Minimally invasive reduction and percutaneous fixation versus open reduction and internal fixation for displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures: A systematic review of the literature

Open Reduction and Internal Fixation with Plate and Screw versus Triplanar External Fixation in the Surgical Treatment of Calcaneal Fractures: A Retrospective Cohort Study

Background: The treatment of displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures (DIACF) is debated. This study compares open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) with minimally invasive osteosynthesis (MIOS). Methods: We conducted a retrospective study on 70 patients with DIACF treated between January 2018 and September 2022, divided into ORIF (n = 50) and MIOS (n = 20) groups. Functional outcomes were assessed using the Maryland Foot Score (MFS) and the Creighton-Nebraska Health Foundation Assessment Scale (CNHFAS). Radiographic outcomes, complication rates, and reintervention rates were evaluated. A chi-square analysis examined the correlation between Sanders classification and treatment choice. Results: The chi-square analysis indicated no significant correlation between the complexity of the fracture and the type of treatment chosen (χ2 = 0.175, p = 0.916). Additionally, the Cochran-Armitage test for trend showed no significant trend in the choice of treatment based on fracture complexity (statistic = 0.048, p = 0.826). A Kaplan-Meier analysis showed a longer time to reintervention for MIOS (p = 0.029). Complication rates were similar, with specific complications varying between groups. Quality-of-life outcomes were comparable. Conclusions: ORIF is preferable for high-demand patients due to better anatomical outcomes, while MIOS suits high-risk patients by reducing reinterventions and complications. Further randomized trials are needed to confirm these findings.

Postoperative complications after displaced intra-articular calcaneal fracture operations

BACKGROUND

The objective was to compare postoperative complications in the management of displaced intra articular calcaneal fractures (DIACF) between two groups; the open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) group versus the percutaneous fixation (PF) group.

METHODS

A total of 243 DIACFs were diagnosed and 127 of them received operations either with ORIF 75 (59.1 %) or PF 52 (40.9 %) between 2004 and 2018. Postoperative complications, radiological Sanders's classification and improvement of Böhler's angle were analyzed.

RESULTS

Early complication rate (<6 weeks), rate of deep wound infections and wound edge necrosis were significantly better in PF than in ORIF patient group. There were no significant differences in late complications (>6 weeks from operation) nor in improvement of Böhler's angle.

CONCLUSION

Complication rate is lower when using PF technique while fracture reduction remains the same compared to the ORIF.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV retrospective cohort study at a single institution.

Biomechanical characteristics of Sanders type II and III calcaneal fractures fixed by open reduction and internal fixation and percutaneous minimally invasive fixation

BACKGROUND

This work investigated the differences in the biomechanical properties of open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) and percutaneous minimally invasive fixation (PMIF) for the fixation of calcaneal fractures (Sanders type II and III calcaneal fractures as examples) through finite element analysis.

METHODS

Based on CT images of the human foot and ankle, according to the principle of three-point fixation, namely the sustentaculum tali, the anterior process and the calcaneal tuberosity were fixed. Three-dimensional finite element models of Sanders type II and III calcaneal fractures fixed by ORIF and PMIF were established. The proximal surfaces of the tibia, fibula and soft tissue were constrained, and ground reaction force and Achilles tendon force loads were added to simulate balanced standing.

RESULTS

The maximum stress was 80.54, 211.59 and 113.88 MPa for the calcaneus, screws and plates in the ORIF group and 70.02 and 209.46 MPa for the calcaneus and screws in the PMIF group, respectively; the maximum displacement was 0.26, 0.21 and 0.12 mm for the calcaneus, screws and plates in the ORIF group and 0.20 and 0.14 mm for the calcaneus and screws in the PMIF group, respectively. The values obtained from the simulation were within the permissible stress and elastic deformation range of the materials used in the model, and there was no significant stress concentration. The maximum stress and displacement of the calcaneus and implants were slightly lower in the PMIF group than in the ORIF group when fixing Sanders type II and III calcaneal fractures.

CONCLUSIONS

This study may provide a reference for optimising the design of implants, the development of individualised preoperative plans and the choice of clinical surgical approach.

Radiological outcomes following open versus percutaneous fixation versus arthroscopically assisted percutaneous fixation of calcaneal fractures: a ten-year retrospective observational study

BACKGROUND

Calcaneal fractures are often major injuries associated with considerable morbidity. The optimal surgical management of displaced calcaneal fractures remains contentious with open, percutaneous and arthroscopically assisted percutaneous approaches all offering potential benefits for patients. The aim of this study was to assess which of these three separate surgical approaches to the management of displaced calcaneal fractures provides the best radiographic deformity correction.

METHODS

This is a retrospective observational study of all calcaneal fractures undergoing operative fixation at a single major trauma centre in the UK. The primary outcome was pre- and post-operative assessment of the deformity correction using radiographic parameters (angle of Gissane and Bohler's angle). Secondary outcomes included fracture configuration, complications and re-operation rate.

RESULTS

Between 01/01/2009 and 31/12/2019, 152 calcaneal fractures in 134 patients underwent operative management via either an open or percutaneous approach. One-way ANOVA testing of the pre- and post-operative radiographic parameters demonstrated that an open approach offered superior post-operative correction of Bohler's angle when compared to percutaneous alone (p < 0.05); however, there was no difference in post-operative angle of Gissane (p > 0.05). The mean follow-up for complication and re-operation data was 3.5 years (range 0.1-12.4). Overall complication rate following all surgical fixation was 7.2% with a further 32.2% requiring further long-term surgical intervention for subtalar arthritis or removal of metalwork.

CONCLUSION

Arthroscopically assisted percutaneous fixation does not offer superior radiographic deformity correction compared to percutaneous technique alone. Open fixation yielded improved correction of Bohler's angle when compared to percutaneous alone; however, there was no difference in post-operative angle of Gissane.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

[Surgical treatment of intra-articular calcaneus fractures with plate osteosynthesis via the sinus tarsi approach]

OBJECTIVE

Surgical treatment of intra-articular calcaneus fractures via a minimally invasive approach.

INDICATIONS

Intra-articular dislocated calcaneus fractures.

CONTRAINDICATIONS

Fracture older than 14 days; poor soft tissue quality in the surgical area.

SURGICAL TECHNIQUE

Patient in lateral position. Identifying the anatomic landmarks. Incision (3-5 cm) from the tip of the fibula to metatarsal IV. Preparation through the subcutis. Retraction of the peroneal tendons. Preparation of the lateral calcaneal wall and later plate position via raspatory. Placement of a Schanz screw in the calcaneal tuberosity from lateral or posterior as a reduction aid for restoring of the calcaneal length and reduction of the hindfoot varus. Reduction of the sustentaculum fragment with the help of fluoroscopy from lateral. Elevation of the subtalar articular surface. Positioning of the calcaneal plate and fixation of the sustentaculum fragment by placing a cannulated screw through the long hole. Afterwards, definite internal fixation of the reduction with locking screws. Completion of the operation with final X‑rays and, if available, an intraoperative computed tomography. Wound closure with closing of the peroneal sheath.

POSTOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT

Lower leg-foot orthoses. Mobilization with partial weight-bearing of the injured foot with 15 kg for 6-8 weeks; subsequently increased load bearing.

RESULTS

Due to the smaller incision and the associated lower soft tissue trauma, the risk of wound healing complications can be reduced. Radiographic and functional outcomes are comparable to the outcomes of calcaneal fractures treated via the extended lateral approach.

Level of Evidence for the Treatment of Chronic Noninsertional Achilles Tendinopathy

BACKGROUND

Noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy affects both athletes and sedentary individuals, and its incidence is rising. Conservative management is the mainstay of treatment, but a variety of operative techniques have been described to treat recalcitrant cases. We seek to outline the current available evidence for surgical management of noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A systematic review was performed using the MEDLINE and EMBASE databases, and all articles were reviewed by at least 2 authors. Each article was assigned a level of evidence in accordance with the standards of Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery. The available data were reviewed and a level of evidence was assigned to each intervention of interest, based on the revised classifications of Wright.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION

A total of 46 articles met inclusion and exclusion criteria. There is fair evidence (grade B) in support of open debridement with 1 level II study, 1 level III study, and 8 level IV studies. There is fair evidence (grade B) in support of arthroscopic or minimally invasive surgical techniques. There is poor evidence (grade C) in support of flexor hallucis longus transfer, longitudinal tenotomy, peritenolysis, gastrocnemius recession, and plantaris excision. There is insufficient evidence (grade I) to provide a recommendation about other surgical treatment methods for noninsertional Achilles tendinopathy.Levels of Evidence: Level III: Systematic review.

Outcomes of Early Weight Bearing in Displaced Intra-articular Calcaneus Fractures Treated with Screws-Only Fixation Technique

Background

Displaced intraarticular calcaneus fracture indicates surgical treatment. The current trend is open reduction and internal fixation with a plate or multiple screws through the sinus tarsi approach. Most postoperative protocols are prolonged non-weight bearing that causes a high socioeconomic burden. This study aims to determine the safety of the early weight-bearing protocol of screws-only fixation in calcaneal fracture.

Materials and Methods

Evaluate displaced intraarticular calcaneus fractures treated with screws-only technique via the sinus tarsi approach in our institution. The first group, from July 2017 to December 2018, allowed patients to start partial weight bearing as tolerated at 4 weeks after surgery. The second group prospectively from January 2019 to March 2020, which assign patients to keep non-weight bearing for 8 weeks. The functional outcomes (Thai Foot and ankle ability measure subjective form, FAAM) were measured 6 months after surgery. The radiographic outcome (Bohler's angle and Gissane angle) was measured on the first day postoperative and 6 months follow-up, and the changes in these angles were recorded.

Results

There were 28 patients in each group. The outcomes were collected and compared by a T-test. In the early weight-bearing group, The FAAM, Bohler's angle loss, and Gissane's angle change were 76.4 ± 14.8, 2.4 ± 3.5, and 6.6 ± 7.8, respectively. In the delayed weight-bearing group, The FAAM, Bohler's angle loss, and Gissane's angle change were 81 ± 14.8, 2 ± 1.8 and 2.6 ± 6.1, respectively. There was no statistically significant difference in FAAM score, Bohler's angle loss, and Gissane's angle change between early and delayed weight-bearing groups.

Conclusion

Screws fixation in calcaneal fracture may be safe to allow early weight-bearing protocol.

Modified Ni-Nail and C-Nail systems for intra-articular fractures of the calcaneus: A biomechancial study

OBJECTIVES

We have proposed a novel intramedullary nail (Ni-Nail) by incorporating a sustentaculum tali screw to improve the fixation stability of minimally invasive treatment for calcaneal fractures. This study aimed to evaluate the biomechanical characters of the Ni-Nail system and compare it with traditional C-Nail system.

METHODS

A finite element model of a Sanders type-IIIAB calcaneal fracture was reconstructed and fixed using two intramedullary nail systems, which was validated by a cadaver study. A vertical loading of 700 N was applied to the subtalar joint surfaces, and 525 N Achilles tendon tension was applied to the superior border of the Achilles tuberosity. The von Mises stresses and fracture displacements of both fixation models were evaluated.

RESULTS

The maximum von Mises stress of the screws of Ni-Nail and C-Nail were 27.92 MPa and 57.42 MPa, respectively, while that of the main nail were 67.44 MPa and 53.01 MPa. In addition, the maximum fracture displacement of the Ni-Nail was larger than that of C-Nail by 15.6% (0.37 mm vs.0.32 mm).

CONCLUSIONS

Our static simulation analysis showed that both Ni-Nail and C-Nail demonstrated similar biomechanical stability for calcaneal fixation. The Ni-Nail features a simple structure that is easier to operate and less traumatizing. Future studies may consider to further evaluate the clinical effectiveness by clinical trials and follow-ups.

Fibula Nail Outcomes in Soft Tissue Compromised Ankle Fractures

BACKGROUND

To determine the clinical outcomes following fibula nail fixation and to identify the indication for the use of fibula nails in lower limb fractures.

METHODS

Retrospective study of adult patients from 2 major trauma centers (MTCs) and 9 trauma units (TUs) who underwent fibula nail fixation for AO/OTA 44 fractures between January 1, 2018, and October 31, 2020. Outcome measures included infection, metalwork complications, nonunion or malunion, time to union, and length of inpatient hospital stay.

RESULTS

Ninety-five patients were included, with a mean age of 66 years; 57.9% of patients were female. The average body mass index was 30. Sixty-nine patients (72.6%) sustained a Weber B and 24 (27.4%) sustained a Weber C fracture. In addition, 26.3% were open fractures and all patients had soft tissue compromise affecting the lateral malleolus. The calculated infection rate for fibula nail was 4.2% and metalwork complication rate was 5.2%. The nonunion and malunion rate was 8.4% and rate of removal of hardware was 2.1%. The average time to union was 12.5 weeks, and length of inpatient stay was 9.4 days (SD 10).

CONCLUSION

This multicenter study demonstrates that use of a fibula nail appears to be a safe approach to treating patients who have a physiologically higher risk of surgery, poor skin condition, and a complex fracture pattern.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, case-control study.

Percutaneous fixation of intraarticular joint-depression calcaneal fractures with different screw configurations - a biomechanical human cadaveric analysis

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to assess the biomechanical performance of different screw configurations for fixation of Sanders type II B joint-depression calcaneal fractures.

METHODS

Fifteen human cadaveric lower limbs were amputated and Sanders II B fractures were simulated. The specimens were randomized to three groups for fixation with different screw configurations. The calcanei in Group 1 were treated with two parallel longitudinal screws, entering superiorly the Achilles tendon insertion, and two screws fixing the intraarticular posterior facet fracture line. In Group 2 two screws entered the tuberosity inferiorly to the Achilles tendon insertion and two transverse screws fixed the posterior facet. In Group 3 two screws were inserted along the bone axis, one transverse screw fixed the posterior facet and one oblique screw was inserted from the posteroplantar part of the tuberosity supporting the posterolateral part of the posterior facet. All specimens were biomechanically tested to failure under progressively increasing cyclic loading.

RESULTS

Initial stiffness did not differ significantly between the groups, P = 0.152. Cycles to 2 mm plantar movement were significantly higher in both Group 1 (15,847 ± 5250) and Group 3 (13,323 ± 4363) compared with Group 2 (4875 ± 3480), P ≤ 0.048. No intraarticular displacement was observed in any group during testing.

CONCLUSIONS

From a biomechanical perspective, posterior facet support by means of buttress or superiorly inserted longitudinal screws results in less plantar movement between the calcaneal tuberosity and the anterior fragments. Inferiorly inserted longitudinal screws are associated with bigger interfragmentary movements.

Percutaneous subtalar joint screw fixation of comminuted calcaneal fractures: a salvage procedure

INTRODUCTION

Malunited comminuted calcaneal fractures result in poor function due subtalar joint arthritis and altered biomechanics. We aimed to assess whether percutaneous subtalar joint screws after fracture reduction provide good outcomes for these difficult injuries.

METHODS

We retrospectively analysed 15 comminuted calcaneal fractures (in 14 patients) treated with percutaneous subtalar screw fixation. All patients had a minimum of 12 months' follow-up. Six patients had open injuries. On the preoperative and the latest postoperative radiograph, Bohlers angle, Gissane angle, calcaneal inclination, width and length, absolute foot height, and posterior facet height were measured. Preoperative computed tomography scans were used to classify the fractures by Sanders classification. Clinical outcome scores were recorded postoperatively.

RESULTS

Mean age was 34.2 ± 14.2 years. Minimum follow-up was 12 months (mean 17.2 ± 4.4 months). Nine patients had a Sanders 4, 3 had a Sanders 3AB, 2 had a Sanders 3BC, and 1 had a Sanders 3AC fracture. Eighty percent of patients had their angle of Gissane, absolute foot height, calcaneal length and inclination restored by this technique. Bohlers angle was restored back into the normal range in 54% of patients. Mean postoperative AOFAS score was 74 ± 11. AOFAS scores positively correlated with postoperative Bohlers angle (Pearson's correlation coefficient 0.85; p = 0.004). One patient (7%) had a wound breakdown postoperatively and three patients (20%) had heel pain from the screws, which improved after removal.

CONCLUSION

Percutaneous subtalar screws offer a reliable option to restore calcaneal anatomy in comminuted calcaneal fractures, with low complication rates. Over 80% of patients had their angle of Gissane, calcaneal length and inclination restored, and over 50% of patients had all radiological parameters restored by this technique. It offers the benefits of percutaneous reduction and fixation and this procedure may be considered an effective first stage prior to definitive subtalar fusion. Further work is needed to review the longer-term outcomes and the conversion rate to arthrodesis.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV (case series), Therapeutic.

Could percutaneous fixation with crossed Schanz pins be an alternative to open reduction in the treatment of intra-articular calcaneal fractures?

PURPOSE

Despite modern operative techniques and a considerable number of studies in the literature, the best treatment for calcaneal fractures remains an enigma for orthopaedic surgeons. The purpose of the study was to compare clinical and radiographic outcomes between anatomic calcaneal plate (ACP) fixation and crossed Schanz pin (CSP) fixation in the treatment of Sanders type II and III displaced intra-articular calcaneus fractures (DICFs).

METHODS

Consecutive 65 patients (49 males, 16 females) who underwent surgery for DCIFs between January 2009 and February 2013 were retrospectively evaluated. The patients were divided into two groups as ACP and CSP according to the operative technique. The groups were compared in terms of demographic features, injury mechanism, operation time, fluoroscopy exposure, complications, full weight-bearing time, functional, and radiological outcomes.

RESULTS

VAS-rest score did not differ significantly between the groups while the VAS-activity score was significantly higher in the CSP group (p = 0.001 and p = 0.645, respectively). Foot Function Index (FFI) was significantly lower, Maryland Foot Score (MFS) and the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society-hindfoot score (AOFAS) were significantly higher in the ACP group (p = 0.047, p = 0.016, and p < 0.001, respectively). While no difference was observed between the preoperative and the early post-operative (1st day) Böhler angle and Gissane angle, both were significantly higher in the ACP group at the post-operative last control (p < 0.001 and p < 0.001, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Although crossed Schanz pin fixation shortens the operation time in displaced intra-articular calcaneus fractures compared to anatomic calcaneal plate, increased fluoroscopy exposure rates and low functional and radiological outcomes are disadvantageous of crossed Schanz pin. Anatomic calcaneal plate is still a better technique for preserving the alignment and elevating the displaced intra-articular segment for good to excellent mid-term results.

Comparison between open reduction and internal fixation and minimally invasive surgery in management of Sanders type II calcaneal fracture: A randomized controlled trial protocol

BACKGROUND

The minimally invasive surgery possesses an essential and growing function in treating the calcaneal fractures, but the related literature on this topic is limited. For our study, the main purpose was to compare the early prognosis of a group of the patients with Sanders type II fracture of calcaneus treated via minimally invasive surgery and open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF).

METHODS

This is a prospective randomized controlled trial in the patients who suffer from displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures. This current study was carried out in accordance with the guidelines of "CONSORT statement" for the randomized controlled studies. All patients were randomly assigned into 2 groups on the basis of a random number table, namely the minimally invasive treatment group and the ORIF group using conventional methods. Inclusion criteria included the followings: aged between 18 to 59 years old; closed and unilateral fracture; patients with displaced intra-articular calcaneal fracture (>2 mm) involving Sanders Type IIC and Type IIB; and patients have enough mental capacity to understand and answer questions in the evaluation scale. In the process of outpatient follow-up, the radiographs were taken at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months. The functional results involved the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Score, Foot Function Index, and the pain score.

CONCLUSIONS

This protocol will give us research directions in future work.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

This study protocol was registered in Research Registry (researchregistry6261).

Outcomes of management of displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures

Despite the advances in operative management, displaced intra-articular calcaneal fractures (DIAFCs) are often associated with long term sequelae, permanent disability, a considerable reduction in quality of life, and a high socio-economic cost. Randomized controlled trials have shown that patient reported outcomes of surgery are no better than those of nonoperative management. Methodological flaws and selection bias may have influenced the results, however, and subgroup analysis showed that some patients could benefit from surgery, whilst patients' preference can be the decisive factor in choosing a management modality. Fractures with significant lateral wall displacement predisposing to impingements often require surgery, and management has to be individualized and tailored to the patient. Surgery does not usually achieve excellent results, though it exposes the patient to potential risks and complications. Wound healing problems and infections affect around 20% of patients when the extensile lateral approach has been used. Sinus tarsi approach and minimally invasive surgery may be viable alternatives, offering similar results with fewer wound complications, but most of the available studies are of low to moderate quality. Late subtalar joint arthrodesis is often required: however, such procedure would be less technically difficult and could result in better foot function should the shape of the calcaneus have been anatomically restored with surgery in the acute phase.

An evaluation of the results of locked plate osteosynthesis applied without the use of bone graft in Sanders type III and IV intra-articular calcaneus fractures

PURPOSE

The clinical and radiological results of locked plate osteosynthesis with an extensive lateral approach without bone graft in Sanders type III and IV intra-articular calcaneus fractures and the factors affecting these results were evaluated retrospectively.

METHODS

A total of 61 patients with Sanders type 3 and 4 calcaneus fractures who underwent a lateral approach with locked plate osteosynthesis were included in the study. The mean follow-up was 44.8 months.

RESULTS

The mean pre- and post-operative Gissane and Bohler's angles were 113.5° ± 13.9° and 106.7° ± 13.6° (p = 0.006) and 2.8° ± 14.1° and 19.6° ± 13.1° (p < 0.001), respectively. The mean post-operative AOFAS scores, SF-36, and Maryland were 80.5 ± 13.6 in type IIIAB, 89.4 ± 6.3 in IIIAC, and 82.4 ± 12.5 in IV; 58.6 ± 14.5 in type IIIAB, 60.3 ± 11.7 in IIIAC, and 58.0 ± 15.6 in IV; and 63.8 ± 7.2 in type IIIAB, 64.3 ± 7.1 in IIIAC, and 62.8 ± 11.7 in IV (p = 0.173, p = 0.932, p = 0.824, respectively). Wound problems were observed in 15 (28.6%) patients. Deep infection was not observed in any patient.

CONCLUSION

The clinical results were similar in type III and IV intra-articular calcaneus fractures applied with locked plate osteosynthesis in an extensive lateral approach and without the use of bone graft. Intra-articular calcaneus fracture fixation with a lateral locked plate is an effective treatment method.