Experimental evaluation of the resolution and quantitative accuracy of temperature-modulated fluorescence tomography

Fast ICCD-based temperature modulated fluorescence tomography

Fluorescence tomography (FT) has become a powerful preclinical imaging modality with a great potential for several clinical applications. Although it has superior sensitivity and utilizes low-cost instrumentation, the highly scattering nature of bio-tissue makes FT in thick samples challenging, resulting in poor resolution and low quantitative accuracy. To overcome the limitations of FT, we previously introduced a novel method, termed temperature modulated fluorescence tomography (TMFT), which is based on two key elements: (1) temperature-sensitive fluorescent agents (ThermoDots) and (2) high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU). The fluorescence emission of ThermoDots increases up to hundredfold with only several degree temperature elevation. The exceptional and reversible response of these ThermoDots enables their modulation, which effectively allows their localization using the HIFU. Their localization is then used as functional a priori during the FT image reconstruction process to resolve their distribution with higher spatial resolution. The last version of the TMFT system was based on a cooled CCD camera utilizing a step-and-shoot mode, which necessitated long total imaging time only for a small selected region of interest (ROI). In this paper, we present the latest version of our TMFT technology, which uses a much faster continuous HIFU scanning mode based on an intensified CCD (ICCD) camera. This new, to the best of our knowledge, version can capture the whole field-of-view (FOV) of 50×30m m 2 at once and reduces the total imaging time down to 30 min, while preserving the same high resolution (∼1.3m m) and superior quantitative accuracy (<7% error) as the previous versions. Therefore, this new method is an important step toward utilization of TMFT for preclinical imaging.

Development of a preclinical CCD-based temperature modulated fluorescence tomography platform

In preclinical research, fluorescence molecular tomography (FMT) is the most sensitive imaging modality to interrogate whole-body and provide 3D distribution of fluorescent contract agents. Despite its superior sensitivity, its mediocre spatial-resolution has been the main barrier to its clinical translation. This limitation is mainly due to the high scattering of optical photons in biological tissue together with the limited boundary measurements that lead to an undetermined and ill-posed inverse problem. To overcome the limitations of FMT, we previously introduced a novel method termed, Temperature Modulated Fluorescence Tomography (TMFT). TMFT utilizes thermos-sensitive fluorescent agents (ThermoDots) as a key component and localizes them with high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU). Scanning the focused HIFU beam having a diameter Ø = 1.3 mm across the tissue while monitoring the variation in the measured fluorescence signals reveals the position of the ThermoDots with high spatial accuracy. We have formerly built a prototype TMFT system that uses optical fibers for detection. In this paper, we present an upgraded version using a CCD camera-based detection that enables non-contact imaging. In this version, the animal under investigation is placed on an ultrasound transparent membrane, which eliminates the need for its immersion in optical matching fluids that were required by the fiber-based system. This CCD-based system will pave the way for convenient and wide-spread use of TMFT in preclinical research. Its performance validation on phantom studies demonstrates that high spatial-resolution (∼1.3 mm) and quantitative accuracy in recovered fluorophore concentration (<3% error) can be achieved.

Development of a theranostic preclinical fluorescence molecular tomography/cone beam CT-guided irradiator platform

Image-guided small animal radiation research platforms allow more precise radiation treatment. Commercially available small animal X-ray irradiators are often equipped with a CT/cone-beam CT (CBCT) component for target guidance. Besides having poor soft-tissue contrast, CBCT unfortunately cannot provide molecular information due to its low sensitivity. Hence, there are extensive efforts to incorporate a molecular imaging component besides CBCT on these radiation therapy platforms. As an extension of these efforts, here we present a theranostic fluorescence tomography/CBCT-guided irradiator platform that provides both anatomical and molecular guidance, which can overcome the limitations of stand-alone CBCT. The performance of our hybrid system is validated using both tissue-like phantoms and mice ex vivo. Both studies show that fluorescence tomography can provide much more accurate quantitative results when CBCT-derived structural information is used to constrain the inverse problem. The error in the recovered fluorescence absorbance reduces nearly 10-fold for all cases, from approximately 60% down to 6%. This is very significant since high quantitative accuracy in molecular information is crucial to the correct assessment of the changes in tumor microenvironment related to radiation therapy.

Multiwavelength photo-magnetic imaging algorithm improved for direct chromophore concentration recovery using spectral constraints

Multiwavelength photo-magnetic imaging (PMI) is a novel combination of diffuse optics and magnetic resonance imaging, to the best of our knowledge, that yields tissue chromophore concentration maps with high resolution and quantitative accuracy. Here, we present the first experimental results, to the best of our knowledge, obtained using a spectrally constrained PMI image reconstruction method, where chromophore concentration maps are directly recovered, unlike the conventional two-step approach that requires an intermediate step of reconstructing wavelength-dependent absorption coefficient maps. The imposition of the prior spectral information into the PMI inverse problem improves the reconstructed image quality and allows recovery of highly quantitative concentration maps, which are crucial for effective cancer detection and characterization. The obtained results demonstrate the higher performance of the direct reconstruction method. Indeed, the reconstructed concentration maps are not only of higher quality but also obtained approximately 2 times faster than the conventional method.

Bayesian reconstruction of fluorescent molecular tomography via iteration of measurements

Fluorescent molecular tomography (FMT) is an important molecular imaging technique for medical diagnosis and treatment. In FMT, a typical forward model is the diffusion approximation. However, this approximation is not valid in biological tissues with low-scattering regions. To overcome this problem, a Bayesian method in combination with the model error is proposed. Further, an iteration method of boundary measurements is incorporated into the reconstruction process to improve the efficiency of reconstruction for FMT. Simulation results obtained demonstrate that the proposed approach can effectively improve the quality of the reconstructed results and speed up the reconstruction process.

Improving sensitivity and imaging depth of ultrasound-switchable fluorescence via an EMCCD-gain-controlled system and a liposome-based contrast agent

Background

The ultrasound-switchable fluorescence (USF) technique was recently developed to achieve high-resolution fluorescence imaging in centimeters-deep tissue. This study introduced strategies to significantly improve imaging sensitivity and depth using an electron multiplying charge-coupled device (EMCCD) camera-based USF imaging system and a newly developed USF contrast agent of indocyanine green (ICG)-encapsulated liposomes. For a quantitative study, a phantom of a sub-millimeter silicone tube embedded in centimeter-thick chicken breast tissue was adopted in this study as a model.

Methods

The synthesized ICG-liposome was characterized and compared with the previously reported ICG-nanogel. The exposure of the EMCCD camera was controlled via the MATLAB (The MathWorks, Inc. USA), instead of an external hardware trigger. The stability of the electron multiplying (EM) gain of the EMCCD camera was compared between two trigger modes: the MATLAB trigger mode and the external hardware trigger mode. The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the USF imaging with different EM gain in various thick tissue was studied.

Results

The hydrodynamic size of the ICG-liposome was ~181 nm. The ICG-liposome had a sharper temperature switching curve and a better USF performance than the previously reported ICG-nanogel. The EM gain was more stable in MATLAB trigger mode than the external hardware trigger mode. Although, as usual, the SNR decreased quickly with the increase of the tissue thickness, the proposed strategies improved the SNR and the imaging depth significantly by adopting the novel contrast agent and controlling the EM gain.

Conclusions

We successfully imaged the sub-millimeter silicone tube with an inner diameter of 0.76 mm and an outer diameter of 1.65 mm in 5.5 cm-thick chicken breast tissue using 808 nm excitation light with a low intensity of 28.35 mW/cm², the improved EMCCD camera-based USF imaging system and the novel ICG-liposomes.

Newly-Engineered Materials for Bio-Imaging Technology: A Focus on the Hybrid System of Ultrasound and Fluorescence

As an emerging technique, ultrasound-modulated fluorescence (UMF), or ultrasound switchable fluorescence (USF) bioimaging has shown promising features to produce deep-tissue and high-resolution fluorescence imaging for biomedical research and health diagnosis. The success of UMF or USF heavily relies on the design of their contrast agents (CAs). We herein surveyed recent advances in the development of such unique CAs, including configuration, mechanism, stability, sensitivity, and selectivity. Meanwhile, UMF or USF instrumentation has emerged as developmental breakthrough technologies to existing bio-imaging techniques. The best performance of UMF or USF bio-imaging requires an interactive response between CAs and the instrument. In this review, the description of UMF or USF instrumentation are also included for clarification and better understanding. Finally, the UMF and USF's performance in bioimaging is evaluated based on signal-to-noise ratio, resolution, imaging depth and speed, using photoacoustic imaging (PAI) as a standard, a well-developed technique of hybrid bio-imaging. Unlike PAI, UMF or USF is still in its early stage. Although results demonstrated a proof-of-concept landmark being reached, significant efforts are needed to improve the performance of UMF or USF.

A thermo-sensitive fluorescent agent based method for excitation light leakage rejection for fluorescence molecular tomography

Fluorescence molecular tomography (FMT) is widely used in preclinical oncology research. FMT is the only imaging technique able to provide 3D distribution of fluorescent probes within thick highly scattering media. However, its integration into clinical medicine has been hampered by its low spatial resolution caused by the undetermined and ill-posed nature of its reconstruction algorithm. Another major factor degrading the quality of FMT images is the large backscattered excitation light component leaking through the rejection filters and coinciding with the weak fluorescent signal arising from a low tissue fluorescence concentration. In this paper, we present a new method based on the use of a novel thermo-sensitive fluorescence probe. In fact, the excitation light leakage is accurately estimated from a set of measurements performed at different temperatures and then is corrected for in the tomographic data. The obtained results show a considerable improvement in both spatial resolution and quantitative accuracy of FMT images due to the proper correction of fluorescent signals.

Feasibility study of high spatial resolution multimodality fluorescence tomography in ex vivo biological tissue

Previously, we demonstrated that temperature-modulated fluorescence tomography (TM-FT) could provide fluorescence images with high quantitative accuracy and the spatial resolution of focused ultrasound. TM-FT is based on scanning the focused ultrasound across the medium to activate temperature-reversible fluorescent nanoprobes (ThermoDots). This technique can resolve small fluorescent targets located several centimeters deep in turbid media with millimeter resolution. Our past studies with this multimodality technique used agar phantoms, which could not represent the true heterogeneous nature of the acoustic and optical properties of biological tissue. In this work, we report the results of the first TM-FT study performed on ex vivo chicken breast tissue. In order to improve the spatial resolution of this technique, diffuse optical tomography is also used to better estimate the optical property maps of the tissue, which is utilized as functional a priori for the TM-FT reconstruction algorithm. These ex vivo results show that TM-FT can accurately recover the concentration and position of a 1.5  mm×5  mm inclusion filled with ThermoDots. Since the inclusion is embedded 2 cm deep in the chicken breast sample, these results demonstrate the great potential of TM-FT for future in vivo small animal imaging.