Thymomas II: a clinicopathologic correlation of 250 cases with a proposed staging system with emphasis on pathologic assessment

Immunotherapy in thymic epithelial tumors: tissue predictive biomarkers for immune checkpoint inhibitors

Thymic epithelial tumors (TETs) are rare malignant neoplasms arising in the thymus gland. Nevertheless, TETs, including thymomas (TMs), thymic carcinomas (TCs), and thymic neuroendocrine neoplasms (TNENs), are the most common mediastinal malignancies overall. A multidisciplinary approach is required for the appropriate diagnostic and therapeutic management of TETs. To date, the main therapeutic strategies are largely depended on the stage of the tumor and they include surgery with or without neoadjuvant or adjuvant therapy, represented by platinum-based chemotherapy, radiotherapy or chemoradiotherapy. Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) are ongoing under evaluation in the advanced or metastatic diseases despite the challenges related to the very low tumor mutation burden (TMB) and the high incidence of immune-related adverse events in TETs. In this regard, predictive impact of tissue biomarkers expression such as programmed cell death ligand-1 (PD-L1), and other emerging biomarkers, as well as their optimal and shared interpretation are currently under evaluation in order to predict response rates to ICIs in TETs.

Thymoma: An Overview

Thymomas are considered one of the most prevalent types of mediastinal epithelial tumors, which frequently develop in the anterior mediastinum. Due to their rarity, these tumors' nomenclature, classification, and staging are likely to be the subject of debate and argument for most expert pathologists. Furthermore, the significance of thymoma histologic classifications have been debated over the past twenty years. While certain advocates argue that staging at the time of diagnosis is more significant, others believe that histologic subtyping has a significant impact on how patients behave clinically. In this review, we will focus on some of the challenges that diagnostic surgical pathologists may experience while evaluating the histopathology of thymomas and staging these tumors. We will additionally glance over the clinical characteristics of these distinct tumors and the current management strategy.

Atypical thymoma (epithelial-rich thymoma, well-differentiated thymic carcinoma, WHO type B3 thymoma): A conundrum

Thymomas composed predominantly of epithelioid tumor cells with scattered lymphocytes have been well recognized in the literature. This subtype of thymoma has been variously termed epithelial-rich thymoma, well-differentiated thymic carcinoma, atypical thymoma, or World Health Organization (WHO) type B3 thymoma. Regardless of the designation however, these tumors are known to show a spectrum of histopathological growth patterns that may pose challenges in interpretation and diagnosis, particularly when dealing with small mediastinoscopic biopsies. Just like any other type of thymoma, those composed predominantly of epithelioid cells may present as encapsulated or invasive tumors. Nevertheless, compared to other subtypes of thymoma, they are uncommon neoplasms. Therefore, it becomes very important to sufficiently sample thymomas before making a diagnosis of a particular subtype, especially when the tumor is rich in epithelioid cells and only has a scant lymphocytic component. Because of the unusual occurrence of these tumors, there are only few large series of cases that attempt to highlight not only the more salient histopathological features but also the most important immunohistochemical and molecular characteristics.

Pediatric Thymoma: A Review and Update of the Literature

Pediatric thymomas are extremely rare and slow-growing malignant tumors. The recent publication of the first Union for International Cancer Control (UICC)/American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) Tumor–Node–Metastasis (TNM) stage classification and updated treatment guidelines for thymomas has prompted us to perform a review of the literature on pediatric thymomas. A search of English-language articles in the PubMed, Cochrane, Web of Science, and Embase databases was conducted. Additional articles were identified through reference lists of retrieved publications. Thirty-two articles involving 82 pediatric thymomas were included. Males comprised 60% of patients, and 13% manifested myasthenia gravis (MG). Histotype B1 (45%) and stage I (52% Masaoka–Koga and 71% UICC/AJCC TNM) were the most frequent. Of note is the possibility that the lack of cases with mixed histologies in the reviewed publications might be related to a sampling issue, as it is well known that the more sections are available for review, the more likely it is that the majority of these neoplasms will show mixed histologies. Both staging systems showed a gradual increase in the percentage of cases, with more advanced stages of disease moving from type A to B3 thymomas. Complete surgical resection (R0) was the main therapeutic approach in Masaoka–Koga stage I (89%) and UICC/AJCC TNM stage I (70%) thymomas. Advanced stages of disease and incomplete surgical resection were most often associated with recurrence and death. An association between stage and outcome, and completeness of resection and outcome, was found. Interestingly, though an association between histotype and staging was found, this does not take into account the possibility of mixed histologies which would reduce the clinical impact of histologic subtyping over staging.

Thymomas With Intravascular and Intracardiac Growth

Thymomas are derived from the epithelial component of the thymus and constitute the most common tumor of the anterior mediastinum. These neoplasms are considered malignant for their potential for invasion and metastases. Several histopathologic subclassification schemes have been proposed over the years, however, correlation of histotypes with prognosis remains controversial. In contrast, studies invariably have shown that staging and resection status correlate with oncologic behavior and disease outcomes. In this regard, several staging systems have been presented, though transcapsular invasion and degree of involvement of adjacent anatomic structures are common denominators of all schemes. Involvement of the great vessels and heart most commonly results from direct invasion, which may lead to unusual clinical presentations such as superior vena cava syndrome. Moreover, intravascular and intracardiac growth with or without direct mural invasion rarely occurs. We provide an overview of thymomas with intravascular and intracardiac involvement.

Thymic Lesions in Myasthenia Gravis: A Clinicopathological Study from India

Background and Objectives: Thymic pathology is common in Myasthenia Gravis(MG) and plays a crucial role in its pathogenesis and clinical outcome. This study aims to discuss the clinicohistopathological spectrum of thymic lesions in MG. Methods: In this retrospective study, MG patients who underwent thymectomy from 2011 to 2020 were included. Clinical, radiological, serological, and histopathological details are described. Results: Of 83 patients(F = 45; M = 38), 7(8%) had ocular myasthenia, and the remaining 76(92%) had the generalized form. At onset, the median age was 36 years(M = 44; F = 31). AChR antibody was positive in 71/79 patients. RNST showed decrement response in 68/78 patients. The histopathological study demonstrated thymoma in 44(53%), thymic hyperplasias [32(38%)], involuted thymus [5(6%)], thymic cyst (1) and thymic lipoma (1). WHO grading of thymoma: B2- 48%, AB-18%, B-18%, B3-14%, A-2.3% . In these, capsular infiltration was noted in 11/44, 9 had focal and 2 had diffuse infiltration. Active germinal centers were present in 20/32 patients with thymic hyperplasia and 4/44 with thymoma. Thymomas were predominant in males and thymic hyperplasia in females. The age of onset and antibody positivity rate was higher in thymoma patients. Conclusion: In our cohort, there is a female preponderance. Thymoma was the commonest pathology followed by hyperplasia. We observed earlier onset of myasthenia in females. AChR antibody positivity rate was more frequent in thymomas. This study indicates that clinico-radiological evaluation adequately supported by serology and histopathology can effectively recognize the type of thymic pathology that can guide these patients’ treatment planning, management, prognosis and follow-up.

Thymoma Staging: An Analysis of the Different Schemas

Over the last years, a number of changes has taken place in the evaluation of thymomas. More recently, the introduction of a TNM staging system in the assessment of thymic epithelial tumors, in general, has been put forward. Important to highlight is that this TNM system is not based on tumor size, and because of that shortcoming, it was in need to borrow most if not all of the information from the experience derived from other schemas that over the years have been tested with larger series of cases. Also important to recognize is that this TNM system is nothing new as previous authors in the past had already attempted to provide a TNM system for thymomas without much success. Therefore, it becomes important that those involved with the staging of thymomas become familiar with previous schemas as the TNM system provides a slight different spin in the T component, while the M component truly represents advance stages of previous schemas. More importantly is to also highlight that despite the specific anatomic structures addressed in the T or M assessment, there is little information in the most important aspect of any staging system-clear definitions of invasion and metastasis and the gross assessment of these tumors to provide an accurate staging. Capsular integrity still remains paramount in such assessment. A critical assessment of TNM system compared with previously proposed staging systems and whether there is a real advancement in applying it is discussed as well as the gross assessment of these tumors to highlight the importance of the staging protocol.

Thymoma: Histologically a heterogenous group of tumors

Over the years the nomenclature of thymomas has been debated regarding the best manner in which these tumors should be grouped. In every schema presented thus far, the main issue has been the presence or lack of lymphocytes and accordingly, the tumors have been place into a specific category. However, even though this concept applies for most of the cases, there are numerous tumors that do not necessarily fit into those categories as either the thymomas show another cellular proliferation associated with the epithelial cells or the epithelial cell themselves are arranged in a pattern that departs from the conventional features of the classic thymoma. Herein we will emphasize those features, which in some circumstances, mainly with small mediastinoscopic biopsies may pose a considerable problem in interpretation. We do consider that the most important issue is to be familiar with the different growth pattern that these tumors may show in order to avoid misdiagnosis. In addition, we consider that regardless of the growth pattern or cellular composition of the tumor, it is highly recommended that these tumors just like any other be carefully sampled and properly stage. Although we are fully aware of the different growth pattern and specific cellular details that thymoma may show, the discussion of each one of those tumors is beyond the scope of this review. Therefore, we have placed more emphasis in those, which in our judgment are more commonly encountered in the daily practice.

Oncological resection, myasthenia gravis and staging as prognostic factors in thymic tumours: a Chilean case series

Background

Thymic epithelial tumours are rare and highly heterogeneous. Reports from the United States suggest an overall incidence of 0.15 per 100,000/year. In contrast, the incidence of these tumours in Latin America is largely unknown and reports are scarce, somewhat limited to case reports.

Methods

Herein, we report a series of 38 thymic tumours from a single institution, retrospectively incorporated into this study. Patient characteristics and outcomes including age, sex, stage, paraneoplastic syndromes, treatment regimens and the date of decease were obtained from medical records.

Results

Most cases in our series were females and young age (<50 years old) and early stage by Masaoka-Koga or the Moran staging systems. Also, a 34% of patients had myasthenia gravis (MG). Next, we analysed overall survival rates in our series and found that the quality of surgery (R0, R1 or R2), MG status and staging (Masaoka-Koga, Moran or TNM) were prognostic factors. Finally, we compared our data to larger thymic tumour series.

Conclusions

Overall, our study confirms complete surgical resection as the standard, most effective treatment for thymic epithelial tumours. Also, the Masaoka-Koga staging system remains as a reliable prognostic factor but also the Moran staging system should be considered for thymomas.

Micronodular Thymomas With Prominent Cystic Changes: A Clinicopathological and Immunohistochemical Study of 25 Cases

Twenty-five cases of micronodular thymomas with prominent cystic changes are presented. The patients are 13 men and 12 women between the ages of 38 and 69 years. Clinically, the majority of patients presented with nonspecific symptoms of cough, chest pain, and dyspnea. Four patients were asymptomatic. Diagnostic imaging showed the presence of an anterior mediastinal mass and surgical resection of the tumor mass was performed in all the patients. Histologically, all the tumors were characterized by the presence of cystic structures of varying sizes lined by different types of epithelium. In addition, the tumors were characterized by nodules of epithelial cells embedded in a lymphocyte-rich stroma with germinal centers. Twenty-one tumors were encapsulated while 4 tumors were minimally invasive. Immunohistochemical stains were positive for keratin in the nodular epithelial component while CD45 and CD20 were positive in the lymphoid component. Clinical follow-up ranging from 12 to 24 months was obtained in 19 patients. All the patients were alive and well without disease. No clinical follow-up was available in 6 patients. The cases presented in this article highlight the existence of cystic micronodular thymomas, which can be easily misdiagnosed as a multilocular thymic cyst.

The role of needle core biopsies in the evaluation of thymic epithelial neoplasms

Thymic epithelial neoplasms are rare tumors derived from thymic epithelium that most often present as large anterior mediastinal masses. The vast majority of thymic epithelial neoplasms fall under the diagnostic category of thymoma, with a smaller percentage qualifying for a diagnosis of thymic carcinoma. The ability to render a definitive diagnosis on these tumors is generally hampered by their deep location and close proximity to vital structures, which makes biopsy sampling for histopathologic evaluation difficult. In recent years, the trend in medicine has been to opt for the least invasive procedure to obtain tissue samples that, by definition, implies also obtaining smaller and smaller biopsies, resulting in lesser amounts of tissue available for examination. In the mediastinum, the most common modalities for procuring biopsy samples from mass lesions include fine-needle aspiration, percutaneous core needle biopsy and video-assisted thoracoscopic biopsy. In this review, we will deal only with the role and limitations of percutaneous core biopsies in the interpretation of thymic epithelial neoplasms.

Cystic and Encapsulated Atypical Thymoma (World Health Organization Type B3)

OBJECTIVES

Eight cases of encapsulated and cystic atypical thymomas (World Health Organization type B3) are presented.

METHODS

Cases were identified after review of more than 500 thymomas. Histologic material from surgical resections was evaluated.

RESULTS

The patients are seven men and one woman aged 43 to 71 years. Seven patients presented with nonspecific symptoms while one mass was found on autopsy. The tumors were 4 to 6 cm in greatest dimension and showed prominent cystic changes with an epithelial proliferation arranged in sheets and cords. Increased mitotic activity and nuclear pleomorphism were not identified. All tumors were encapsulated. Immunohistochemical studies showed the tumor cells positive for keratin cocktail, keratin 5/6, and p63. Clinical follow-up was available in five patients. All were alive without recurrence.

CONCLUSIONS

These cases represent an unusual variant of atypical thymoma that can be misdiagnosed as thymic carcinoma or multilocular thymic cyst. Awareness of this histologic growth pattern is important for accurate diagnosis.

Expression of PD-1 and PD-L1 in thymic epithelial neoplasms

Thymic epithelial neoplasms are rare tumors that are difficult to diagnose and treat. Programmed death 1 (PD-1) receptor and its ligand (PD-L1) are expressed by various malignancies and are considered a prognostic factor and immunotherapeutic target. We examined the expression of both antibodies in 100 thymic epithelial neoplasms to assess their use as a biomarker and to correlate their expression with clinicopathological parameters. Whole-tissue sections of 74 thymomas and 26 thymic carcinomas were examined. Expression of PD-1 and PD-L1 was evaluated by immunohistochemistry and scored by the percentage of positive T-cells or tumor cells, respectively. Cases with strong membranous reactivity of the antibody in ≥5% of T-cells (PD-1) or tumor cells (PD-L1), respectively, were considered positive. Expression of PD-1 was detected in 52/100 cases (52%) including 6/26 thymic carcinomas (23%) and 46/74 thymomas (62%). PD-L1 was positive in 61/100 cases (61%) including 14/26 thymic carcinomas (54%) and 47/74 thymomas (64%). A total of 82 cases (82%) showed expression of PD-1 or PD-L1. PD-1⁺ cases were associated with higher stage in thymic carcinoma (P=0.01) and PD-1^- cases with thymic carcinoma histology (P=0.0014), whereas PD-L1⁺ cases were associated with neoadjuvant therapy in thymoma (P=0.0065). There was no statistical difference between PD-1 or PD-L1 expression status and other clinicopathological parameters including overall survival. PD-1 and/or PD-L1 are expressed in up to 82% of thymic epithelial neoplasms. These results confirm that these tumors should be considered for PD-1/PD-L1-targeted therapy, however their predictive value in terms of prognosis remains uncertain.

Evolution of Classification of Thymic Epithelial Tumors in the Era of Dr Thomas V. Colby

CONTEXT

-Numerous histomorphologic and staging classifications of thymic epithelial tumors (TETs) have been proposed during the last century, suggesting that the classification of these tumors is challenging and controversial. Difficulties of classifying TETs include various combinations of epithelial cells and lymphocytes and the paucity of these tumors. The prognostic significance, specifically of the histomorphologic classifications, has been debated. Early classifications were also challenged by the uncertainty of the neoplastic component(s) of the tumor.

OBJECTIVE

-To discuss the evolution of the histomorphologic classification and the staging system of TET. Controversies and problems of some classifications and their importance for therapeutic management and prognosis will be reviewed. Classifications that incorporated new concepts and approaches at the time or outcome studies will be highlighted. Current classifications will be discussed and the staging system that was recently proposed for the upcoming eighth American Joint Committee on Cancer staging will be described.

DATA SOURCES

-Search of literature database (PubMed) and current (2015) World Health Organization classification.

CONCLUSIONS

-Histomorphologic and staging classifications of TET have evolved during the last century and especially during the era of Thomas V. Colby, MD. Evidence supports that the staging system has prognostic implications independent of and superior to the histomorphologic classification. Histomorphology appears to be important for biologic features of TET.

Immunophenotypic and prognostic analysis of PAX8 and TTF-1 expressions in neuroendocrine carcinomas of thymic origin: A comparative study with their pulmonary counterparts

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the immunoreactivity of TTF-1 and PAX8 in neuroendocrine carcinoma of thymic (TNEC) and pulmonary origins (PNEC), and whether their immunophenotyping could be used to distinguish between NEC of the two sites, as well as prognosis of patients with TNEC.

METHODS

Twenty-two cases of TNEC and 20 cases of PNEC were selected for immunohistochemical analysis using PAX8 and TTF-1. Clinical data and follow-up information were obtained for survival analyses.

RESULTS

TTF-1 immunoreactivity was seen in 19 PNEC cases (95%) and 13 TNEC cases (59.1%). PAX8 was negative in all pulmonary tumors while positive in 19 thymic cases (86.4%). TTF-1 positivity was associated with high sensitivity but low specificity for PNEC, and adding PAX8 negativity significantly increased the specificity. PAX8 positivity alone showed essentially 100% specificity and 86.4% sensitivity for TNEC. Survival analysis showed lung metastasis as a significant prognostic factor in TNEC.

CONCLUSION

Our study demonstrated that TTF-1/PAX8 immunophenotyping may be helpful for differential diagnosis of NECs of pulmonary and thymic origins. TTF-1+/PAX8- immunophenotyping showed high specificity for PNECs, while PAX8+ alone showed a good diagnostic accuracy for TNEC. Lung metastasis was a predictive factor that associated with survival of TNEC patients. J. Surg. Oncol. 2016;114:697-702. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Thymomas With Extensive Clear Cell Component: A Clinicopathologic and Immunohistochemical Study of Nine Cases

OBJECTIVES

Nine cases of thymomas with an extensive clear cell component are presented.

METHODS

The patients were six men and three women aged between 45 and 62 years (mean, 52 years). Presenting symptoms included shortness of breath, chest pain, and cough. Diagnostic imaging revealed anterior mediastinal masses in all patients, and all underwent thymectomy.

RESULTS

Grossly, the tumors varied from 3 to 9 cm in the greatest dimension. Four cases were invasive and five encapsulated. Histologically, the tumors were characterized by an epithelial cell component with extensive clear cell change, admixed with lymphocytes in varying proportions. Immunohistochemically, the tumors demonstrated the typical immunophenotype of thymomas characterized by positive staining of the epithelial cells for pancytokeratin and cytokeratin 5/6, absent expression of CD5 and c-kit, and reactivity of the lymphocytes for terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase. Clinical follow-up available for six patients showed that all were alive and well 12 to 24 months after surgical resection.

CONCLUSIONS

The cases herein presented highlight an unusual feature in thymoma that has more commonly been ascribed to thymic carcinoma. They also emphasize the importance of correct diagnosis to determine the appropriate treatment strategy and to accurately predict prognosis.

Patterns of metastasis and recurrence in thymic epithelial tumours: longitudinal imaging review in correlation with histological subtypes

AIM

To determine the patterns of metastasis and recurrence in thymic epithelial tumours based on longitudinal imaging studies, and to correlate the patterns with World Health Organization (WHO) histological classifications.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seventy-seven patients with histopathologically confirmed thymomas (n=62) and thymic carcinomas (n=15) who were followed with cross-sectional follow-up imaging after surgery were retrospectively studied. All cross-sectional imaging studies during the disease course were reviewed to identify metastasis or recurrence. The sites of involvement and the time of involvement measured from surgery were recorded.

RESULTS

Metastasis or recurrence was noted in 24 (31%) of the 77 patients. Patients with metastasis or recurrence were significantly younger than those without (median age: 46 versus 60, respectively; p=0.0005), and more commonly had thymic carcinomas than thymomas (p=0.002). The most common site of involvement was the pleura (17/24), followed by the lung (9/24), and thoracic nodes (9/24). Abdominopelvic involvement was noted in 12 patients, most frequently in the liver (n=8). Lung metastasis was more common in thymic carcinomas than thymomas (p=0.0005). Time from surgery to the development of metastasis or recurrence was shortest in thymic carcinoma, followed by high-risk thymomas, and was longest in low-risk thymoma (median time in months: 25.1, 68.8, and not reached, respectively; p=0.0015).

CONCLUSIONS

The patterns of metastasis and recurrence of thymic epithelial tumours differ significantly across histological subgroups, with thymic carcinomas more commonly having metastasis with shorter length of time after surgery. The knowledge of different patterns of tumour spread may contribute to further understanding of the biological and clinical behaviours of these tumours.

State of the Art: MR Imaging of Thymoma

Thymoma is the most common primary malignancy of the anterior mediastinum and the most common thymic epithelial neoplasm, but it is a rare tumor that constitutes less than 1% of adult malignancies. Computed tomography (CT) is currently the imaging modality of choice for distinguishing thymoma from other anterior mediastinal masses, characterizing the primary tumor, and staging the disease. However, magnetic resonance imaging is also effective in evaluating and characterizing anterior mediastinal masses and staging thymoma in patients with contraindications to contrast-material-enhanced CT such as contrast allergy and/or renal failure.

Modified Masaoka stage and size are independent prognostic predictors in thymoma and modified Masaoka stage is superior to histopathologic classifications

INTRODUCTION

The prognostic value of histopathologic classifications of thymoma is debated. Problematic reproducibility might cause this controversy. We studied the prognostic significance of three histopathologic classifications of thymomas after three thoracic pathologists agreed upon thymoma subtype and invasion. We also compared the outcome to established prognostic parameters.

METHODS

Patients, surgically treated for thymic epithelial neoplasm at Mayo Clinic (1942-2008), were staged according to the modified Masaoka staging and the recently proposed staging by Moran. Three thoracic pathologists independently classified all cases according to the World Health Organization, Bernatz, and proposed Suster and Moran classification. Only thymoma that all three pathologists diagnosed as the same histopathologic subtype and extent of invasion were included in outcome analysis.

RESULTS

In 214 (proposed Suster and Moran classification), 145 (World Health Organization classification), and 120 cases (Bernatz classification), reviewers agreed upon subtype of thymoma and invasion and follow-up was available. Median follow-up time was 7.5-7.7 years (range between classifications). All histopathologic classifications were associated with overall survival (OS) and disease-free survival (p ≤ 0.0001 to p = 0.048); only Bernatz classification was independent of modified Masaoka staging associated with OS (p = 0.04). Modified Masaoka stage predicted outcome independent of all histopathologic classifications and resection status and strongly correlated with the proposed Moran stage (correlation coefficient, 0.95). Thymoma size and age were prognostic parameters for OS independent of any histopathologic classification.

CONCLUSIONS

Histopathologic classifications of thymomas are associated with prognosis but are in general not independent predictors of outcome. Modified Masaoka stage and proposed Moran staging are independent prognostic parameters for thymoma and superior to histopathologic classifications.

Diaphragm Appearance: A Clue to the Diagnosis of Pulmonary and Extrapulmonary Pathology

The diaphragm is often overlooked or incompletely evaluated when interpreting chest radiographs. Alterations in the appearance of the diaphragm on chest radiographs such as elevation, contour abnormalities, adjacent lucency, and calcifications can offer clues to pulmonary and extrapulmonary pathology. Familiarity with common causes of these alterations facilitates the appropriate selection of additional imaging and leads to the diagnosis of both benign and life-threatening processes. This article reviews normal variations in the appearance of the diaphragm as well as those associated with pulmonary and extrapulmonary pathology.

Expression of cell cycle and apoptosis regulators in thymus and thymic epithelial tumors

The human thymus supports the production of self-tolerant T cells with competent and regulatory functions. Various cellular components of the thymic microenvironment such as thymic epithelial cells (TEC) and dendritic cells play essential roles in thymic T cell differentiation. The multiple cellular events occurring during thymic T cell and TEC differentiation involve proteins regulating cell cycle and apoptosis. Dysregulation of the cell cycle and apoptosis networks is involved in the pathogenesis of thymic epithelial tumors (TET) which are divided into two broad categories, thymomas and thymic carcinomas. The present review focuses on the usefulness of the analysis of the expression patterns of major cell cycle and apoptosis regulators in order to gain insight in the histophysiology of thymus and the histopathology, the clinical behavior and the biology of TET.

ITMIG consensus statement on the use of the WHO histological classification of thymoma and thymic carcinoma: refined definitions, histological criteria, and reporting

INTRODUCTION

The 2004 version of the World Health Organization classification subdivides thymic epithelial tumors into A, AB, B1, B2, and B3 (and rare other) thymomas and thymic carcinomas (TC). Due to a morphological continuum between some thymoma subtypes and some morphological overlap between thymomas and TC, a variable proportion of cases may pose problems in classification, contributing to the poor interobserver reproducibility in some studies.

METHODS

To overcome this problem, hematoxylin-eosin-stained and immunohistochemically processed sections of prototypic, "borderland," and "combined" thymomas and TC (n = 72) were studied by 18 pathologists at an international consensus slide workshop supported by the International Thymic Malignancy Interest Group.

RESULTS

Consensus was achieved on refined criteria for decision making at the A/AB borderland, the distinction between B1, B2, and B3 thymomas and the separation of B3 thymomas from TCs. "Atypical type A thymoma" is tentatively proposed as a new type A thymoma variant. New reporting strategies for tumors with more than one histological pattern are proposed.

CONCLUSION

These guidelines can set the stage for reproducibility studies and the design of a clinically meaningful grading system for thymic epithelial tumors.

Staging of thymic epithelial neoplasms: thymoma and thymic carcinoma

Thymic epithelial neoplasms are uncommon tumors that have been the subject of interest in the last few decades with regard to their histogenesis, histopathologic classification, treatment and prognosis. These tumors are a group of heterogenous neoplasms that are often difficult to subtype and the value of such subclassification with regard to prognosis remains obscure. One factor, however, that appears strongly associated with clinical behavior is tumor staging. The focus of this review will be an overview of the different staging systems for thymic epithelial neoplasms that have been presented in the literature over the years. Particular emphasis is paid to the latest developments in this context.

FDG PET-CT aids in the preoperative assessment of patients with newly diagnosed thymic epithelial malignancies

INTRODUCTION

Advanced thymoma (stage III and IV) is difficult to detect by computed tomography (CT), yet it is important to distinguish between early (stage I and II) and advanced disease before surgery, as patients with locally advanced tumors require neoadjuvant chemotherapy to enable effective resection. This study assessed whether the amount of fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) uptake can predict advanced thymoma and whether it can separate thymoma from thymic cancer.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed FDG positron emission tomography (PET)-CT scans of 51 consecutive newly diagnosed patients with thymic epithelial malignancy. PET-CT findings documented focal FDG activity: SUVmax, SUVmean, SUVpeak, and total body volumetric standardized uptake value (SUV) measurements. These were correlated with Masaoka-Koga staging and World Health Organization classification. Wilcoxon ranked sum tests were used to assess association between SUV and pathological stage, cancer type, and classification.

RESULTS

Among the study patients, 37 had thymoma, 12 thymic carcinoma, and 2 thymic carcinoid. Higher focal FDG uptake was seen in patients with type B3 thymoma than in those with type A, AB, B1, or B2 thymoma (p < 0.006). FDG uptake was higher in patients with thymic carcinoma or carcinoid than in patients with thymoma (p < 0.0003), with more variable associations with volumetric SUV measurements. There was no significant association observed between higher focal FDG uptake and advanced-stage disease in thymoma patients (p > 0.09), although greater FDG-avid tumor volume was significantly associated with advanced disease (p < 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Focal FDG uptake cannot predict advanced thymoma but is helpful in distinguishing thymoma from thymic carcinoma, or the more aggressive thymoma, type B3.

Thymoma: a population-based study of the management and outcomes for the province of British Columbia

INTRODUCTION

Thymomas are rare neoplasms with variable clinical behavior. Our primary study aim was to analyze treatment practices and outcomes in a population-based cohort of thymoma patients. We hypothesized that stage I and II thymomas would have high cure rates with resection and adjuvant radiation, whereas locally advanced cases would benefit from multimodality therapy.

METHODS

All patients, diagnosed with thymoma or thymic carcinoma in British Columbia between 1994 and 2009, were identified using the British Columbia Cancer Agency Registry. Chart review was used to collect demographic and treatment data. Detailed pathology review was performed using the World Health Organization classification.

RESULTS

One hundred and seventy-one patients were identified for analysis. The 5-year overall survival was 93.3%, 88.7%, 74.6%, 43.4% for stages I, II, III, and IV, respectively. Survival varied significantly among patients with thymoma compared with thymic carcinoma. In patients with stage II disease, adjuvant radiation did not confer an overall survival or recurrence-free survival benefit. Seventy-five patients had locally advanced disease. There was practice variation in treatment of these patients. Patients with thymoma undergoing trimodality treatment had a 5-year median overall survival of 80%, whereas patients with thymic carcinoma had poor outcomes despite aggressive treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Survival rates in this population-based series were comparable to those in previously published reports. The ideal management of thymic tumors involves a multidisciplinary approach, particularly in locally advanced disease and selection of patients for adjuvant radiation therapy.

Staging of primary mediastinal tumors

Primary mediastinal tumors, with the exception of lymphoma, are generally rare neoplasms. The diagnosis, classification, and treatment of these tumors still cause some degree of difficulty due to their low incidence and morphologic heterogeneity. This is particularly true for thymic epithelial neoplasms, that is, thymoma and thymic carcinoma, and also applies to primary neuroendocrine carcinomas of the thymus and primary mediastinal germ cell tumors. The appropriate staging of these tumors, likewise, has been a matter of debate over the years and numerous proposals for the staging of thymic epithelial neoplasms have been put forward in the last few decades. Unfortunately, variations of such proposals have been used in some instances to stage other tumors such as thymic neuroendocrine carcinomas and germ cell tumors, which has led to the often inappropriate use of a single staging system for different types of tumors with different biological behavior. This review will provide an overview of the staging of primary mediastinal tumors with special emphasis on more recent assessments in this particular area.