Severe crouch gait in spastic diplegia can be prevented

Distal femoral osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement for the treatment of crouch gait in patients with bilateral spastic cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND

Crouch gait, or flexed knee gait, represents a common gait pattern in patients with spastic bilateral cerebral palsy (CP). Distal femoral extension and/or shortening osteotomy (DFEO/DFSO) and patellar tendon advancement (PTA) can be considered as viable options when knee flexion contractures are involved. Better outcomes have been reported after a combination of both, independently of the presence of knee extensor lag. In this study, we evaluated the clinical and kinematic outcomes of these procedures.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We reviewed a cohort of 52 limbs (28 patients) who were treated for crouch gait by DFEO/DFSO alone (group 1, n = 15) or DFEO/DFSO + PTA (group 2, n = 37) as a part of single event multilevel surgery (SEMLS). The mean age at surgery was 14 years, and the mean follow-up time was 18 months. The physical examination data and three-dimensional standardized gait analysis were collected and analyzed before the surgery and postoperatively.

RESULTS

Overall knee range of motion improved in all limbs. The knee flexion decreased significantly in both groups at initial, mid, and terminal stance. Hip flexion significantly decreased in mid-stance for limbs in group 2. Both clinical and gait parameters were most improved in limbs who underwent DFEO/DFSO + PTA. Increased pelvic tilt was observed in both groups after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Although DFEO/DFSO alone was successful in correcting knee flexion contractures, PTA has helped to improve knee extensor lag and knee extension during gait.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic level IV.

Demonstrating the utility of Instrumented Gait Analysis in the treatment of children with cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND

Instrumented gait analysis (IGA) has been around for a long time but has never been shown to be useful for improving patient outcomes. In this study we demonstrate the potential utility of IGA by showing that machine learning models are better able to estimate treatment outcomes when they include both IGA and clinical (CLI) features compared to when they include CLI features alone.

DESIGN

We carried out a retrospective analysis of data from ambulatory children diagnosed with cerebral palsy who were seen at least twice at our gait analysis center. Individuals underwent a variety of treatments (including no treatment) between sequential gait analyses. We fit Bayesian Additive Regression Tree (BART) models that estimated outcomes for mean stance foot progression to demonstrate the approach. We built two models: one using CLI features only, and one using CLI and IGA features. We then compared the models' performance in detail. We performed similar, but less detailed, analyses for a number of other outcomes. All results were based on independent test data from a 70%/30% training/testing split.

RESULTS

The IGA model was more accurate than the CLI model for mean stance-phase foot progression outcomes (RMSEIGA = 11∘, RMSECLI = 13∘) and explained more than 1.5 × as much of the variance (R2IGA = .45, R2CLI = .28). The IGA model outperformed the CLI model for every level of treatment complexity, as measured by number of simultaneous surgeries. The IGA model also exhibited superior performance for estimating outcomes of mean stance-phase knee flexion, mean stance-phase ankle dorsiflexion, maximum swing-phase knee flexion, gait deviation index (GDI), and dimensionless speed.

INTERPRETATION

The results show that IGA has the potential to be useful in the treatment planning process for ambulatory children diagnosed with cerebral palsy. We propose that the results of machine learning outcome estimators-including estimates of uncertainty-become the primary IGA tool utilized in the clinical process, complementing the standard medical practice of conducting a through patient history and physical exam, eliciting patient goals, reviewing relevant imaging data, and so on.

Three-Dimensional Instrumented Gait Analysis for Children With Cerebral Palsy: An Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guideline

BACKGROUND

Children with cerebral palsy (CP) who walk have complex gait patterns and deviations often requiring physical therapy (PT)/medical/surgical interventions. Walking in children with CP can be assessed with 3-dimensional instrumented gait analysis (3D-IGA) providing kinematics (joint angles), kinetics (joint moments/powers), and muscle activity.

PURPOSE

This clinical practice guideline provides PTs, physicians, and associated clinicians involved in the care of children with CP, with 7 action statements on when and how 3D-IGA can inform clinical assessments and potential interventions. It links the action statement grades with specific levels of evidence based on a critical appraisal of the literature.

CONCLUSIONS

This clinical practice guideline addresses 3D-IGA's utility to inform surgical and non-surgical interventions, to identify gait deviations among segments/joints and planes and to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions. Best practice statements provide guidance for clinicians about the preferred characteristics of 3D-IGA laboratories including instrumentation, staffing, and reporting practices.Video Abstract: Supplemental digital content available at http://links.lww.com/PPT/A524.

Does patella lowering as part of multilevel surgery improve knee kinematics in children with cerebral palsy and crouch gait? A meta-analysis of comparative studies

Purpose

To evaluate differences in knee kinematic outcomes of patellar-lowering surgery, specifically patellar tendon advancement or patellar tendon shortening, compared with no-patellar-lowering surgery in multilevel surgery for children with cerebral palsy and crouch gait.

Methods

Four databases were searched to retrieve studies published from inception until 2023. Three reviewers independently screened for studies with observational or randomized control designs, comparing two groups of patients with cerebral palsy and crouch gait who underwent multilevel surgery (with patellar-lowering surgery versus no-patellar-lowering surgery), where various gait analysis outcomes were reported (CRD42023450692). The risk of bias was assessed with the Risk Of Bias In Non-randomised Studies - of Interventions (ROBINS-I) tool.

Results

Seven studies (249 patients and 368 limbs) met the eligibility criteria. Patients undergoing patellar-lowering surgery demonstrated statistically significant improvements in knee flexion at initial contact (mean difference = -6.39; 95% confidence interval = [-10.4, -2.75]; p = 0.0006; I2 = 84%), minimum knee flexion in stance (mean difference = -14.27; 95% confidence interval = [-18.31, -10.23]; p < 0.00001; I2 = 89%), and clinical knee flexion contracture (mean difference = -5.6; 95% confidence interval = [-9.59, -1.6]; p = 0.006; I2 = 95%), with a significant increase in anterior pelvic tilt (mean difference = 2.97; 95% confidence interval = [0.58, 5.36]; p = 0.01; I2 = 15%). However, improvements in gait deviation index and decrease in peak knee flexion in swing did not reach statistical significance. Subgroup analysis reduced heterogeneity and revealed (1) greater improvement using patellar tendon shortening versus patellar tendon advancement techniques; (2) lack of knee flexion contracture improvement in high-quality or longer-term studies; (3) longer-term improvement only in minimum knee flexion in stance, with a decrease in peak knee flexion in swing; and (4) an inability to assess the potential benefit of rectus femoris procedure and hamstring preservation.

Conclusions

Overall, the combination of patellar-lowering surgery with multilevel surgery demonstrated superior improvements in stance-phase knee kinematics compared with multilevel surgery alone, despite an increase in anterior pelvic tilt and a longer-term knee flexion reduction during the swing phase.

Level of evidence

Level III, Systematic review of level III studies.

A case series on the effect of dynamic neoprene orthosis on lower limb kinematic variables in children with cerebral palsy

PURPOSE

This study examined the effects of a dynamic neoprene orthosis on kinematic variables of gait in children with spastic bilateral cerebral palsy (CP).

METHODS

Five children (whose median age was 9.6 years and who ranged in age from six to 12) with spastic bilateral CP and flexed knee at levels I-III of the Gross Motor Function Classification System were examined using kinematic gait analysis in three different conditions: 1) with dynamic neoprene orthosis; 2) without dynamic neoprene orthosis (immediate effect); and 3) without orthosis after six weeks of intervention.

RESULTS

The comparison between condition one (with dynamic neoprene orthosis) and condition two (without dynamic neoprene orthosis) demonstrated the existence of improvements in minimum hip and knee flexion variables. Moreover, the results indicated that the improvements remained constant in several key gait variables after six weeks.

CONCLUSION

The results varied from subject to subject, and there were signs of improvement in some of the subjects. Therefore, it was not possible to draw conclusions at a group level. Nonetheless, a number of individuals may benefit from this type of orthosis.

Crouch Gait in Cerebral Palsy: Current Concepts Review

Background and Objective

Crouch gait is the most common pathological gait pattern in cerebral palsy and is commonly seen in patients with spastic diplegia. It is characterized by excessive knee flexion throughout the stance phase of gait cycle. The aim of this review is to discuss the current literature about CG for a more comprehensive understanding.

Methods

A literature review about various aspects of crouch gait in cerebral palsy was undertaken. This included its etiology and pathophysiology, biomechanics in crouch gait, natural history of untreated crouch gait, clinical and radiological evaluation and different modalities of available treatment.

Results

The etiology is multifactorial and the pathophysiology is poorly understood. This makes its management challenging, thereby leading to a variety of available treatment modalities. Inadvertent lengthening of muscle-tendon units is an important cause and can be avoided. A meticulous clinical and radiological evaluation of patients, supplemented by observational and instrumented gait analysis is mandatory in choosing correct treatment modality and improving the treatment outcome. Younger children can be managed satisfactorily by various non-operative methods and spasticity reduction measures. However, crouch gait in cerebral palsy has a progressive natural history and surgical interventions are needed frequently. The current literature supports combination of various soft tissue and bony procedures as a part of single event multilevel surgery. Growth modulation in the form of anterior distal femur hemiepiphysiodesis for correction of fixed flexion deformity of knee has shown encouraging results and can be an alternative in younger children with sufficient growth remaining.

Conclusions

In spite of extensive research in this field, the current understanding about crouch gait has many knowledge gaps. Further studies about the etiopathogenesis and biomechanics of crouch using instrumented gait analysis are suggested. Similarly, future research should focus on the long term outcomes of different treatment modalities through comparative trials.

Quantitative measures of motor development in Angelman syndrome

Angelman Syndrome is a rare neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by developmental delay, lack of speech, seizures, intellectual disability, characteristic behavior, and movement disorders. Clinical gait analysis provides the opportunity for movement quantification to investigate an observed maladaptive change in gait pattern and offers an objective outcome of change. Pressure-sensor-based technology, inertial and activity monitoring, and instrumented gait analysis (IGA) were employed to define motor abnormalities in Angelman syndrome. Temporal-spatial gait parameters of persons with Angelman Syndrome (pwAS) show deficiencies in gait performance through walking speed, step length, step width, and walk ratio. pwAS walk with reduced step lengths, increased step width, and greater variability. Three-dimensional motion kinematics showed increased anterior pelvic tilt, hip flexion, and knee flexion. PwAS have a walk ratio more than two standard deviations below controls. Dynamic electromyography showed prolonged activation of knee extensors, which was associated with a decreased range of motion and the presence of hip flexion contractures. Use of multiple gait tracking modalities revealed that pwAS exhibit a change in gait pattern to a flexed knee gait pattern.  Cross-sectional studies of individuals with AS show a regression toward this maladaptive gait pattern over development in pwAS ages 4-11. PwAS unexpectedly did not have spasticity associated with change in gait pattern. Multiple quantitative measures of motor patterning may offer early biomarkers of gait decline consistent with critical periods of intervention, insight into appropriate management strategies, objective primary outcomes, and early indicators of adverse events.

Surgical Management of Severe Equinus Deformity in Ambulatory Children With Cerebral Palsy

BACKGROUND

Tendo Achilles lengthening (TAL) for the management of equinus contractures in ambulatory children with cerebral palsy (CP) is generally not recommended due to concerns of over-lengthening, resulting in weakness and plantar flexor insufficiency. However, in some cases, surgical correction of severe equinus deformities can only be achieved by TAL. The goal of this study is to assess the outcomes following TAL in these cases.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study of children with CP with severe equinus contractures (ankle dorsiflexion with the knee extended of -20 degrees or worse) who underwent TAL as part of a single event multilevel surgery, with preoperative and postoperative gait analysis studies. Continuous data were analyzed by paired t test, and categorical data by McNemar Test.

RESULTS

There were 60 subjects: 42 unilateral, 18 bilateral CP; 41 GMFCS II, 17 GMFCS I; mean age at surgery was 10.6 years, mean follow-up was 1.3 years. Ankle dorsiflexion with the knee extended improved from -28 to 5 degrees (P<0.001). The ankle Gait Variable Score improved from 34.4 to 8.6 (P<0.001). The ankle moment in terminal stance improved from 0.43 to 0.97 Nm/kg (P<0.001). Significant improvements (P<0.001) were seen in radiographic measures of foot alignment following surgery. There were few significant differences in the outcome parameters between subjects with unilateral versus bilateral CP (eg, only the bilateral group showed improved but persistent increased knee flexion in mid-stance).

CONCLUSIONS

The outcomes following TAL for the management of severe equinus deformity in ambulatory children with CP were favorable 1 year after surgery, with significant improvements in all domains measured.

SIGNIFICANCE

This study does not advocate for the widespread use of TAL to correct equinus deformity in children with CP. However, it does show that good short-term outcomes following TAL are possible in properly selected subjects with severe contractures when the dosing of the surgery is optimal (correction of contracture to between 0 and 5 degrees of dorsiflexion with the knee extended) and the procedure is performed in the setting of single event multilevel surgery with subsequent proper orthotic management and rehabilitation.

Long-term outcome of hamstring lengthening versus transfer and the role of biceps femoris lengthening in patients with spastic diplegia and dynamic knee flexion in gait

BACKGROUND

Orthopedic treatment of flexed-knee gait consists of hamstring lengthening along with surgery at other levels. Transfer of the semitendinosus (hamstring transfer) was introduced to avoid increase of anterior pelvic tilt as well as reduce risk of recurrence.

METHODS

We retrospectively assessed children with spastic cerebral palsy and flexed-knee gait pre-operatively, 1 year post-operatively, and at a minimum of 7 years post-operatively.

RESULTS

The 39 patients were a mean 9.4 ± 3.4 years at the time of surgery, 20 subjects underwent hamstring transfer, and 19 subjects had hamstring lengthening with mean follow-up 9.1 years. Passive range of motion improved initially, but regressed at long term. Dynamic minimum knee flexion in stance decreased in both groups at the first post-operative study, and was maintained at final follow-up in 64-67% of patients. There was a small increase in anterior pelvic tilt at the 1-year follow-up which subsequently decreased to less than pre-operative in the hamstring lengthening group but remained mildly increased (5°) in the hamstring transfer group at final follow-up. Success in correcting stance knee flexion of the entire group was 69% of the Gross Motor Function Classification System grades I and II and 60% of the Gross Motor Function Classification System grade III subjects. Gait profile Score and sagittal knee Gait Variable Score both showed clinically important improvement after surgery and was mostly maintained long term for both groups. Lateral hamstring lengthening was beneficial in more severe patients, with minimal risk of adverse effects.

CONCLUSION

Hamstring surgery as part of single event multi-level surgery (SEMLS) is effective in correcting flexed-knee gait in 60%-70% of patients with minimal effect on anterior pelvic tilt. There was no added advantage to hamstring transfer. Biceps Femoris lengthening may be beneficial and without significant additional risk.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

level III.

Distal femoral extension osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement or shortening in ambulatory children with cerebral palsy: A modified Delphi consensus study and literature review

PURPOSE

In children with cerebral palsy, flexion deformities of the knee can be treated with a distal femoral extension osteotomy combined with either patellar tendon advancement or patellar tendon shortening. The purpose of this study was to establish a consensus through expert orthopedic opinion, using a modified Delphi process to describe the surgical indications for distal femoral extension osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement/patellar tendon shortening. A literature review was also conducted to summarize the recent literature on distal femoral extension osteotomy and patellar tendon shortening/patellar tendon advancement.

METHOD

A group of 16 pediatric orthopedic surgeons, with more than 10 years of experience in the surgical management of children with cerebral palsy, was established. The group used a 5-level Likert-type scale to record agreement or disagreement with statements regarding distal femoral extension osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement/patellar tendon shortening. Consensus for the surgical indications for distal femoral extension osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement/patellar tendon shortening was achieved through a modified Delphi process. The literature review, summarized studies of clinical outcomes of distal femoral extension osteotomy/patellar tendon shortening/patellar tendon advancement, published between 2008 and 2022.

RESULTS

There was a high level of agreement with consensus for 31 out of 44 (70%) statements on distal femoral extension osteotomy. Agreement was lower for patellar tendon advancement/patellar tendon shortening with consensus reached for 8 of 21 (38%) of statements. The literature review included 25 studies which revealed variation in operative technique for distal femoral extension osteotomy, patellar tendon advancement, and patellar tendon shortening. Distal femoral extension osteotomy and patellar tendon advancement/patellar tendon shortening were generally effective in correcting knee flexion deformities and extensor lag, but there was marked variation in outcomes and complication rates.

CONCLUSION

The results from this study will provide guidelines for surgeons who care for children with cerebral palsy and point to unresolved questions for further research.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

level V.

Cost savings for single event multilevel surgery in comparison to sequential surgery in ambulatory children with cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this study was to determine the differences in billable provider charges between single event multilevel surgery (SEMLS) based on comprehensive gait analysis and a staged surgical approach (SSA) without comprehensive gait analysis for the orthopedic treatment of ambulatory children with cerebral palsy (CP).

METHODS

The charges associated with nine common orthopedic surgical combinations (both unilateral and bilateral, soft tissue or soft tissue plus bony) for children with CP were determined and compared between SEMLS and SSA. The charges included surgical, anesthesia, operating room, recovery room, hospital stay, physical therapy, and, for SEMLS only, comprehensive computerized gait analysis.

RESULTS

Total charges to complete each combination was higher for SSA than for SEMLS. The differential ranged from $10,247 to $75,069 with the percentage difference ranging from 20% to 47%. The mean difference was $43,606 (p = 0.0002). The dollar difference (r = 0.98, p < 0.0001) and percentage difference (r = 0.79, p = 0.01) were both related to the total charge of the SEMLS surgery.

SIGNIFICANCE

Financial costs are lower for SEMLS vs. SSA for the treatment of multilevel gait issues in children with CP. The cost of gait analysis is much smaller than the cost differential between SEMLS and SSA. Although some patients who have SEMLS may need additional orthopedic surgery with associated costs, this is also possible for SSA. Therefore, due to the many benefits of SEMLS, which also include more informed treatment decision-making as well as reduced time away from school and work (for caregivers), SEMLS guided by gait analysis is recommended over SSA for the treatment of gait disorders in children with CP.

The change in sagittal plane gait patterns from childhood to maturity in bilateral cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND

The longitudinal stability of sagittal gait patterns in diplegic cerebral palsy (CP), stratified using the Rodda classification, is currently unknown.

RESEARCH QUESTION

What is the trajectory of sagittal plane gait deformities as defined by the Rodda classification in a large cohort treated with orthopedic surgery guided by gait analysis?

METHODS

A retrospective study utilized gait analysis to evaluate sagittal gait parameters before age 8 and after age 15 years. Individual limbs were categorized at each time point according to the Rodda classification based on mean sagittal plane knee and ankle angle during stance. Welch's t-tests compared gait variables from early childhood with maturity and examined changes associated with plantarflexor lengthening surgery.

RESULTS

100 youth with CP were evaluated twice: at a mean age of 5.49 ± 1.18 and 19.09 ± 4.32 years, respectively. Gross Motor Function Classification System distribution at maturity was I (10.5 %), II (55.2 %), III (28.6 %), and IV (5.7 %). At the initial visit, most limbs were in either true equinus (30 %) or jump-knee gait (26.5 %). At maturity, crouch gait (52.5 %) was the most common classification, of which 47.6 % were mild (1-3 standard deviations from age-matched norm; 21°-30°) and 52.4 % moderate or severe. For the entire cohort, at initial and final visits, respectively, mean knee flexion in stance was 26.8°±14.8° and 25.9°±11.4° (p = 0.320), ankle dorsiflexion in stance increased from -0.3°±11.5° to 9.0°±6.0° (p < 0.001), and passive knee flexion contracture was -2.3°±7.0° and -3.9°±8.0° (p = 0.043). In children who started in true equinus, apparent equinus, and crouch, there was no difference in stance phase knee flexion at maturity between those who underwent plantarflexor lengthenings versus those who did not (p > 0.18).

SIGNIFICANCE

The trend in this cohort was toward crouch with increased stance phase ankle dorsiflexion from early childhood to maturity. Plantarflexor lengthenings were not a significant factor in the progression of stance phase knee flexion.

Gutenberg Gait Database, a ground reaction force database of level overground walking in healthy individuals

The Gutenberg Gait Database comprises data of 350 healthy individuals recorded in our laboratory over the past seven years. The database contains ground reaction force (GRF) and center of pressure (COP) data of two consecutive steps measured - by two force plates embedded in the ground - during level overground walking at self-selected walking speed. The database includes participants of varying ages, from 11 to 64 years. For each participant, up to eight gait analysis sessions were recorded, with each session comprising at least eight gait trials. The database provides unprocessed (raw) and processed (ready-to-use) data, including three-dimensional GRF and two-dimensional COP signals during the stance phase. These data records offer new possibilities for future studies on human gait, e.g., the application as a reference set for the analysis of pathological gait patterns, or for automatic classification using machine learning. In the future, the database will be expanded continuously to obtain an even larger and well-balanced database with respect to age, sex, and other gait-specific factors.

The influence of preoperative knee flexion contracture severity on short-term outcome of orthopedic surgery in ambulatory children with bilateral cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND

Indications and cutoff value of deformities to determine surgical procedures for flexed knee gait are not clear. The aim was to determine the influence of none or mild, and moderate preoperative knee flexion contracture on the improvement of gait after orthopedic surgery in children with bilateral cerebral palsy (CP).

METHODS

Inclusion criteria; bilateral CP, Gross Motor Function Classification System level I-III, and pre- and post operative-gait analysis. The 132 individuals identified were categorized into 2 groups based on the severity of knee flexion contracture (group 1: none or less than 11°; group 2: greater than or equal to 11°), and then matched according to the exact same soft tissue and/or bony orthopedic surgical procedures performed. The indication for surgery was to prevent progressive development of knee flexion contracture and stance phase flexed knee gait. Pre- and postoperative physical examination and gait analysis data were analyzed retrospectively.

RESULTS

Sixty (30 + 30) children, with mean age 10.6 years in each group, were included. The average follow-up time was 17 months. Gait Deviation Index (GDI) improved in group 1 from mean 66 (SD 19) to 74 (15), p = 0.004, and in group 2 from 60 (13) to 69 (15), p = 0.001. Knee flexion in stance improved in group 1 from 21.4 (16.1) to 12.1 (16.0) degrees, p = 0.002, and in group 2 from 32.2 (14.2) to 17.0 (15.9), p = 0.001. Step length improved in both groups, p = 0.017 and p = 0.008, respectively. Only in group 2 significant improvement was noted in walking speed, p = 0.018 and standing function, Gross Motor Function Measure (GMFM-D), p = 0.001. Knee flexion contracture decreased in group 1 from mean 4.6 (5.3) to 2.1 (8.3) degrees, p = 0.071 and in group 2 from 17.2 (4.9) to 9.6 (9.3), p = 0.001. There was no statistical difference between groups in pre-post improvement of GDI or other variables, except GMFM-D.

CONCLUSIONS

Relative mild to moderate preoperative knee flexion contracture does not influence the short-term improvement of gait after orthopedic surgery in children with bilateral CP.

Postoperative changes in vertical ground reaction forces, walking barefoot and with ankle-foot orthoses in children with Cerebral Palsy

BACKGROUND

Children with cerebral palsy often have problems to support the body centre of mass, seen as increased ratio between excessive vertical ground reaction forces during weight acceptance and decreased forces below bodyweight in late stance. We aimed to examine whether increasing ankle range of motion through surgery and restraining motion with ankle-foot orthoses postoperatively would have impact on the vertical ground reaction force in weight acceptance and late stance.

METHODS

Ground reaction forces were recorded from 24 children with bilateral and 32 children with unilateral cerebral palsy, each measured walking barefoot before and after triceps surae lengthening. Postoperatively, the children were also measured walking with ankle-foot orthoses. Changes in vertical ground reaction forces between the three conditions were evaluated with functional curve and descriptive peak analyses; accounting for repeated measures and within-subject correlation.

FINDINGS

After surgery, there were decreased vertical ground reaction forces in weight acceptance and increased forces in late stance. Additional significant changes with ankle-foot orthoses involved increased vertical forces in weight acceptance, and in late stance corresponding to bodyweight (bilateral, from 92% to 98% bodyweight; unilateral, from 94% to 103% bodyweight) postoperatively.

INTERPRETATION

Our findings confirmed that surgery affected vertical ground reaction forces to approach more normative patterns. Additional changes with ankle-foot orthoses indicated further improved ability to support bodyweight and decelerate centre of mass in late stance.

Musculoskeletal Pathology in Cerebral Palsy: A Classification System and Reliability Study

This article presents a classification of lower limb musculoskeletal pathology (MSP) for ambulant children with cerebral palsy (CP) to identify key features from infancy to adulthood. The classification aims to improve communication, and to guide referral for interventions, which if timed appropriately, may optimise long-term musculoskeletal health and function. Consensus was achieved by discussion between staff in a Motion Analysis Laboratory (MAL). A four-stage classification system was developed: Stage 1: Hypertonia: Abnormal postures are dynamic. Stage 2: Contracture: Fixed shortening of one or more muscle-tendon units. Stage 3: Bone and joint deformity: Torsional deformities and/or joint instability (e.g., hip displacement or pes valgus), usually accompanied by contractures. Stage 4: Decompensation: Severe pathology where restoration of optimal joint and muscle-tendon function is not possible. Reliability of the classification was tested using the presentation of 16 clinical cases to a group of experienced observers, on two occasions, two weeks apart. Reliability was found to be very good to excellent, with mean Fleiss' kappa ranging from 0.72 to 0.84. Four-stages are proposed to classify lower limb MSP in children with CP. The classification was reliable in a group of clinicians who work together. We emphasise the features of decompensated MSP in the lower limb, which may not always benefit from reconstructive surgery and which can be avoided by timely intervention.

Three-Dimensional Gait Analysis in Children Undergoing Gastrocsoleus Lengthening for Equinus Secondary to Cerebral Palsy

Background and Objectives: Equinus is the most common deformity in children with cerebral palsy, and surgical lengthening of the gastrocsoleus muscle-tendon unit is the most commonly performed operation for children with cerebral palsy. Treatment outcomes of orthopaedic surgery can be measured objectively with three-dimensional gait analysis. This study examined the quality of evidence for gastrocsoleus lengthening surgery based on objective measures. Materials and Methods: A search was performed with Medline, Embase and PubMed from 1990 to 25 August 2020 using the keywords "cerebral palsy", "equinus", "surgery" and "gait analysis". Only studies of gastrocsoleus lengthening surgery using three-dimensional gait analysis were included, yielding 34 studies. Results: Fourteen studies reported swing phase kinematics and all studies reported a significant improvement. Rates of recurrent equinus and calcaneus were reported in 21 studies and varied widely based on follow-up period and surgical technique. Conclusions: Poor study quality and marked variability in study samples and interventions made comparison difficult. Future studies should consider prospective design, controls or comparison groups and more detailed breakdowns of outcomes by cerebral palsy subtype, sagittal gait pattern, and equinus type in order to allow more rigorous treatment recommendations to be made.

Crouch gait or flexed-knee gait in cerebral palsy: Is there a difference? A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Crouch or flexed-knee gait is one of the most common pathological gait patterns in cerebral palsy (CP). Differences exist in definitions used; the degree of knee flexion, inclusion of hip or ankle position, and timing in the gait cycle. This ambiguity may be responsible for variations in prevalence rates and difficulty comparing data across studies.

RESEARCH QUESTION

What are the kinematic parameters used to define crouch or flexed-knee gait in CP gait? A secondary aim was to examine the quality of data reporting, focusing on the sample characteristics, inclusion/exclusion criteria and the choice of limb included for analysis.

METHODS

Articles included in this review reported on a specified cohort of adults or children with crouch or flexed-knee gait assessed with 3-dimensional gait analysis. A customised data extraction and quality assessment table was designed specific to the research question.

RESULTS

The majority (75 %) of included studies used the term crouch gait. Where the pattern was defined, 80 % of crouch papers and 94 % of flexed-knee gait papers based this solely on knee position. Kinematic parameters were clearly defined when they provided objective values of knee flexion, supported this with rationale and provided a reference point in the gait cycle. Only 22 % of crouch papers and 19 % of flexed-knee gait papers provided this information. The majority of studies (67 % crouch; 90 % flexed-knee) specified which limb(s) were included for analysis with the majority including both limbs. Objective values of knee flexion ranged from 8 o to 30 o.

SIGNIFICANCE

This review highlights that crouch and flexed knee are synonymous and ambiguity exists in the kinematic definition making it difficult to make compare data amongst study cohorts. Future research should provide detailed definitions including the threshold value of knee flexion, how it was derived, the timing in the gait cycle and the limb(s) included in analysis.

Clinical efficacy of instrumented gait analysis: Systematic review 2020 update

BACKGROUND

This paper updates our 2011 systematic review on the clinical efficacy of three-dimensional instrumented gait analysis (3DGA).

RESEARCH QUESTION

What is the current evidence base pertaining to the clinical efficacy of 3DGA?

METHODS

We identified English language articles published from September 2009 to October 2019 reporting primary research that used typical motion analysis laboratory methods to study human walking. Five gait laboratory experts classified articles according to the highest type of efficacy they addressed: type 1 (technical), 2 (diagnostic accuracy), 2b (outcome prediction), 3-4 (diagnostic thinking and treatment), 5 (patient outcome), 6 (societal). Articles classified into type 3-4 and higher were rated for quality using LEGEND.

RESULTS

Of 2712 articles related to the efficacy of 3DGA, over 99% addressed technical (n = 313), diagnostic (n = 1466), or outcome prediction (n = 927) efficacy. Six type 3-4 studies showed that 3DGA changes treatment plans, increases clinicians' confidence in their treatment decisions, and increases agreement among clinicians. Two type 5 articles based on a randomized controlled trial demonstrated that patient outcomes improved only when 3DGA data were available and its recommendations were followed. A population-based type 5 study found that the incidence of severe crouch gait dropped from 25% to 4% following practice changes including the addition of 3DGA. The strength of evidence was mainly 3b (lesser quality prospective cohort studies) but also included stronger studies (three level 2 controlled clinical trials).

SIGNIFICANCE

Literature related to the clinical efficacy of 3DGA has grown substantially over the last decade. Thousands of articles contribute to continued improvement of data collection and interpretation, as well as understanding of gait pathology and treatment. A smaller number of studies clearly demonstrate the efficacy of 3DGA in changing and reinforcing treatment decisions, increasing clinicians' confidence in treatment planning, and increasing agreement among clinicians, as well as the potential to improve patient outcomes.

Distal Femoral Shortening Osteotomy for Severe Knee Flexion Contracture and Crouch Gait in Cerebral Palsy

Although there have been advancements of surgical techniques to correct gait abnormalities seen in patients with cerebral palsy, the crouch gait remains one of the most difficult problems to treat. The purpose of this retrospective study was to examine our results of distal femoral shortening osteotomy (DFSO) and patellar tendon advancement (PTA), performed in patients with crouch gait associated with severe knee flexion contracture. A total of 33 patients with a mean fixed knee contracture of 38° were included in the study. The mean age at the time of surgery was 12.2 years and the mean follow-up was 26.9 months. The measurements of clinical, radiological, and gait parameters were performed before and after surgery. The mean degrees of knee flexion contracture, Koshino index of patella height, and Gait Deviation Index were found to be significantly improved at the time of final follow-up. The maximum knee extension during the stance phase improved by an average of 25°, and the range of knee motion during gait increased postoperatively. On the other hand, the mean anterior pelvic tilt increased by 9.9°. Also, the maximum knee flexion during the swing phase decreased and the timing of peak knee flexion was observed to be delayed. We conclude that combined procedure of DFSO and PTA is an effective and safe surgical method for treating severe knee flexion contracture and crouch gait. However, the surgeons should be aware of the development of increased anterior pelvic tilt and stiff knee gait after the index operation.

Use of 3D gait analysis as predictor of Achilles tendon lengthening surgery outcomes in children with cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND

In children with spastic cerebral palsy (CP), the treatment of equinus foot with Achilles tendon lengthening (ATL) surgery is associated with high incidence of overcorrection, which may result in crouch gait.

AIM

We aimed to assess if gait pattern in preoperative time could be a predictor of the surgery outcome.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional retrospective study.

SETTING

Movement Analysis Lab of IRCCS San Raffaele Pisana Hospital in Rome (Italy).

POPULATION

Eighteen children (mean age 9.6±4.7 years) with spastic diplegia CP who underwent bilateral ATL surgery to correct equinus foot were involved.

METHODS

Participants underwent 3D gait analysis before and approximately 12 months after surgery. Primary measures were spatiotemporal, kinematic (summarized by Gait Variable Scores, GVSs) and kinetic parameters. The gait patterns for each leg was defined from kinematic data, using a quantitative classification: plantar flexor knee extension (PFKE) index. The CP group was split into true equinus and jump gait.

RESULTS

The equinus foot was successfully corrected as demonstrated by the improvement of GVS ankle dorsi-plantarflexion. However, there was a high rate of overcorrection in the true equinus, characterized by increases in knee flexion-extension GVS (8.7° pre vs. 16.7° post P<0.05) and knee flexion angle at initial contact (5.2° vs. 20.6° P<0.05) and by a decrease in the maximum ankle power generated at push-off (1.49 vs. 0.83 W/kg P<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Assessment of motor phenotype in preoperative time are good predictors of the results of ATL surgery. In children with true equinus gait, the increase of knee flexion subsequent to ATL is an early indicator that this technique will lead to crouch gait. These results show the influence of true equinus and jump gait patterns on the outcomes of the ATL.

CLINICAL REHABILITATION IMPACT

Therefore, we propose that this approach could have clinical value to evaluate and prescribe rehabilitation in children with CP disease, proposing different solutions depending on motor phenotype.

Impact of ankle-foot orthoses on gait 1 year after lower limb surgery in children with bilateral cerebral palsy

BACKGROUND:

Different types of ankle-foot orthoses are commonly used following lower limb surgery in children with bilateral spastic cerebral palsy. After three-dimensional gait analysis 1 year postoperatively, many children are recommended continued use of ankle-foot orthoses.

OBJECTIVES:

Our aims were to quantify the impact of ankle-foot orthoses on gait 1 year postoperatively and evaluate predictors for clinically important improvement.

STUDY DESIGN:

Prospective cohort study.

METHODS:

A total of 34 ambulating children with bilateral cerebral palsy, with mean age 11 years (range 6-17), comprising 12 girls and 22 boys, were measured with three-dimensional gait analysis preoperatively (barefoot) and 1 year postoperatively (barefoot and with ankle-foot orthoses). Outcome was evaluated using gait profile score, key kinematic, kinetic and temporal-spatial variables in paired sample comparisons. Logistic regression was used to evaluate predictors for clinically important improvement with orthoses (⩾1.6° change in gait profile score).

RESULTS:

Walking barefoot 1 year postoperatively, major improvements were seen in gait profile score and key variables. With ankle-foot orthoses, there were significantly improved step length and velocity, additional moderate reduction/improvement in gait profile score and knee moments and decreased stance ankle dorsiflexion compared to barefoot. Children using ground reaction ankle-foot orthoses ( n = 14) decreased stance knee flexion from 13.9° walking barefoot to 8.2° with orthoses. High gait profile score and more gait dysfunction preoperatively were significant predictors of clinically important improvement walking with orthoses.

CONCLUSION:

The results indicate improved gait function walking with ankle-foot orthoses versus barefoot 1 year after lower limb surgery. Stronger impact of ankle-foot orthoses was found in children with more pronounced gait dysfunction preoperatively.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

The 1-year postoperative three-dimensional gait analysis is a useful method to assess treatment outcome after lower limb surgery in children with bilateral cerebral palsy and could also guide clinicians whether further treatment with ankle-foot orthoses is indicated, using clinically important differences as thresholds to evaluate their impact on gait.

What's New in the Orthopaedic Treatment of Cerebral Palsy

BACKGROUND

The orthopaedic treatment of the patient with cerebral palsy (CP) is complex and must take into account the heterogeneity and natural history of the condition. Although the goals of management are for the most part universal, the specific interventions and outcome measures used to reach these goals are wide ranging. This update serves to summarize some of the recent publications in the field of pediatric orthopaedics that have made important contributions to our understanding and care of the patient with CP.

METHODS

We searched the PubMed database using the following terms: "cerebral palsy" AND "orthopedic." The results were then filtered to include only review papers or clinical trials published in English from 2010 to 2014. The obtained list of references was then reviewed for publications in the fields of lower extremity muscle imbalance, foot and ankle deformities, hip and acetabular dysplasia, and advances in orthopaedic-related technology.

RESULTS

Updates in the field of pediatric orthopaedics are constant and the current level of evidence for the effectiveness of specific treatment modalities in patients with CP was reviewed. The search method yielded 153 publications, of which 31 papers were identified as having contributed important new findings.

CONCLUSIONS

Our understanding of orthopaedic treatments for children with CP continues to grow and expand. The studies reviewed illustrate just some of the strides we have taken in utilizing evidence-based surgical decision making in practice. Nevertheless, there remains a paucity of randomized controlled trials and higher evidence research, which may contribute to the variability in current practices among providers. By elucidating these gaps we can more purposefully delegate our time and resources into targeted areas of research.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 4-literature review.

Effectiveness of surgical and non-surgical management of crouch gait in cerebral palsy: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a prevalent group of neuromotor disorders caused by early injury to brain regions or pathways that control movement. Patients with CP exhibit a range of functional motor disabilities and pathologic gait patterns. Crouch gait, characterized by increased knee flexion throughout stance, is a common gait pattern in CP that increases energy costs of walking and contributes to ambulatory decline. Our aim was to perform the first systematic literature review on the effectiveness of interventions utilized to ameliorate crouch gait in CP.

METHODS

Comprehensive searches of five medical databases yielded 38 papers with 30 focused on orthopaedic management.

RESULTS

Evidence supports the use of initial hamstring lengthenings and rectus femoris transfers, where indicated, for improving objective gait measures with limited data on improving gait speed or gross motor function. In contrast, evidence argues against hamstring transfers and revision hamstring lengthening, with recent interest in more technically demanding corrective procedures. Only eight studies evaluated alternatives to surgery, specifically strength training, botulinum toxin or orthoses, with inconsistent and/or short-lived results.

CONCLUSIONS

Although crouch in CP is recognized clinically as a complex multi-joint, multi-planar gait disorder, this review largely failed to identify interventions beyond those which directly address sagittal plane knee motion, indicating a major knowledge gap. Quality of existing data was notably weak, with few studies properly controlled or adequately sized. Outcomes from specific procedures are confounded by multilevel surgeries. Successful longer term strategies to prevent worsening of crouch and subsequent functional decline are needed.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Systematic review.

Gait analysis in children with cerebral palsy

Cerebral palsy (CP) children present complex and heterogeneous motor disorders that cause gait deviations.

Clinical gait analysis (CGA) is needed to identify, understand and support the management of gait deviations in CP. CGA assesses a large amount of quantitative data concerning patients’ gait characteristics, such as video, kinematics, kinetics, electromyography and plantar pressure data.

Common gait deviations in CP can be grouped into the gait patterns of spastic hemiplegia (drop foot, equinus with different knee positions) and spastic diplegia (true equinus, jump, apparent equinus and crouch) to facilitate communication. However, gait deviations in CP tend to be a continuum of deviations rather than well delineated groups. To interpret CGA, it is necessary to link gait deviations to clinical impairments and to distinguish primary gait deviations from compensatory strategies.

CGA does not tell us how to treat a CP patient, but can provide objective identification of gait deviations and further the understanding of gait deviations. Numerous treatment options are available to manage gait deviations in CP. Generally, treatments strive to limit secondary deformations, re-establish the lever arm function and preserve muscle strength.

Additional roles of CGA are to better understand the effects of treatments on gait deviations.

Cite this article: Armand S, Decoulon G, Bonnefoy-Mazure A. Gait analysis in children with cerebral palsy. EFORT Open Rev 2016;1:448-460. DOI: 10.1302/2058-5241.1.000052.

Evaluation and management of crouch gait

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Crouch gait is defined as excessive ankle dorsiflexion, knee and hip flexion during the stance phase. This gait disorder is common among patients with cerebral palsy. The present article brings an up-to-date literature review on the pathoanatomy, natural history, and treatment of this frequent gait abnormality.

RECENT FINDINGS

Hamstrings are often not shortened in patients with crouch. Patella alta must be addressed if surgery is performed. Surgical correction of joint contractures and lever arm dysfunction can be effectively achieved through a single-event multilevel surgery.

SUMMARY

Crouch gait is a common gait deviation, often seen among ambulatory diplegic and quadriplegic patients, once they reach the pubertal spurt, when weak muscles can no longer support a toe walking pattern because of rapidly increased weight. This form of gait is highly ineffective and might compromise walking ability over time. The anterior knee is overloaded; pain, extensor mechanism failure, and arthritis might develop. Its progressive nature often requires surgical intervention. The cause of crouch gait is multifactorial, and surgery should be tailored to meet the individual's specific anatomic and physiologic abnormalities.

A functional electrical stimulation system improves knee control in crouch gait

BACKGROUND

Crouch gait is a major sagittal plane deviation in children diagnosed with cerebral palsy (CP). It is defined as a combination of excessive ankle dorsiflexion and knee and hip flexion throughout the stance phase. To the best of our knowledge, functional electrical stimulation (FES) has not been used to decrease the severity of crouch gait in CP subjects and assist in achieving lower limb extension.

PURPOSE

To evaluate the short- and long-term effects of FES to the quadriceps muscles in preventing crouch gait and achieving ankle plantar flexion, knee and hip extension at the stance phase.

METHODS

An 18-year-old boy diagnosed with CP diplegia [Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) level II] was evaluated. The NESS L300(®) Plus neuroprosthesis system provided electrical stimulation of the quadriceps muscle. A three-dimensional gait analysis was performed using an eight-camera system measuring gait kinematics and spatiotemporal parameters while the subject walked shod only, with ground reaction ankle foot orthotics (GRAFOs) and using an FES device.

RESULTS

Walking with the FES device showed an increase in the patient's knee extension at midstance and increased knee maximal extension at the stance phase. In addition, the patient was able to ascend and descend stairs with a "step-through" pattern immediately after adjusting the FES device.

CONCLUSIONS

This report suggests that FES to the quadriceps muscles may affect knee extension at stance and decrease crouch gait, depending on the adequate passive range of motion of the hip, knee extension, and plantar flexion. Further studies are needed in order to validate these results.

Systematic Review of Cerebral Palsy Registries/Surveillance Groups: Relationships between Registry Characteristics and Knowledge Dissemination

The aims of this study were to provide a comprehensive summary of the body of research disseminated by Cerebral Palsy (CP) registries and surveillance programs from January 2009 through May 2014 in order to describe the influence their results have on our overall understanding of CP. Secondly, registries/surveillance programs and the work they produced were evaluated and grouped using standardized definitions and classification systems.

METHOD

A systematic review search in PubMed, CINAH and Embase for original articles published from 1 January 2009 to 20 May 2014 originating from or supported by population based CP registries and surveillance programs or population based national registries including CP were included. Articles were grouped by 2009 World CP Registry Congress aim, registry/surveillance program classification, geographical region, and the International Classification of Function, Disability and Health (ICF) domain. Registry variables were assessed using the ICF-CY classification.

RESULTS

Literature searches returned 177 articles meeting inclusion criteria. The majority (69%) of registry/surveillance program productivity was related to contributions as a Resource for CP Research. Prevention (23%) and Surveillance (22%) articles were other areas of achievement, but fewer articles were published in the areas of Planning (17%) and Raising the Profile of CP (2%). There was a range of registry/surveillance program classifications contributing to this productivity, and representation from multiple areas of the globe, although most of the articles originated in Europe, Australia, and Canada. The domains of the ICF that were primarily covered included body structures and function at the early stages of life. Encouragingly, a variety of CP registry/surveillance program initiatives included additional ICF domains of participation and environmental and personal factors.

INTERPRETATION

CP registries and surveillance programs, including novel non-traditional ones, have significantly contributed to the understanding of how CP affects individuals, families and society. Moving forward, the global CP registry/surveillance program community should continue to strive for uniformity in CP definitions, variables collected and consistency with international initiatives like the ICF so that databases can be consolidated for research use. Adaptation to new technologies can improve access, reduce cost and facilitate information transfer between registrants, researchers and registries/surveillance programs. Finally, increased efforts in documenting variables of individuals with CP into adulthood should be made in order to expand our understanding of CP across the lifespan.

Patellar tendon shortening for flexed knee gait in spastic diplegia

We evaluated the outcome of three different approaches to the management of flexed knee gait patients with spastic diplegia. The three surgical procedures were patellar tendon shortening (PTS), PTS combined with rotational osteotomies of the femur and/or tibia, and PTS combined with supracondylar extension osteotomy (SEO) of the distal femur. The primary outcome measure was gait kinematics. The knee gait variable score (GVS) and the gait profile score (GPS) were derived from gait kinematics. 24 patients (16 male and 8 female), mean age 16.1 years (SD 5.8 years), who had surgery between 2002 and 2008, were followed for a mean of 22 months. Knee extension during gait improved by a mean of 20° throughout the gait cycle, with an improvement in the knee GVS of 14° (p<0.001). The overall gait pattern improved with a mean decrease in GPS of 4.6°. Correction of patella alta was demonstrated by an improvement in the Koshino index from 1.34 pre-operatively to 1.10 post-operatively (p<0.001). Knee and gait kinematics, physical examination measures and Koshino Index improved in all three surgical groups, suggesting that a tailored approach to the correction of flexed knee gait in spastic diplegia is both feasible and appropriate.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Endoscopic gastrocnemius release

Endoscopic gastrocnemius release (EGR) is a recently developed procedure that is a reliable option for surgical management of ankle equinus contracture. Comfort with endoscopic equipment and surgical anatomy, especially the sural nerve, is of paramount importance for performing the procedure safely, effectively, and efficiently. The primary advantage of the procedure is improved cosmesis and decreased wound complications of the smaller surgical scars. The current body of literature of clinical outcomes for EGR consists of limited level IV case series with broad variations in study rigor, author training background, and the surgical technique itself.

Crouch gait changes after planovalgus foot deformity correction in ambulatory children with cerebral palsy

Ambulatory children with cerebral palsy (CP) may present with several gait patterns due to muscular spasticity, commonly with crouch gait. Several factors may contribute to continuous knee flexion during gait, including hamstring and gastrocnemius contracture. In planovalgus foot deformity, the combination of heel equinus, talonavicular joint dislocation, midfoot break and external tibial torsion also contribute to crouch gait as part of lever arm dysfunction. In this retrospective cohort study, we assessed 21 children with CP (34 feet) who underwent planovalgus foot correction as a single level surgery. Fifteen feet underwent subtalar fusion and 19 feet had lateral calcaneal lengthening. Patients who underwent knee, hip or pelvis surgeries were excluded from the study. The aim was to examine the changes in gait pattern and the correlation between the changes of knee flexion at stance phase with the other kinematic and kinetic parameters after foot surgery. Post surgery change of Maximum knee extension at stance (MKE-dif) was the outcome of interest. The magnitude of change in MKE after surgery increased (less crouch after surgery) in patients who had milder preoperative planovalgus feet and higher preoperative ankle maximum dorsiflexion at stance and ankle power. The gain of knee extension after surgery correlated with correction of ankle hyperdorsiflexion and with increase of knee extension at initial contact and knee power. Patients with high preoperative ankle maximum dorsiflexion may benefit from surgical foot deformity correction to achieve decreased ankle dorsiflexion with no knee surgical intervention.

Lengthening of the gastrocnemius-soleus complex: an anatomical and biomechanical study in human cadavers

BACKGROUND

Lengthening of the gastrocnemius-soleus complex is frequently performed for equinus deformity. Many techniques have been described, but there is uncertainty regarding the precise details of some surgical procedures.

METHODS

The surgical anatomy of the gastrocnemius-soleus complex was investigated, and standardized approaches were developed for the procedures described by Baumann, Strayer, Vulpius, Baker, Hoke, and White. The biomechanical characteristics of these six procedures were then compared in three randomized trials involving formaldehyde-preserved human cadaveric lower limbs. After one of the lengthening procedures was performed, a measured dorsiflexion force was applied across the metatarsal heads with use of a torque dynamometer. Lengthening of the gastrocnemius-soleus complex was measured directly, by measuring the gap between the ends of the fascia or tendon.

RESULTS

The gastrocnemius-soleus musculotendinous unit was subdivided into three zones. In Zone 1, it was possible to lengthen the gastrocnemius-soleus complex in either a selective or a differential manner-i.e., to lengthen the gastrocnemius alone or to lengthen the gastrocnemius and soleus by different amounts. The procedures performed in this zone (Baumann and Strayer procedures) were very stable but were limited with regard to the amount of lengthening achieved. Zone-2 lengthenings of the conjoined gastrocnemius aponeurosis and soleus fascia (Vulpius and Baker procedures) were not selective but were stable and resulted in significantly greater lengthening than Zone-1 procedures (p < 0.001). In Zone 3 (Hoke and White procedures), lengthenings of the Achilles tendon were neither selective nor stable but resulted in significantly greater lengthening than Zone-1 or 2 procedures (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical procedures for the correction of equinus deformity by lengthening of the gastrocnemius-soleus complex vary in terms of selectivity, stability, and range of correction. Procedures for the correction of equinus deformity have different anatomical and biomechanical characteristics. Clinical trials are needed to determine whether these differences are of clinical importance. It may be appropriate for surgeons to select a procedure involving the zone best suited to the clinical needs of a specific patient.

Stability of the Gross Motor Function Classification System after single-event multilevel surgery in children with cerebral palsy

AIM

There are conflicting reports about the stability of the Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) in children with cerebral palsy (CP) after orthopaedic surgery. We studied the stability of the GMFCS in children with bilateral spastic CP after single-event multilevel surgery, using the Gait Profile Score (GPS) as the primary outcome measure.

METHOD

This was a retrospective cohort study of 107 children (46 females, 61 males) with bilateral spastic CP, classified as GMFCS level II or III, who underwent surgery at a single tertiary institution between 1997 and 2008. The mean age at surgery was 10 years 7 months (SD 2 y 8 mo). The primary outcome measure was the GPS. Changes in GMFCS level were studied at multiple time points before and after intervention.

RESULTS

Gait dysfunction was partially corrected, with a mean improvement of 28% in the GPS. The GMFCS remained stable and unchanged in 95% of children and improved by one level in 5% of children. The improvement in GPS was three times the minimal clinically important difference. The mean age at final postoperative GPS assessment was 11 years 10 months (SD 2 y 10 mo) and at final GMFCS assessment was 15 years 7 months (SD 3 y 9 mo).

INTERPRETATION

Stability of the GMFCS was confirmed in the majority of children with bilateral spastic CP after single-event multilevel surgery, despite statistically and clinically significant improvements in gait dysfunction and functional mobility. This information is important in realistic goal-setting and in counselling families.

Management of children with ambulatory cerebral palsy: an evidence-based review. Commentary by Hugh Williamson Gait Laboratory staff

The evaluation of complex interventions, such as Single Event Multilevel Surgery (SEMLS) requires more than randomized controlled trials. Rehabilitation following SEMLS is prolonged and the outcomes of interest may not be apparent for 5 years or more after the surgery. We suggest long term, prospective cohort studies with objective outcome measures be recognized as of equal importance to randomized controlled trials. The evidence in support of instrumented gait analysis (IGA) is also reviewed. We suggest that clinical levels of evidence are not an appropriate method to evaluate a measurement tool. Specifically, IGA should be evaluated in terms of validity, reliability and cost effectiveness. We demonstrate that the use of IGA has improved medium and long term outcomes in ambulant children with cerebral palsy in a center where IGA has been used routinely both for planning SEMLS and for monitoring outcomes.