Small RNA-mediated regulation of DNA dosage in the ciliate Oxytricha

The origin of RNA interference: Adaptive or neutral evolution?

The origin of RNA interference (RNAi) is usually explained by a defense-based hypothesis, in which RNAi evolved as a defense against transposable elements (TEs) and RNA viruses and was already present in the last eukaryotic common ancestor (LECA). However, since RNA antisense regulation and double-stranded RNAs (dsRNAs) are ancient and widespread phenomena, the origin of defensive RNAi should have occurred in parallel with its regulative functions to avoid imbalances in gene regulation. Thus, we propose a neutral evolutionary hypothesis for the origin of RNAi in which qualitative system drift from a prokaryotic antisense RNA gene regulation mechanism leads to the formation of RNAi through constructive neutral evolution (CNE). We argue that RNAi was already present in the ancestor of LECA before the need for a new defense system arose and that its presence helped to shape eukaryotic genomic architecture and stability.

Where does RNA interference come from? This Essay describes a new step-by-step evolutionary model of how RNA interference might have originated in early eukaryotes through neutral events from the molecular machinery present in prokaryotes.

Chromosome organization and gene expansion in the highly fragmented genome of the ciliate Strombidium stylifer

Chromosomes are well-organized carriers of genetic information in eukaryotes and are usually quite long, carrying hundreds and thousands of genes. Intriguingly, a clade of single-celled ciliates, Spirotrichea, feature nanochromosomes-also called "gene-sized chromosomes". These chromosomes predominantly carry only one gene, flanked by short telomere sequences. However, the organization and copy number variation of the chromosomes in these highly fragmented genomes remain unexplored in many groups of Spirotrichea, including the marine Strombidium. Using deep genome sequencing, we assembled the macronuclear genome of Strombidium stylifer into more than 18,000 nanochromosomes (~2.4 Kb long on average). Our results show that S. stylifer occupies an intermediate position during the evolutionary history of Strombidium lineage and experienced significant expansions in several gene families related to guanyl ribonucleotide binding. Based on the nucleotide distribution bias analysis and conserved motifs search in non-genic regions, we found that the subtelomeric regions have a conserved adenine-thymine (AT)-rich sequence motif. We also found that the copy number of nanochromosomes lacks precise regulation. This work sheds light on the unique features of chromosome structure in eukaryotes with highly fragmented genomes and reveals that a rather specialized evolutionary strategy at the genomic level has resulted in great diversity within the ciliated lineages.

An essential role for the piRNA pathway in regulating the ribosomal RNA pool in C. elegans

Piwi-interacting RNAs (piRNAs) are RNA effectors with key roles in maintaining genome integrity and promoting fertility in metazoans. In Caenorhabditis elegans loss of piRNAs leads to a transgenerational sterility phenotype. The plethora of piRNAs and their ability to silence transcripts with imperfect complementarity have raised several (non-exclusive) models for the underlying drivers of sterility. Here, we report the extranuclear and transferable nature of the sterility driver, its suppression via mutations disrupting the endogenous RNAi and poly-uridylation machinery, and copy-number amplification at the ribosomal DNA locus. In piRNA-deficient animals, several small interfering RNA (siRNA) populations become increasingly overabundant in the generations preceding loss of germline function, including ribosomal siRNAs (risiRNAs). A concomitant increase in uridylated sense rRNA fragments suggests that poly-uridylation may potentiate RNAi-mediated gene silencing of rRNAs. We conclude that loss of the piRNA machinery allows for unchecked amplification of siRNA populations, originating from abundant highly structured RNAs, to deleterious levels.

Disruption of a ∼23-24 nucleotide small RNA pathway elevates DNA damage responses in Tetrahymena thermophila

Endogenous RNA interference (RNAi) pathways regulate a wide range of cellular processes in diverse eukaryotes, yet in the ciliated eukaryote, Tetrahymena thermophila, the cellular purpose of RNAi pathways that generate ∼23–24 nucleotide (nt) small (s)RNAs has remained unknown. Here, we investigated the phenotypic and gene expression impacts on vegetatively growing cells when genes involved in ∼23–24 nt sRNA biogenesis are disrupted. We observed slower proliferation and increased expression of genes involved in DNA metabolism and chromosome organization and maintenance in sRNA biogenesis mutants RSP1Δ, RDN2Δ, and RDF2Δ. In addition, RSP1Δ and RDN2Δ cells frequently exhibited enlarged chromatin extrusion bodies, which are nonnuclear, DNA-containing structures that may be akin to mammalian micronuclei. Expression of homologous recombination factor Rad51 was specifically elevated in RSP1Δ and RDN2Δ strains, with Rad51 and double-stranded DNA break marker γ-H2A.X localized to discrete macronuclear foci. In addition, an increase in Rad51 and γ-H2A.X foci was also found in knockouts of TWI8, a macronucleus-localized PIWI protein. Together, our findings suggest that an evolutionarily conserved role for RNAi pathways in maintaining genome integrity may be extended even to the early branching eukaryotic lineage that gave rise to Tetrahymena thermophila.

Transcribed germline-limited coding sequences in Oxytricha trifallax

The germline-soma divide is a fundamental distinction in developmental biology, and different genes are expressed in germline and somatic cells throughout metazoan life cycles. Ciliates, a group of microbial eukaryotes, exhibit germline-somatic nuclear dimorphism within a single cell with two different genomes. The ciliate Oxytricha trifallax undergoes massive RNA-guided DNA elimination and genome rearrangement to produce a new somatic macronucleus (MAC) from a copy of the germline micronucleus (MIC). This process eliminates noncoding DNA sequences that interrupt genes and also deletes hundreds of germline-limited open reading frames (ORFs) that are transcribed during genome rearrangement. Here, we update the set of transcribed germline-limited ORFs (TGLOs) in O. trifallax. We show that TGLOs tend to be expressed during nuclear development and then are absent from the somatic MAC. We also demonstrate that exposure to synthetic RNA can reprogram TGLO retention in the somatic MAC and that TGLO retention leads to transcription outside the normal developmental program. These data suggest that TGLOs represent a group of developmentally regulated protein-coding sequences whose gene expression is terminated by DNA elimination.

The Compact Macronuclear Genome of the Ciliate Halteria grandinella: A Transcriptome-Like Genome with 23,000 Nanochromosomes

How to achieve protein diversity by genome and transcriptome processing is essential for organismal complexity and adaptation. The present work identifies that the macronuclear genome of Halteria grandinella, a cosmopolitan unicellular eukaryote, is composed almost entirely of gene-sized nanochromosomes with extremely short nongenic regions.

How to achieve protein diversity by genome and transcriptome processing is essential for organismal complexity and adaptation. The present work identifies that the macronuclear genome of Halteria grandinella, a cosmopolitan unicellular eukaryote, is composed almost entirely of gene-sized nanochromosomes with extremely short nongenic regions. This challenges our usual understanding of chromosomal structure and suggests the possibility of novel mechvanisms in transcriptional regulation. Comprehensive analysis of multiple data sets reveals that Halteria transcription dynamics are influenced by: (i) nonuniform nanochromosome copy numbers correlated with gene-expression level; (ii) dynamic alterations at both the DNA and RNA levels, including alternative internal eliminated sequence (IES) deletions during macronucleus formation and large-scale alternative splicing in transcript maturation; and (iii) extremely short 5′ and 3′ untranslated regions (UTRs) and universal TATA box-like motifs in the compact 5′ subtelomeric regions of most chromosomes. This study broadens the view of ciliate biology and the evolution of unicellular eukaryotes, and identifies Halteria as one of the most compact known eukaryotic genomes, indicating that complex cell structure does not require complex gene architecture.

Morpholino-Mediated Knockdown of Ciliary Genes in Euplotes vannus, a Novel Marine Ciliated Model Organism

Cilia are highly conserved organelles present in almost all types of eukaryotic cells, and defects in cilia structure and/or function are related to many human genetic disorders. Single-celled ciliated protists, which possess diverse types of cilia, are remarkable model organisms for studying cilia structures and functions. Euplotes vannus is a representative ciliate with many intriguing features; for example, it possesses extensively fragmented somatic genomes and a high frequency of + 1 programmed ribosomal frameshifting. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying these remarkable traits remain largely unknown, mainly due to the lack of efficient genetic manipulation tools. Here, we describe the first application of a morpholino-based strategy to knockdown gene expression in E. vannus. Through interfering with the function of two ciliary genes, ZMYND10 and C21ORF59, we showed that these two genes are essential for the ciliary motility and proliferation of E. vannus cells. Strikingly, both ZMYND10- and C21ORF59-knockdown cells developed shorter cilia in the ventral cirri, a special type of ciliary tuft, suggesting a novel role for these genes in the regulation of cilia length. Our data provide a new method to explore gene function in E. vannus, which may help us to understand the functions of evolutionarily conserved cilia-related genes as well as other biological processes in this intriguing model.

Roles of Noncoding RNAs in Ciliate Genome Architecture

Ciliates are an interesting model system for investigating diverse functions of noncoding RNAs, especially in genome defence pathways. During sexual development, the ciliate somatic genome undergoes massive rearrangement and reduction through removal of transposable elements and other repetitive DNA. This is guided by a multitude of noncoding RNAs of different sizes and functions, the extent of which is only recently becoming clear. The genome rearrangement pathways evolved as a defence against parasitic DNA, but interestingly also use the transposable elements and transposases to execute their own removal. Thus, ciliates are also a good model for the coevolution of host and transposable element, and the mutual dependence between the two. In this review, we summarise the genome rearrangement pathways in three diverse species of ciliate, with focus on recent discoveries and the roles of noncoding RNAs.

•

Ciliate genomes undergo massive rearrangement and reduction during development.

•

Transposon elimination is guided by small RNAs and carried out by transposases.

•

New pathways for noncoding RNA production have recently been discovered in ciliates.

•

Diverse ciliate species have different mechanisms for RNA-guided genome remodeling.

Conserved chromosomal functions of RNA interference

RNA interference (RNAi), a cellular process through which small RNAs target and regulate complementary RNA transcripts, has well-characterized roles in post-transcriptional gene regulation and transposon repression. Recent studies have revealed additional conserved roles for RNAi proteins, such as Argonaute and Dicer, in chromosome function. By guiding chromatin modification, RNAi components promote chromosome segregation during both mitosis and meiosis and regulate chromosomal and genomic dosage response. Small RNAs and the RNAi machinery also participate in the resolution of DNA damage. Interestingly, many of these lesser-studied functions seem to be more strongly conserved across eukaryotes than are well-characterized functions such as the processing of microRNAs. These findings have implications for the evolution of RNAi since the last eukaryotic common ancestor, and they provide a more complete view of the functions of RNAi.

Exogenous RNAi mechanisms contribute to transcriptome adaptation by phased siRNA clusters in Paramecium

Extensive research has characterized distinct exogenous RNAi pathways interfering in gene expression during vegetative growth of the unicellular model ciliate Paramecium. However, role of RNAi in endogenous transcriptome regulation, and environmental adaptation is unknown. Here, we describe the first genome-wide profiling of endogenous sRNAs in context of different transcriptomic states (serotypes). We developed a pipeline to identify, and characterize 2602 siRNA producing clusters (SRCs). Our data show no evidence that SRCs produce miRNAs, and in contrast to other species, no preference for strand specificity of siRNAs. Interestingly, most SRCs overlap coding genes and a separate group show siRNA phasing along the entire open reading frame, suggesting that the mRNA transcript serves as a source for siRNAs. Integrative analysis of siRNA abundance and gene expression levels revealed surprisingly that mRNA and siRNA show negative as well as positive associations. Two RNA-dependent RNA Polymerase mutants, RDR1 and RDR2, show a drastic loss of siRNAs especially in phased SRCs accompanied with increased mRNA levels. Importantly, most SRCs depend on both RDRs, reminiscent to primary siRNAs in the RNAi against exogenous RNA, indicating mechanistic overlaps between exogenous and endogenous RNAi contributing to flexible transcriptome adaptation.

Should dsRNA treatments applied in outdoor environments be regulated?

The New Zealand Environmental Protection Authority (EPA) issued a Decision that makes the use of externally applied double-stranded (ds)RNA molecules on eukaryotic cells or organisms technically out of scope of legislation on new organisms, making risk assessments of such treatments in the open environment unnecessary. The Decision was based on its view that the treatment does not create new or genetically modified organisms and rests on the EPA's conclusions that dsRNA is not heritable and is not a mutagen. For these reasons EPA decided that treatments using dsRNA do not modify genes or other genetic material. I found from an independent review of the literature on the topic indicated, however, that each of the major scientific justifications relied upon by the EPA was based on either an inaccurate interpretation of evidence or failure to consult the research literature pertaining to additional types of eukaryotes. The Decision also did not take into account the unknown and unique eukaryotic biodiversity of New Zealand. The safe use of RNA-based technology holds promise for addressing complex and persistent challenges in public health, agriculture and conservation. However, by failing to restrict the source or means of modifying the dsRNA, the EPA removed regulatory oversight that could prevent unintended consequences of this new technology such as suppression of genes other than those selected for suppression or the release of viral genes or genomes by failing to restrict the source or means of modifying the dsRNA.

Programmed Chromosome Deletion in the Ciliate Oxytricha trifallax

The ciliate Oxytricha trifallax contains two nuclei: a germline micronucleus and a somatic macronucleus. These two nuclei diverge significantly in genomic structure. The micronucleus contains approximately 100 chromosomes of megabase scale, while the macronucleus contains 16,000 gene-sized, high ploidy "nanochromosomes." During its sexual cycle, a copy of the zygotic germline micronucleus develops into a somatic macronucleus via DNA excision and rearrangement. The rearrangement process is guided by multiple RNA-based pathways that program the epigenetic inheritance of sequences in the parental macronucleus of the subsequent generation. Here, we show that the introduction of synthetic DNA molecules homologous to a complete native nanochromosome during the rearrangement process results in either loss or heavy copy number reduction of the targeted nanochromosome in the macronucleus of the subsequent generation. This phenomenon was tested on a variety of nanochromosomes with different micronuclear structures, with deletions resulting in all cases. Deletion of the targeted nanochromosome results in the loss of expression of the targeted genes, including gene knockout phenotypes that were phenocopied using alternative knockdown approaches. Further investigation of the chromosome deletion showed that, although the full length nanochromosome was lost, remnants of the targeted chromosome remain. We were also able to detect the presence of telomeres on these remnants. The chromosome deletions and remnants are epigenetically inherited when backcrossed to wild type strains, suggesting that an undiscovered mechanism programs DNA elimination and cytoplasmically transfers to both daughter cells during conjugation. Programmed deletion of targeted chromosomes provides a novel approach to investigate genome rearrangement and expands the available strategies for gene knockout in Oxytricha trifallax.

Transformation with Artificial Chromosomes in Oxytricha trifallax and Their Applications

Oxytricha trifallax, like other ciliates, has separate germline and somatic nuclei. The diploid germline genome in the micronucleus is composed of long conventional chromosomes. The macronucleus contains a somatic genome which is naturally fragmented into thousands of kilobase-sized chromosomes. Here, we develop a method to stably incorporate artificial chromosomes into the macronucleus. We report two cases of successful transformation and demonstrate the use of somatic transformation to investigate gene regulation and gene function in Oxytricha We show that the transformed artificial chromosomes are maintained through multiple asexual divisions. Furthermore, they support the transcriptional regulation of the native chromosome from which they were derived and are translated to produce functional proteins. To test if transformed chromosomes are amenable to practical applications, we generated a tagged version of a representative gene (AL1) and used it to co-precipitate associated proteins. This revealed an association with nucleic acid binding proteins, specifically RNA-binding proteins, and RNA immunoprecipitation of AL1 revealed its association with multiple RNAs. The use of artificial chromosomes in Oxytricha enables an array of genetic and molecular biological assays, as well as new avenues of inquiry into the epigenetic programming of macronuclear development and genome rearrangement.

Identification of a DNA N6-Adenine Methyltransferase Complex and Its Impact on Chromatin Organization

DNA N6-adenine methylation (6mA) has recently been described in diverse eukaryotes, spanning unicellular organisms to metazoa. Here, we report a DNA 6mA methyltransferase complex in ciliates, termed MTA1c. It consists of two MT-A70 proteins and two homeobox-like DNA-binding proteins and specifically methylates dsDNA. Disruption of the catalytic subunit, MTA1, in the ciliate Oxytricha leads to genome-wide loss of 6mA and abolishment of the consensus ApT dimethylated motif. Mutants fail to complete the sexual cycle, which normally coincides with peak MTA1 expression. We investigate the impact of 6mA on nucleosome occupancy in vitro by reconstructing complete, full-length Oxytricha chromosomes harboring 6mA in native or ectopic positions. We show that 6mA directly disfavors nucleosomes in vitro in a local, quantitative manner, independent of DNA sequence. Furthermore, the chromatin remodeler ACF can overcome this effect. Our study identifies a diverged DNA N6-adenine methyltransferase and defines the role of 6mA in chromatin organization.