Optimization of fluorescent imaging in the operating room through pulsed acquisition and gating to ambient background cycling

AAPM Task Group Report 311: Guidance for performance evaluation of fluorescence-guided surgery systems

The last decade has seen a large growth in fluorescence-guided surgery (FGS) imaging and interventions. With the increasing number of clinical specialties implementing FGS, the range of systems with radically different physical designs, image processing approaches, and performance requirements is expanding. This variety of systems makes it nearly impossible to specify uniform performance goals, yet at the same time, utilization of different devices in new clinical procedures and trials indicates some need for common knowledge bases and a quality assessment paradigm to ensure that effective translation and use occurs. It is feasible to identify key fundamental image quality characteristics and corresponding objective test methods that should be determined such that there are consistent conventions across a variety of FGS devices. This report outlines test methods, tissue simulating phantoms and suggested guidelines, as well as personnel needs and professional knowledge bases that can be established. This report frames the issues with guidance and feedback from related societies and agencies having vested interest in the outcome, coming from an independent scientific group formed from academics and international federal agencies for the establishment of these professional guidelines.

Ambient Light Resistant Shortwave Infrared Fluorescence Imaging for Preclinical Tumor Delineation via the pH Low-Insertion Peptide Conjugated to Indocyanine Green

Shortwave infrared (900-1,700 nm) fluorescence imaging (SWIRFI) has shown significant advantages over visible (400-650 nm) and near-infrared (700-900 nm) fluorescence imaging (reduced autofluorescence, improved contrast, tissue resolution, and depth sensitivity). However, there is a major lag in the clinical translation of preclinical SWIRFI systems and targeted SWIRFI probes. Methods: We preclinically show that the pH low-insertion peptide conjugated to indocyanine green (pHLIP ICG), currently in clinical trials, is an excellent candidate for cancer-targeted SWIRFI. Results: pHLIP ICG SWIRFI achieved picomolar sensitivity (0.4 nM) with binary and unambiguous tumor screening and resection up to 96 h after injection in an orthotopic breast cancer mouse model. SWIRFI tumor screening and resection had ambient light resistance (possible without gating or filtering) with outstanding signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) values at exposures from 10 to 0.1 ms. These SNR and CNR values were also found for the extended emission of pHLIP ICG in vivo (>1,100 nm, 300 ms). Conclusion: SWIRFI sensitivity and ambient light resistance enabled continued tracer clearance tracking with unparalleled SNR and CNR values at video rates for tumor delineation (achieving a tumor-to-muscle ratio above 20). In total, we provide a direct precedent for the democratic translation of an ambient light resistant SWIRFI and pHLIP ICG ecosystem, which can instantly improve tumor resection.

Assessment of open-field fluorescence guided surgery systems: implementing a standardized method for characterization and comparison

Significance

Fluorescence guided surgery (FGS) has demonstrated improvements in decision making and patient outcomes for a wide range of surgical procedures. Not only can FGS systems provide a higher level of structural perfusion accuracy in tissue reconstruction cases but they can also serve for real-time functional characterization. Multiple FGS devices have been Food and Drug administration (FDA) cleared for use in open and laparoscopic surgery. Despite the rapid growth of the field, there has been a lack standardization methods.

Aim

This work overviews commonalities inherent to optical imaging methods that can be exploited to produce such a standardization procedure. Furthermore, a system evaluation pipeline is proposed and executed through the use of photo-stable indocyanine green fluorescence phantoms. Five different FDA-approved open-field FGS systems are used and evaluated with the proposed method.

Approach

The proposed pipeline encompasses the following characterization: (1) imaging spatial resolution and sharpness, (2) sensitivity and linearity, (3) imaging depth into tissue, (4) imaging system DOF, (5) uniformity of illumination, (6) spatial distortion, (7) signal to background ratio, (8) excitation bands, and (9) illumination wavelength and power.

Results

The results highlight how such a standardization approach can be successfully implemented for inter-system comparisons as well as how to better understand essential features within each FGS setup.

Conclusions

Despite clinical use being the end goal, a robust yet simple standardization pipeline before clinical trials, such as the one presented herein, should benefit regulatory agencies, manufacturers, and end-users to better assess basic performance and improvements to be made in next generation FGS systems.

Out-of-Phase Imaging after Optical Modulation (OPIOM) for Multiplexed Fluorescence Imaging Under Adverse Optical Conditions

Fluorescence imaging has become a powerful tool for observations in biology. Yet it has also encountered limitations to overcome optical interferences of ambient light, autofluorescence, and spectrally interfering fluorophores. In this account, we first examine the current approaches which address these limitations. Then we more specifically report on Out-of-Phase Imaging after Optical Modulation (OPIOM), which has proved attractive for highly selective multiplexed fluorescence imaging even under adverse optical conditions. After exposing the OPIOM principle, we detail the protocols for successful OPIOM implementation.

Short-Wave Infrared Emitting Nanocomposites for Fluorescence-Guided Surgery

Fluorescence-guided surgery (FGS) is an emerging technique for tissue visualization during surgical procedures. Structures of interest are labeled with exogenous probes whose fluorescent emissions are acquired and viewed in real-time with optical imaging systems. This study investigated rare-earth-doped albumin-encapsulated nanocomposites (REANCs) as short-wave infrared emitting contrast agents for FGS. Experiments were conducted using an animal model of 4T1 breast cancer. The signal-to-background ratio (SBR) obtained with REANCs was compared to values obtained using indocyanine green (ICG), a near-infrared dye used in clinical practice. Prior to resection, the SBR for tumors following intratumoral administration of REANCs was significantly higher than for tumors injected with ICG. Following FGS, evaluation of fluorescence intensity levels in excised tumors and at the surgical bed demonstrated higher contrast between tissues at these sites with REANC contrast than ICG. REANCs also demonstrated excellent photostability over 2 hours of continuous illumination, as well as the ability to perform FGS under ambient lighting, establishing these nanocomposites as a promising contrast agent for FGS applications.

An overview of the current clinical status of optical imaging in head and neck cancer with a focus on Narrow Band imaging and fluorescence optical imaging

Early and accurate identification of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) is important to improve treatment outcomes and prognosis. New optical imaging techniques may assist in both the diagnostic process as well as in the operative setting by real-time visualization and delineation of tumor. Narrow Band Imaging (NBI) is an endoscopic technique that uses blue and green light to enhance mucosal and submucosal blood vessels, leading to better detection of (pre)malignant lesions showing aberrant blood vessel patterns. Fluorescence optical imaging makes use of near-infrared fluorescent agents to visualize and delineate HNSCC, resulting in fewer positive surgical margins. Targeted fluorescent agents, such as fluorophores conjugated to antibodies, show the most promising results. The aim of this review is: (1) to provide the clinical head and neck surgeon an overview of the current clinical status of various optical imaging techniques in head and neck cancer; (2) to provide an in-depth review of NBI and fluorescence optical imaging, as these techniques have the highest potential for clinical implementation; and (3) to describe future improvements and developments within the field of these two techniques.

Fluorescence Guided Surgery

Fluorescence guided surgery (FGS) is an imaging technique that allows the surgeon to visualise different structures and types of tissue during a surgical procedure that may not be as visible under white light conditions. Due to the many potential advantages of fluorescence guided surgery compared to more traditional clinical imaging techniques such as its higher contrast and sensitivity, less subjective use, and ease of instrument operation, the research interest in fluorescence guided surgery continues to grow over various key aspects such as fluorescent probe development and surgical system development as well as its potential clinical applications. This review looks to summarise some of the emerging opportunities and developments that have already been made in fluorescence guided surgery in recent years while highlighting its advantages as well as limitations that need to be overcome in order to utilise the full potential of fluorescence within the surgical environment.

Dynamic Contrast for Plant Phenotyping

Noninvasiveness, minimal handling, and immediate response are favorable features of fluorescence readout for high-throughput phenotyping of labeled plants.Yet, remote fluorescence imaging may suffer from an autofluorescent background and artificial or natural ambient light. In this work, the latter limitations are overcome by adopting reversibly photoswitchable fluorescent proteins (RSFPs) as labels and Speed OPIOM (out-of-phase imaging after optical modulation), a fluorescence imaging protocol exploiting dynamic contrast. Speed OPIOM can efficiently distinguish the RSFP signal from autofluorescence and other spectrally interfering fluorescent reporters like GFP. It can quantitatively assess gene expressions, even when they are weak. It is as quantitative, sensitive, and robust in dark and bright light conditions. Eventually, it can be used to nondestructively record abiotic stress responses like water or iron limitations in real time at the level of individual plants and even of specific organs. Such Speed OPIOM validation could find numerous applications to identify plant lines in selection programs, design plants as environmental sensors, or ecologically monitor transgenic plants in the environment.

Real-time fiber-based fluorescence lifetime imaging with synchronous external illumination: A new path for clinical translation

Time-correlated single photon counting is the "gold-standard" method for fluorescence lifetime measurements and has demonstrated potential for clinical deployment. However, the translation of the technology into clinic is hindered by the use of ultrasensitive detectors, which make the fluorescence acquisition impractical with bright lighting conditions such as in clinical settings. We address this limitation by interleaving periodic fluorescence detection with synchronous out-of-phase externally modulated light source, thus guaranteeing specimen illumination and a fluorescence signal free from bright background light upon temporal separation. Fluorescence lifetime maps are generated in real-time from single-point measurements by tracking a reference beam and using the phasor approach. We demonstrate the feasibility and practicality of this technique in a number of biological specimens, including real-time mapping of degraded articular cartilage. This method is compatible and can be integrated with existing clinical microscopic, endoscopic and robotic modalities, thus offering a new pathway towards label-free diagnostics and surgical guidance in a number of clinical applications.

Multi-Wavelength Fluorescence in Image-Guided Surgery, Clinical Feasibility and Future Perspectives

With the rise of fluorescence-guided surgery, it has become evident that different types of fluorescence signals can provide value in the surgical setting. Hereby a different range of targets have been pursued in a great variety of surgical indications. One of the future challenges lies in combining complementary fluorescent readouts during one and the same surgical procedure, so-called multi-wavelength fluorescence guidance. In this review we summarize the current clinical state-of-the-art in multi-wavelength fluorescence guidance, basic technical concepts, possible future extensions of existing clinical indications and impact that the technology can bring to clinical care.

The Clinical Application of Fluorescence-Guided Surgery in Head and Neck Cancer

Although surgical resection has been the primary treatment modality of solid tumors for decades, surgeons still rely on visual cues and palpation to delineate healthy from cancerous tissue. This may contribute to the high rate (up to 30%) of positive margins in head and neck cancer resections. Margin status in these patients is the most important prognostic factor for overall survival. In addition, second primary lesions may be present at the time of surgery. Although often unnoticed by the medical team, these lesions can have significant survival ramifications. We hypothesize that real-time fluorescence imaging can enhance intraoperative decision making by aiding the surgeon in detecting close or positive margins and visualizing unanticipated regions of primary disease. The purpose of this study was to assess the clinical utility of real-time fluorescence imaging for intraoperative decision making. Methods: Head and neck cancer patients (n = 14) scheduled for curative resection were enrolled in a clinical trial evaluating panitumumab-IRDye800CW for surgical guidance (NCT02415881). Open-field fluorescence imaging was performed throughout the surgical procedure. The fluorescence signal was quantified as signal-to-background ratios to characterize the fluorescence contrast of regions of interest relative to background. Results: Fluorescence imaging was able to improve surgical decision making in 3 cases (21.4%): identification of a close margin (n = 1) and unanticipated regions of primary disease (n = 2). Conclusion: This study demonstrates the clinical applications of fluorescence imaging on intraoperative decision making. This information is required for designing phase III clinical trials using this technique. Furthermore, this study is the first to demonstrate this application for intraoperative decision making during resection of primary tumors.

Intraoperative Assessment of Parathyroid Viability using Laser Speckle Contrast Imaging

Post-surgical hypoparathyroidism and hypocalcemia are known to occur after nearly 50% of all thyroid surgeries as a result of accidental disruption of blood supply to healthy parathyroid glands, which are responsible for regulating calcium. However, there are currently no clinical methods for accurately identifying compromised glands and the surgeon relies on visual assessment alone to determine if any gland(s) should be excised and auto-transplanted. Here, we present Laser Speckle Contrast Imaging (LSCI) for real-time assessment of parathyroid viability. Taking an experienced surgeon's visual assessment as the gold standard, LSCI can be used to distinguish between well vascularized (n = 32) and compromised (n = 27) parathyroid glands during thyroid surgery with an accuracy of 91.5%. Ability to detect vascular compromise with LSCI was validated in parathyroidectomies. Results showed that this technique is able to detect parathyroid gland devascularization before it is visually apparent to the surgeon. Measurements can be performed in real-time and without the need to turn off operating room lights. LSCI shows promise as a real-time, contrast-free, objective method for helping reduce hypoparathyroidism after thyroid surgery.