Dose-area product values in frequently performed complex paediatric radiology examinations

Paediatric urological investigations--dose comparison between urology-related and CT irradiation

BACKGROUND

Urological investigation in children frequently involves high radiation doses; however, the issue of radiation for these investigations receives little attention compared with CT.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the radiation dose from paediatric urological investigations with CT, which is commonly regarded as the more major source of radiation exposure.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted a retrospective audit in a tertiary paediatric centre of the number and radiation dose of CT scans, micturating cystourethrography exams and urological nuclear medicine scans from 2006 to 2011. This was compared with radiation doses in the literature and an audit of the frequency of these studies in Australia.

RESULTS

The tertiary centre audit demonstrated that the ratio of the frequency of urological to CT examinations was 0.8:1 in children younger than 17 years. The ratio of the radiation dose of urological to CT examinations was 0.7:1. The ratio in children younger than 5 years was 1.9:1. In Australia the frequency of urological procedures compared with CT was 0.4:1 in children younger than 17 years and 3.1:1 in those younger than 5 years. The ratio of radiation-related publications was 1:9 favouring CT.

CONCLUSION

The incidence and radiation dose of paediatric urological studies is comparable to those of CT. Nevertheless the radiation dose of urological procedures receives considerably less attention in the literature.

Avaliação das doses de radiação em uretrocistografia miccional de crianças

OBJETIVO: Analisar o produto dose-área, a dose de entrada na pele do paciente e as doses relativas à fluoroscopia e às radiografias em exames de cistouretrografia miccional em crianças. MATERIAIS E MÉTODOS: Foram avaliados os procedimentos em 37 pacientes, realizados por quatro médicos do serviço. As medições foram realizadas com um equipamento composto de uma câmara de ionização acoplada diretamente à saída do tubo de raios X e um eletrômetro (Diamentor) ligado diretamente ao computador, para a coleta dos dados. RESULTADOS: Foi observada alguma heterogeneidade na realização do procedimento, que não segue padrão de técnica radiográfica. São realizadas em média 11 radiografias por exame, usando tempo longo de fluoroscopia, com dose média final mais alta que a encontrada em referências da literatura. CONCLUSÃO: A adoção da técnica de alta quilovoltagem nas radiografias e o uso restrito da fluoroscopia podem proporcionar importante redução das doses durante a realização deste procedimento, porque o maior contribuinte para as altas doses verificadas foi a utilização da fluoroscopia.

Organ and effective doses in infants undergoing upper gastrointestinal (UGI) fluoroscopic examination

To provide more detailed data on organ and effective doses in digital upper gastrointestinal (UGI) fluoroscopy studies of newborns and infants, the present study was conducted employing the time-sequence videotape-analysis technique used in a companion study of newborn and infant voiding cystourethrograms (VCUG). This technique was originally pioneered [O. H. Suleiman, J. Anderson, B. Jones, G. U. Rao, and M. Rosenstein, Radiology 178, 653-658 (1991)] for adult UGI examinations. Individual video frames were analyzed to include combinations of field size, field center, x-ray projection, image intensifier, and magnification mode. Additionally, the peak tube potential and the mA or mAs values for each segment/subsegment or digital photospot were recorded for both the fluoroscopic and radiographic modes of operation. The data from videotape analysis were then used in conjunction with a patient-scalable newborn tomographic computational phantom to report both organ and effective dose values via Monte Carlo radiation transport. The study includes dose estimates for five simulated UGI examinations representative of patients ranging from three to six months of age. Effective dose values for UGI examinations ranged from 1.17 to 6.47 mSv, with a mean of 3.14 mSv and a large standard deviation of 2.15 mSv. The colon, lungs, stomach, liver, and esophagus absorbed doses in sum were found to constitute between 63 and 75% of the effective dose in these UGI studies. Representing 23-30% of the effective dose, the lungs were found to be the most significant organ in the effective dose calculation. Approximately 80-95% of the effective dose is contributed by the dynamic fluoroscopy segments with larger percentages found in longer studies. The mean effective dose for newborn UGI examinations was not found to be statistically different from that seen in newborn VCUG examinations.

Organ and effective doses in newborns and infants undergoing voiding cystourethrograms (VCUG): A comparison of stylized and tomographic phantoms

The time-sequence videotape-analysis methodology, developed [Sulieman et al., Radiology 178, 653-658 (1991)] for use in tissue dose estimations in adult fluoroscopy examinations and utilized [Bolch et al., Med. Phys. 30, 667-680 (2003)] for analog fluoroscopy in newborn patients, has been extended to the study of digital fluoroscopic examinations of the urinary bladder in newborn and infant female patients. Individual frames of the fluoroscopic and radiographic video were analyzed with respect to unique combinations of field size, field center, projection, tube potential, and tube current (mA), and integral tube current (mAs), respectively. The dosimetry study was conducted on five female patients of ages ranging from four-days to 66 days. For each patient, three different phantoms were utilized: a stylized computational phantom of the reference newborn (3.5 kg), a tomographic computational phantom of the reference newborn (3.5 kg), and (3) a tomographic computational phantom uniformly rescaled to match patient total-body mass. The latter phantom set circumvented the need for mass-dependent rescaling of recorded technique factors (kVp, mA, mAs, etc.), and thus represented the highest degree of patient specificity in the individual organ dose assessment. Effective dose values for the voiding cystourethrogram examination ranged from 0.6 to 3.2 mSv, with a mean and standard deviation of 1.8+/-0.9 mSv. The ovary and colon equivalent doses contributed in total approximately 65%-80% of the effective dose in these fluoroscopy studies. Percent differences in the effective dose assessed using the two tomographic phantoms (one fixed at 3.5 kg with rescaled technique factors rescaled and one physically rescaled to individual patient masses with no adjustment of recorded technique factors) ranged for -49% to +15%. Percent differences in effective dose found using the 3.5 kg stylized phantom and the 3.5 kg tomographic phantom, both with patient-specific rescaling of technique factors, ranged from -10% to +17%. These differences are due in part to a reduced ovary dose in the tomographic phantom for right posterior oblique (RPO) views when compared to those seen in the stylized phantom.

Mesure pratique de l’irradiation en radiopédiatrie : utilisation du produit dose surface en fluorographie numérique et pour les radiographies pulmonaires néonatales

PURPOSE

Control of radiation dose in pediatric radiology requires knowledge of the reference levels for all examinations. These data are useful for daily quality assessment, but are not perfectly known for some radiographic examinations. The purpose of our study was to evaluate the dose related to voiding cystourethrograms (VCUG), upper GI (UGI) and intravenous urography (IVU). Neonatal chest radiographs in the intensive care unit were also evaluated.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

For examinations with contrast material (478VCUG, 220UGI, 80IVU), the children were divided in groups based on their weight, from 5 to 30 Kg. Measurements were performed using an ionization chamber and expressed with the dose-area product (DAP). For chest radiographs, a direct measurement of the entrance-skin dose was performed, with secondary calculation of the DAP.

RESULTS

For VCUGs, the DAP ranged between 42.89cGy.cm2 and 125.41cGy.cm2. The range was between 76.43 and 150.62cGy.cm2 for UGIs and between 49.06 and 83.33cGy.cm2 for IVUs. For neonate chest radiographs, DAP calculations were between 0.29 and 0.99cGy.cm2.

CONCLUSION

These values represent our reference doses. They allow continuous monitoring of our radiographic technical parameters and radiographic equipment and help to correct and improve them if necessary.

A video analysis technique for organ dose assessment in pediatric fluoroscopy: applications to voiding cystourethrograms (VCUG)

The time-sequence videotape-analysis methodology, originally developed by Sulieman et al. [Radiol. 178, 653-658 (1991)] for use in tissue dose estimation in adult fluoroscopy exams, has been adapted to the study of the newborn voiding cystourethrogram (VCUG). Individual frames of fluoroscopic and radiographic video were analyzed with respect to unique combinations of field size, field center, projection, tube potential, and mA or mAs, respectively. A modified version of the stylized ORNL newborn model was coupled to the MCNP4C radiation transport code to report organ doses per unit entrance air kerma (free-in-air) for each identified x-ray field. A series of urinary bladder models was additionally developed representing the organ at differing stages of contrast filling. The technique was subsequently applied to two patients, a 3-month male and a 1-month female, examined via a conventional fluoroscopy system used just prior to departmental conversion to digital systems. The effective dose to these patients was estimated as 0.47 mSv and 1.36 mSv, respectively (ratio of 2.9). Corresponding ratios of cumulative fluoroscopy time and entrance air kerma were 2.2 and 1.6, respectively. For the male patient, the mean percent dose contribution from fluoroscopy for all irradiated organs was 71 +/- 12%, while that value for the female patient was 88 +/- 4%.

Comparison of radiation dose from intravenous urography and 99Tcm DMSA scintigraphy in children

Intravenous urography (i.v.u.) and 99Tcm DMSA scintigraphy are possible alternative diagnostic techniques in paediatric renal investigation. Radiation dose comparisons between them have been complicated in the past by the lack of paediatric data. In this study, evaluations relevant to children are used to compare estimates of effective dose from the two techniques. For the radiographic procedures, standard operating parameters and representative age-dependent values of entrance surface dose were established from recent literature. Conversion factors relating effective dose to entrance surface dose and dose-area product are presented and used to obtain values of effective dose for single radiographs of abdomen, kidneys and pelvis. Suggested i.v.u. procedures consisting of four ("minimum") or eight ("average") radiographs were adopted to derive the effective dose for full i.v.u. examinations. 99Tcm DMSA dose estimates, taken from our published work using an administered activity schedule based on body surface area, are almost constant at about 1 mSv for all children. In comparison, mean i.v.u. doses based on the "average" number of radiographs are similar to DMSA doses for infants (< 1 year) but may be twice as high for older children. Although the differences between procedures at this level of dose do not in themselves provide grounds for preference, when coupled with the lower diagnostic sensitivity of i.v.u. they suggest limitations of this procedure for detection of a renal scar.

The average dose-area product at intravenous urography in 205 adults

The intravenous urography (IVU) is the most important and most frequently performed radiological examination in urology. This prospective study determined the dose-area product as a measurement of radiation dose in 205 adult patients undergoing IVU. Average dose-area product was 1017 cGy cm2. An average 3.7 radiographs were obtained per patient. Tomographic views were required in only 8.8% of cases. Radiation dose is dependent not only on the number and size of the obtained radiographs, but on the physical constitution of the patient. The dose-area products measured show a clear relationship to the body weight of the patient.