Less isn't always more

Satellite-Like W-Elements: Repetitive, Transcribed, and Putative Mobile Genetic Factors with Potential Roles for Biology and Evolution of Schistosoma mansoni

A large portion of animal and plant genomes consists of noncoding DNA. This part includes tandemly repeated sequences and gained attention because it offers exciting insights into genome biology. We investigated satellite-DNA elements of the platyhelminth Schistosoma mansoni, a parasite with remarkable biological features. Schistosoma mansoni lives in the vasculature of humans causing schistosomiasis, a disease of worldwide importance. Schistosomes are the only trematodes that have evolved separate sexes, and the sexual maturation of the female depends on constant pairing with the male. The schistosome karyotype comprises eight chromosome pairs, males are homogametic (ZZ) and females are heterogametic (ZW). Part of the repetitive DNA of S. mansoni are W-elements (WEs), originally discovered as female-specific satellite DNAs in the heterochromatic block of the W-chromosome. Based on new genome and transcriptome data, we performed a reanalysis of the W-element families (WEFs). Besides a new classification of 19 WEFs, we provide first evidence for stage-, sex-, pairing-, gonad-, and strain-specific/preferential transcription of WEs as well as their mobile nature, deduced from autosomal copies of full-length and partial WEs. Structural analyses suggested roles as sources of noncoding RNA-like hammerhead ribozymes, for which we obtained functional evidence. Finally, the variable WEF occurrence in different schistosome species revealed remarkable divergence. From these results, we propose that WEs potentially exert enduring influence on the biology of S. mansoni. Their variable occurrence in different strains, isolates, and species suggests that schistosome WEs may represent genetic factors taking effect on variability and evolution of the family Schistosomatidae.

An RNA-centric historical narrative around the Protein Data Bank

Some of the amazing contributions brought to the scientific community by the Protein Data Bank (PDB) are described. The focus is on nucleic acid structures with a bias toward RNA. The evolution and key roles in science of the PDB and other structural databases for nucleic acids illustrate how small initial ideas can become huge and indispensable resources with the unflinching willingness of scientists to cooperate globally. The progress in the understanding of the molecular interactions driving RNA architectures followed the rapid increase in RNA structures in the PDB. That increase was consecutive to improvements in chemical synthesis and purification of RNA molecules, as well as in biophysical methods for structure determination and computer technology. The RNA modeling efforts from the early beginnings are also described together with their links to the state of structural knowledge and technological development. Structures of RNA and of its assemblies are physical objects, which, together with genomic data, allow us to integrate present-day biological functions and the historical evolution in all living species on earth.

Slow molecular recognition by RNA

Molecular recognition is central to biological processes, function, and specificity. Proteins associate with ligands with a wide range of association rate constants, with maximal values matching the theoretical limit set by the rate of diffusional collision. As less is known about RNA association, we compiled association rate constants for all RNA/ligand complexes that we could find in the literature. Like proteins, RNAs exhibit a wide range of association rate constants. However, the fastest RNA association rates are considerably slower than those of the fastest protein associations and fall well below the diffusional limit. The apparently general observation of slow association with RNAs has implications for evolution and for modern-day biology. Our compilation highlights a quantitative molecular property that can contribute to biological understanding and underscores our need to develop a deeper physical understanding of molecular recognition events.

Numerous small hammerhead ribozyme variants associated with Penelope-like retrotransposons cleave RNA as dimers

Hammerhead ribozymes represent the most common of the 9 natural classes of self-cleaving RNAs. The hammerhead catalytic core includes 11 highly-conserved nucleotides located largely within the unpaired regions of a junction formed by stems I, II and III. The vast majority of previously reported examples carry an additional pseudoknot or other tertiary interactions between nucleotides that precede stem I and nucleotides in the loop of stem II. These extra contacts are critical for high-speed RNA catalysis. Herein, we report the discovery of ∼150,000 additional variant hammerhead representatives that exhibit diminished stem III substructures. These variants are frequently associated with Penelope-like retrotransposons, which are a type of mobile genetic element. Kinetic analyses indicate that these RNAs form dimers to cleave RNA.

Bridging the gap between theory and experiment to derive a detailed understanding of hammerhead ribozyme catalysis

Herein we summarize our progress toward the understanding of hammerhead ribozyme (HHR) catalysis through a multiscale simulation strategy. Simulation results collectively paint a picture of HHR catalysis: HHR first folds to form an electronegative active site pocket to recruit a threshold occupation of cationic charges, either a Mg(2+) ion or multiple monovalent cations. Catalytically active conformations that have good in-line fitness are supported by specific metal ion coordination patterns that involve either a bridging Mg(2+) ion or multiple Na(+) ions, one of which is also in a bridging coordination pattern. In the case of a single Mg(2+) ion bound in the active site, the Mg(2+) ion undergoes a migration that is coupled with deprotonation of the nucleophile (C17:O2'). As the reaction proceeds, the Mg(2+) ion stabilizes the accumulating charge of the leaving group and significantly increases the general acid ability of G8:O2'. Further computational mutagenesis simulations suggest that the disruptions due to mutations may severely impact HHR catalysis at different stages of the reaction. Catalytic mechanisms supported by the simulation results are consistent with available structural and biochemical experiments, and together they advance our understanding of HHR catalysis.

Conformational heterogeneity and the determinants of tertiary stabilization in the hammerhead ribozyme from Dolichopoda cave crickets

Repetitive DNA elements in Dolichopoda cave cricket genomes contain extended hammerhead ribozymes that are functional in adult crickets, but that exhibit very low self-cleavage activity in vitro relative to other extended hammerhead ribozymes. We find that the parental ribozyme tends to misfold into alternate secondary structures in vitro, complicating analysis of contributions by specific nucleotides to activity under biologically relevant magnesium concentrations. However, minor sequence alterations that stabilize the active secondary structure, without altering candidate tertiary interacting nucleotides, boosted observed rates more than 50-fold (4.4 ± 1.7 min(-1)) and doubled the cleavage extent (>60%) in submillimolar magnesium. Productive alterations included flipping two base pairs in stem I, lengthening stem I and opening stem III to generate a trans-cleaving ribozyme. Specific peripheral nucleotides involved in tertiary stabilization were then identified through kinetic analysis for a series of sequence variants and by correlating plateau cleavage values with band intensity in native gel electrophoresis. These results demonstrate that conformational heterogeneity governs self-cleavage by the wild-type Dolichopoda hammerhead ribozyme in vitro, and they suggest a strategy for improving activity and enhancing the suitability of HHRz for intracellular and biotechnology applications.

Tertiary contacts control switching of the SAM-I riboswitch

Riboswitches are non-coding RNAs that control gene expression by sensing small molecules through changes in secondary structure. While secondary structure and ligand interactions are thought to control switching, the exact mechanism of control is unknown. Using a novel two-piece assay that competes the anti-terminator against the aptamer, we directly monitor the process of switching. We find that the stabilization of key tertiary contacts controls both aptamer domain collapse and the switching of the SAM-I riboswitch from the aptamer to the expression platform conformation. Our experiments demonstrate that SAM binding induces structural alterations that indirectly stabilize the aptamer domain, preventing switching toward the expression platform conformer. These results, combined with a variety of structural probing experiments performed in this study, show that the collapse and stabilization of the aptamer domain are cooperative, relying on the sum of key tertiary contacts and the bimodal stability of the kink-turn motif for function. Here, ligand binding serves to shift the equilibrium of aptamer domain structures from a more open toward a more stable collapsed form by stabilizing tertiary interactions. Our data show that the thermodynamic landscape for riboswitch operation is finely balanced to allow large conformational rearrangements to be controlled by small molecule interactions.

T box transcription antitermination riboswitch: influence of nucleotide sequence and orientation on tRNA binding by the antiterminator element

Many bacteria utilize riboswitch transcription regulation to monitor and appropriately respond to cellular levels of important metabolites or effector molecules. The T box transcription antitermination riboswitch responds to cognate uncharged tRNA by specifically stabilizing an antiterminator element in the 5'-untranslated mRNA leader region and precluding formation of a thermodynamically more stable terminator element. Stabilization occurs when the tRNA acceptor end base pairs with the first four nucleotides in the seven nucleotide bulge of the highly conserved antiterminator element. The significance of the conservation of the antiterminator bulge nucleotides that do not base pair with the tRNA is unknown, but they are required for optimal function. In vitro selection was used to determine if the isolated antiterminator bulge context alone dictates the mode in which the tRNA acceptor end binds the bulge nucleotides. No sequence conservation beyond complementarity was observed and the location was not constrained to the first four bases of the bulge. The results indicate that formation of a structure that recognizes the tRNA acceptor end in isolation is not the determinant driving force for the high phylogenetic sequence conservation observed within the antiterminator bulge. Additional factors or T box leader features more likely influenced the phylogenetic sequence conservation.

Structure-function relationships in RNA and RNP enzymes: recent advances

The structural biology of ribozymes and ribonucleoprotein (RNP) enzymes is now sufficiently advanced that a true dialogue between structural and functional studies is possible. In this review, we consider three important systems in which an integration of structural and biochemical data has recently led to major advances in mechanistic understanding. In the hammerhead ribozyme, application-driven biochemical studies led to the discovery of a key structural interaction that had been omitted from previously-studied constructs. A new crystal structure of the resulting, tertiary-stabilized hammerhead has resolved a remarkable number of longstanding paradoxes in the structure-function relationship of this ribozyme. In the Group I intron ribozyme, a flurry of high-resolution structures has largely confirmed, but in some cases refined or challenged, a detailed model of a metalloenzyme active site that had previously been derived by meticulous quantitative metal ion rescue experiments. Finally, for the peptidyl transferase center of the ribosome, recent biochemical and chemical results motivated by the pioneering crystal structures have suggested a picture of a catalytic mechanism dominated by proximity and orientation effects and substrate-assisted catalysis. These results refocus attention on catalysis as a property of the integrated RNP machinery as a whole, as opposed to a narrow concern with the RNA functional groups in immediate contact with the reactive center.

High hydrostatic pressure approach proves RNA catalytic activity without magnesium

High hydrostatic pressure (HHP) technique was used to evaluate a mechanism of RNA hydrolysis with RNA. We showed that hammerhead ribozyme specifically cleaves RNA substrate at HHP in the absence of Mg(2+). A deoxyribozyme "10-23" was active in the same conditions. These results pointed out that the hydrolytic activity of nucleic acid depends on proper tertiary structure of a complex with a substrate. They prove that magnesium ion is not directly involved in catalysis process. On that basis we show the mechanism of RNA hydrolysis catalyzed with nucleic acids at HHP.

T box riboswitch antiterminator affinity modulated by tRNA structural elements

A unique RNA-RNA interaction occurs between uncharged tRNA and the untranslated mRNA leader region of bacterial T box genes. The interaction results in activation of a transcriptional antitermination molecular switch (riboswitch) by stabilizing an antiterminator RNA element and precluding formation of a competing transcriptional terminator RNA element. The stabilization requires the base pairing of cognate tRNA acceptor end nucleotides with the antiterminator. To develop an appropriate model system for detailed structural studies and to screen for small molecule disruption of this important RNA-RNA interaction, steady-state fluorescence measurements of antiterminator model RNAs were used to determine the dissociation constant for model tRNA binding. The antiterminator-binding affinity for the full, minihelix, microhelix, and tetramer tRNA models differed by orders of magnitude. In addition, not all of the tRNA models exhibited functionally relevant binding specificity. The results from these experiments highlight the importance of looking beyond the level of known base pairing interactions when designing functionally relevant models of riboswitch systems.

A tale in molecular recognition: the hammerhead ribozyme

A new crystal structure of the hammerhead ribozyme demonstrates the influence of peripheral tertiary contacts on the local conformations around the active site. This structure resolves many conflicting results obtained on reduced systems.

Engineering high-speed allosteric hammerhead ribozymes

Full-length hammerhead ribozymes were subjected to in vitro selection to identify variants that are allosterically regulated by theophylline in the presence of a physiologically relevant concentration of Mg(2+). The population of allosteric ribozymes resulting from 15 rounds of in vitro selection yielded variants with observed rate constants (k (obs)) as high as 8 min(-1) in the presence of theophylline and maximal k (obs) increases of up to 285-fold compared to rate constants measured in the absence of effector. The selected ribozymes have kinetic characteristics that are predicted to be sufficient for cellular gene control applications, but do not exhibit any activity in reporter gene assays. The inability of the engineered RNAs to control gene expression suggests that the in vitro and in vivo folding pathways of the RNAs are different. These results provide several key pieces of information that will aid in future efforts to engineer allosteric ribozymes for gene control applications.

When to believe what you see

The recent X-ray crystal structure of a hammerhead ribozyme derived from Schistosoma mansoni containing the rate-enhancing peripheral domain has a catalytic core that is very different from the catalytic core present in the structure of the "minimal" hammerhead, which lacks a peripheral domain (Martick and Scott, 2006). The new structure reconciles many of the disagreements between the minimal hammerhead structure and the biochemical data on the cleavage properties of chemically modified hammerheads. The new structure also emphasizes the dynamic nature of small RNA domains and provides a cautionary tale for everyone who tries to use structure to understand function.

A database search for hammerhead ribozyme motifs

The hammerhead ribozyme is the smallest naturally occurring RNA endonuclease. It is found in subviral plant pathogens and transcripts of satellite DNA from a limited number of organisms. We have performed a database search for novel examples of this catalytic RNA, taking into consideration the recently defined structural requirements for an efficient cleavage under physiological magnesium ion concentrations. In this search, we find, apart from the known examples, several hundreds of motifs in organisms of all kingdoms of life. In a first set of experiments, we analysed hammerhead ribozymes from Arabidopsis thaliana. We found that these sequences are tissue-specifically expressed and that they undergo self-cleavage in planta. Furthermore, their activity under physiological magnesium ion concentrations depends on functional loop-loop interactions, as shown by the lack of activity of appropriate mutants.

Low-magnesium, trans-cleavage activity by type III, tertiary stabilized hammerhead ribozymes with stem 1 discontinuities

BACKGROUND

Low concentrations of free magnesium in the intracellular environment can present critical limitations for hammerhead ribozymes, especially for those that are designed for intermolecular (trans) cleavage of a host or pathogen RNA. Tertiary stabilizing motifs (TSM's) from natural and artificial ribozymes with a "type I" topology have been exploited to stabilize trans-cleaving hammerheads. Ribozymes with "type II" or "type III" topologies might seem incompatible with conversion to trans-cleavage designs, because opening the loop at the end of stem 1 or stem 2 to accommodate substrate binding is expected to disrupt the TSM and eliminate tertiary stabilization.

RESULTS

Stem 1, together with single-stranded segments capping or internal to this stem, contains both the substrate-binding and tertiary stabilization functions. This stem was made discontinuous within the sTRSV hammerhead ribozyme, thereby separating the two functions into discrete structural segments. The resulting ribozyme, designated "RzC," cleaved its 13 nucleotide target substrate at MgCl2 concentrations as low as 0.2 mM at 25 degrees C and 0.5 mM at 37 degrees C. Under multiple-turnover conditions, nearly thirty turnovers were observed at the highest substrate:RzC ribozyme ratios. Similar stabilization was observed for several derivatives of RzC. Catalytic activity was diminished or eliminated at sub-millimolar MgCl2 concentrations for ribozymes with weakened or deleted tertiary interactions. Eadie-Hofstee analysis revealed that the stabilized and non-stabilized ribozymes bind their substrates with equivalent affinities, suggesting that differences in observed activity are not the result of diminished binding. Some of the stabilized and non-stabilized ribozymes appear to fold into a heterogeneous collection of conformers, only a subset of which are catalytically active.

CONCLUSION

Hammerhead ribozymes with the "type III" topology can be converted to a tertiary, trans-cleavage design. Separating the stabilization and substrate recognition functions of stem 1 increases cleavage activity at physiological concentrations of divalent magnesium while retaining recognition of exogenous targets. Trans-cleaving ribozymes that exploit the tertiary stabilizing motifs of all natural hammerhead topologies can therefore be used in intracellular applications.

Ribozyme motif structure mapped using random recombination and selection

Isolating the core functional elements of an RNA is normally performed during the characterization of a new RNA in order to simplify further biochemical analysis. The removal of extraneous sequence is challenging and can lead to biases that result from the incomplete sampling of deletion variants. An impartial solution to this problem is to construct a library containing a large number of deletion constructs and to select functional RNA isolates that are at least as efficient as their full-length progenitors. Here, we use nonhomologous recombination and selection to isolate the catalytic core of a pyrimidine nucleotide synthase ribozyme. A variable-length pool of approximately 10(8) recombinant molecules that included deletions, inversions, and translocations of a 271-nucleotide-long ribozyme isolate was constructed by digesting and randomly religating its DNA genome. In vitro selection for functional ribozymes was then performed in a size-dependent and a size-independent manner. The final pools had nearly equivalent catalytic rates even though their length distributions were completely different, indicating that a diverse range of deletion constructs were functionally active. Four short sequence islands, requiring as little as 81 nt of sequence, were found within all of the truncated ribozymes and could be folded into a secondary structure consisting of three helix-loops. Our findings suggest that nonhomologous recombination is a highly efficient way to isolate a ribozyme's core motif and could prove to be a useful method for evolving new ribozyme functions from pre-existing sequences in a manner that may have played an important role early in evolution.

Comparative single-turnover kinetic analyses oftrans-cleaving hammerhead ribozymes with naturally derived non-conserved sequence motifs

trans-Cleaving hammerhead ribozyme variants were generated with mimicked non-conserved internal loop motifs derived from five structurally diverse natural cis-cleaving ribozymes. Most modified trans-cleaving variants showed enhanced single-turnover cleavage rates relative to minimal counterparts that lack tertiary interactions between internal loop motifs I and II, and relative to controls with sequence changes in loop I. The trans-cleaving ribozyme derived from the positive strand of peach latent mosaic viroid had the highest observed cleavage rate, suggesting a structurally optimized motif that facilitates rapid formation of the ribozyme catalytic center in a trans-reaction.

Characterization of a native hammerhead ribozyme derived from schistosomes

A recent re-examination of the role of the helices surrounding the conserved core of the hammerhead ribozyme has identified putative loop-loop interactions between stems I and II in native hammerhead sequences. These extended hammerhead sequences are more active at low concentrations of divalent cations than are minimal hammerheads. The loop-loop interactions are proposed to stabilize a more active conformation of the conserved core. Here, a kinetic and thermodynamic characterization of an extended hammerhead sequence derived from Schistosoma mansoni is performed. Biphasic kinetics are observed, suggesting the presence of at least two conformers, one cleaving with a fast rate and the other with a slow rate. Replacing loop II with a poly(U) sequence designed to eliminate the interaction between the two loops results in greatly diminished activity, suggesting that the loop-loop interactions do aid in forming a more active conformation. Previous studies with minimal hammerheads have shown deleterious effects of Rp-phosphorothioate substitutions at the cleavage site and 5' to A9, both of which could be rescued with Cd2+. Here, phosphorothioate modifications at the cleavage site and 5' to A9 were made in the schistosome-derived sequence. In Mg2+, both phosphorothioate substitutions decreased the overall fraction cleaved without significantly affecting the observed rate of cleavage. The addition of Cd2+ rescued cleavage in both cases, suggesting that these are still putative metal binding sites in this native sequence.