The placement of middle ear ventilation tubes: some indications and complications

Finnish approach to the treatment of acute otitis media. Report of the Finnish Consensus Conference

The theme of the first consensus conference to be held in Finland was the treatment of acute otitis media. The statements and recommendations accepted by the conference, which was organized according to the National Institutes of Health model, are presented in this report. On the basis of scientific knowledge, clinical experience, and conditions in Finland, the conference delegates concluded that penicillin V, in large doses, is still the drug of first choice in this disease. The importance of surgical drainage of the middle ear was stressed, as was the necessity of careful follow-up of the patient until the condition is completely healed. Decongestants were considered rather useless. In the prevention of recurrent attacks, adenoidectomy but not tonsillectomy was regarded as being of help, tympanostomy of probable benefit, antimicrobial (sulfonamide) prophylaxis worth considering in selected cases, but the effect of pneumococcal vaccination poor. The conference delegates agreed that uncomplicated acute otitis media should, as before, usually be treated by physicians taking care of children at the primary health care level.

A comparison of retention and complication rates of large-bore (Paparella II) and small-bore middle ear ventilating tubes

Large-bore myringotomy tubes are usually reserved for the treatment of refractory middle ear effusion. Theoretically, they have an extended intubation time and a higher complication rate. There is, however, scant support of this in the literature. The duration of intubation, efficacy, and complication rates of the large-bore Paparella type II tube were compared with Paparella type I, Shepard, and Armstrong tubes. The study included 242 patients with 600 intubations. In addition, a subpopulation of patients receiving their initial intubation during this study was reviewed. Findings were similar for both groups. Paparella type II tubes had a prolonged period of intubation and a decreased reintubation rate when compared with the smaller bore tubes. Larger bore tubes had an increased complication rate when compared with the smaller bore tubes. Complications included occasional or frequent otorrhea and an increased rate of permanent perforation of the tympanic membrane. There was no instance of cholesteatoma formation secondary to intubation. Guidelines are presented for the use of the Paparella type II tube.

Aberrant internal carotid artery in the middle ear

Aberrant internal carotid artery in the middle ear is a rare anomaly. Myringotomy in a patient with this anomaly caused violent hemorrhage, requiring immediate packing and eventual ligation of the artery. The anomaly may represent the artery bulging through a dehiscent bony canal, or it may be due to traction on the developing carotid by a persistent stapedial artery. Various middle ear symptoms have been reported in earlier cases. Diagnosis is by angiography, and therapy is surgical.

Effects of large-bore middle ear ventilation tubes

Patients with chronic otitis media that did not respond to conventional treatment were studied for the types and incidence of complications from the use of large-bore tubes inserted into their ears. The most common complication was otorrhea (41%, 50 of 123 ears). Permanent perforation occurred in 25% (17/68 ears). Use of large-bore tubes proved effective and continues to be indicated in certain conditions of chronic otitis media that are refractory to other forms of treatment.

Otitis media with effusion: a steroid and antibiotic therapeutic trial before surgery

Eustachian tube dysfunction has been considered the main factor in the etiology of otitis media with effusion (OME). A short-term systemic steroid therapy, with combined chemotherapeutics, yielded 53.1% cure in 160 children in which OME had been diagnosed, whereas only 12.5% of similar 116 children were cured by chemotherapeutic treatment alone. It is postulated that steroids, acting by a mechanism much similar to the one in the newborn lung, increase the level of a tubal surface active agent, thus enhancing Eustachian tube refunctioning. This combined treatment, we believe, deserves its place as a routine conservative trial before surgery.

Comparative study of various ventilating tubes

In less than 20 years, insertion of middle ear ventilating tubes has become perhaps the most common operative procedure. It was not possible to find a study that adequately compares the performance of the many different types of tympanostomy tubes available. The ideal ventilating tube is defined; it has not yet been designed.