Histology of vancomycin-supplemented impacted bone allografts in revision total hip arthroplasty

Current Insights in the Application of Bone Grafts for Local Antibiotic Delivery in Bone Reconstruction Surgery

Introduction: Bone implant related infection is still one of the biggest challenges in bone and joint surgery. Antibiotic impregnated bone grafts seem to be promising in both treatment and prevention of these infections. However, great variance in methodology predominates this field of research. This paper gives an overview of the published literature.

Methods: The PRISMA-flowchart was used as protocol for article selection. Medline was searched and articles were selected in accordance with predetermined exclusion criteria.

Results: Forty-eight articles were included in the synthesis. Topics including bone graft type, manipulations of the graft, elution profile, bacterial inhibition, osteotoxicity, incorporation, special impregnation methods, clinical use and storage were investigated.

Therapeutically, high initial levels seem appropriate for biofilm eradication. A single stage procedure in the treatment of bone implant related infection seems feasible. Prophylactically, the literature indicates a reduction of postoperative infections when using antibiotic impregnated bone grafts.

Conclusion: Bone grafts are a suitable carrier for local antibiotic application both therapeutically and prophylactically.

Effect of antibiotic impregnation time on the release of gentamicin from cryopreserved allograft bone chips: an in vitro study

Freezing is the most common method for storing bones until use in skeletal reconstruction. However, the effect of freezing at different temperatures on antibiotic delivery from antibiotic-coated bone chips has not been evaluated. In this study, we compared antibiotic delivery in vitro from gentamicin-coated human bone stored at different temperatures impregnated for different time periods. Bone chips obtained from human femur heads were chemically cleaned and mixed with gentamicin sulfate solution for 1 h and 10 h respectively. Samples of both groups were cryopreserved for 4 months at - 20 °C, 4 months at - 80 °C, or evaluated immediately without freezing. Antibiotic release from the bone chips was measured using Bacillus subtilis as an indicator strain. Zones of inhibition and rates of gentamicin were higher for the samples impregnated for 10 h as compared to 1 h. There was no significant difference between non-cryopreservation, cryopreservation at different temperatures of - 20 and - 80 °C on the release of gentamicin from bone chips even after storage for 4 months.

Gentamicin-Loaded Polysaccharide Membranes for Prevention and Treatment of Post-operative Wound Infections in the Skeletal System

PURPOSE

To develop polysaccharide-based membranes that allow controlled and localized delivery of gentamicin for the treatment of post-operative bone infections.

METHODS

Membranes made of gellan gum (GUM), sodium alginate (ALG), GUM and ALG crosslinked with calcium ions (GUM + Ca and ALG + Ca, respectively) as well as reference collagen (COL) were produced by freeze-drying. Mechanical properties, drug release, antimicrobial activity and cytocompatibility of the membranes were assessed.

RESULTS

The most appropriate handling and mechanical properties (Young's modulus, E = 92 ± 4 MPa and breaking force, F _MAX  = 2.6 ± 0.1 N) had GUM + Ca membrane. In contrast, COL membrane showed F _MAX  = 0.14 ± 0.02 N, E = 1.0 ± 0.3 MPa and was deemed to be unsuitable for antibiotic delivery. The pharmacokinetic data demonstrated a uniform and sustainable delivery of gentamicin from GUM + Ca (44.4 ± 1.3% within 3 weeks), while for COL, ALG and ALG + Ca membranes the most of the drug was released within 24 h (55.3 ± 1.9%, 52.5 ± 1.5% and 37.5 ± 1.8%, respectively). Antimicrobial activity against S. aureus and S. epidermidis was confirmed for all the membranes. GUM + Ca and COL membranes supported osteoblasts growth, whereas on ALG and ALG + Ca membranes cell growth was reduced.

CONCLUSIONS

GUM + Ca membrane holds promise for effective treatment of bone infections thanks to favorable pharmacokinetics, bactericidal activity, cytocompatibility and good mechanical properties.

Single-Stage Hip and Knee Exchange for Periprosthetic Joint Infection

Periprosthetic joint infections following hip and knee arthroplasty are challenging complications for Orthopaedic surgeons to manage. The single-stage exchange procedure is becoming increasingly popular with promising results. At our Institute we have demonstrated favourable or similar outcomes compared to the 'gold-standard' two-stage exchange, and other published single-stage results. The aim of this study is to describe the patient selection criteria and perioperative steps in a single-stage exchange for hip and knee arthroplasty undertaken at our Institute. The outlined protocol can be performed using standard debridement, attention to detail and well-recognised reconstructive techniques.

Polymer-controlled release of tobramycin from bone graft void filler

Despite clinical, material, and pharmaceutical advances, infection remains a major obstacle in total joint revision surgery. Successful solutions must extend beyond bulk biomaterial and device modifications, integrating locally delivered pharmaceuticals and physiological cues at the implant site, or within large bone defects with prominent avascular spaces. One approach involves coating clinically familiar allograft bone with an antibiotic-releasing rate-controlling polymer membrane for use as a matrix for local drug release in bone. The kinetics of drug release from this system can be tailored via alterations in the substrate or the polymeric coating. Drug-loaded polycaprolactone coating releases bioactive tobramycin from both cadaveric-sourced cancellous allograft fragments and synthetic hybrid coralline ceramic bone graft fragments with similar kinetics over a clinically relevant 6-week timeframe. However, micron-sized allograft particulate provides extended bioactive tobramycin release. Addition of porogen polyethylene glycol to the polymer coating formulation changes tobramycin release kinetics without significant impact on released antibiotic bioactivity. Incorporation of oil-microencapsulated tobramycin into the polymer coating did not significantly modify tobramycin release kinetics. In addition to releasing inhibitory concentrations of tobramycin, antibiotic-loaded allograft bone provides recognized beneficial osteoconductive potential, attractive for decreasing orthopedic surgical infections with improved filling of dead space and new bone formation.

Bone grafting and two-stage revision total hip arthroplasty

Periprosthetic deep infection in combination with substantial bone loss is one of the most challenging situations in revision hip surgery. We believe the effective management of these patients requires infection control as well as bone reconstruction. A review of our previously published studies on antibiotic loaded bone allografts is presented in this paper. These investigations provided us with information on the use of bone allografts in combination with antibiotics in cases of previous infection. Our protocol is based on removal of implants, meticulous debridement, parenteral antibiotic therapy and a second-stage reconstruction with vancomycin-supplemented bone allografts to treat an infected hip arthroplasty. We observed that vancomycin does not affect bone allograft incorporation at concentrations that are 300 times higher than the minimum inhibitory concentration for Staphylococcus aureus and Staphylococcus epidermidis. We also obtained adequate pharmacokinetics using these composites, with high local levels without renal impairment. This method has the capacity of acetabular and femoral bone stock restoration, with sound fixation and without increasing the rate of reinfection.

Immobilized antibiotics to prevent orthopaedic implant infections

Many surgical procedures require the placement of an inert or tissue-derived implant deep within the body cavity. While the majority of these implants do not become colonized by bacteria, a small percentage develops a biofilm layer that harbors invasive microorganisms. In orthopaedic surgery, unresolved periprosthetic infections can lead to implant loosening, arthrodeses, amputations and sometimes death. The focus of this review is to describe development of an implant in which an antibiotic tethered to the metal surface is used to prevent bacterial colonization and biofilm formation. Building on well-established chemical syntheses, studies show that antibiotics can be linked to titanium through a self-assembled monolayer of siloxy amines. The stable metal-antibiotic construct resists bacterial colonization and biofilm formation while remaining amenable to osteoblastic cell adhesion and maturation. In an animal model, the antibiotic modified implant resists challenges by bacteria that are commonly present in periprosthetic infections. While the long-term efficacy and stability is still to be established, ongoing studies support the view that this novel type of bioactive surface has a real potential to mitigate or prevent the devastating consequences of orthopaedic infection.

Antibiotic-impregnated bone grafts in orthopaedic and trauma surgery: a systematic review of the literature

There exist several options for local antibiotic therapy in orthopaedic and trauma surgery. Over the past years, the use of antibiotic-impregnated bone grafts (AIBGs) has become a popular procedure in the treatment of bone and joint infections. A major advantage of AIBGs involves the possibility of impregnation of various antibiotics depending on the sensitivity profile of the causative organism, whereas an additional surgery with removal of the antibiotic carrier is not necessary, as in the use of antibiotic-loaded bone cement. However, generalized conclusions cannot be clearly drawn from the existing literature due to differences of bone used, impregnation method, antibiotics, their doses, laboratory circumstances, or clinical indications. The present work reviews the literature regarding this topic and sheds some light onto the choice of bone and antibiotics, manufacturing details, and clinical experience.

Incidence of deep infection in aseptic revision THA using vancomycin-impregnated impacted bone allograft

The addition of antibiotic to cement is a frequent practice in aseptic revision hip surgery There is concern about adding vancomycin to cement due to potential effects on mechanical properties and prolonged elution of subtherapeutic levels antibiotic. Bone allografts can store and provide high levels of vancomycin to surrounding tissues. We analyzed the incidence of infection after one-stage aseptic revision hip reconstruction utilizing acetabular and/or femoral vancomycin-impregnated impacted bone allograft and a THA fixed with cement containing no antibiotic. We hypothesized that the infection rate may be similar to that reported in the literature following traditional impaction grafting using antibiotic loaded cement. Seventy five consecutive patients (80 hips) with a preoperative Merle D'Aubigné and Postel functional score averaging 4.8 points were followed up for a mean of 36 months (range 24 - 59 months). The incidence of infection was 1.25% (CI 95%=96.26-100%). A deep infection (thought to be haematognous in origin) occurred in 1 patient 2 years after the index surgery. The average postoperative Merle D´Aubigne score was 16.2 points. The last radiographic evaluation demonstrated a less than 5 mm acetabular migration and a less than 5 mm femoral subsidence in all cases. Vancomycin-supplemented allografts restored bone stock and provided sound fixation with a low incidence of infection. This incidence of deep sepsis is similar to that reported with antibiotic-loaded PMMA but without the reported mechanical and pharmacological disadvantages.

Bacterial colonization of bone allografts: establishment and effects of antibiotics

BACKGROUND

Bone grafts are frequently used to supplement bone stock and to establish structural stability. However, graft-associated infection represents a challenging complication leading to increased patient morbidity and healthcare costs.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

We therefore designed this study to (1) determine if increasing initial S. aureus inoculation of bone allograft results in a proportionate increase in colonization; (2) assess if antibiotics decrease colonization and if antibiotic tethering to allograft alters its ability to prevent bacterial colonization; and (3) determine if covalent modification alters the allograft topography or its biological properties.

METHODS

Allograft bone and vancomycin-modified bone (VAN-bone) was challenged with different doses of S. aureus for times out to 24 hours in the presence or absence of solution vancomycin. Bacterial colonization was assessed by fluorescence, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and by direct colony counting. Cell density and distribution of osteoblast-like cells on control and modified allograft were then compared.

RESULTS

Bacterial attachment was apparent within 6 hours with colonization and biofilm formation increasing with time and dose. Solution vancomycin failed to prevent bacterial attachment whereas VAN-bone successfully resisted colonization. The allograft modification did not affect the attachment and distribution of osteoblast-like cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Allograft bone was readily colonized by S. aureus and covered by a biofilm with especially florid growth in natural topographic niches. Using a novel covalent modification, allograft bone was able to resist colonization by organisms while retaining the ability to allow adhesion of osteoblastic cells.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Generation of allograft bone that can resist infection in vivo would be important in addressing one of the most challenging problems associated with the use of allograft, namely infection.

In vitro elution of moxifloxacin from cancellous bone allografts

The characteristics of cancellous bone allografts as carriers of moxifloxacin are described. Particles of cancellous bone were compressed into a wire-mesh cylinder and impregnated into a solution of moxifloxacin for different time periods. Five replicas were impregnated for 1 h; another five for 24 h; and another five for 48 h. Impregnated allografts were then transferred into vials containing 5 ml of Mueller-Hinton broth and incubated at 37 degrees C. Broth was replaced daily. Concentrations of moxifloxacin in broth were determined after analysis by an high performance liquid chromatography system. Moxifloxacin was eluted at very high concentrations within the first days. Concentrations remained above 100 microg/ml until day 8 and above 40 microg/ml until day 20. It is concluded that cancellous bone allografts may allow the adequate in vitro elution of moxifloxacin. The latter results support their application in experimental models of osteomyelitis.

In vitro release of fusidic acid and teicoplanin from cancellous bone allografts

The characteristics of cancellous bone allografts as carriers of fusidic acid and teicoplanin are described. Particles of cancellous bone were compressed into a wiremesh cylinder; five replicas were impregnated for one hour into fusidic acid; and another five for one hour into teicoplanin. Elution was estimated daily. Concentrations of fusidic acid and teicoplanin were determined by a microbiological assay. Both antibiotics were eluted at very high concentrations within the first days. Allografts impregnated in fusidic acid provided concentrations above 20 microg/ml for 20 days. Eluted teicoplanin after day 4 was below 10 microg/ml. It is concluded that cancellous bone allografts may allow adequate in vitro elution of fusidic acid but not of teicoplanin. The latter results support their application in experimental models of osteomyelitis.

The Long Oblique Revision component in revision arthroplasty of the hip

Migration of the acetabular component may give rise to oval-shaped bone defects in the acetabulum. The oblong implant is designed to fill these defects and achieve a stable cementless anchorage with no significant bone loss. We prospectively reviewed 133 oblong long oblique revision components at a mean follow-up of 9.74 years (0.6 to 14). All had been used in revisions for defects of type IIB to IIIB according to Paprosky. Aseptic loosening was the reason for revision in 11 cases (8.3%) and deep infection in seven (5.3%). The probability of implant survival over a 12-year follow-up estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method gave a survival rate of 0.85% respectively 0.90% when deep infection was excluded as the endpoint.

Our study supports the use of these components in defects from IIB to IIIA. The main precondition for success is direct contact of more than half of the surface of the implant with the host acetabular bone.

Viability of impacted bone allografts under metal mesh at the calcar in revision surgery of the hip

Metal meshes are used in revision surgery of the hip to contain impacted bone grafts in cases with cortical or calcar defects in order to provide rotational stability to the stem. However, the viability of bone allografts under these metal meshes has been uncertain. We describe the histological appearances of biopsies obtained from impacted bone allografts to the calcar contained by a metal mesh in two femoral reconstructions which needed further surgery at 24 and 33 months after the revision procedure. A line of osteoid and viable new bone was observed on the surface of necrotic trabeculae. Active bone marrow between these trabeculae showed necrotic areas in some medullary spaces with reparative fibrous tissue and isolated reactive lymphocytes. This is interpreted as reparative changes after revascularisation of the cancellous allografts. These pathological findings are similar to those reported in allografts contained by cortical host bone and support the hypothesis that incorporation of morcellised bone under metal meshes is not affected by these devices.

Bone allografts: What they can offer and what they cannot

Bone allografts can be used in any kind of surgery involving bone from minor defects to major bone loss after tumour resection. This review describes the various types of bone grafts and the current knowledge on bone allografts, from procurement and preparation to implantation. The surgical conditions for optimising the incorporation of bone are outlined, and surgeon expectations from a bone allograft discussed.

Vancomycin-supplemented cancellous bone allografts in hip revision surgery

We explored the role of vancomycin-supplemented cancellous bone allografts in hip revision surgery. We evaluated the incorporation of these allografts in 18 pigs' radiographs, histology, and immunohistochemistry. High-quality radiographs, histologic examination, and immunologic expression of metalloproteinase-13 and transforming growth factor-beta 2 indicated vancomycin did not considerably affect bone graft incorporation. Elution, bioactivity, and nephrotoxicity were subsequently tested in 20 patients who underwent hip reconstruction with this method. Local active bactericidal levels of vancomycin reached 1400.5 microg/mL (average 5-point level, 367.19 microg/mL). Vancomycin was present in urine until day 15 without any sign of nephrotoxicity. Clinical analysis was performed in 30 patients whose hips underwent reconstruction with vancomycin-supplemented cancellous bone allograft. At a minimum 2-year followup, infection control was attained in 29 of 30 patients (reinfection rate, 3.3%; 95% confidence interval, 0.08-17%) without evidence of graft resorption. Histologic observations performed in two patients whose hips were reconstructed with this technique were similar to the ones reported in nonsupplemented bone allografts. Our findings encourage the continued use of vancomycin-supplemented bone allografts in reconstructive orthopaedic surgery.

Iontophoresis of antibiotics into segmental allografts

Iontophoresis is a novel technique which may be used to facilitate the movement of antibiotics into the substance of bone using an electrical potential applied externally. We have examined the rate of early infection in allografts following application of this technique in clinical practice. A total of 31 patients undergoing revision arthroplasty or surgery for limb salvage received 34 iontophoresed sequential allografts, of which 26 survived for a minimum of two years. The mean serum antibiotic levels after operation were low (gentamicin 0.37 mg/l (0.2 to 0.5); flucloxacillin 1 mg/l (0 to 1) and the levels in the drains were high (gentamicin 40 mg/l (2.5 to 131); flucloxacillin 17 mg/l (1 to 43). There were no early deep infections. Two late infections were presumed to be haemotogenous; 28 of the 34 allografts were retained. In 12 patients with pre-existing proven infection further infection has not occurred at a mean follow-up of 51 months (24 to 82).