High-throughput characterization of photocrosslinker-bearing ion channel variants to map residues critical for function and pharmacology

Using automated patch clamp electrophysiology platforms in ion channel drug discovery: an industry perspective

INTRODUCTION

Automated patch clamp (APC) is now well established as a mature technology for ion channel drug discovery in academia, biotech and pharma companies, and in contract research organizations (CRO), for a variety of applications including channelopathy research, compound screening, target validation and cardiac safety testing.

AREAS COVERED

Ion channels are an important class of drugged and approved drug targets. The authors present a review of the current state of ion channel drug discovery along with new and exciting developments in ion channel research involving APC. This includes topics such as native and iPSC-derived cells in ion channel drug discovery, channelopathy research, organellar and biologics in ion channel drug discovery.

EXPERT OPINION

It is our belief that APC will continue to play a critical role in ion channel drug discovery, not only in 'classical' hit screening, target validation and cardiac safety testing, but extending these applications to include high throughput organellar recordings and optogenetics. In this way, with advancements in APC capabilities and applications, together with high resolution cryo-EM structures, ion channel drug discovery will be re-invigorated, leading to a growing list of ion channel ligands in clinical development.

Structural basis for excitatory neuropeptide signaling

Rapid signaling between neurons is mediated by ligand-gated ion channels, cell-surface proteins with an extracellular ligand-binding domain and a membrane-spanning ion channel domain. The degenerin/epithelial sodium channel (DEG/ENaC) superfamily is diverse in terms of its gating stimuli, with some DEG/ENaCs gated by neuropeptides, and others gated by pH, mechanical force or enzymatic activity. The mechanism by which ligands bind to and activate DEG/ENaCs is poorly understood. Here we dissected the structural basis for neuropeptide-gated activity of a neuropeptide-gated DEG/ENaC, FMRFamide-gated sodium channel 1 (FaNaC1) from the annelid worm Malacoceros fuliginosus, using cryo-electron microscopy. Structures of FaNaC1 in the ligand-free resting state and in several ligand-bound states reveal the ligand-binding site and capture the ligand-induced conformational changes of channel gating, which we verified with complementary mutagenesis experiments. Our results illuminate channel gating in DEG/ENaCs and offer a structural template for experimental dissection of channel pharmacology and ion conduction.

Dynamic conformational changes of acid-sensing ion channels in different desensitizing conditions

Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are proton-gated cation channels that contribute to fast synaptic transmission and have roles in fear conditioning and nociception. Apart from activation at low pH, ASIC1a also undergoes several types of desensitization, including acute desensitization, which terminates activation; steady-state desensitization, which occurs at sub-activating proton concentrations and limits subsequent activation; and tachyphylaxis, which results in a progressive decrease in response during a series of activations. Structural insights from a desensitized state of ASIC1 have provided great spatial detail, but dynamic insights into conformational changes in different desensitizing conditions are largely missing. Here, we use electrophysiology and voltage-clamp fluorometry to follow the functional changes of the pore along with conformational changes at several positions in the extracellular and upper transmembrane domain via cysteine-labeled fluorophores. Acute desensitization terminates activation in wild type, but introducing an N414K mutation in the β11-12 linker of mouse ASIC1a interfered with this process. The mutation also affected steady-state desensitization and led to pronounced tachyphylaxis. Although the extracellular domain of this mutant remained sensitive to pH and underwent pH-dependent conformational changes, these conformational changes did not necessarily lead to desensitization. N414K-containing channels also remained sensitive to a known peptide modulator that increases steady-state desensitization, indicating that the mutation only reduced, but not precluded, desensitization. Together, this study contributes to our understanding of the fundamental properties of ASIC1a desensitization, emphasizing the complex interplay between the conformational changes of the extracellular domain and the pore during channel activation and desensitization.

Photomodulation of the ASIC1a acidic pocket destabilizes the open state

Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are important players in detecting extracellular acidification throughout the brain and body. ASICs have large extracellular domains containing two regions replete with acidic residues: the acidic pocket, and the palm domain. In the resting state, the acidic pocket is in an expanded conformation but collapses in low pH conditions as the acidic side chains are neutralized. Thus, extracellular acidification has been hypothesized to collapse the acidic pocket that, in turn, ultimately drives channel activation. However, several observations run counter to this idea. To explore how collapse or mobility of the acidic pocket is linked to channel gating, we employed two distinct tools. First, we incorporated the photocrosslinkable noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) 4-azido-L-phenylalanine (AzF) or 4-benzoyl-L-phenylalanine (BzF) into several positions in the acidic pocket. At both E315 and Y318, AzF incorporation followed by UV irradiation led to right shifts in pH response curves and accelerations of desensitization and deactivation, consistent with restrictions of acidic pocket mobility destabilizing the open state. Second, we reasoned that because Cl- ions are found in the open and desensitized structures but absent in the resting state structures, Cl- substitution would provide insight into how stability of the pocket is linked to gating. Anion substitution resulted in faster deactivation and desensitization, consistent with the acidic pocket regulating the stability of the open state. Taken together, our data support a model where acidic pocket collapse is not essential for channel activation. Rather, collapse of the acidic pocket influences the stability of the open state of the pore.

Conformational decoupling in acid-sensing ion channels uncovers mechanism and stoichiometry of PcTx1-mediated inhibition

Acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are trimeric proton-gated cation channels involved in fast synaptic transmission. Pharmacological inhibition of ASIC1a reduces neurotoxicity and stroke infarct volumes, with the cysteine knot toxin psalmotoxin-1 (PcTx1) being one of the most potent and selective inhibitors. PcTx1 binds at the subunit interface in the extracellular domain (ECD), but the mechanism and conformational consequences of the interaction, as well as the number of toxin molecules required for inhibition, remain unknown. Here, we use voltage-clamp fluorometry and subunit concatenation to decipher the mechanism and stoichiometry of PcTx1 inhibition of ASIC1a. Besides the known inhibitory binding mode, we propose PcTx1 to have at least two additional binding modes that are decoupled from the pore. One of these modes induces a long-lived ECD conformation that reduces the activity of an endogenous neuropeptide. This long-lived conformational state is proton-dependent and can be destabilized by a mutation that decreases PcTx1 sensitivity. Lastly, the use of concatemeric channel constructs reveals that disruption of a single PcTx1 binding site is sufficient to destabilize the toxin-induced conformation, while functional inhibition is not impaired until two or more binding sites are mutated. Together, our work provides insight into the mechanism of PcTx1 inhibition of ASICs and uncovers a prolonged conformational change with possible pharmacological implications.

Metabolic and electrolyte abnormalities as risk factors in drug-induced long QT syndrome

Drug-induced long QT syndrome (diLQTS) is the phenomenon by which the administration of drugs causes prolongation of cardiac repolarisation and leads to an increased risk of the ventricular tachycardia known as torsades de pointes (TdP). In most cases of diLQTS, the primary molecular target is the human ether-à-go-go-related gene protein (hERG) potassium channel, which carries the rapid delayed rectifier current (I_Kr) in the heart. However, the proarrhythmic risk associated with drugs that block hERG can be modified in patients by a range of environmental- and disease-related factors, such as febrile temperatures, alterations in pH, dyselectrolytaemias such as hypokalaemia and hypomagnesemia and coadministration with other drugs. In this review, we will discuss the clinical occurrence of drug-induced LQTS in the context of these modifying factors as well as the mechanisms by which they contribute to altered hERG potency and proarrhythmic risk.

Development of ASIC1a ligand-gated ion channel drug screening assays across multiple automated patch clamp platforms

Human acid-sensing ion channels (ASIC) are ligand-gated ionotropic receptors expressed widely in peripheral tissues as well as sensory and central neurons and implicated in detection of inflammation, tissue injury, and hypoxia-induced acidosis. This makes ASIC channels promising targets for drug discovery in oncology, pain and ischemia, and several modulators have progressed into clinical trials. We describe the use of hASIC1a as a case study for the development and validation of low, medium and high throughput automated patch clamp (APC) assays suitable for the screening and mechanistic profiling of new ligands for this important class of ligand-gated ion channel. Initial efforts to expand on previous manual patch work describing an endogenous hASIC1a response in HEK cells were thwarted by low current expression and unusual pharmacology, so subsequent work utilized stable hASIC1a CHO cell lines. Ligand-gated application protocols and screening assays on the Patchliner, QPatch 48, and SyncroPatch 384 were optimized and validated based on pH activation and nM-μM potency of reference antagonists (e.g., Amiloride, Benzamil, Memantine, Mambalgin-3, A-317567, PcTx1). By optimizing single and stacked pipette tip applications available on each APC platform, stable pH-evoked currents during multiple ligand applications enabled cumulative EC₅₀ and IC₅₀ determinations with minimized receptor desensitization. Finally, we successfully demonstrated for the first time on an APC platform the ability to use current clamp to implement the historical technique of input resistance tracking to measure ligand-gated changes in membrane conductance on the Patchliner platform.

Molecular Investigation of Chicken Acid-Sensing Ion Channel 1 β11-12 Linker Isomerization and Channel Kinetics

Structures of the trimeric acid-sensing ion channel have been solved in the resting, toxin-bound open and desensitized states. Within the extracellular domain, there is little difference between the toxin-bound open state and the desensitized state. The main exception is that a loop connecting the 11th and 12th β-strand, just two amino acid residues long, undergoes a significant and functionally critical re-orientation or flipping between the open and desensitized conformations. Here we investigate how specific interactions within the surrounding area influence linker stability in the "flipped" desensitized state using all-atom molecular dynamics simulations. An inherent challenge is bringing the relatively slow channel desensitization and recovery processes (in the milliseconds to seconds) within the time window of all-atom simulations (hundreds of nanoseconds). To accelerate channel behavior, we first identified the channel mutations at either the Leu414 or Asn415 position with the fastest recovery kinetics followed by molecular dynamics simulations of these mutants in a deprotonated state, accelerating recovery. By mutating one residue in the loop and examining the evolution of interactions in the neighbor, we identified a novel electrostatic interaction and validated prior important interactions. Subsequent functional analysis corroborates these findings, shedding light on the molecular factors controlling proton-mediated transitions between functional states of the channel. Together, these data suggest that the flipped loop in the desensitized state is stabilized by interactions from surrounding regions keeping both L414 and N415 in place. Interestingly, very few mutations in the loop allow for equivalent channel kinetics and desensitized state stability. The high degree of sequence conservation in this region therefore indicates that the stability of the ASIC desensitized state is under strong selective pressure and underlines the physiological importance of desensitization.

The M1 and pre-M1 segments contribute differently to ion selectivity in ASICs and ENaCs

The ability to discriminate between different ionic species, termed ion selectivity, is a key feature of ion channels and forms the basis for their physiological function. Members of the degenerin/epithelial sodium channel (DEG/ENaC) superfamily of trimeric ion channels are typically sodium selective, but to a surprisingly variable degree. While acid-sensing ion channels (ASICs) are weakly sodium selective (sodium:potassium ratio ∼10:1), ENaCs show a remarkably high preference for sodium over potassium (>500:1). This discrepancy may be expected to originate from differences in the pore-lining second transmembrane segment (M2). However, these show a relatively high degree of sequence conservation between ASICs and ENaCs, and previous functional and structural studies could not unequivocally establish that differences in M2 alone can account for the disparate degrees of ion selectivity. By contrast, surprisingly little is known about the contributions of the first transmembrane segment (M1) and the preceding pre-M1 region. In this study, we used conventional and noncanonical amino acid-based mutagenesis in combination with a variety of electrophysiological approaches to show that the pre-M1 and M1 regions of mASIC1a channels are major determinants of ion selectivity. Mutational investigations of the corresponding regions in hENaC show that these regions contribute less to ion selectivity, despite affecting ion conductance. In conclusion, our work suggests that the remarkably different degrees of sodium selectivity in ASICs and ENaCs are achieved through different mechanisms. These results further highlight how M1 and pre-M1 are likely to differentially affect pore structure in these related channels.

The suitability of high throughput automated patch clamp for physiological applications

Although automated patch clamp (APC) devices have been around for many years and have become an integral part of many aspects of drug discovery, high throughput instruments with gigaohm seal data quality are relatively new. Experiments where a large number of compounds are screened against ion channels are ideally suited to high throughput APC, particularly when the amount of compound available is low. Here we evaluate different APC approaches using a variety of ion channels and screening settings. We have performed a screen of 1920 compounds on GluN1/GluN2A NMDA receptors for negative allosteric modulation using both the SyncroPatch 384 and FLIPR. Additionally, we tested the effect of 36 arthropod venoms on Na_V 1.9 using a single 384-well plate on the SyncroPatch 384. As an example for mutant screening, a range of acid-sensing ion channel variants were tested and the success rate increased through fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) prior to APC experiments. Gigaohm seal data quality makes the 384-format accessible to recording of primary and stem cell-derived cells on the SyncroPatch 384. We show recordings in voltage and current clamp modes of stem cell-derived cardiomyocytes. In addition, the option of intracellular solution exchange enabled investigations into the effects of intracellular Ca²⁺ and cAMP on TRPC5 and HCN2 currents, respectively. Together, these data highlight the broad applicability and versatility of APC platforms and also outlines some limitations of the approach. KEY POINTS: High throughput automated patch clamp (APC) can be used for a variety of applications involving ion channels. Lower false positive rates were achieved using automated patch clamp versus a fluorometric imaging plate reader (FLIPR) in a high throughput compound screen against NMDA receptors.  Genetic variants and mutations can be screened on a single 384-well plate to reduce variability of experimental parameters. Intracellular solution can be perfused to investigate effects of ions and second messenger systems without the need for excised patches. Primary cells and stem cell-derived cells can be used on high throughput APC with reasonable success rates for cell capture, voltage clamp measurements and action potential recordings in current clamp mode.