irradiated with single doses of 15-32 Gy 250 kV X-rays. Hyperthermia, at temperatures of 42-, 43- and 44 +/- 0.1 degrees C for 30 min was applied to the cervical vertebral column and immediate adjacent tissues for 5-10 min or 7 h after X-irradiation. Over a period of 18-21 months, animals were followed up to monitor neurological complications occurring as a result of damage to the spinal cord (Sminia et al. 1991). We also noted the development of neoplasms either inside or outside the cervical region. The data on tumour incidence were analysed retrospectively using the actuarial method. Although hyperthermia alone was not carcinogenic, it led to a significant increase of radiation-induced tumours. This increase of radiation carcinogenesis was observed both with hyperthermia applied 5-10 min after X-rays and with an interval of 7 h between X-rays and heat. Cancer induction was highest after the lower radiation doses (16 Gy) combined with high heat doses (30 min 44 degrees C). The latent period for induction of tumours by X-rays was 472 +/- 19 days (mean +/- SEM; n = 24). Latency was significantly shortened by hyperthermia to 404 +/- 34 days (n = 22) if applied 5-10 min after X-rays and to 348 +/- 6 days (n = 33) with an interval of 7 h. Histology revealed that 86% (38/44) of the examined tumours found inside the volume treated with hyperthermia and irradiation were sarcomas. The percentage of animals with a tumour outside the treated volume was almost the same for all treatment groups. Most of these tumours were of the mammary gland type.

Incidence of tumours in the cervical region of the rat after treatment with radiation and hyperthermia

The incidence of tumours in the irradiated cervical region in female Wistar (WU) rats after retreatment of part of the volume with hyperthermia was examined retrospectively. The cervical spinal cord (cervical 5-thoracic 2) was irradiated with a single dose of 15, 18 or 20 Gy. Ninety days thereafter, the cervical region was heated by means of a microwave applicator at a maximum temperature of 43 degrees C for 50-90 min measured at the vertebral column. Over a period of 18 months after treatment, animals were regularly observed. Neurological complications and the development of neoplasms were noted. From the 354 animals included in the study, 82 animals developed a tumour. Hyperthermia alone was not carcinogenic, but enhanced the carcinogenesis induced by radiation. The percentage of animals that developed a tumour inside the volume treated with hyperthermia 90 days after irradiation was significantly higher relative to radiation alone (33 +/- 5 per cent versus 4 +/- 2 per cent, P less than 0.001). The duration of the latent period before appearance of these tumours was not affected (355 +/- 18 days versus 425 +/- 54 days). No significant differences in the percentage of animals that developed a tumour at another site were observed between different treatment groups. Histology revealed that 88 per cent (14/16) of the examined tumours found inside the treated volume after hyperthermia and irradiation were soft tissue rhabdomyosarcomas. Outside the treated volume, most tumours were tumours of the mammary gland.

The effect of hyperthermia on the early- and late-appearing mouse foot reactions and on radiation carcinogenesis: Part II. Effect on radiation carcinogenesis (thermal enhancement and oxygen enhancement)

The effect of hyperthermia on radiation carcinogenesis was investigated in the C3Hf/Sed mouse foot. The foot was irradiated under hypoxic conditions, in air, or under hyperbaric oxygen conditions to evaluate the oxygen effect. Hyperthermia at 43.5 degrees C for 45 min was given by immersing the animal foot into a constant temperature water bath. A malignant tumor in the irradiated foot was first observed congruent to 250 days after irradiation. Tumors developed in the irradiated area until day 850. RCD50, or 50% radiation carcinogenesis dose was the endpoint and was calculated based on the tumor incidence 650 days after irradiation. RCD50 following radiation given alone under hypoxic conditions was 66.3 (60.0-73.2) Gy, and the oxygen enhancement ratio (hypoxic/hyperbaric oxygen) was 3.0 (2.5-3.5). Radiation carcinogenesis was enhanced by hyperthermia given with a 20 min treatment interval with no significant alteration in the oxygen effect. Thermal enhancement was greatest when hyperthermia was given 20 min prior to irradiation (2.5 [2.2-2.9] under hypoxia). No thermal enhancement was observed when two treatments were given with a treatment interval of 2 days. The median time to develop a malignant tumor decreased with increasing radiation dose. This median time was shorter following combined hyperthermia and irradiation (423 days) than following radiation alone (504 days). Histological studies revealed that more than 80% of tumors were soft tissue sarcomas, and the most common tumor was fibrosarcoma. Squamous cell carcinoma was found in 7% of all tumors.

The effect of hyperthermia on the early and late appearing mouse foot reactions and on the radiation carcinogenesis: effect on the early and late appearing reactions

The effect of hyperthermia on radiation-induced early- and late-appearing foot reactions was studied in C3Hf/Sed mice derived from our defined flora mouse colony. The animal foot was irradiated with 137Cs gamma-rays under hypoxic, air, or hyperbaric oxygen (O2 30 psi) conditions. Hyperthermia of 43.5 degrees C for 45 min was given locally in a water bath where a constant temperature +/- 0.1 degrees C was maintained. Treatment intervals between the 2 treatments were 20 min and 2 days. For the early-appearing reactions scores taken between the 14th and 35th post-irradiation days were averaged. Late-appearing reactions became apparent after approximately the 200th post-treatment day and increased with time. The foot reaction was enhanced by hyperthermia given 20 min before or after irradiation. Dose response curves for radiation given 20 min after hyperthermia for acute-appearing reactions lacked shoulders, whereas those following the same treatment schedule for late-appearing reactions showed significant shoulders. The thermal enhancement ratios (TER) for score 2.0 (complete epilation) early- and late-appearing reactions depended on the treatment interval and sequence. The TER values were greater for a short treatment interval (20 min.) than for a long treatment interval (2 days). Thermal enhancement was greater for hyperthermia given before irradiation compared to the reverse sequence. The TER values were always smaller for the late-appearing reactions than for the acute-appearing reactions. The relationships between early reaction scores and late reaction scores showed that the late reactions following combined heat and radiation are less extensive than those following radiation alone if they were compared at radiation doses which induced an equal level of early reactions. This difference was most significant at low early reaction scores and decreased with increasing score level.

Reversible injury after mild hyperthermia

Skin contraction and leg contracture resulted from immersion of mice legs in a water bath at temperatures of 42.5 degrees to 43.7 degrees C for 45 to 90 minutes. The maximum contracture was observed between 5 and 15 days after treatment, but little damage remained after about 30 days. After healing of the early tissue damage, there was no progression of residual damage in skin up to 490 days after treatment. In contrast, radiation-induced contracture develops rapidly after 14 days, and may continue to progress for 100 days or more. In the present studies, leg contracture could be attributed primarily to injury in the skin, because skinning the legs before measuring eliminated most of the contracture. Temperature differences between subcutaneous tissue and deep muscle were not consistently observed or statistically significant, and probably made little or no contribution to the difference in thermal response of these tissues.

Thermochemotherapy (combined cyclophosphamide and hyperthermia) with or without hyperglycemia as an adjuvant to radiotherapy

Our previous study demonstrated the presence of a thermochemotherapy-resistant cell fraction in a tumor. The present study investigated whether thermochemotherapy-resistant cells are radioresistant and whether thermochemotherapy changes the size of hypoxic cell fraction in the tumor. Early generation isotransplants of a spontaneous fibrosarcoma, FSa-II tumors, were used. A radiation dose that yields 50% tumor control rate in 150 days after local irradiation, TCD50, was determined. Cyclophosphamide (CY) was the test agent. TCD50 values of the 4 mm tumor following gamma-ray alone given under hypoxic conditions or in air were 80.9 or 65.8 Gy, respectively. Thermochemotherapy reduced TCD50 values congruent to 20 Gy, suggesting that thermochemotherapy resistant cells are not identical to the radioresistant cells. Glucose administered 60 min before thermochemotherapy further reduced TCD50 values. Foot-reaction scored in the tumor-controlled animals was significantly less severe following combined thermochemo- and radiotherapy compared to that following radiotherapy alone. Acute foot reaction studies also supported this observation. These results indicated that thermochemotherapy could be an excellent adjuvant to radiotherapy. Further studies using a 6 mm tumor indicated that thermochemotherapy was less effective on the large tumor than on the small tumor. Indirect analysis showed no significant changes in the size of hypoxic cell fraction following thermochemotherapy.