The Many Chemists Who Could Have Proposed the Woodward-Hoffmann Rules But Didn't: The Organic Chemists Who Discovered the Smoking Guns[ ]

It is a reasonable question to ask, why, as of 1965 when the five Woodward-Hoffmann communications appeared, did no other organic chemist discover the orbital symmetry rules for pericyclic reactions? Two theoretical chemists - Luitzen Oosterhoff (in 1961) and Kenichi Fukui (in 1964) had discovered portions of the orbital symmetry rules before Woodward and Hoffmann. Why not organic chemists? Indeed, perhaps the greatest motivation to discover the mechanism of a mysterious reaction is to uncover key examples of that mysterious reaction in your very own laboratory. The stories of 20 chemists and R. B. Woodward are discussed in this paper which is Paper 6 in a 27-paper series on the history of Woodward-Hoffmann rules. Social, political, and scientific explanations will also be presented as partial explanations as to why none of these individuals - except Woodward with Hoffmann - solved the pericyclic no-mechanism problem.

History of the Woodward-Hoffmann Rules. The No-Mechanism Puzzle

This is Paper 2 in the 27-paper series on the history of the development of the Woodward-Hoffmann rules. Paper 2 takes the reader back to the 1950s and early 1960s, before the publication of the first Woodward-Hoffmann paper in January 1965. The scope of the pericyclic no-mechanism problem is described along with many of the key "hints" or "clues" to orbital symmetry control that were available in the literature prior to 1965. A chronology of reactions with alternating stereospecificities is provided. A second chronology of alternating theoretical hints is provided, e. g., 4n+2 versus 4n. Another chronology is provided, that of the development of frontier molecular orbital theory, with and without phases and nodes. A tabulation is provided of 36 instances in which the MOs of 1,3-butadiene were reported in the literature. A knowledge of the MOs of 1,3-butadiene, plus a knowledge of some of the alternating stereospecific reactions, could have led many chemists to the solution of the pericyclic no-mechanism problem before Woodward and Hoffmann.

Sudden polarization and zwitterion formation as a pseudo-Jahn–Teller effect: a new insight into the photochemistry of alkenes

We show that the intermediates of photochemical reactions—sudden polarization and zwitterion formations—are consequences of the pseudo-Jahn–Teller effect (PJTE), which facilitates a better understanding, rationalization, prediction, and manipulation of the corresponding chemical and biological processes.

Photosensitized Conversion of 9,10-Deoxytridachione to Photodeoxytridachione

[reaction: see text] The photochemical conversion of 9,10-deoxytridachione to photodeoxytridachione has been photosensitized. The conversion was also quenched by piperylene. Photodeoxytridachione was produced in good yields under conditions in which only the cyclohexadiene group is sensitized. The results show that some, and perhaps all, of the photoreactions of 9,10-deoxytridachione occur through a triplet excited state. The mechanistic and biosynthetic implications of these results are discussed.

Conformer-specific photoconversion of 25-hydroxytachysterol to 25-hydroxyprevitamin D3: role in the production of vitamin Ds

The photochemical goal in the production of vitamin Ds (Vit Ds) is to maximize the conversion of the provitamins (Pros) to the previtamins (Pres) while minimizing stoichiometric losses to undesirable over-irradiation products. The last step in the syntheses, the [1,7]-sigmatropic rearrangement of the Pres to the Vits, is thermally induced. The competition between cis-trans photoisomerization and photocyclization of the Pres is known to be highly excitation-wavelength specific. It inspired Havinga's nonequilibration of excited rotamers (NEER) principle and more recent alternative explanations. In contrast, the photochemistry of tachysterol has been reported to be relatively unexceptional with Tachy --> Pre quantum yields in the 0.10-0.13 range, independent of lambdaexc. Examination of the spectrum of the 25-hydroxy derivative of tachysterol (HOTachy) reveals vibronic structure between 295 and 260 nm and a broad structureless shoulder between 330 and 295 nm. These features are consistent with absorption by at least two Tachy conformers. We show that these conformers differ dramatically in their trans-to-cis photoisomerization efficiency. The Tachy --> Pre quantum yield at 313 nm (0.42) in degassed methanol solution is substantially higher than at 254 nm (0.12). On the basis of recent theoretical predictions, it is likely that 313 nm selectively excites the cEc HOTachy conformer which gives photoisomerization much more efficiently than do the other expected conformers (cEt, most abundant, and tEt). Efficient conversion of HOPro D3 to HOPre D3 is accomplished by a two-stage 254/313-nm irradiation sequence. Use of 313 nm in the second step is preferable to previously proposed much longer wavelengths that were hardly absorbed by HOTachy.

Direct Spectroscopic Detection of a Zwitterionic Excited State

Two electrons in two weakly coupled orbitals give rise to two states (diradical) with electrons residing in separate orbitals and two states (zwitterionic) with both electrons paired in one orbital or the other. This two-electron, two-orbital state manifold has eluded experimental confirmation because the zwitterionic states have been difficult to locate. Two-photon excitation of fluorescence from Mo(2)CI(4)(PMe(3))(4) (D2d) has been measured with linearly and circularly polarized light. From the polarization ratio and the energy of the observed transition, the 2(1)A(1) (delta*delta*) excited state has been located and characterized. In conjunction with the one-photon allowed (1)B(2) (deltadelta*) excited state, the zwitterionic state manifold for the quadruply bonded metal-metal class of compounds is thus established.