Total hip replacement for patients with active tuberculosis of the hip: a systematic review and pooled analysis

Total hip arthroplasty in active and advanced tubercular arthritis: a systematic review of the current evidence

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review.

INTRODUCTION

Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a well-acknowledged surgical intervention to restore a painless and mobile joint in patients with osteoarticular tubercular arthritis of the hip joint. However, there is still substantial uncertainty about the ideal management, clinical and functional outcomes following THA undertaken in patients with acute Mycobacterium tuberculosis (TB) hip infections.

AIM OF THE STUDY

To undertake a systematic review and evaluate existing literature on patients undergoing THA for acute mycobacterium tuberculosis arthritis of the hip.

METHODS

A systematic review of electronic databases of PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, Web of Science and Cochrane Library was performed on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. The search focused on "arthroplasty in cases with tuberculosis of hip joint" since inception of databases until July 2023. Data on patient demographics, clinical characteristics, treatment administered, surgical interventions and outcome, as reported in the included studies, were recorded. Median (range) and mean (standard deviation) were used to summarise the data for continuous variables (as reported in the original studies); and frequency/percentage was employed for categorical variables. Available data on Harris hip scores and complications were statistically pooled using random-effects meta-analysis or fixed-effect meta-analysis, as appropriate RESULTS: Among a total of 1695 articles, 15 papers were selected for qualitative summarisation and 12 reporting relevant data were included for proportional meta-analysis. A total of 303 patients (mean age: 34 to 52 years; mean follow-up: 2.5 to 10.5 years) were included in our systematic review. In a majority of included studies, postero-lateral approach and non-cemented prosthesis were employed. Fourteen studies described a single-staged procedure in the absence of sinus, abscess and tubercular infection syndrome (TIS). All surgeries were performed under cover of prolonged course of multi-drug anti-tubercular regimen. The mean Harris hip score (HHS) at final follow-up was 91.36 [95% confidence interval (CI): 89.56-93.16; I2:90.44%; p<0.001]. There were 30 complications amongst 174 (9.9%) patients (95% CI: 0.06-0.13; p=0.14; I2=0%).

CONCLUSION

THA is a safe and effective surgical intervention in patients with active and advanced TB arthritis of hip. It is recommended that the surgery be performed under cover of multi-drug anti-tubercular regimen. In patients with active sinus tracts, abscesses and TIS, surgery may be accomplished in a multi-staged manner. The clinical (range of motion, deformity correction, walking ability and pain scores), radiological (evidence of radiological reactivation and implant incorporation) and function outcome (as assessed by HHS) significantly improve after THA in these patients.

Total hip arthroplasty in different types of advanced tubercular hip arthritis: is it justified

PURPOSE

Total hip arthroplasty (THA) provides a good treatment option for the patients in late arthritis stage. We present our experience of THA in various spectrums of disease.

METHODS

Retrospective study including 23 advanced tubercular hip arthritis patients over a period of 13 years. The patients with active discharging sinus were excluded from the study. The patients were divided into three groups: group 1 (healed TB), group 2 (active TB), and group 3 (intraoperative surprise). The preoperative and postoperative antitubercular treatment (ATT) was administered to all the patients as per the protocol for various duration. All patients underwent THA (cementless or hybrid) after investigations including MRI. The patients were followed up with clinic-radiological and laboratory investigations.

RESULTS

The mean age of the patients was 58.2 years with 16 males and seven females. There were 14 healed TB hips, eight active TB hips, and one intraoperative TB hip patient. Preoperative ATT duration in group 1 varied from one to two weeks and in group 2 patient's average was 9.6 weeks (range: 6-12weeks). Postoperatively, ATT was given for a minimum of ten months extending to 16 months. Cementless THA was performed in 17 patients and hybrid THA (cemented stem) in six patients. Only one patient had aseptic loosening of the stem and revision arthroplasty was done.

CONCLUSION

THA is a viable option and provides mobile, stable hip in tubercular hip arthritis even in active TB hip patients. ATT is important in the management and prevent the reactivation of the disease.

Tuberculous arthritis of native joints - a systematic review and European Bone and Joint Infection Society workgroup report

Introduction: The aim of this systematic review was to assess the existing published data on the diagnosis and management of tuberculosis (TB) arthritis involving native joints in adults aged 18 years and older. Methods: This study was performed in accordance with the guidelines provided in the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analysis extension for Scoping Reviews (PRISMA-ScR). Results: The systematic review of the literature yielded 20 data sources involving 573 patients from nine countries. There was considerable variation amongst the studies in terms of the approach to diagnosis and management. The diagnosis was mostly made by microbiological tissue culture. Medical management involved a median of 12 months of anti-tubercular treatment (interquartile range, IQR, of 8-16; range of 4-18 months). The duration of preoperative treatment ranged from 2 to 12 weeks. Surgery was performed on 87 % of patients and varied from arthroscopic debridement to complete synovectomies combined with total joint arthroplasty. The mean follow-up time of all studies was 26 months (range of 3-112 months). Recurrence rates were reported in most studies, with an overall average recurrence rate of approximately 7.4 % (35 of 475 cases). Conclusions: The current literature on TB arthritis highlights the need for the establishment of standardized guidelines for the confirmation of the diagnosis. Further research is needed to define the optimal approach to medical and surgical treatment. The role of early debridement in active TB arthritis needs to be explored further. Specifically, comparative studies are required to address questions around the use of medical treatment alone vs. in combination with surgical intervention.

Total Hip Replacement in Active and Inactive Tuberculosis Hip: A Systematic Review

Introduction

Tuberculosis of the hip joint is a debilitating disease that can result in severe joint destruction, eventually leading to painful arthritis of the hip. Total hip arthroplasty (THA) in patients with advanced arthritis offers a painless and mobile joint with good functional outcome but some aspects of THA in TB hip have been controversial in the past due to the concerns of disease reactivation, especially when disease activity is factored in. Various factors like timing of surgery, Antitubercular therapy (ATT) initiation timing, reactivation, complications etc needs to be evaluated very carefully before planning for such cases.

Methods

Electronic databases like MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane library, Clinicaltrials gov and OpenGrey were searched. The key words used were "Tuberculosis", "Tuberculosis of hip", Hip tuberculosis, "TB", "THR", "total hip replacement", "total hip arthroplasty","THA", "ankylosed hip", "fused hip", "arthrodesis" along with boolean operators "AND" and "OR". Out of a total of 1634 articles, 38 were selected for full text review and 22 articles were finally included in the study.

Results

For the timing of surgery most authors relied on the inflammatory markers to settle down with ATT before performing THA. 15 authors advocated use of pre-operative ATT with 6 studies recommending at least 2 weeks and 3 studies advocating atleast 3 months of ATT pre surgery.Single stage THA was performed in most studies(214 hips vs 18 hips) as opposed to 2 or 3 stage surgery. In the active disease 72.8% of the hips had uncemented prosthesis, 25.6% hips underwent cemented and 1.5% hips had hybrid THA fixation. Overall reactivation of the infection was seen in 2.47% cases. All authors reported excellent clinical improvement (mean HHS improvement 37.17 to 88.62).

What is the Level of Evidence Substantiating Commercial Payers' Coverage Policies for Total Joint Arthroplasty?

BACKGROUND

The prevalence of total joint arthroplasty (TJA) in the United States has drawn the attention of health care stakeholders. The payers have also used a variety of strategies to regulate the medical necessity of these procedures. The purpose of this study was to examine the level of evidence of the coverage policies being used by commercial payers in the United States.

METHODS

The references of the coverage policies of four commercial insurance companies were reviewed for type of document, level of evidence, applicability to a TJA population, and success of nonoperative treatment in patients with severe degenerative joint disease.

RESULTS

282 documents were reviewed. 45.8% were primary journal articles, 14.2% were level I or II, 41.2% were applicable to patients who were candidates for TJA, and 9.9% discussed the success of nonoperative treatment in patients who would be candidates for TJA.

CONCLUSION

Most of the references cited by commercial payers are of a lower level of scientific evidence and not applicable to patients considered to be candidates for TJA. This is relatively uniform across the reviewed payers. The dearth of high-quality literature cited by commercial payers reflects the lack of evidence and difficulty in conducting high level studies on the outcomes of nonoperative versus operative treatment for patients with severe, symptomatic osteoarthritis. Patients, surgeons, and payers would all benefit from such studies and we encourage professional societies to strive toward that end through multicenter collaboration.

Total hip arthroplasty in tubercular arthritis of the hip - Surgical challenges and choice of implants

Osteoarticular tuberculosis of the hip joint can be a debilitating disease that can result in severe cartilage degeneration, destruction, and eventual painful arthritis of the hip. Usually, a secondary affliction to a primary lung disease, Tuberculosis (TB) of the hip can be difficult to diagnose due to its indolent natural history and deep-seated nature of the hip joint itself. Untreated, ultimately TB hip leads to disabling arthritis of the hip with limitation of activities of daily living, livelihood, and socio-economic consequences. Historic surgical options such as arthrodesis and excision arthroplasty of TB hip have limitations and several disadvantages. Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a viable option to restore mobility and relieve pain in patients with severe post-tuberculous arthritis but has been controversial in the past due to the concerns of disease reactivation. We evaluate the current role of THA in TB of the hip, its various applications in different presenting scenarios with a guide to surgical tips and tricks for managing this challenging condition.

Tubercular arthritis presenting as osteonecrosis of the femoral head: A case report

A tuberculosis hip that presents as osteonecrosis of the femoral head is an extremely rare condition. There are no previous reports of this condition, and there is no consensus on the method of total hip arthroplasty for this group of patients. We present a case of a 72-year-old man who had clinical gradual hip pain in both hips for 1 year. He was diagnosed with post-collapsed osteonecrosis of the femoral head in both hips and was scheduled for total hip arthroplasty of the left hip. During his clinical follow-up, he suddenly experienced excruciating acute pain. Investigation to rule out infection was positive for only C-reactive proteins, but his synovial fluid work-up was negative. An intraoperative finding revealed that there was collapse of the femoral head with eroded acetabular cartilage and rice body–like synovitis. Total hip arthroplasty was performed, and the tissue was sent for diagnosis. Tissue acid-fast bacilli were positive, so the patient received anti-tuberculosis drugs for 9 months, with no recurrent infection. Tuberculosis arthritis presenting as osteonecrosis of the femoral head is a complex condition that is difficult to diagnose due to the radiographic pictures of femoral head collapse and arthritic change being similar in both diseases. Acute pain onset with rapid collapse of the femoral head should be a consideration or suspect for this infectious condition. Hence, investigation to rule out infection is important. Anti-tuberculosis drugs are the standard treatment for early or advanced arthritis, and one-stage or two-stage total hip arthroplasty is the choice of treatment for advanced arthritis.

Extraspinal articular tuberculosis: An 11-year retrospective study of demographic features and clinical outcomes in East London

OBJECTIVES

To describe demographic features, clinical outcomes and diagnostic delay amongst patients with extra-spinal articular tuberculosis (TB) in a low-incidence setting.

METHODS

Cases of TB treated at our institution between 2004 and 2014 were identified via the London TB register (LTBR). Demographic features of extra-spinal articular TB cases were compared to controls with TB at all other sites. For articular cases (excluding individuals <16 years or with spinal TB without peripheral joint involvement) clinical data were retrospectively collected.

RESULTS

6,146 TB patients were identified over the study period; 146 (2.4%) cases had extra-spinal articular infection. There was no difference in median age between extra-spinal articular TB cases and controls with TB at other sites (31 vs 32 years, p = 0.57). Articular cases were more likely to be male (70.6% vs 59.5%, p = 0.007), Bangladeshi (28.7% vs 18.0%) or Pakistani (24.0% vs 16.1%) and were less likely to be Black-African (9.5% vs 19.8%) (p < 0.001). 93 cases were included in the case series; 85 (88.5%) were migrants and 83 (89.2%) were South Asian. Knee and elbow joints were affected in 22 (23.7%) and 18 (19.4%) cases respectively. The median durations of pre-healthcare and healthcare associated delay were 16 and 6 weeks respectively. Where mycobacterial culture was performed, 57/75 (76%) were positive for Mycobacterium tuberculosis. 86 (92.5%) cases received standard quadruple therapy for a median of 6 months (IQR 6-9). Recurrence of TB infection occurred in 4 (4.3%) cases and there were no TB related deaths. Seven (7.6%) cases required surgical intervention.

CONCLUSIONS

Extra-spinal articular TB more commonly affected men and people of South Asian ethnicity. Significant diagnostic delays were identified, including avoidable healthcare-associated delays.

Extra-Spinal Osteoarticular Tuberculosis: A Retrospective Analysis of 103 Cases

Introduction. Many studies in the literature deals with epidemiology, diagnosis and management of spinal tuberculosis but there is scant amount of such data for extraspinal osteoarticular TB. Material and methods. Demographic patient data like age, sex, bone and joint involved, side involved, duration of symptoms was noted. All suspected cases of extra-spinal musculoskeletal TB with positive acid-fast bacilli (AFB) staining or positive cartridge based nucleic acid amplification test (CBNAAT) or histopathological evidence of granulomatous infection and minimum 1 year follow up after completion of 12-month ATT were included in the study. Outcome evaluation was done on the basis of residual pain, range of motion of joint along with deformity of the affected part, if any. Results. A total of 103 patients (55 males, 48 females) were analyzed. The mean duration of treatment was 14.2±2.8 months. The mean age of the patients at presentation was 30.5±18.5 years. The most common site affected was the ankle joint followed by hip and knee. 95 cases (92.2%) were diagnosed by histopathological examination of synovial tissue or material obtained from core biopsy. 90 cases (87.3%) were treated conservatively on oral drugs only while 13 cases (12.7%) were treated operatively. Outcome after completion of ATT were graded as good in 46 (46.9%), fair and poor each in 26 patients (26.5%). Conclusion. Extraspinal osteoarticular TB can be managed effectively by 12-month ATT if diagnosed early. Some cases with advanced arthritis can be salvaged with implant arthroplasty or arthrodesis under cover of ATT.

Peripheral Bacterial Septic Arthritis: Review of Diagnosis and Management

Septic arthritis refers to an infection in a joint due to a bacterial, mycobacterial, or fungal cause. Joint infections are a serious cause of morbidity and mortality and constitute a true musculoskeletal emergency. The estimated incidence of septic arthritis in the general population is between 2 and 6 cases per 100,000 people per year. The most common presentation is an acute monoarthritis. Identification of organisms in the synovial fluid is the criterion standard for diagnosis. Synovial fluid aspiration should be performed prior to initiating antibiotics. While no diagnostic cutoff exists for synovial fluid white blood cell count, increasing leukocytosis is associated with a higher likelihood of an infectious cause of arthritis, and patients commonly present with values greater than 50,000/μL. The cornerstones of treating septic bacterial arthritis are adequate drainage and antimicrobials. Joint drainage is always recommended in septic arthritis; however, no clear guidelines or strong evidence exist to guide the preferred method of drainage. Options for joint drainage include daily needle aspiration, arthroscopy, or open surgical drainage via arthrotomy.

[Infections of non-prosthetically treated joints]

BACKGROUND

Septic arthritis is a common orthopedic emergency. Immediate establishment of the diagnosis and administration of an adequate therapy is paramount in minimizing morbidity and mortality in this severe condition.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of the present review was to evaluate the existing evidence in order to give an overview on current best practice in diagnostics and treatment of septic arthritis in adults and children.

RESULTS

Joint infections result from either hematogenous spread or direct inoculation of bacteria into the joint, mostly iatrogenically. Predisposing risk factors include recent orthopedic joint surgery, i. v. drug abuse, pre-existing inflammatory and degenerative joint diseases and old age. Although pathogens differ in different populations and age groups Staphylococcus aureus is the single most frequently isolated causative organism, followed by streptococci. Although diagnosis is based on an integration of medical patient history, clinical and laboratory findings and imaging studies, joint fluid analysis remains the mainstay in establishing a valid diagnosis. The range of differential diagnostics is broad and includes non-infectious inflammatory joint diseases, such as gout or reactive arthritis. Once a diagnosis has been established treatment should be started immediately. Treatment is based on adequate antibiotic therapy and joint drainage until dryness. There is a paucity of studies on the optimal antibiotic regimen, route of application and duration of therapy. Moreover, no high-quality studies exist on the optimal mode of joint drainage. While superiority has yet to be shown, operative treatment in terms of arthroscopic lavage must be considered the standard of care in Germany. Finally, despite promising results in children, the role of corticosteroids as an adjunct to antibiotic treatment in adults has yet to be clarified.

Two-stage total hip arthroplasty for patients with advanced active tuberculosis of the hip

Background

Treatment of advanced active tuberculosis (TB) of the hip is confronted with great challenges. Although one-stage total hip arthroplasty (THA) is considered as a safe procedure for most patients by some authors, there are still exceptions. The purpose of this paper was to investigate the feasibility and effectiveness of two-stage THA for selected patients with advanced active TB of the hip.

Methods

Nine consecutive patients with advanced active tuberculous arthritis of the hip were reviewed in this study. Out of these nine patients, the hips of five were destroyed extensively with difficulties of thorough debridement at one operation, and the hips of the other four were detected of sinus tracts. Nine patients received the two-stage total hip arthroplasty (THA) protocol and the perioperative antituberculous medication between January 2008 and December 2013. During the first stage, a debridement was carried out after at least 2 weeks of antituberculous chemotherapy to remove abscesses and infected and necrotic tissues as thoroughly as possible, followed by antituberculous chemotherapy for a minimum of 3 months (average 4.2 months). During the second stage, hip prosthesis was implanted if the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and the C-reactive protein (CRP) were normal and the wound was well healed. Antituberculous chemotherapy was continued for 6–9 months postoperatively to constitute a total duration of a minimum of 12 months after the first operation. The patients were then evaluated based on the reactivation of infection, the Harris hip score system, X-ray, ESR, and CRP.

Results

The average follow-up was 40 months (range, 18–72 months). No reactivation of TB or superimposed infection was observed in all patients. The ESR and CRP returned to the normal level with no liver injury. The average Harris hip score was increased from 35 (range, 15–55) preoperatively to 91.5 (range, 83–97) at the final follow-up. The X-ray film showed no prosthesis shift or loosening.

Conclusions

Two-stage THA is an alternative treatment option for patients with advanced active tuberculosis of the hip under some difficult conditions. The hip with sinus tracts or destroyed extensively with difficulties of thorough debridement at one operation may be regarded as indications.

Implant-associated mycobacterium tuberculosis infection following surgical management of fractures: a retrospective observational study

In this retrospective observational cohort study, we describe 17 patients out of 1775 treated for various fractures who developed mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) infection after surgery. The cohort comprised 15 men and two women with a mean age of 40 years (24 to 70). A total of ten fractures were open and seven were closed. Of these, seven patients underwent intramedullary nailing of a fracture of the long bone, seven had fractures fixed with plates, two with Kirschner-wires and screws, and one had a hemiarthroplasty of the hip with an Austin Moore prosthesis. All patients were followed-up for two years. In all patients, the infection resolved, and in 14 the fractures united. Nonunion was seen in two patients one of whom underwent two-stage total hip arthroplasty (THA) and the other patient was treated using excision arthoplasty. Another patient was treated using two-stage THA. With only sporadic case reports in the literature, MTB infection is rarely clinically suspected, even in underdeveloped and developing countries, where pulmonary and other forms of TB are endemic. In developed countries there is also an increased incidence among immunocompromised patients. In this paper we discuss the pathogenesis and incidence of MTB infection after surgical management of fractures and suggest protocols for early diagnosis and management.

Tuberculosis of hip: A current concept review

Tuberculosis (TB) of the hip is second to spine only hence a good number of cases are visiting the medical facilities every year. Many present in the advanced stage of the disease due to delayed diagnosis. In early stages of TB of hip, there is a diagnostic dilemma when plain X-rays are negative. In the present time, diagnostic modalities have improved from the days when diagnosis was based essentially on clinicoradiological presentation alone. By the time definite radiological changes appear on plain X-ray, the disease has moderately advanced. The modern diagnostic facilities like ultrasonography (USG) or magnetic resonance imaging of the hip joint, USG guided aspiration of synovial fluid and obtaining the material for polymerase chain reaction and tissue diagnosis must be utilized. In the treatment, current emphasis is more on mobility with stability at hip. Joint debridement, skeletal traction, and mobilization exercises may give more satisfying results as compared to the immobilization by hip spica. Adults with advanced arthritis and healed infection should be informed and discussed the various treatment modalities including the joint replacement. More and more surgeons are taking up the challenge of putting the total hip replacement in the active stage of the disease. Until the long term results in active disease are well established, we recommend it for the healed disease only in selected cases.