Main clinical, therapeutic and technical factors related to patient's maximum skin dose in interventional cardiology procedures

Radiation doses during cardiac catheterisation procedures in India: a multicentre study: Radiation dose study

AIMS

Established, evidence-based measures of radiation are required to minimise its hazards, while maintaining adequate image quality. The aim of this study is to evaluate radiation data and generate reference radiation levels for commonly performed coronary catheterisation procedures in India.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In this prospective, observational study, all procedures were performed in accordance with the established standards using Innova IGS 520/2100-IQ catheterisation laboratories. Demographic, procedural and radiation data were collected. Dose reference limits (DRL) were established as the 75th percentile of the total distribution. There were 2,906 coronary angiograms (CAG), 750 percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI) and 715 CAG+PCI. DRLs for dose area product were: 19.6 Gy·cm2 for CAG, 49.8 Gy·cm2 for PCI and 72.0 Gy·cm2 for CAG+PCI, respectively. Median cumulative air kerma levels were: 185 mGy for CAG, 533mGy for PCI, and 891 mGy for CAG+PCI. Male gender, higher BMI, combining CAG+PCI, fluoroscopy time, number of cine frames, and image acquisition settings were significant contributors to increased radiation dose.

CONCLUSIONS

This study established reference radiation dose levels for diagnostic and interventional coronary procedures in India, which were comparable to and in the lower range of international standards.

IMPACT OF PELVIC AND RAD-BOARD LEAD SHIELDS ON OPERATOR AND PATIENT RADIATION DOSE IN TRANS-RADIAL CORONARY PROCEDURES

BACKGROUND

Trans-radial approach for cardiac catheterisation procedures has long been associated with high operator and patient radiation dose. The aim of the present study was to determine the effect of pelvic and radial shields on decreasing coronary procedure radiation doses.

METHODS

A total of 418 patients randomly underwent diagnostic and therapeutic cardiac procedures with and without the pelvic and rad-board lead shields during the procedures. The operator and patient doses were then determined by means of a personal dosimeter and dose area product (DAP), respectively.

RESULTS

The shields decreased the operator radiation dose by 40% in coronary angiography (CA) and by 45% during angioplasty (PCI). These results were achieved at the cost of increased patient radiation dose.

CONCLUSION

Pelvic lead shields combined with rad-board shields are highly effective in reducing operator radiation dose in trans-radial approach, but it is only achieved at the cost of increased patient DAP.

[Evaluation of the incidence of radiodermatitis lesions in interventional cardiology]

PURPOSE

The percutaneous coronary interventions use large doses of ionizing radiation, particularly when treating complex lesions. The incidence of radio-induced skin lesions is poorly known. Our goal was to evaluate the frequency of occurrence of such lesions, as well as the factors that may contribute to a high radiation dose. The recommended DAP (dose-area product) cutoff for skin monitoring after percutaneous coronary interventions is 500Gy cm².

PATIENTS AND METHOD

We prospectively studied the incidence of acute (after 5-7 days) and subacute (after 7 days to 6 months) skin lesions following angioplasty with a dose-area product (DAP) ≥200Gy cm² in patients who underwent coronary angioplasty in our center in 2013.

RESULTS

Nine hundred and thirty three consecutive procedures were analyzed, of which 102 with a DAP ≥200Gy cm². Three patients presented an acute lesion. Two of these three patients also had subacute lesions. Another patient presented only a subacute lesion. 4.82% (95% CI: [0-10]) of the patients with a DAP ≥200Gy cm² developed radiodermitis lesions, or 0.47% (95% CI: [0-0.9]) of all the patients who underwent angioplasty. The Body Mass Index and the elective (as opposed to energy) procedures were independently associated with a procedure with a DAP ≥200Gy cm².

CONCLUSION

Radiodermatitis lesions occur for 4.82% of patients benefiting from procedures with a DAP ≥200Gy cm². We suggest the establishment of a DAP threshold for dermal monitoring of patients of 200Gy cm² per procedure instead of 500Gy cm².

MEASUREMENT OF PATIENT SKIN DOSE DISTRIBUTIONS IN THREE LEBANESE INTERVENTIONAL CARDIOLOGY SUITES

Using a mesh of 30 thermoluminescent dosemeters, adults' patient skin doses were measured for 99 coronary angiography (CA) and 89 percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI) performed in three Lebanese hospitals. Average peak skin dose (Dskin,max) were 152 mGy (range: 16-1144) for CAs and 576 mGy (range: 7-3361) for PCIs. While only four patients had a Dskin,max value exceeding the 2 Gy threshold for skin injuries, several patients had skin dose values above 1 Gy at several distinct locations proving that Dskin,max alone is not sufficient for repetitive procedures; 2D dose maps are required instead. Dskin,max correlated well with total air kerma-area product (PKA,T) for PCI in Hospitals 1 and 2 (R = 0.91 and 0.76, respectively) enabling the setup of an alert level at PKA,T = 240 and 210 Gy cm2, respectively, corresponding to a Dskin,max of 2 Gy. This was not possible for Hospital 3 due to weak correlations between Dskin,max and PKA,T.

Determinants of Greater Peak Radiation Skin Dose in Contemporary Percutaneous Coronary Interventions

BACKGROUND

Skin radiation injuries, especially radiation ulcers, are serious side effects caused by ionizing radiation during percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI). Because skin radiation injuries are closely associated with the peak skin dose, it is important to minimize the peak skin dose. The aim of the present study was to investigate the determinants of greater peak skin dose in current PCI.

METHODS

We included 707 consecutive coronary artery lesions, and divided them into an excess radiation group (n = 26; defined as peak skin dose ≥2 Gy) and a standard radiation group (n = 681; defined as peak skin dose <2 Gy). Clinical, lesion, and procedural characteristics were compared between the 2 groups. Univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses were performed to identify determinants of the excess radiation group.

RESULTS

A multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that body surface area (BSA) [0.1 m² increase: odds ratio (OR) 1.39, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.13-1.71, P < 0.01], PCI to a right coronary artery (RCA) (OR 3.11, 95% CI 1.35-7.17, P < 0.01), and PCI to a chronic total occlusion (CTO) (OR 6.69, 95% CI 2.65-16.87, P < 0.01) were significantly associated with the excess radiation group.

CONCLUSIONS

Greater BSA, PCI to RCA lesions, and PCI to CTO lesions were significantly associated with excess radiation dose. The first step in the prevention of radiation injuries in current PCI will be to recognize these risk factors.

PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION OF RADIATION DOSE TO PATIENTS FROM CARDIOVASCULAR INTERVENTIONAL PROCEDURES IN TANZANIA

Although contemporary cardiac X-ray exams are typically set so benefits outweighs the risk, the growing use and increasing complexity of the cardiovascular interventional radiological (CVIR) procedures does increase the risk of radiation-related tissue effects and stochastic effects to the individual patients and the population. In view of these radiological concerns there is a need to investigate factors that influence the doses received by the patients and enable optimisation needed. The air kerma area product (KAP), cumulative air kerma (CAK) and fluoroscopy time (FT) to patients from two major CVIR procedures: coronary angiography (CA) and percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI), were obtained from two major hospitals in Tanzania. The CAK and KAP were determined using ionisation chambers equipped in each angiographic unit. The median values of the KAP, CAK and FT for the CA procedures were 37.8 Gy cm2, 425.5 mGy and 7.6 min, respectively, while for the PCI were 86.5 Gy cm2, 1180.3 mGy and 19.0 min, respectively. The overall differences among individual KAP, CAK and FT values across the two hospitals investigated differed by factors of up to 33.5, 58.7 and 26.3 for the CA, while for the PCI procedures differed by factors of up to 10.9, 25.3 and 13.8, respectively. The mean values of KAP and FT for both CA and PCI were mostly higher than those reported values for Ireland, Belgium, Greece, France, China and Australia. The third quartiles of the KAP, CAK and FT for both CA and PCI were relatively above the preliminary diagnostic reference levels proposed by the IAEA, DIMOND III and SENTINEL. The observed substantial variations of mean values of technical parameters and patient doses (KAP, CAK and FT values) observed for the CA and PCI procedures inter and intra-hospitals were mainly explained by the complexity of the CVIR procedures, the nature of pathology, patient-specific characteristics, the variation in levels of skills and experiences among IC personnel, and the different procedural protocols employed among interventional cardiologists and hospitals. The observed great variations of procedural protocols and patient doses within and across the hospitals and relative higher dose than reported values from the literature call for the need to optimise radiation dose to patient from IC procedures.

DOSIMETRY DURING PERCUTANEOUS CORONARY INTERVENTIONS OF CHRONIC TOTAL OCCLUSIONS

Percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI) of coronary chronic total occlusions (CTO) increase the risk of high radiation exposure for both the patient and the cardiologist. This study evaluated the maximum dose to the patients' skin (MSD) and the exposure of the cardiologists during CTO-PCI. Moreover, the efficiency of radioprotective drapes to reduce cardiologist exposure was assessed. Patient dose was measured during 31 procedures; dose to the cardiologist's extremities were measured during 65 procedures, among which 31 were performed with radioprotective drapes. The MSD was high (median: 1254 mGy; max: 6528 mGy), and higher than 2 Gy for 33% of the patients. The dose to the cardiologists' extremities per procedure was also of concern (median: 25-465 μSv), particularly to the left eye (median: 68 μSv; max: 187 μSv). Radioprotective drapes reduced the exposure to physician's upper limbs and eyes; especially to the left side (from -28 to -49%).

Radiation dose from percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty procedure performed using a flat detector for different clinical angiographic projections

The radiation dose from complex cardiac procedures is of concern due to the lengthy fluoroscopic screening time and vessel complexities. This study intends to assess radiation dose based on angiographic projection and vessel complexities for clinical protocols used in the performance of percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA). Dose-area product (DAP), reference air kerma (K _a,r) and real-time monitoring of tube potentials and tube current for each angiographic projection and dose setting were evaluated for 66 patients who underwent PTCA using a flat detector system. The mean DAP and cumulative K _a,r were 32.71 Gy cm² (0.57 Gy), 51.24 Gy cm² (0.9 Gy) and 102.03 Gy cm² (1.77 Gy) for single-, double- and triple-vessel PTCA, respectively. Among commonly used angiographic projections, left anterior oblique 45°-caudal 35° reached 2 Gy in 55 min using a low-dose fluoroscopy setting and 21 min for a medium-dose setting. Use of a low-dose setting for fluoroscopic screening showed a radiation dose reduction of 39% compared with a medium-dose setting.

Comparison of Patient Skin Dose Evaluated Using Radiochromic Film and Dose Calculation Software

PURPOSE

To compare, in an interventional radiology setting, peak skin doses (PSDs) delivered as calculated using a dedicated software tool and as measured using radiochromic film. To assess the utility of this dose calculation software tool in routine clinical practice.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

First, radiochromic films were positioned on the examination table in the back of an adult anthropomorphic phantom to measure PSD, and X-ray examinations were simulated. Then, films were again positioned in the patient's back for 59 thoracic or abdominopelvic endovascular interventions. The results obtained with the radiochromic films were taken as a reference and were statistically compared with those of the software.

RESULTS

With measured PSDs ranging from 100 to 7000 mGy, the median software-film difference was 8.5%. Lin's concordance coefficient was 0.98 [0.97; 0.99] (p < 0.001), meaning that concordance was excellent between the two methods. For the films where PSD exceeded 1000 mGy, the median difference in the measured value was 8.7% [- 1.3; 21.1], with a maximum discrepancy of 34%. Lin's concordance coefficient was 0.98 [0.96; 1] (p < 0.001), meaning that concordance was excellent between the two methods.

CONCLUSION

Comparison between radiochromic films and the software tool showed that the software is a suitable tool for a simple and reliable estimation of PSD. The software seems to be a good alternative to films, whose use remains complex.

Assessment of Patient's Peak Skin Dose Using Gafchromic Films During Interventional Cardiology Procedures: Routine Experience Feedback

To assess the interest of Gafchromic films in detection of patient's peak skin dose (PSD) in interventional cardiology. A prospective study of 112 patients was conducted (July-December 2015). Three diagnostic and therapeutic procedures were evaluated: coronary angiography (CA), coronary angiography and coronary angioplasty for one or two vessels disease (CA-PTCA) and coronary angioplasty of complex chronic total occlusion (CTO). Dosimetric indicators (DIs) were collected and PSD were measured with Gafchromic films. Dose distribution was evaluated within 10 'Thorax Body-zone' defined by the system. Correlations between PSD and DI or dose distribution were computed. Delivered dose increased in complex procedures. The PSD were 0.121 ± 0.063 Gy for CA, 0.256 ± 0.142 Gy for CA-PTCA and 1.116 ± 0.721 Gy for CTO. High correlations were observed for PSD and DI as well for dose distribution within the 'Thorax Body-zone'. Film dosimetry is suggested for CTO procedures since the threshold of 2 Gy for skin injuries is likely to be exceeded.

Novel X-ray image noise reduction technology reduces patient radiation dose while maintaining image quality in coronary angiography

AIMS

The consequences of high radiation dose for patient and staff demand constant improvements in X-ray dose reduction technology. This study assessed non-inferiority of image quality and quantified patient dose reduction in interventional cardiology for an anatomy-specific optimised cine acquisition chain combined with advanced real-time image noise reduction algorithms referred to as 'study cine', compared with conventional angiography.

METHODS

Fifty patients underwent two coronary angiographic acquisitions: one with advanced image processing and optimised exposure system settings to enable dose reduction (study cine) and one with standard image processing and exposure settings (reference cine). The image sets of 39 patients (18 females, 21 males) were rated by six experienced independent reviewers, blinded to the patient and image characteristics. The image pairs were randomly presented. Overall 85 % of the study cine images were rated as better or equal quality compared with the reference cine (95 % CI 0.81-0.90). The median dose area product per frame decreased from 55 to 26 mGy.cm(2)/frame (53 % reduction, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that the novel X-ray imaging technology provides non-inferior image quality compared with conventional angiographic systems for interventional cardiology with a 53 % patient dose reduction.

Patient's Radiation Exposure in Coronary Angiography and Angioplasty: The Impact of Different Projections

Introduction: We aimed to determine angiography projections with lower Dose Area Product (DAP) rate by measuring the mean DAP and fluoroscopy times in coronary angiography (CAG) and percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) and calculating DAP rate in different projections.

Methods: DAP and fluoroscopy times were measured in all employed projections in real-time in 75 patients who underwent CAG or PCI by a single cardiologist in Madani Cardiovascular University Hospital (45 in CAG group and 30 in PCI group). DAP rate was calculated in both groups and in all projections. The projections with highest and lowest DAP rate were determined.

Results: Mean DAP was 436.73±315.85 dGy×cm² in CAG group and 643.26±359.58 dGy×cm² in PCI group. The projection 40° LAO/0° had the highest DAP rate in CAG group (28.98 dGy×cm²/ sec) and it was highest in 20° RAO/30° CR in PCI group (29.83 dGy×cm²/sec). The latter projection was also the most employed projection in PCI group.

Conclusion: The amount of radiation dose in this study is in consistent with the previous reports. Specific angiographic projections expose patients to significantly higher radiation and they should be avoided and replaced by less irradiating projections whenever possible.

Overall measurements of dose to patients in common interventional cardiology procedures

This study was designed to measure peak skin dose (PSD), dose-area product (DAP), cumulative dose (CD) and fluoroscopy time (FT) for interventional cardiology procedures and to evaluate whether patient doses were higher than that in other published data. Three cardiac procedure types, including coronary angiography (CAG), percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) and radio frequency (RF) ablation, were entered into the study. Data of four special metrics (PSD, DAP, CD and FT) for these procedures were collected and measured. A total of 238 patients who underwent interventional radiology procedures participated in this study. For every procedure, data about PSD were resulted from six TLD arrays and DAP, CD and FT were collected from the displayed monitor. The mean, standard deviation (SD), range and third quartile of the distribution of PSD, DAP, CD and FT recorded and measured on spot were calculated for all procedures. High-dose cases were specifically recorded. There was wide variation in the doses observed for different instances of the same procedure. PSD for PTCA and RF ablation ranged from 0.1 Gy to more than 3 Gy. Of 238 instances, there were 22 (9.2 %) with PSDs greater than 2 Gy and 4 (1.7 %) than 3 Gy. The third quartile of the distribution for PTCA had exceeded the DIMOND preliminary reference levels by 41.1 % in DAP and 25.0 % in FT. Mean DAP was in the range of reported values for CAG procedure, but higher than all data obtained in literatures for PTCA. Data from this study are in the range of most reported values for CAG and RF ablation procedure, while higher than that obtained in some literatures for PTCA. In case of a constant delivering of high doses to patient and physician himself, thorough training of interventionalists and staff is necessary, and the legislation has to be revised and set dose constrains especially for the interventional high-dose procedures.

Understanding and Minimising Occupational Radiation in the Catheterisation Laboratory with PISAX and the ACIST CVi® Contrast Delivery System

This paper provides an overview of radiation exposure and its associated risks in the cardiac catheterisation laboratory (cath lab), as well as strategies to minimise radiation exposure for operators, cath lab staff and patients. The benefits of using a mobile 2 mm lead equivalent radiation shield (PISAX) and adoption of an automated contrast injection system (the ACIST CVi® Contrast Delivery System) are discussed, and the potential advantages of their combination are reviewed.