Detection of RNA nucleoside modifications with the uridine-specific ribonuclease MC1 from Momordica charantia

Analysis of RNA and Its Modifications

Ribonucleic acids (RNAs) are key biomolecules responsible for the transmission of genetic information, the synthesis of proteins, and modulation of many biochemical processes. They are also often the key components of viruses. Synthetic RNAs or oligoribonucleotides are becoming more widely used as therapeutics. In many cases, RNAs will be chemically modified, either naturally via enzymatic systems within a cell or intentionally during their synthesis. Analytical methods to detect, sequence, identify, and quantify RNA and its modifications have demands that far exceed requirements found in the DNA realm. Two complementary platforms have demonstrated their value and utility for the characterization of RNA and its modifications: mass spectrometry and next-generation sequencing. This review highlights recent advances in both platforms, examines their relative strengths and weaknesses, and explores some alternative approaches that lie at the horizon.

Mapping m6A Sites on HIV-1 RNA Using Oligonucleotide LC-MS/MS

The biological significance of chemical modifications to the ribonucleic acid (RNA) of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) has been recognized. However, our understanding of the site-specific and context-dependent roles of these chemical modifications remains limited, primarily due to the absence of nucleotide-resolution mapping of modification sites. In this study, we present a method for achieving nucleotide-resolution mapping of chemical modification sites on HIV-1 RNA using liquid chromatography and tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). LC-MS/MS, a powerful tool capable of directly analyzing native RNAs, has proven effective for mapping RNA modifications in small RNA molecules, including ribosomal RNA and transfer RNA. However, longer RNAs have posed challenges, such as the 9 Kb HIV-1 virion RNA, due to the complexity of and ambiguity in mass differences among RNase T1-cleaved RNA fragments in LC-MS/MS data. Here, we introduce a new target RNA enrichment method to isolate small local RNA fragments of HIV-1 RNA that potentially harbor site-specific N6-methyladenosine (m6A) modifications. In our initial trial, we used target-specific DNA probes only and encountered insufficient RNA fragmentation due to inefficient S1 digestion near the target site. Recognizing that inefficient S1 digestion by HIV-1 RNA is likely due to the formation of secondary structures in proximity to the target site, we designed multiple DNA probes annealing to various sites of HIV-1 RNA to better control the structures of RNA substrates for S1 digestion. The use of these non-target DNA probes significantly improved the isolation of more homogeneous target RNA fragments of approximately 50 bases in length. Oligonucleotide LC-MS/MS analysis of these isolated target RNA fragments successfully separated and detected both m6A-methylated and non-methylated oligomers at the two m6A-predicted sites. The principle of this new target enrichment strategy holds promise and should be broadly applicable to the analysis of any lengthy RNA that was previously deemed infeasible for investigation using oligonucleotide LC-MS/MS.

Nuclease P1 Digestion for Bottom-Up RNA Sequencing of Modified siRNA Therapeutics

siRNA therapeutics provide a selective and powerful approach to reduce the expression of disease-causing genes. For regulatory approval, these modalities require sequence confirmation which is typically achieved by intact tandem mass spectrometry sequencing. However, this process produces highly complex spectra which are difficult to interpret and typically results in less than full sequence coverage. We sought to develop a bottom-up siRNA sequencing platform to ease sequencing data analysis and provide full sequence coverage. Analogous to bottom-up proteomics, this process requires chemical or enzymatic digestion to reduce the oligonucleotide length down to analyzable lengths, but siRNAs commonly contain modifications that inhibit the degradation process. We tested six digestion schemes for their feasibility to digest the 2' modified siRNAs and identified that nuclease P1 provides an effective digestion workflow. Using a partial digestion, nuclease P1 provides high 5' and 3' end sequence coverage with multiple overlapping digestion products. Additionally, this enzyme provides high-quality and highly reproducible RNA sequencing no matter the RNA phosphorothioate content, 2'-fluorination status, sequence, or length. Overall, we developed a robust enzymatic digestion scheme for bottom-up siRNA sequencing using nuclease P1, which can be implemented into existing sequence confirmation workflows.

Human RNase 4 improves mRNA sequence characterization by LC–MS/MS

With the rapid growth of synthetic messenger RNA (mRNA)-based therapeutics and vaccines, the development of analytical tools for characterization of long, complex RNAs has become essential. Tandem liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS) permits direct assessment of the mRNA primary sequence and modifications thereof without conversion to cDNA or amplification. It relies upon digestion of mRNA with site-specific endoribonucleases to generate pools of short oligonucleotides that are then amenable to MS-based sequence analysis. Here, we showed that the uridine-specific human endoribonuclease hRNase 4 improves mRNA sequence coverage, in comparison with the benchmark enzyme RNase T1, by producing a larger population of uniquely mappable cleavage products. We deployed hRNase 4 to characterize mRNAs fully substituted with 1-methylpseudouridine (m¹Ψ) or 5-methoxyuridine (mo⁵U), as well as mRNAs selectively depleted of uridine–two key strategies to reduce synthetic mRNA immunogenicity. Lastly, we demonstrated that hRNase 4 enables direct assessment of the 5′ cap incorporation into in vitro transcribed mRNA. Collectively, this study highlights the power of hRNase 4 to interrogate mRNA sequence, identity, and modifications by LC–MS/MS.

RNA Cleavage Properties of Nucleobase-Specific RNase MC1 and Cusativin Are Determined by the Dinucleotide-Binding Interactions in the Enzyme-Active Site

Knowledge of the cleavage specificity of ribonucleases is critical for their application in RNA modification mapping or RNA-protein binding studies. Here, we detail the cleavage specificity and efficiency of ribonuclease MC1 and cusativin using a customized RNA sequence that contained all dinucleotide combinations and homopolymer sequences. The sequencing of the oligonucleotide digestion products by a semi-quantitative liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (LC-MS) analysis documented as little as 0.5-1% cleavage levels for a given dinucleotide sequence combination. While RNase MC1 efficiently cleaved the [A/U/C]pU dinucleotide bond, no cleavage was observed for the GpU bond. Similarly, cusativin efficiently cleaved Cp[U/A/G] dinucleotide combinations along with UpA and [A/U]pU, suggesting a broader specificity of dinucleotide preferences. The molecular interactions between the substrate and active site as determined by the dinucleotide docking studies of protein models offered additional evidence and support for the observed substrate specificity. Targeted alteration of the key amino acid residues in the nucleotide-binding site confirms the utility of this in silico approach for the identification of key interactions. Taken together, the use of bioanalytical and computational approaches, involving LC-MS and ligand docking of tertiary structural models, can form a powerful combination to help explain the RNA cleavage behavior of RNases.

On-line Sequencing of CRISPR Guide RNAs and Their Impurities via the Use of Immobilized Ribonuclease Cartridges Attached to a 2D/3D-LC-MS System

In this study, for the first time, the automated digestion and sequencing of an RNA molecule via the use of immobilized RNase cartridges attached to a multidimensional liquid chromatography (LC)-mass spectrometry (MS) system are presented. We first developed an on-line digestion-HILIC two-dimensional (2D)-LC-MS method in order to sequence CRISPR guide RNAs for gene editing. Three RNases (T1, A, and U2) were immobilized on polyetheretherketone cartridges, and their performance was evaluated. Ultrafast digestions were performed within 2.3 min with the on-line approach versus 30 min via the conventional off-line approach. The higher sequence coverage was achieved by the RNase T1 (71%), which is the same as the off-line mode. A 20-fold reduction in the gRNA sample amount was achieved with the on-line digestion approach (6.5 μg) in comparison to that with the off-line approach (130 μg). In the second step, a three-dimensional (3D)-LC-MS method was developed for the sequencing of fractions collected on-line across the main peak and the partially separated tail by the reference ion-pairing RPLC method. Additional insights were gained in order to better understand the cause of the main peak tailing.

Technical challenges in defining RNA modifications

It is well established that DNA base modifications play a key role in gene regulation during development and in response to environmental stress. This type of epigenetic control of development and environmental responses has been intensively studied over the past few decades. Similar to DNA, various RNA species also undergo modifications that play important roles in, for example, RNA splicing, protein translation, and the avoidance of immune surveillance by host. More than 160 different types of RNA modifications have been identified. In addition to base modifications, RNA modification also involves splicing of pre-mRNAs, leading to as many as tens of transcript isoforms from a single pre-RNA, especially in higher organisms. However, the function, prevalence and distribution of RNA modifications are poorly understood. The lack of a suitable method for the reliable identification of RNA modifications constitutes a significant challenge to studying their functions. This review focuses on the technologies that enable de novo identification of RNA base modifications and the alternatively spliced mRNA transcripts.

Full Sequencing of CRISPR/Cas9 Single Guide RNA (sgRNA) via Parallel Ribonuclease Digestions and Hydrophilic Interaction Liquid Chromatography-High-Resolution Mass Spectrometry Analysis

CRISPR/Cas9 is a powerful genome editing approach in which a Cas9 enzyme and a single guide RNA (sgRNA) form a ribonucleoprotein complex effectively targeting site-specific cleavages of DNA. Accurate sequencing of sgRNA is critical to patient safety and is the expectation by regulatory agencies. In this paper, we present the full sequencing of sgRNA via parallel ribonuclease (RNase) T1, A, and U2 digestions and the simultaneous separation and identification of the digestion products by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) coupled to high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS). When using RNase T1 digestion alone, a maximal sequence coverage of 81% was obtained excluding the nonunique fragments. Full sgRNA sequencing was achieved using unique fragments generated by RNase T1, A, and U2 parallel digestions. Thorough optimization of sgRNA digestions was performed by varying the nuclease-to-sgRNA ratio, buffer conditions, and reaction times. A biocompatible ethylene-bridged hybrid amide column was evaluated for the separation of RNase digestion products. To our knowledge, it is the first time that (i) RNA digests are separated and identified by HILIC-HRMS and (ii) chemically modified sgRNAs are directly sequenced via a bottom-up approach.

Enhanced expression and purification of nucleotide-specific ribonucleases MC1 and Cusativin

Combinations of ribonucleases (RNases) are commonly used to digest RNA into oligoribonucleotide fragments prior to liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) analysis. The distribution of the RNase target sequences or nucleobase sites within an RNA molecule is critical for achieving a high mapping coverage. Cusativin and MC1 are nucleotide-specific endoribonucleases encoded in the cucumber and bitter melon genomes, respectively. Their high specificity for cytidine (Cusativin) and uridine (MC1) make them ideal molecular biology tools for RNA modification mapping. However, heterogenous recombinant expression of either enzyme has been challenging because of their high toxicity to expression hosts and the requirement of posttranslational modifications. Here, we present two highly efficient and time-saving protocols that overcome these hurdles and enhance the expression and purification of these RNases. We first purified MC1 and Cusativin from bacteria by expressing and shuttling both enzymes to the periplasm as MBP-fusion proteins in T7 Express lysY/I^qE. coli strain at low temperature. The RNases were enriched using amylose affinity chromatography, followed by a subsequent purification via a C-terminal 6xHIS tag. This fast, two-step purification allows for the purification of highly active recombinant RNases significantly surpassing yields reported in previous studies. In addition, we expressed and purified a Cusativin-CBD fusion enzyme in P. pastoris using chitin magnetic beads. Both Cusativin variants exhibited a similar sequence preference, suggesting that neither posttranslational modifications nor the epitope-tags have a substantial effect on the sequence specificity of the enzyme.

Locating chemical modifications in RNA sequences through ribonucleases and LC-MS based analysis

Knowledge of the structural information is essential for understanding the functional details of modified RNA. Cellular non-coding RNA such as rRNA, tRNA and even viral RNAs contain a number of post-transcriptional modifications with varied degree of diversity and density. In this chapter, we discuss the use of a combination of biochemical and analytical tools such as ribonucleases and liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry approaches for characterization of modified RNA. We present the protocols and alternate strategies for obtaining confident modified sequence information to facilitate the understanding of function.

Analysis of the epitranscriptome with ion-pairing reagent free oligonucleotide mass spectrometry

RNA modifications gain growing attention as a new frontier in the life sciences but with the rise of RNA vaccines also in biomedical drug development. Impeccable characterization of RNA modifications within their sequence context remains an analytical challenge. Oligonucleotide mass spectrometry (ON-MS), an approach similar to bottom-up proteome analysis, is capable of defining a short 5-15 nucleotide sequence context of an RNA modification while delivering information on the chemical character of the modified nucleotide. Commonly, ON-MS requires the use of ion pairing reagents for ON separation which is not compatible with most other MS-based applications and only few laboratories run dedicated MS instruments for the task. Here, we present an ON-MS technique which is independent of ion pairing reagents and can be used on any available mass spectrometer without risking its sensitivity for other analytes. In this chapter, we describe the experiments necessary for ON-MS method development, ON-MS application to native and synthetic RNAs and finally a guideline for data analysis.

Micro-flow hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography coupled with triple quadrupole mass spectrometry detects modified nucleosides in the transfer RNA pool of cyanobacteria

Post-transcriptional modification of nucleosides is observed in almost all elements of RNA. Modified nucleosides finely tune the structure of RNA molecules and affect vital functions, such as the modified wobble position 34 of transfer RNAs expanding the reading preference of anticodons to codons. Recent investigations have revealed that the modification species and their frequencies in an RNA element are not stable but vary with specific cellular factors including metabolites and particular proteins (writers, readers, and erasers). To understand the link between dynamic RNA modifications and biological processes, sensitive and reliable methods for determining modified nucleosides are required. In this study, micro-flow (8 μL/min) hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography was coupled with triple quadrupole mass spectrometry for the simultaneous determination of adenosine, uridine, cytidine, guanosine, and 20 modified nucleosides. The method was calibrated using 0.1-1000 nM standards (∼0.03-300 ng/mL) and successfully applied to the determination of transfer RNA modifications in the model cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus PCC 7942. A protocol for the isolation of a clean transfer RNA pool was optimized, requiring only 25 ng for the identification and quantification of transfer RNA modifications. This micro-flow liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry method constitutes the first step toward monitoring dynamic ribonucleoside modifications in a limited RNA sample.

Full-Range Profiling of tRNA Modifications Using LC-MS/MS at Single-Base Resolution through a Site-Specific Cleavage Strategy

Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are the most heavily modified RNA species. Liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) is a powerful tool for characterizing tRNA modifications, which involves pretreating tRNAs with base-specific ribonucleases to produce smaller oligonucleotides amenable to MS. However, the quality and quantity of products from base-specific digestions are severely impacted by the base composition of tRNAs. This often leads to a loss of sequence information. Here, we report a method for the full-range profiling of tRNA modifications at single-base resolution by combining site-specific RNase H digestion with the LC-MS/MS and RNA-seq techniques. The key steps were designed to generate high-quality products of optimal lengths and ionization properties. A linear correlation between collision energies and the m/z of oligonucleotides significantly improved the information content of collision-induced dissociation (CID) spectra. False positives were eliminated by up to 95% using novel inclusion criteria for collecting a census of modifications. This method is illustrated by the mapping of mouse mitochondrial tRNA^His(GUG) and tRNA^Val(UAC), which were hitherto not investigated. The identities and locations of the five species of modifications on these tRNAs were fully characterized. This approach is universally applicable to any tRNA species and provides an experimentally realizable pathway to the de novo sequencing of post-transcriptionally modified tRNAs with high sequence coverage.

The nature of the modification at position 37 of tRNAPhe correlates with acquired taxol resistance

Acquired drug resistance is a major obstacle in cancer therapy. Recent studies revealed that reprogramming of tRNA modifications modulates cancer survival in response to chemotherapy. However, dynamic changes in tRNA modification were not elucidated. In this study, comparative analysis of the human cancer cell lines and their taxol resistant strains based on tRNA mapping was performed by using UHPLC-MS/MS. It was observed for the first time in all three cell lines that 4-demethylwyosine (imG-14) substitutes for hydroxywybutosine (OHyW) due to tRNA-wybutosine synthesizing enzyme-2 (TYW2) downregulation and becomes the predominant modification at the 37th position of tRNAphe in the taxol-resistant strains. Further analysis indicated that the increase in imG-14 levels is caused by downregulation of TYW2. The time courses of the increase in imG-14 and downregulation of TYW2 are consistent with each other as well as consistent with the time course of the development of taxol-resistance. Knockdown of TYW2 in HeLa cells caused both an accumulation of imG-14 and reduction in taxol potency. Taken together, low expression of TYW2 enzyme promotes the cancer survival and resistance to taxol therapy, implying a novel mechanism for taxol resistance. Reduction of imG-14 deposition offers an underlying rationale to overcome taxol resistance in cancer chemotherapy.

Improved RNA modification mapping of cellular non-coding RNAs using C- and U-specific RNases

Locating ribonucleoside modifications within an RNA sequence requires digestion of the RNA into oligoribonucleotides of amenable size for subsequent analysis by LC-MS (liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry). This approach, widely referred to as RNA modification mapping, is facilitated through ribonucleases (RNases) such as T1 (guanosine-specific), U2 (purine-selective) and A (pyrimidine-specific) among others. Sequence coverage by these enzymes depends on positioning of the recognized nucleobase (such as guanine or purine or pyrimidine) in the sequence and its ribonucleotide composition. Using E. coli transfer RNA (tRNA) and ribosomal RNA (rRNA) as model samples, we demonstrate the ability of complementary nucleobase-specific ribonucleases cusativin (C-specific) and MC1 (U-specific) to generate digestion products that facilitate confident mapping of modifications in regions such as G-rich and pyrimidine-rich segments of RNA, and to distinguish C to U sequence differences. These enzymes also increase the number of oligonucleotide digestion products that are unique to a specific RNA sequence. Further, with these additional RNases, multiple modifications can be localized with high confidence in a single set of experiments with minimal dependence on the individual tRNA abundance in a mixture. The sequence overlaps observed with these complementary digestion products and that of RNase T1 improved sequence coverage to 75% or above. A similar level of sequence coverage was also observed for the 2904 nt long 23S rRNA indicating their utility has no dependence on RNA size. Wide-scale adoption of these additional modification mapping tools could help expedite the characterization of modified RNA sequences to understand their structural and functional role in various living systems.

Mapping post-transcriptional modifications in Staphylococcus aureus tRNAs by nanoLC/MSMS

RNA modifications are involved in numerous biological processes. These modifications are constitutive or modulated in response to adaptive processes and can impact RNA base-pairing formation, protein recognition, RNA structure and stability. tRNAs are the most abundantly modified RNA molecules. Analysis of the roles of their modifications in response to stress, environmental changes, and infections caused by pathogens, has fueled new research areas. Nevertheless, the detection of modified nucleotides in RNAs is still a challenging task. We present here a reliable method to identify and localize tRNA modifications, which was applied to the human pathogenic bacteria, Staphyloccocus aureus. The method is based on a separation of tRNA species on a two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis followed by nano liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. We provided a list of modifications mapped on 25 out of the 40 tRNA species (one isoacceptor for each amino acid). This method can be easily used to monitor the dynamics of tRNA modifications in S. aureus in response to stress adaptation and during infection of the host, a relatively unexplored field.

Oligonucleotide Sequence Mapping of Large Therapeutic mRNAs via Parallel Ribonuclease Digestions and LC-MS/MS

Characterization of mRNA sequences is a critical aspect of mRNA drug development and regulatory filing. Herein, we developed a novel bottom-up oligonucleotide sequence mapping workflow combining multiple endonucleases that cleave mRNA at different frequencies. RNase T1, colicin E5, and mazF were applied in parallel to provide complementary sequence coverage for large mRNAs. Combined use of multiple endonucleases resulted in significantly improved sequence coverage: greater than 70% sequence coverage was achieved on mRNAs near 3000 nucleotides long. Oligonucleotide mapping simulations with large human RNA databases demonstrate that the proposed workflow can positively identify a single correct sequence from hundreds of similarly sized sequences. In addition, the workflow is sensitive and specific enough to detect minor sequence impurities such as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) with a sensitivity of less than 1%. LC-MS/MS-based oligonucleotide sequence mapping can serve as an orthogonal sequence characterization method to techniques such as Sanger sequencing or next-generation sequencing (NGS), providing high-throughput sequence identification and sensitive impurity detection.

tRNA Modification Profiles and Codon-Decoding Strategies in Methanocaldococcus jannaschii

tRNAs play a critical role in mRNA decoding, and posttranscriptional modifications within tRNAs drive decoding efficiency and accuracy. The types and positions of tRNA modifications in model bacteria have been extensively studied, and tRNA modifications in a few eukaryotic organisms have also been characterized and localized to particular tRNA sequences. However, far less is known regarding tRNA modifications in archaea. While the identities of modifications have been determined for multiple archaeal organisms, Haloferax volcanii is the only organism for which modifications have been extensively localized to specific tRNA sequences. To improve our understanding of archaeal tRNA modification patterns and codon-decoding strategies, we have used liquid chromatography and tandem mass spectrometry to characterize and then map posttranscriptional modifications on 34 of the 35 unique tRNA sequences of Methanocaldococcus jannaschii A new posttranscriptionally modified nucleoside, 5-cyanomethyl-2-thiouridine (cnm⁵s²U), was discovered and localized to position 34. Moreover, data consistent with wyosine pathway modifications were obtained beyond the canonical tRNA^Phe as is typical for eukaryotes. The high-quality mapping of tRNA anticodon loops enriches our understanding of archaeal tRNA modification profiles and decoding strategies.IMPORTANCE While many posttranscriptional modifications in M. jannaschii tRNAs are also found in bacteria and eukaryotes, several that are unique to archaea were identified. By RNA modification mapping, the modification profiles of M. jannaschii tRNA anticodon loops were characterized, allowing a comparative analysis with H. volcanii modification profiles as well as a general comparison with bacterial and eukaryotic decoding strategies. This general comparison reveals that M. jannaschii, like H. volcanii, follows codon-decoding strategies similar to those used by bacteria, although position 37 appears to be modified to a greater extent than seen in H. volcanii.

Improving RNA modification mapping sequence coverage by LC-MS through a nonspecific RNase U2-E49A mutant

We report the identification and use of a mutant of the purine selective ribonuclease RNase U2 that randomly cleaves RNA in a manner that is directly compatible with RNA modification mapping by mass spectrometry. A number of RNase U2 mutants were generated using site-saturation mutagenesis. The enzyme activity and specificity were tested using oligonucleotide substrates, which revealed an RNase U2 E49A mutant with limited specificity and a tendency to undercut RNA. Using this mutant, RNA digestion conditions were optimized to yield long, overlapping digestion products, which improve sequence coverage in RNA modification mapping experiments. The analytical utility of this mutant was demonstrated by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) mapping of several modified RNAs where 100% sequence coverage could be obtained using only a single enzymatic digestion. This new mutant facilitates more accurate and efficient RNA modification mapping than traditional highly base-specific RNases that are currently used.

Detection of ribonucleoside modifications by liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry

A small set of ribonucleoside modifications have been found in different regions of mRNA including the open reading frame. Accurate detection of these specific modifications is critical to understanding their modulatory roles in facilitating mRNA maturation, translation and degradation. While transcriptome-wide next-generation sequencing (NGS) techniques could provide exhaustive information about the sites of one specific or class of modifications at a time, recent investigations strongly indicate cautionary interpretation due to the appearance of false positives. Therefore, it is suggested that NGS-based modification data can only be treated as predicted sites and their existence need to be validated by orthogonal methods. Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) is an analytical technique that can yield accurate and reproducible information about the qualitative and quantitative characteristics of ribonucleoside modifications. Here, we review the recent advancements in LC-MS/MS technology that could help in securing accurate, gold-standard quality information about the resident post-transcriptional modifications of mRNA.

Improved application of RNAModMapper - An RNA modification mapping software tool - For analysis of liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) data

Research into post-transcriptional processing and modification of RNA continues to speed forward, as their ever-emerging role in the regulation of gene expression in biological systems continues to unravel. Liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) has proven for over two decades to be a powerful ally in the elucidation of RNA modification identity and location, but the technique has not proceeded without its own unique technical challenges. The throughput of LC-MS/MS modification mapping experiments continues to be impeded by tedious and time-consuming spectral interpretation, particularly during for the analysis of complex RNA samples. RNAModMapper was recently developed as a tool to improve the interpretation and annotation of LC-MS/MS data sets from samples containing post-transcriptionally modified RNAs. Here, we delve deeper into the methodology and practice of RNAModMapper to provide greater insight into its utility, and remaining hurdles, in current RNA modification mapping experiments.

Modern Approaches for Identification of Modified Nucleotides in RNA

This review considers approaches for detection of modified monomers in the RNA structure of living organisms. Recently, some data on dynamic alterations in the pool of modifications of the key RNA species that depend on external factors affecting the cells and physiological conditions of the whole organism have been accumulated. The recent studies have presented experimental data on relationship between the mechanisms of formation of modified/minor nucleotides of RNA in mammalian cells and the development of various pathologies. The development of novel methods for detection of chemical modifications of RNA nucleotides in the cells of living organisms and accumulation of knowledge on the contribution of modified monomers to metabolism and functioning of individual RNA species establish the basis for creation of novel diagnostic and therapeutic approaches. This review includes a short description of routine methods for determination of modified nucleotides in RNA and considers in detail modern approaches that enable not only detection but also quantitative assessment of the modification level of various nucleotides in individual RNA species.

RNAModMapper: RNA Modification Mapping Software for Analysis of Liquid Chromatography Tandem Mass Spectrometry Data

Liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) has proven to be a powerful analytical tool for the characterization of modified ribonucleic acids (RNAs). The typical approach for analyzing modified nucleosides within RNA sequences by mass spectrometry involves ribonuclease digestion followed by LC-MS/MS analysis and data interpretation. Here we describe a new software tool, RNAModMapper (RAMM), to assist in the interpretation of LC-MS/MS data. RAMM is a stand-alone package that requires user-submitted DNA or RNA sequences to create a local database against which collision-induced dissociation (CID) data of modified oligonucleotides can be compared. RAMM can interpret MS/MS data containing modified nucleosides in two modes: fixed and variable. In addition, RAMM can also utilize interpreted MS/MS data for RNA modification mapping back against the input sequence(s). The applicability of RAMM was first tested using total tRNA isolated from Escherichia coli. It was then applied to map modifications found in 16S and 23S rRNA from Streptomyces griseus.

Novel ribonuclease activity of cusativin from Cucumis sativus for mapping nucleoside modifications in RNA

A recombinant ribonuclease, cusativin, was characterized for its cytidine-specific cleavage ability of RNA to map chemical modifications. Following purification of native cusativin protein as described before (Rojo et al. Planta 194:328, 17), partial amino acid sequencing was carried out to identify the corresponding protein coding gene in cucumber genome. Cloning and heterologous expression of the identified gene in Escherichia coli resulted in successful production of active protein as a C-terminal His-tag fusion protein. The ribonuclease activity and cleavage specificity of the fusion protein were confirmed with a variety of tRNA isoacceptors and total tRNA. Characterization of cusativin digestion products by ion-pairing reverse-phase liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (IP-RP-LC-MS) analysis revealed cleavage of CpA, CpG, and CpU phosphodiester bonds at the 3'-terminus of cytidine under optimal digestion conditions. Ribose methylation or acetylation of cytosine inhibited RNA cleavage. The CpC phosphodiester bond was also resistant to cusativin-mediated RNA cleavage; a feature to our knowledge has not been reported for other nucleobase-specific ribonucleases. Here, we demonstrate the analytical utility of such a novel feature for obtaining high-sequence coverage and accurate mapping of modified residues in substrate RNAs. Graphical abstract Cytidine-specific novel ribonuclease activity of cusativin.

Stable Isotope Labeling for Improved Comparative Analysis of RNA Digests by Mass Spectrometry

Even with the advent of high throughput methods to detect modified ribonucleic acids (RNAs), mass spectrometry remains a reliable method to detect, characterize, and place post-transcriptional modifications within an RNA sequence. Here we have developed a stable isotope labeling comparative analysis of RNA digests (SIL-CARD) approach, which improves upon the original ¹⁸O/¹⁶O labeling CARD method. Like the original, SIL-CARD allows sequence or modification information from a previously uncharacterized in vivo RNA sample to be obtained by direct comparison with a reference RNA, the sequence of which is known. This reference is in vitro transcribed using a ¹³C/¹⁵N isotopically enriched nucleoside triphosphate (NTP). The two RNAs are digested with an endonuclease, the specificity of which matches the labeled NTP used for transcription. As proof of concept, several transfer RNAs (tRNAs) were characterized by SIL-CARD, where labeled guanosine triphosphate was used for the reference in vitro transcription. RNase T1 digestion products from the in vitro transcript will be 15 Da higher in mass than the same digestion products from the in vivo tRNA that are unmodified, leading to a doublet in the mass spectrum. Singlets, rather than doublets, arise if a sequence variation or a post-transcriptional modification is present that results in a relative mass shift different from 15 Da. Moreover, the use of the in vitro synthesized tRNA transcript allows for quantitative measurement of RNA abundance. Overall, SIL-CARD simplifies data analysis and enhances quantitative RNA modification mapping by mass spectrometry. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Mapping Post-Transcriptional Modifications onto Transfer Ribonucleic Acid Sequences by Liquid Chromatography Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Liquid chromatography, coupled with tandem mass spectrometry, has become one of the most popular methods for the analysis of post-transcriptionally modified transfer ribonucleic acids (tRNAs). Given that the information collected using this platform is entirely determined by the mass of the analyte, it has proven to be the gold standard for accurately assigning nucleobases to the sequence. For the past few decades many labs have worked to improve the analysis, contiguous to instrumentation manufacturers developing faster and more sensitive instruments. With biological discoveries relating to ribonucleic acid happening more frequently, mass spectrometry has been invaluable in helping to understand what is happening at the molecular level. Here we present a brief overview of the methods that have been developed and refined for the analysis of modified tRNAs by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry.

Pseudouridine in the Anticodon of Escherichia coli tRNATyr(QΨA) Is Catalyzed by the Dual Specificity Enzyme RluF

Pseudouridine is found in almost all cellular ribonucleic acids (RNAs). Of the multiple characteristics attributed to pseudouridine, making messenger RNAs (mRNAs) highly translatable and non-immunogenic is one such feature that directly implicates this modification in protein synthesis. We report the existence of pseudouridine in the anticodon of Escherichia coli tyrosine transfer RNAs (tRNAs) at position 35. Pseudouridine was verified by multiple detection methods, which include pseudouridine-specific chemical derivatization and gas phase dissociation of RNA during liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS). Analysis of total tRNA isolated from E. coli pseudouridine synthase knock-out mutants identified RluF as the enzyme responsible for this modification. Furthermore, the absence of this modification compromises the translational ability of a luciferase reporter gene coding sequence when it is preceded by multiple tyrosine codons. This effect has implications for the translation of mRNAs that are rich in tyrosine codons in bacterial expression systems.

Sequence mapping of transfer RNA chemical modifications by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry

Mass spectrometry is a powerful analytical tool for identifying and characterizing structural modifications to the four canonical bases in RNA, information that is lost when using techniques such as PCR for RNA analysis. Here we described an updated method for sequence mapping of modified nucleosides in transfer RNA. This modification mapping approach utilizes knowledge of the modified nucleosides present in the sample along with the genome-derived tRNA sequence to readily locate modifications site-specifically in the tRNA sequence. The experimental approach involves isolation of the tRNA of interest followed by separate enzymatic digestion to nucleosides and oligonucleotides. Both samples are analyzed by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) and the data sets are then combined to yield the modification profile of the tRNA. Data analysis is facilitated by the use of unmodified sequence exclusion lists and new developments in software that can automate MS/MS spectral annotation. The method is illustrated using tRNA-Asn isolated from Thermus thermophilus.