Effects of Adaptation on the Lateral Geniculate Response to Light Increment and Decrement*

Contrast constancy in natural scenes in shadow or direct light: A proposed role for contrast-normalisation (non-specific suppression) in visual cortex

The range of contrasts in natural scenes is generally thought to far exceed the limited dynamic ranges of individual contrast-encoding neurons in the primary visual cortex. The visual system may employ gain-control mechanisms (Ohzawa et al. 1985) to compensate for the mismatch between the range of natural contrast energies and the limited dynamic range of visual neurons; one proposed mechanism is contrast normalisation or non-specific suppression (Heeger 1992a). This paper aims to evaluate the role of contrast normalisation in human contrast perception, using a computer model of primary visual cortex. The model uses orthogonal pairs of Gabor patches to simulate simple-cell receptive-fields to calculate local, band-limited contrast in a series of 50 digitised photographs of natural scenes. The average range of contrast energies in each image was 2.29 log units, while the "lifetime range" each model simple cell would see across all images was 2.98 log units. These ranges are greater than the dynamic range of real mammalian simple cells. Contrast normalisation (dividing contrast responses by the summed responses of all nearby neurons) reduces contrast ranges, perhaps sufficiently to match them to neurons' limited dynamic ranges. Comparison of images taken under diffuse and direct lighting conditions showed that contrast normalisation can sometimes match these conditions effectively. This may lead to perceptual contrast constancy in the face of spurious changes in contrast caused by natural environmental conditions.

Calculating the contrasts that retinal ganglion cells and LGN neurones encounter in natural scenes

Visual responses are known to depend on stimulus contrast and not simply on the absolute levels of retinal illumination. Here, we have determined the contrasts that mammalian retinal ganglion cells and lateral geniculate neurones (LGN) are likely to encounter in real world scenes. Local contrasts were calculated in 135 calibrated images of a variety of real world scenes using contrast operators that closely mirror the characteristic receptive-field organisation of mammalian retinal ganglion cells and LGN neurones. We have found that the frequency distribution of the calculated local contrasts has a pronounced peak at zero contrast and that it tails off roughly exponentially with increasing positive and negative contrasts; about 90% of the contrasts in the images were within the equivalent range of +/-0.5 Michelson and Weber contrasts. Further analysis suggests that the characteristic forms of the contrast-response functions of mammalian retinal and LGN neurones are matched to the range of contrasts that they experience when viewing real world images.

Light-induced discomfort and pain in migraine

Quantitative thresholds for discomfort and pain with monocular and binocular light stimuli were measured in 67 controls and 67 migraine patients (37 migraine with aura and 30 migraine without aura). Patients were more photophobic during attack than outside attack (p < 0.03), and they were more sensitive to light than controls even between attacks (p < or = 0.0001). We found no differences in light sensitivity between migraine with aura and migraine without aura (p > or = 0.93). Unilateral pain affected light sensitivity on both sides. When asked with a questionnaire, 74% of patients answered that they were sensitive to light outside attack and 100% were sensitive during attack. Pain thresholds were generally lower among sensitive than non-sensitive patients (p = 0.004), indicating some agreement between subjective opinion and objective measurements of photophobia. Photophobia seems to be an intrinsic property of migraineurs. It is increased by migraine pain, but seems to be unrelated to migraine characteristics such as nausea, severity of attacks, pain character and pain laterality.

Adaptation mechanisms in spatial vision--II. Flash thresholds and background adaptation

To examine how the mechanisms of light adaptation affect spatial pattern vision, contrast detection thresholds were measured for sinusoidal (increment-Gabor) probes on flashed backgrounds in the presence of steady adapting backgrounds. The thresholds for all spatial frequencies (1-12 c/deg), flashed-background intensities (dark to 4 log td) and adapting-background intensities (dark to 4 log td) were adequately described by a simple model consisting of a compressive nonlinearity (a modified Naka-Rushton function), a subtractive adaptation factor, and a multiplicative adaptation factor. For all five subjects the compressive nonlinearity was found to vary systematically with spatial frequency; for all but one subject, the subtractive and multiplicative factors were found to be relatively constant.

Properties of the visual channels that underlie adaptation to gradual change of luminance

Following adaptation to a spatially uniform patch of light that is gradually brightening (or dimming), a steady test patch appears to be gradually dimming (or brightening). We measured this ramp aftereffect with a nulling method, as a function of the amplitude and temporal repetition rate of the adapting sawtooth waveform and at various retinal eccentricities and levels of dark adaptation. We conclude that the underlying visual channels respond best to large-amplitude sweeps in luminance of at least 20 dB (1 log unit); but they are fairly insensitive to the temporal rate of this sweep. The channels are present out to an eccentricity of at least 40 degrees but they almost disappear during dark adaptation. The ramp aftereffects were asymmetrical: the subjectively darkening aftereffect produced by a brightening adapting ramp was slightly stronger than vice versa.

Transcranial Doppler ultrasonographic assessment of intermittent light stimulation at different frequencies

Seven normal adult volunteers underwent intermittent photic stimulation at frequencies of 5-60 Hz while their posterior cerebral arteries were monitored using transcranial Doppler ultrasound. Baseline measurements were obtained under conditions of total darkness, and sampling was also done during continuous illumination. Overall variation in mean flow velocity between complete darkness and continuous illumination was 9.8%, but the maximal change (expressed as percentage deviation from baseline) occurred consistently when stimulation was undertaken at frequencies of 10 (21%) and 20 (19%) Hz (p = 0.05). Frequencies higher than 20 Hz resulted in mean flow velocity variations that were not significantly different from that found during continuous illumination. The optimal frequency of intermittent visual stimulation required to induce measurable changes in posterior cerebral artery Doppler characteristics appears to be in the range 10-20 Hz.

Intensity coding and luxotonic activity in the ground squirrel lateral geniculate nucleus

The responses of contrast-sensitive cells in the ground squirrel LGN were studied. In most cells the response to an on-off stimulus was comprised of two components: a sustained on and a transient on-off. The sustained component amplitude was a power function of the light intensity and disappeared altogether at low temperature while the transient component was insensitive to the light intensity and to a drop in temperature. These cells were also luxotonic; they increased their average firing rate when the intensity of a steady stimulus was increased. The possible relation of the luxotonic activity to the diurnal nature of the ground squirrel is discussed.

Symmetry and constancy in the perception of negative and positive luminance contrast

The perception of suprathreshold luminance contrast was investigated by forced-choice psychophysical procedures that were designed to define contrast equivalence relations. Observers compared the perceived contrast of rectangular bars that were presented for 500 msec at 3.9 deg on opposite sides of the fovea. The results show a nearly symmetrical relation between the perception of negative and positive contrast that is largely invariant over four decades of background luminance. Thus, for any fixed background luminance, equal absolute contrasts evoke approximately equal perceived contrasts. Symmetry also held with variations in the width, the eccentricity, and the focus of the bars. Symmetry was investigated further by determining equivalent contrast relations for negative contrasts as a function of background luminance and by contrast scaling. These results show evidence for nearly perfect contrast constancy for targets of low to moderate contrast and departures form constancy for high-contrast targets. These new findings on negative contrast, symmetry, and contrast constancy are discussed in relation to underlying mechanisms for contrast perception and classic experiments on brightness and lightness constancy.

Temporal integration following intensification of long-lasting visual displays

Duration of visible persistence is known to be inversely related to the duration of the inducing stimulus, within a critical interval estimated at between 100 and 150 msec. Stimuli longer than the critical interval yield little or no persistence. Six experiments investigated whether a brief period of intensification at the end of a stimulus longer than the critical interval could restore visible persistence. In the first experiment, a punctate stimulus ceased to give rise to visible persistence at exposure durations longer than the critical interval. The second experiment showed that persistence could be restored to a long display by briefly intensifying the component dots just before the end of the display. The remaining four experiments explored the limits and the distinguishing characteristics of this effect. Two alternative explanations of the results are described and evaluated.

The luminance and response range of monkey retinal ganglion cells to white light

The responses of single retinal ganglion cells of the monkey to spot stimuli were recorded with extracellular microelectrodes. The stimulus was centered on the receptive field, adjusted in diameter to optimally excite the cell and incremented and decremented from the background level. The response range was defined as the difference between the maximum and minimum response amplitude evoked with a wide range of luminances. The difference in luminance between the luminances which evoked the maximum and minimum responses was defined as the luminance range for dynamic response. The response amplitude range and luminance range to white light were negatively correlated to one another for the population of cells studied in central vision. The phasic cells had smaller luminance ranges for dynamic responses and a greater response magnitude for small changes in luminance from background than the tonic cells.

Intensity coding in primate visual system

The pupil reflex and the discharge of LGN cells of the awake macaque were measured under stimulus conditions that yielded evidence for wide-range intensity coding in human psychophysical experiments. Ganzfeld flashes of white light were delivered under dark-adapted conditions to the surgically immobilized eye of the monkey while the other eye was observed in the infrared. Three-sec flashes elicited a consensual pupil reflex that was graded from -8 to 0 log Lamberts (L), indicating that the optic nerve fibers are capable of coding at least an 8 log-unit range of light intensity. In the physiological experiments, shorter flashes (0.1-0.5 sec) but otherwise identical conditions elicited monotonically graded responses from one type of LGN cell over the photopic range of -5 to 0 log L. Responses from other types of LGN cells were also graded over wide ranges but had different thresholds and, in some cases, nonmonotonic intensity-response functions. Latency of the excitatory LGN responses decreased with increasing intensity according to a power function with slope of-0.08. The pupil reflex and the LGN cell excitatory responses approximate power functions of light intensity with exponents of 0.22 and 0.14-0.29 respectively. The range of intensity coding found for single LGN cells is the widest yet reported for diffuse stimuli.

Effects of subcortical lesions on visual intensity discriminations in rats

The role of several subcortical structures in visual intensity discrimination was examined by comparing the effects of localized lesions on a variety of intensity discriminations. In Experiment 1 light avoidance was unimpaired after lesions of the ventral lateral geniculate nucleus (LGNv), nucleus lateralis posterior (TLP), nucleus posterior of Gurdijian (NPG), dorsal pretectum (PTd), and ventral pretectum (PTv). The LGNv, TLP, NPG and PTv, but not the PTd, groups were impaired on a simultaneous black versus white (BW) discrimination in Experiment 2. None of these groups was impaired on a horizontal versus vertical discrimination (HV). The TLP group showed a transient impairment on a successive light versus dark discrimination, not present with the LGNv and NPG groups (Experiment 3). In Experiment 4 all three groups were impaired on a successive BW discrimination. In Experiment 5 rats with LGNv lesions but not with TLP lesions had elevated relative brightness thresholds. Both groups had normal absolute thresholds. The results are related to the possibility that information about intensity and pattern is coded in separate visual pathways.